“Medusa” by Carol Ann Duffy: A Critical Analysis

“Medusa” by Carol Ann Duffy, first appeared in 1999 as part of her poetry collection The World’s Wife, reimagines mythological and historical figures.

"Medusa" by Carol Ann Duffy: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “Medusa” by Carol Ann Duffy

“Medusa” by Carol Ann Duffy, first appeared in 1999 as part of her poetry collection The World’s Wife, reimagines mythological and historical figures through the voices of their female counterparts, casting a fresh, feminist lens on familiar stories. In “Medusa,” Duffy gives voice to the infamous Gorgon from Greek mythology, exploring themes of jealousy, transformation, and self-destruction as Medusa reflects on her monstrous appearance, caused by her husband’s perceived betrayal. The poem is celebrated for its vivid, visceral language and psychological depth, inviting readers to empathize with Medusa’s pain and complex emotions rather than viewing her solely as a monstrous figure. Duffy’s retelling humanizes Medusa, aligning with the collection’s overarching feminist aim to reclaim and reinterpret female characters often marginalized or vilified in classical literature. This transformative portrayal has resonated widely, contributing to the poem’s enduring popularity and critical acclaim.

Text: “Medusa” by Carol Ann Duffy

A suspicion, a doubt, a jealousy
grew in my mind,
which turned the hairs on my head to filthy snakes
as though my thoughts
hissed and spat on my scalp.

My bride’s breath soured, stank
in the grey bags of my lungs.
I’m foul mouthed now, foul tongued,
yellow fanged.
There are bullet tears in my eyes.
Are you terrified?

Be terrified.
It’s you I love,
perfect man, Greek God, my own;
but I know you’ll go, betray me, stray
from home.
So better by for me if you were stone.

I glanced at a buzzing bee,
a dull grey pebbly fell
to the ground.
I glanced at a singing bird,
a handful of dusty gravel
spattered down.

I looked at a ginger cat,
a housebrick
shattered a bowl of milk.
I looked at a snuffling pig,
a boulder rolled
in a heap of shit.

I stared in the mirror.
Love gone bad
showed me a Gorgon.
I stared at a dragon.
Fire spewed
from the mouth of a mountain.

And here you come
with a shield for a heart
and a sword for a tongue
and your girls, your girls.
Wasn’t I beautiful
Wasn’t I fragrant and young?

Look at me now.

Annotations: “Medusa” by Carol Ann Duffy
LineAnnotation
A suspicion, a doubt, a jealousyIntroduces the cause of Medusa’s transformation: emotional insecurity leading to jealousy, foreshadowing the physical and mental decay that follows.
grew in my mind,Suggests that jealousy takes root within her thoughts, emphasizing its gradual but consuming growth.
which turned the hairs on my head to filthy snakesSymbolic of her transformation into the Gorgon; her emotions literally manifest in a monstrous form.
as though my thoughtsReflects her self-awareness; she understands that her own thoughts contribute to her change.
hissed and spat on my scalp.The personification of thoughts as hissing and spitting underlines the toxic nature of her jealousy.
My bride’s breath soured, stankJealousy corrupts her, changing even her breath; the term “bride” adds irony as she transforms away from traditional notions of purity.
in the grey bags of my lungs.“Grey bags” implies sickness or decay, underscoring her internal corruption.
I’m foul mouthed now, foul tongued,Emphasizes how jealousy affects her words and personality, transforming her speech into something repulsive.
yellow fanged.Connotes decay and monstrous imagery, indicating how jealousy disfigures her physically.
There are bullet tears in my eyes.Her tears are violent, likening emotional pain to a physical weapon.
Are you terrified?Direct address challenges the reader (or lover), implying Medusa’s awareness of her terrifying transformation.
Be terrified.A command that reflects both self-awareness and resentment, as if taking ownership of her monstrous identity.
It’s you I love,Confession of love, showing that her jealousy stems from an intense emotional connection.
perfect man, Greek God, my own;References her lover’s idealized form, “Greek God” adding irony since Greek mythology depicts him as her undoing.
but I know you’ll go, betray me, straySuggests insecurity and fear of abandonment, fueling her transformation as she anticipates betrayal.
from home.Reflects her anxiety about infidelity, associating betrayal with leaving their shared home.
So better by for me if you were stone.Foreshadows her power to turn things to stone, with a sense of vengeance or protection from betrayal.
I glanced at a buzzing bee,Describes the power of her gaze, which transforms even small creatures.
a dull grey pebble fellThe bee turns to stone, illustrating her destructive capability.
to the ground.Highlights the finality of her power, reducing life to lifelessness.
I glanced at a singing bird,Shows the natural beauty that surrounds her and her unfortunate power to destroy it.
a handful of dusty gravelThe bird becomes stone, an image of beauty reduced to something barren and dead.
spattered down.Implies violence and the inevitability of her curse; everything she looks at is destroyed.
I looked at a ginger cat,Depicts a domestic, gentle creature, indicating that her power doesn’t discriminate.
a housebrickThe cat hardens to stone, mirroring the transformation in her heart.
shattered a bowl of milk.Suggests the destruction of innocence, as milk symbolizes nurturing.
I looked at a snuffling pig,Observes even humble animals are not safe from her gaze, showing her universal effect.
a boulder rolledThe pig, too, turns to stone, underscoring her isolation as everything around her dies.
in a heap of shit.Graphic imagery intensifies her revulsion with herself and her surroundings.
I stared in the mirror.Self-reflection; she confronts her monstrous self, understanding her own transformation.
Love gone badMedusa attributes her state to a corrupted love, indicating she once had love but it has soured.
showed me a Gorgon.Realizes that she has become the mythological creature she dreaded, symbolizing her loss of humanity.
I stared at a dragon.Implies the fierceness and monstrosity of her own image; comparing herself to another mythical monster.
Fire spewedSymbolizes her rage, as if her inner emotions are externalized.
from the mouth of a mountain.The dragon and mountain imagery add scale to her anger, showing it as powerful and natural.
And here you comeThe arrival of her lover with weapon-like qualities, suggesting an impending confrontation.
with a shield for a heartImplies he is emotionally guarded, symbolized by the shield, as though he is prepared to confront her.
and a sword for a tongueHis words are sharp, suggesting he might be as destructive in their relationship as she has been.
and your girls, your girls.Implies infidelity or unfaithfulness, which is the root of her jealousy.
Wasn’t I beautifulA reflection on her former beauty, showing her regret and the loss she feels.
Wasn’t I fragrant and young?Remembers her youth and innocence, lost to jealousy and transformation.
Look at me now.A final acknowledgment of her state, forcing the reader (or her lover) to confront the monster she has become due to her jealousy.
Literary And Poetic Devices: “Medusa” by Carol Ann Duffy
Poetic DeviceExampleExplanation
Alliteration“foul mouthed, foul tongued”Repetition of the ‘f’ sound emphasizes her monstrous transformation and bitterness.
Allusion“Greek God”Refers to Greek mythology, where Medusa’s story originates, giving context to her tragic transformation.
Anaphora“I glanced at… I glanced at… I looked at…”Repetition of phrase beginnings emphasizes her destructive power, affecting all she sees.
Antithesis“Love gone bad”Contrast between love and its decay highlights the transformation of positive emotion into something toxic.
Apostrophe“Are you terrified? Be terrified.”Directly addresses her lover, inviting fear and emphasizing her awareness of her own terrifying transformation.
Assonance“yellow fanged”Repetition of the ‘a’ sound creates a harsh tone that mirrors her grotesque physical transformation.
Caesura“Love gone bad / showed me a Gorgon.”A pause in the line reflects her moment of self-realization, marking a shift in her identity.
Connotation“snakes,” “Gorgon,” “stone”These words carry connotations of danger, myth, and punishment, reinforcing Medusa’s cursed, monstrous identity.
Direct Address“Wasn’t I beautiful… Look at me now.”Medusa addresses her lover directly, showing vulnerability and forcing him to confront the change he caused.
Enjambment“I glanced at a buzzing bee, / a dull grey pebble fell”The continuation of the thought into the next line builds tension as her curse unfolds.
Hyperbole“Fire spewed from the mouth of a mountain”Exaggerates her anger, likening it to volcanic rage, underscoring the intensity of her emotions.
Imagery“bullet tears in my eyes”Vivid image associates her tears with violence, reflecting the pain and anger consuming her.
Irony“perfect man, Greek God”Ironic because this “perfect” lover has contributed to her curse, showing the disparity between his appearance and his actions.
Metaphor“a shield for a heart and a sword for a tongue”Metaphorically describes her lover as guarded and hurtful, suggesting he is emotionally distant and harmful with his words.
Onomatopoeia“hissed and spat”The sounds echo a snake’s noise, connecting to her curse and the venomous nature of her thoughts.
Oxymoron“bullet tears”Combines violence and sadness, showing how her emotions have become as dangerous as weapons.
Personification“my thoughts hissed and spat”Attributes snake-like behavior to her thoughts, emphasizing the intensity of her jealousy and rage.
Repetition“Wasn’t I beautiful / Wasn’t I fragrant and young?”Repeats rhetorical questions to express regret and nostalgia for her lost beauty and innocence.
Simile“as though my thoughts hissed and spat”Compares her thoughts to venomous snakes, showing how jealousy has corrupted her mind.
Symbolism“stone”Symbolizes the loss of life, vibrancy, and warmth, representing the emotional barrenness inflicted by her curse.
Themes: “Medusa” by Carol Ann Duffy
  1. Jealousy and Possessiveness: Medusa’s transformation is driven by jealousy, which corrupts both her body and mind. The poem opens with, “A suspicion, a doubt, a jealousy grew in my mind,” establishing how deeply jealousy has taken root within her. Her fixation on her lover’s potential betrayal leads her to imagine him as “perfect man, Greek God, my own,” revealing a possessive love that ultimately becomes toxic. This consuming jealousy manifests in her power to turn things to stone, symbolizing the destructive effect of possessiveness on relationships.
  2. Transformation and Self-Destruction: Medusa’s jealousy not only affects her mind but also physically alters her, turning her hair into “filthy snakes” and her mouth into something “foul tongued, yellow fanged.” Her reflection in the mirror shows her transformed into a “Gorgon,” a creature of mythology, symbolizing how intense negative emotions can distort one’s self-image and humanity. This theme of transformation illustrates the destructive potential of inner turmoil and how unresolved jealousy or rage can alter one’s identity.
  3. Isolation and Alienation: Medusa’s curse isolates her, as everything she loves or values turns to stone with her gaze. Describing her interactions with living things, she observes, “I glanced at a singing bird, a handful of dusty gravel spattered down,” showing how her power renders her incapable of connection. Her isolation is underscored by her direct address to her lover, “It’s you I love… but I know you’ll go, betray me,” as she anticipates abandonment, leaving her emotionally and physically isolated.
  4. Lost Beauty and Innocence: Medusa reflects on her former self, questioning, “Wasn’t I beautiful / Wasn’t I fragrant and young?” These rhetorical questions express her nostalgia for her lost innocence and beauty, which have been eroded by jealousy and bitterness. The poem’s transformation from beauty to monstrosity mirrors her inner decay, and her lament at the poem’s end, “Look at me now,” captures her regret and the irrevocable consequences of her emotions. This theme speaks to the tragedy of losing one’s original self to darker feelings, a cautionary tale about the cost of unchecked jealousy.
Literary Theories and “Medusa” by Carol Ann Duffy
Literary TheoryApplication to “Medusa”References from the Poem
Feminist TheoryA feminist lens explores how Medusa’s transformation and pain are responses to patriarchal betrayal and objectification. Duffy reclaims Medusa’s voice, giving her agency to express her emotions.“perfect man, Greek God, my own” reflects societal expectations placed on women to remain faithful, while her jealousy and transformation challenge the passive role typically assigned to female figures.
Psychoanalytic TheoryThis theory examines Medusa’s jealousy as a manifestation of inner turmoil and unconscious desires. Her transformation into a Gorgon symbolizes the psychological effects of suppressed rage and betrayal fears.“A suspicion, a doubt, a jealousy grew in my mind” indicates a descent into paranoia, while “bullet tears in my eyes” conveys suppressed violence, suggesting unresolved emotional conflict.
Mythological/Archetypal TheoryMedusa’s character embodies the archetype of the “Monstrous Feminine,” often depicted as a fearful figure in mythology. Duffy’s poem reinterprets this archetype, offering Medusa’s perspective and examining the tragedy behind her monstrosity.“showed me a Gorgon” aligns her with the mythical archetype, while the final lines, “Wasn’t I beautiful / Look at me now,” reveal her tragic loss of innocence and humanity.
Critical Questions about “Medusa” by Carol Ann Duffy
  • How does jealousy transform Medusa, both emotionally and physically?
  • The poem opens with Medusa describing how “A suspicion, a doubt, a jealousy grew in my mind,” illustrating the gradual and invasive nature of jealousy. This emotion corrupts her from within, turning her “thoughts” into venomous “snakes” that hiss and spit. Her jealousy affects her physical state, as she becomes “foul mouthed, foul tongued, yellow fanged,” reflecting how destructive emotions can manifest physically. This transformation raises questions about the power of unchecked jealousy to alter one’s identity, showing that Medusa’s inner turmoil has a tangible impact on her outer form.
  • How does Duffy’s Medusa subvert traditional gender roles and expectations?
  • Through a feminist lens, Medusa’s character defies the passive female archetype by voicing her rage and frustration. Her jealousy stems from her fear of her lover’s betrayal, whom she describes as a “perfect man, Greek God, my own.” In traditional myth, Medusa is often depicted as a monster without agency, but Duffy reclaims her perspective, giving her voice and self-awareness. Medusa’s declaration, “It’s you I love… but I know you’ll go, betray me,” captures the pressures and emotional toll of unreciprocated loyalty, subverting the silent, enduring woman stereotype and highlighting the cost of these expectations on women.
  • What role does isolation play in Medusa’s identity and self-perception?
  • Medusa’s curse isolates her from the world, as everything she looks at becomes lifeless stone. This destructive gaze not only separates her physically but emotionally, as she watches her surroundings crumble. The lines “I glanced at a singing bird, a handful of dusty gravel spattered down” illustrate how even innocent life suffers under her gaze. Medusa’s isolation is further compounded by her lover’s anticipated betrayal, making her jealousy and self-loathing self-reinforcing. Her curse thus becomes a metaphor for emotional isolation, as her own fears and insecurities push her further into solitude.
  • What does Medusa’s lament for her lost beauty suggest about self-worth and societal expectations?
  • In the final lines, Medusa reflects, “Wasn’t I beautiful / Wasn’t I fragrant and young?” These questions reveal her nostalgia and longing for her past self, lamenting the beauty and innocence she has lost. This longing indicates that her self-worth may have been tied to her appearance, a reflection on societal expectations that prioritize a woman’s beauty over other attributes. By ending with the resigned phrase, “Look at me now,” Medusa’s transformation critiques the transience of beauty and the heavy toll societal pressures can take on a woman’s identity, raising questions about the true nature of worth and self-image.
Literary Works Similar to “Medusa” by Carol Ann Duffy
  1. “Eurydice” by Carol Ann Duffy – Like “Medusa,” this poem gives voice to a traditionally silent female figure from mythology, presenting a feminist reinterpretation of Eurydice’s story.
  2. “Lady Lazarus” by Sylvia Plath – Plath’s poem also explores themes of transformation and self-empowerment in the face of suffering, depicting a woman who reclaims control over her narrative.
  3. “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock” by T.S. Eliot – This poem shares Medusa’s introspective tone, delving into insecurities and self-image, though through the perspective of a man grappling with inadequacy and alienation.
  4. “Mirror” by Sylvia Plath – This poem examines self-perception and the fear of aging, resonating with Medusa’s lament over her lost beauty and the changing reflection she sees in herself.
  5. “Goblin Market” by Christina Rossetti – While not directly about jealousy, this poem addresses themes of temptation, transformation, and female identity, focusing on the dangers that societal expectations impose on women.
Representative Quotations of “Medusa” by Carol Ann Duffy
QuotationContextTheoretical Perspective
“A suspicion, a doubt, a jealousy grew in my mind”Opening line that sets the tone, revealing the root of Medusa’s transformation as jealousy.Psychoanalytic Theory – Examines jealousy as a psychological force that transforms Medusa’s mind and body.
“which turned the hairs on my head to filthy snakes”Illustrates her physical transformation as a manifestation of inner turmoil.Feminist Theory – Reflects how societal pressures on women to remain faithful affect their self-image.
“My bride’s breath soured, stank in the grey bags of my lungs”Indicates how jealousy corrupts her even physically, tainting her purity.Psychoanalytic Theory – Shows how intense emotions affect the body, linking mental state to physical decay.
“I’m foul mouthed now, foul tongued, yellow fanged”Suggests her internal rage has made her monstrous and repulsive.Feminist Theory – Challenges traditional feminine ideals of gentleness by showing her anger outwardly.
“Are you terrified? Be terrified.”Direct address to her lover, inviting fear and expressing her awareness of her terrifying transformation.Reader-Response Theory – Engages the reader directly, challenging them to confront Medusa’s wrath.
“It’s you I love, perfect man, Greek God, my own”Her lover is idealized, though ironically, as he has played a part in her transformation.Irony and Feminist Theory – Highlights her disillusionment with the male ideal and its destructive effects on women.
“I glanced at a singing bird, a handful of dusty gravel spattered down”Shows her curse in action, turning a living creature to stone.Mythological/Archetypal Theory – Reinforces Medusa’s role as a cursed figure whose power isolates her.
“I stared in the mirror. Love gone bad showed me a Gorgon.”Medusa realizes her transformation, seeing herself as a monster in the mirror.Psychoanalytic and Feminist Theory – Reflects self-perception altered by betrayal, mirroring societal judgments of “fallen” women.
“Wasn’t I beautiful, wasn’t I fragrant and young?”Medusa’s nostalgic lament for her lost beauty and innocence.Feminist and Psychoanalytic Theory – Questions societal value placed on female beauty, expressing loss and longing.
“Look at me now.”Final line that forces the reader or lover to confront her monstrous change, a result of her emotional pain.Reader-Response and Tragic Theory – Invites the audience to reflect on her tragic transformation and societal expectations.
Suggested Readings: “Medusa” by Carol Ann Duffy
  1. Prihermawan, Widyanto Tulus. THE JEALOUSY IN CAROL ANN DUFFY’S “MEDUSA”. Diss. Diponegoro University, 2014.
  2. Duffy, Carol Ann. “Medusa.” Carol Ann Duffy, The World’s Wife, London: Picador (1999): 40.
  3. Duffy, Carol Ann. The World’s Wife. Vol. 6. Pan Macmillan, 2015.

“Mary Had a Little Lamb”: A Critical Analysis

“Mary Had a Little Lamb” first appeared in 1830 as part of Sarah Josepha Hale’s collection titled Poems for Our Children.

"Mary Had a Little Lamb": A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “Mary Had a Little Lamb”

“Mary Had a Little Lamb” first appeared in 1830 as part of Sarah Josepha Hale’s collection titled Poems for Our Children. The poem’s main idea centers on the gentle, affectionate relationship between a young girl, Mary, and her loyal lamb, exploring themes of innocence, kindness, and the emotional bonds between children and animals. Its popularity grew due to its simple, memorable rhythm and relatable storyline, making it accessible for young readers and widely embraced in educational settings. The poem became especially notable as an early example of American children’s literature and has endured through generations as a staple in nursery rhymes, symbolizing the warmth of childhood and the joy of companionship.

Text: “Mary Had a Little Lamb”

Mary had a little lamb,

Its fleece was white as snow;

And everywhere that Mary went

The lamb was sure to go.

It followed her to school one day,

Which was against the rule;

It made the children laugh and play

To see a lamb at school.

And so the teacher turned it out,

But still it lingered near,

And waited patiently about

Till Mary did appear.

Why does the lamb love Mary so?

The eager children cry;

Why, Mary loves the lamb, you know,

The teacher did reply.

Annotations: “Mary Had a Little Lamb”

LineAnnotation
Mary had a little lamb,Introduces the central characters: Mary and her lamb, indicating a personal relationship. “Little” conveys endearment.
Its fleece was white as snow;Describes the lamb’s appearance, emphasizing its purity and innocence, symbolized by “white as snow.”
And everywhere that Mary wentSuggests the lamb’s strong attachment to Mary, as it follows her everywhere, hinting at loyalty and devotion.
The lamb was sure to go.Reinforces the lamb’s unwavering companionship, highlighting its steadfastness and close bond with Mary.
It followed her to school one day,The lamb breaks social norms by following Mary to school, adding a playful element to the narrative.
Which was against the rule;Indicates the lamb’s presence at school as a rule-breaking event, showcasing its persistence and innocence.
It made the children laugh and playThe lamb’s presence at school amuses the children, creating a lighthearted, joyful scene that breaks routine.
To see a lamb at school.Reinforces the novelty and humor of a lamb in an unexpected setting, adding charm to the poem.
And so the teacher turned it out,The teacher enforces school rules by removing the lamb, symbolizing authority and societal expectations.
But still it lingered near,Despite being turned away, the lamb stays close by, showing its loyalty and reluctance to part from Mary.
And waited patiently aboutThe lamb’s patience further demonstrates its attachment and devotion, embodying themes of loyalty.
Till Mary did appear.The lamb’s dedication is rewarded when Mary returns, suggesting mutual affection and companionship.
Why does the lamb love Mary so?The children’s curiosity about the lamb’s loyalty adds a reflective, moral dimension to the poem.
The eager children cry;Describes the children’s enthusiasm, representing natural curiosity and innocence.
Why, Mary loves the lamb, you know,The teacher explains that the lamb’s love is reciprocated, hinting at a moral lesson about love and kindness.
The teacher did reply.Concludes with the teacher’s wisdom, imparting a simple yet powerful message on the nature of love and loyalty.
Literary And Poetic Devices: “Mary Had a Little Lamb”
DeviceExampleExplanation
Alliteration“little lamb”The repetition of the “l” sound creates a pleasing rhythm and emphasizes the close bond between Mary and the lamb.
Anaphora“And everywhere that Mary went / The lamb was sure to go.”The repeated use of “And” at the beginning of lines emphasizes continuity and flow.
Anthropomorphism“The lamb was sure to go.”The lamb displays human-like loyalty and attachment, bringing it to life as a character.
Assonance“Mary had a little lamb”The repetition of the “a” sound in “Mary,” “had,” and “lamb” creates a soft, musical quality to the line.
Caesura“Why, Mary loves the lamb, you know,”The comma creates a natural pause, highlighting the revelation of Mary’s love for the lamb.
Consonance“Till Mary did appear.”The repetition of the “r” sound at the end of words adds rhythm and cohesion to the line.
End Rhyme“lamb” / “snow” / “go”Pairs of rhyming words at the ends of lines, such as “snow” and “go,” create a regular rhyme scheme.
Enjambment“And waited patiently about / Till Mary did appear.”The thought flows over the line break, emphasizing the lamb’s patience in waiting for Mary.
Hyperbole“Its fleece was white as snow”An exaggerated comparison that emphasizes the purity and innocence of the lamb.
Imagery“Its fleece was white as snow”Vividly describes the lamb’s appearance, allowing readers to visualize its purity and innocence.
Internal Rhyme“Why, Mary loves the lamb, you know”The rhyme within the line (“lamb” and “you know”) adds to the sing-song quality of the poem.
Irony“Which was against the rule”There’s humor in the idea of a lamb breaking a rule by attending school, which is unusual and unexpected.
Metaphor“Its fleece was white as snow”Compares the lamb’s fleece to snow without using “like” or “as,” enhancing the purity of its appearance.
MeterThe poem’s consistent rhythmThe poem follows a steady, rhythmic meter that makes it easy to memorize and recite, adding musicality.
MoodPlayful and innocentThe poem’s light-hearted events, like the lamb at school, contribute to a playful, innocent mood.
Personification“The lamb was sure to go”Assigns the lamb human characteristics, such as determination and loyalty, enhancing its role in the story.
Repetition“Mary had a little lamb”Repeating this line reinforces the theme and rhythm, helping readers remember the core of the poem.
Rhetorical Question“Why does the lamb love Mary so?”Poses a question for reflection, drawing readers to consider the reasons for the lamb’s loyalty.
Simile“Its fleece was white as snow”Directly compares the lamb’s fleece to snow using “as,” enhancing the image of purity and innocence.
SymbolismThe lamb represents innocenceThe lamb symbolizes purity, innocence, and loyalty, making it central to the poem’s moral message.
Themes: “Mary Had a Little Lamb”
  1. Innocence and Purity: The poem captures a childlike sense of innocence and purity, epitomized by Mary and her lamb. The lamb’s “fleece was white as snow,” symbolizing its purity and innocence, which reflects Mary’s own gentle nature. This association underscores the idealized purity of childhood, a time free from the complexities of adult life. The image of the lamb as “white as snow” not only paints a vivid picture but also aligns with the theme of unblemished innocence.
  2. Loyalty and Companionship: The unwavering loyalty of the lamb to Mary is central to the poem, symbolizing true companionship. “And everywhere that Mary went / The lamb was sure to go” highlights this devotion, as the lamb accompanies her out of love rather than obligation. This close companionship reflects an idealized bond, suggesting that loyalty comes naturally in relationships built on love and kindness. The lamb’s constant presence reinforces the theme that true friends remain by one’s side regardless of circumstances.
  3. Joy and Playfulness: The presence of the lamb brings an element of joy and playfulness, especially highlighted by the children’s reactions at school. When the lamb follows Mary to school, “It made the children laugh and play,” showing that its unexpected appearance sparks delight among the children. This theme of joy emphasizes the simplicity of happiness in childhood, where even a small, unusual event becomes a source of fun and laughter. The lamb’s behavior breaks the routine, bringing spontaneity into a structured environment.
  4. Love and Reciprocity: The poem underscores that love is mutual and that kindness is often reciprocated. The line, “Why does the lamb love Mary so? / Why, Mary loves the lamb, you know,” suggests that the lamb’s affection for Mary is rooted in her own kindness toward it. This explanation by the teacher introduces a moral message that love begets love; genuine affection, as shown by Mary, naturally fosters loyalty and attachment. This theme serves as a gentle lesson in empathy, illustrating that caring actions build strong, loving relationships.
Literary Theories and “Mary Had a Little Lamb”
Literary TheoryExplanationReference from the Poem
Feminist TheoryExamines the portrayal of gender roles and the influence of gender on relationships and actions.The poem subtly emphasizes Mary’s nurturing and caring role, evident in her connection to the lamb, which “waited patiently” for her.
Psychoanalytic TheoryFocuses on unconscious motives and childhood innocence, often analyzing attachment and affection.The lamb’s devotion to Mary and the children’s curiosity (“Why does the lamb love Mary so?”) highlights themes of attachment and love.
StructuralismAnalyzes the structure and language of the text, observing patterns and binary oppositions.The repetitive rhyme scheme and predictable structure mirror the innocence and simplicity of the poem’s theme and setting in school.
Critical Questions about “Mary Had a Little Lamb”
  • What does the lamb symbolize in Mary’s life, and how does it reflect her character?
  • The lamb appears as a symbol of innocence and loyalty, qualities that are mirrored in Mary’s own character. The poem emphasizes this connection through the line, “Why, Mary loves the lamb, you know,” showing that Mary’s kindness and affection are the reasons for the lamb’s unwavering loyalty. This mutual affection highlights Mary as a nurturing figure, suggesting that her compassion attracts innocence and purity, which the lamb embodies.
  • How does the poem explore the concept of rules versus innocence?
  • The poem contrasts societal rules with the innocence of a childlike bond, especially when it describes how the lamb followed Mary “to school one day, / Which was against the rule.” This incident serves as a critique of rigid structures that may stifle innocent, joyful acts, such as a lamb’s harmless presence in a school. Through this juxtaposition, the poem questions the necessity of certain societal norms when they interfere with innocent expressions of companionship and joy.
  • How does the teacher’s reaction to the lamb reveal adult attitudes toward childhood playfulness?
  • The teacher’s decision to “turn out” the lamb from school demonstrates an adult enforcement of rules and order over the spontaneous joy that the lamb’s presence brings to the children. This response reflects a common adult view that values discipline over playful curiosity, which contrasts with the children’s reaction, as they “laugh and play” at seeing the lamb. The teacher’s actions underscore a tension between childhood innocence and the constraints imposed by adult authority.
  • What does the poem suggest about the nature of love and attachment?
  • The line, “Why does the lamb love Mary so?” reveals a child’s curiosity about the nature of love and attachment, questioning why the lamb feels such a bond with Mary. The teacher’s answer, “Mary loves the lamb, you know,” implies that love begets love, suggesting that attachment is a natural response to affection. The poem thus proposes that love is reciprocal and that genuine affection can transcend species, connecting beings through mutual care and kindness.
Literary Works Similar to “Mary Had a Little Lamb”
  1. “The Lamb” by William Blake
    Like Mary Had a Little Lamb, this poem uses a lamb as a symbol of innocence and purity, reflecting on creation and kindness.
  2. “Little Boy Blue” by Eugene Field
    This poem similarly touches on themes of childhood innocence and the bond between children and their cherished animals.
  3. “The Owl and the Pussycat” by Edward Lear
    This playful poem mirrors the theme of companionship and features animals in an innocent, whimsical adventure, much like the lamb’s journey with Mary.
  4. “The Cow” by Robert Louis Stevenson
    Stevenson’s poem shares a focus on the affection children feel for animals, describing a cow in tender, simple language.
  5. “The Tyger” by William Blake
    Although more intense, this poem complements The Lamb by Blake and explores the duality of innocence and strength in creation, reflecting a symbolic exploration of animals.
Representative Quotations of “Mary Had a Little Lamb”
QuotationContextTheoretical Perspective
“Mary had a little lamb, / Its fleece was white as snow;”Introduces the innocent and pure relationship between Mary and the lamb.Symbolism – The lamb symbolizes innocence and purity.
“And everywhere that Mary went / The lamb was sure to go.”Demonstrates the lamb’s loyalty to Mary and their inseparable bond.Psychoanalytic Theory – Suggests attachment and dependency.
“It followed her to school one day, / Which was against the rule;”The lamb defies societal norms by entering the school with Mary.Structuralism – Examines rules versus innocence and defiance.
“It made the children laugh and play / To see a lamb at school.”The lamb’s presence brings joy to the children, highlighting its novelty.Reader-Response Theory – Engages the reader’s nostalgic joy.
“And so the teacher turned it out,”The teacher enforces rules by removing the lamb from the school environment.Feminist Theory – Examines adult control over innocence.
“But still it lingered near, / And waited patiently about”Despite being turned out, the lamb remains close, showing loyalty.Psychoanalytic Theory – Represents persistent attachment.
“Till Mary did appear.”The lamb patiently waits for Mary, underscoring its devotion.New Criticism – Focus on loyalty and dedication as themes.
“Why does the lamb love Mary so? / The eager children cry;”Reflects children’s curiosity about love and attachment.Psychoanalytic Theory – Inquiry into the nature of affection.
“Why, Mary loves the lamb, you know,”The teacher’s response emphasizes reciprocal affection.Feminist Theory – Love as a natural bond outside adult norms.
“The teacher did reply.”Shows the adult role in explaining emotions to children.Structuralism – Adult role in shaping children’s perceptions.

Suggested Readings: “Mary Had a Little Lamb”

  1. Goose, Mother, et al. “MARY HAD A LITTLE LAMB.” The Lamb Cycle: What the Great English Poets Would Have Written About Mary and Her Lamb (Had They Thought of It First), Brandeis University Press, 2023, pp. 1–2. JSTOR, https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctv30m1f51.5. Accessed 13 Nov. 2024.
  2. Pound, Gomer. “Mason’s Hand in ‘Mary’s Lamb.'” The Bulletin of Historical Research in Music Education, vol. 7, no. 1, 1986, pp. 23–27. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/40214696. Accessed 13 Nov. 2024.
  3. Altstetter, Mabel F. “Early American Magazines for Children.” Peabody Journal of Education, vol. 19, no. 3, 1941, pp. 131–36. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/1489322. Accessed 13 Nov. 2024.
  4. Loomis, C. Grant. “Mary Had a Parody: A Rhyme of Childhood in Folk Tradition.” Western Folklore, vol. 17, no. 1, 1958, pp. 45–51. JSTOR, https://doi.org/10.2307/1497253. Accessed 13 Nov. 2024.
  5. Smith, Andrew F. “The First Thanksgiving.” Gastronomica, vol. 3, no. 4, 2003, pp. 79–85. JSTOR, https://doi.org/10.1525/gfc.2003.3.4.79. Accessed 13 Nov. 2024.

“Eurydice” by Carol Ann Duffy: A Critical Analysis

“Eurydice” by Carol Ann Duffy first appeared in her 1999 poetry collection The World’s Wife. This celebrated anthology reimagines classical myths, historical figures, and iconic stories through the voices of often-overlooked female characters, offering a feminist reinterpretation of these narratives.

"Eurydice" by Carol Ann Duffy: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “Eurydice” by Carol Ann Duffy

“Eurydice” by Carol Ann Duffy first appeared in her 1999 poetry collection The World’s Wife. This celebrated anthology reimagines classical myths, historical figures, and iconic stories through the voices of often-overlooked female characters, offering a feminist reinterpretation of these narratives. In “Eurydice,” Duffy reexamines the myth of Orpheus and Eurydice from Eurydice’s perspective, challenging the traditional portrayal of her as a passive figure and instead presenting her as a self-aware and independent woman. The poem explores themes of female agency, voice, and resistance against male-centric narratives, resonating with contemporary readers and contributing to its enduring popularity. Duffy’s witty and subversive style, combined with her keen social commentary, makes “Eurydice” a standout piece in the collection, emblematic of her broader critique of patriarchal traditions in literature and culture.

Text: “Eurydice” by Carol Ann Duffy

Girls, I was dead and down

in the Underworld, a shade,

a shadow of my former self, nowhen.

It was a place where language stopped,

a black full stop, a black hole

Where the words had to come to an end.

And end they did there,

last words,

famous or not.

It suited me down to the ground.

So imagine me there,

unavailable,

out of this world,

then picture my face in that place

of Eternal Repose,

in the one place you’d think a girl would be safe

from the kind of a man

who follows her round

writing poems,

hovers about

while she reads them,

calls her His Muse,

and once sulked for a night and a day

because she remarked on his weakness for abstract nouns.

Just picture my face

when I heard –

Ye Gods –

a familiar knock-knock at Death’s door.

Him.

Big O.

Larger than life.

With his lyre

and a poem to pitch, with me as the prize.

Things were different back then.

For the men, verse-wise,

Big O was the boy. Legendary.

The blurb on the back of his books claimed

that animals,

aardvark to zebra,

flocked to his side when he sang,

fish leapt in their shoals

at the sound of his voice,

even the mute, sullen stones at his feet

wept wee, silver tears.

Bollocks. (I’d done all the typing myself,

I should know.)

And given my time all over again,

rest assured that I’d rather speak for myself

than be Dearest, Beloved, Dark Lady, White Goddess etc., etc.

In fact girls, I’d rather be dead.

But the Gods are like publishers,

usually male,

and what you doubtless know of my tale

is the deal.

Orpheus strutted his stuff.

The bloodless ghosts were in tears.

Sisyphus sat on his rock for the first time in years.

Tantalus was permitted a couple of beers.

The woman in question could scarcely believe her ears.

Like it or not,

I must follow him back to our life –

Eurydice, Orpheus’ wife –

to be trapped in his images, metaphors, similes,

octaves and sextets, quatrains and couplets,

elegies, limericks, villanelles,

histories, myths…

He’d been told that he mustn’t look back

or turn round,

but walk steadily upwards,

myself right behind him,

out of the Underworld

into the upper air that for me was the past.

He’d been warned

that one look would lose me

for ever and ever.

So we walked, we walked.

Nobody talked.

Girls, forget what you’ve read.

It happened like this –

I did everything in my power

to make him look back.

What did I have to do, I said,

to make him see we were through?

I was dead. Deceased.

I was Resting in Peace. Passé. Late.

Past my sell-by date…

I stretched out my hand

to touch him once

on the back of the neck.

Please let me stay.

But already the light had saddened from purple to grey.

It was an uphill schlep

from death to life

and with every step

I willed him to turn.

I was thinking of filching the poem

out of his cloak,

when inspiration finally struck.

I stopped, thrilled.

He was a yard in front.

My voice shook when I spoke –

Orpheus, your poem’s a masterpiece.

I’d love to hear it again…

He was smiling modestly,

when he turned,

when he turned and he looked at me.

What else?

I noticed he hadn’t shaved.

I waved once and was gone.

The dead are so talented.

The living walk by the edge of a vast lake

near, the wise, drowned silence of the dead.

Annotations: “Eurydice” by Carol Ann Duffy
StanzaAnnotation
1st StanzaIntroduces Eurydice as a “shade” in the Underworld, emphasizing her detachment from life and language. The imagery of silence and the absence of words underscores her death and disconnection.
2nd StanzaDepicts her existence in the Underworld as one of peace and relief, free from the constraints of being Orpheus’s muse. This subverts traditional myth by portraying the Underworld as a refuge.
3rd StanzaSatirizes Orpheus’s portrayal of her as a muse and critiques the male-centric tradition of immortalizing women through their relationships with men. It questions the authenticity of Orpheus’s artistry.
4th StanzaMockingly elevates Orpheus’s legend, highlighting his supposed universal appeal. This ironic tone undermines his grandeur and reclaims Eurydice’s agency.
5th StanzaReveals Eurydice’s discontent with being reduced to a mere poetic subject, preferring her own voice over being objectified in literary tropes. Demonstrates her feminist stance.
6th StanzaCompares the Gods to publishers, exposing the power dynamics and male dominance in the narrative and artistic spaces. Sets the stage for Eurydice’s resistance.
7th StanzaNarrates Orpheus’s descent into the Underworld, using hyperbolic imagery to ridicule his self-importance. Highlights the absurdity of his poetic dominance.
8th StanzaDetails the conditions of the deal for Eurydice’s return, satirizing poetic forms and emphasizing the artistic constraints she faces. Reflects her disillusionment.
9th StanzaEurydice actively manipulates Orpheus to look back, emphasizing her agency and determination to remain in the Underworld. This subversion of the myth portrays her as the architect of her own fate.
10th StanzaCaptures the dramatic moment when Orpheus turns, illustrating Eurydice’s wit and intelligence in orchestrating her own liberation. Challenges the traditional depiction of Orpheus as a hero.
11th StanzaConcludes with a reflection on the divide between the dead and the living, framing the dead as possessing a profound wisdom. Highlights the themes of silence, autonomy, and Eurydice’s reclaimed voice.
Literary And Poetic Devices: “Eurydice” by Carol Ann Duffy
Literary/Poetic DeviceExampleExplanation
Alliteration“Dead and down in the Underworld”Repetition of the ‘d’ sound emphasizes the finality and darkness of the Underworld.
AllusionReferences to “Orpheus,” “Sisyphus,” and “Tantalus”Draws on Greek mythology to frame the narrative and provide cultural context.
Ambiguity“The dead are so talented”Can imply wisdom or irony about the silence and creativity of the dead.
Anaphora“I was dead. Deceased. I was Resting in Peace.”Repetition at the start of phrases emphasizes Eurydice’s detachment and her death.
Assonance“A shadow of my former self”Repetition of vowel sounds (‘a’ and ‘o’) creates a melancholic rhythm.
Caesura“Bollocks. (I’d done all the typing myself…)”A pause in the middle of the line to add a conversational tone and humor.
Colloquialism“Bollocks”Informal language adds humor and modernity, contrasting with the traditional mythological tone.
Contrast“The living walk by the edge of a vast lake” vs. “The wise, drowned silence of the dead”Highlights the gap between the living’s triviality and the dead’s wisdom.
Dramatic Irony“I did everything in my power to make him look back”Readers know Eurydice’s intentions, while Orpheus remains unaware.
Enjambment“But already the light had saddened / from purple to grey.”Line break carries over the meaning, reflecting a smooth yet somber transition.
Hyperbole“Animals, aardvark to zebra, flocked to his side when he sang”Exaggeration of Orpheus’s abilities mocks his supposed grandeur.
Imagery“The light had saddened from purple to grey”Vivid sensory detail conveys the fading hope and transition.
Irony“A familiar knock-knock at Death’s door. Him. Big O.”Juxtaposes humor with the seriousness of the Underworld setting.
Metaphor“The Underworld, a shade, a shadow of my former self”Describes Eurydice’s death through a metaphor for absence and loss of self.
Paradox“The one place you’d think a girl would be safe from…a man”Contrasts the supposed safety of the Underworld with Orpheus’s intrusion.
Personification“Even the mute, sullen stones at his feet wept wee, silver tears”Gives human traits to inanimate objects to mock Orpheus’s alleged impact.
Repetition“Girls, I was dead and down”Repetition of ‘dead’ emphasizes her separation from life.
Satire“The Gods are like publishers, usually male”Critiques male-dominated artistic and literary spaces with humor.
Symbolism“The lyre”Represents Orpheus’s poetic and artistic power, which Eurydice rejects.
ToneA mix of humor, defiance, and irony throughoutCreates a feminist, subversive retelling of a classic myth.
Themes: “Eurydice” by Carol Ann Duffy
  • Female Agency and Empowerment: Eurydice” challenges traditional representations of women in mythology, presenting a narrative where the titular character asserts her independence. Eurydice actively manipulates Orpheus, ensuring her own return to the Underworld: “I did everything in my power to make him look back.” This act of defiance symbolizes her rejection of being defined solely as a muse or an extension of Orpheus’s artistry. Her refusal to be trapped in his metaphors and poetic forms—“I’d rather speak for myself than be Dearest, Beloved, Dark Lady”—emphasizes her desire for autonomy and a voice of her own, making this a feminist reclamation of her identity.
  • Critique of Male-Centric Artistic Traditions: The poem critiques the patriarchal dominance in artistic and literary traditions, satirizing Orpheus’s perceived genius and his treatment of Eurydice as an artistic object. The line “The Gods are like publishers, usually male” metaphorically exposes the systemic bias that sidelines women’s voices in favor of male narratives. By portraying Orpheus as self-centered and oblivious—“He was smiling modestly when he turned, when he turned and he looked at me”—Duffy underscores the limitations of male-centric storytelling, which often silences or distorts female experiences.
  • Freedom Through Silence and Death: The Underworld is portrayed as a place of peace and liberation for Eurydice, contrasting with traditional depictions of it as a realm of punishment. “It suited me down to the ground” reflects her contentment in a space where she is free from Orpheus’s gaze and oppressive influence. Death becomes a metaphor for freedom from societal and relational constraints, symbolizing her ultimate escape from the roles imposed on her by others. Her parting observation—“The wise, drowned silence of the dead”—elevates the quiet autonomy of the Underworld over the chaotic, performative life above.
  • Subversion of Myth and Storytelling: Duffy reimagines the Orpheus and Eurydice myth, flipping the focus from the heroic male figure to the silenced female perspective. By rewriting the tale—“Forget what you’ve read. It happened like this”—Duffy questions the authority and reliability of traditional myths. The poem’s witty, ironic tone and its focus on Eurydice’s resistance to Orpheus’s attempts at rescue subvert the heroic narrative, highlighting how myth can be reinterpreted to reflect contemporary themes of equality and autonomy.
Literary Theories and “Eurydice” by Carol Ann Duffy
Literary TheoryExplanation and RelevanceReferences from the Poem
Feminist TheoryFeminist literary theory examines texts for representations of gender inequality and patriarchal dominance. “Eurydice” critiques the silencing of women and the objectification of Eurydice as Orpheus’s muse. Duffy reclaims her voice, showing Eurydice as an autonomous figure who rejects traditional roles.“I’d rather speak for myself than be Dearest, Beloved, Dark Lady, White Goddess etc., etc.” demonstrates her desire for independence and resistance to being objectified.
PostmodernismPostmodernism challenges established narratives, embraces multiple perspectives, and questions the reliability of myths. Duffy subverts the traditional Orpheus and Eurydice myth, reframing the story from Eurydice’s point of view and rejecting Orpheus’s heroism.“Forget what you’ve read. It happened like this.” reflects the postmodern skepticism of authoritative historical and literary narratives.
Psychoanalytic TheoryPsychoanalytic theory explores subconscious desires, conflicts, and the dynamics of relationships. Eurydice’s actions reflect her internal struggle for freedom from Orpheus’s controlling presence. Her manipulation of Orpheus to ensure her return to the Underworld reveals her deep desire for autonomy.“I did everything in my power to make him look back.” highlights her subconscious need to break free from his dominance and reclaim her individuality.
Critical Questions about “Eurydice” by Carol Ann Duffy
  • How does “Eurydice” challenge traditional gender roles in mythology?
  • Duffy reimagines Eurydice as an assertive character, rejecting her portrayal as a passive figure in the original myth. The poem critiques the patriarchal tradition of women being defined by their relationships to men, evident in lines like, “I’d rather speak for myself than be Dearest, Beloved, Dark Lady, White Goddess etc., etc.” This line underscores Eurydice’s frustration with being reduced to a poetic subject, raising the question of how myths perpetuate gender hierarchies and what it means for women to reclaim their voices in such narratives.
  • What role does humor play in the feminist critique of the poem?
  • Duffy employs wit and irony to deconstruct Orpheus’s legendary status, transforming him from a heroic figure into a source of comedic exaggeration. Phrases like, “Bollocks. (I’d done all the typing myself, I should know)” mock Orpheus’s artistic claims and highlight Eurydice’s agency. The humor not only makes the critique more accessible but also subverts the gravity of myth, inviting readers to question how seriously these male-centered stories should be taken.
  • How does the poem explore the concept of freedom through silence and death?
  • For Eurydice, the Underworld represents liberation from societal and relational constraints. Her description of death as a state where “language stopped, a black full stop” contrasts sharply with the verbose world of Orpheus’s poetry. This imagery portrays death as a form of escape and silence as a space for autonomy. The question arises: does Duffy suggest that true freedom for women in oppressive systems can only exist outside those systems, even in symbolic death?
  • In what ways does the poem reflect on the power dynamics of storytelling?
  • Duffy’s Eurydice critiques the male dominance in storytelling, likening the Gods to publishers—“usually male”—to draw parallels between the classical and modern artistic worlds. This critique questions whose voices are prioritized in cultural narratives. By declaring, “Forget what you’ve read. It happened like this,” Eurydice reclaims her narrative, prompting readers to consider how myths and histories might be reimagined if told from silenced perspectives.
Literary Works Similar to “Eurydice” by Carol Ann Duffy
  1. “Medusa” by Carol Ann Duffy
    Shares a feminist reinterpretation of a classical myth, focusing on the voice of a traditionally vilified female figure, giving her agency and emotional depth.
  2. “The Lady of Shalott” by Alfred, Lord Tennyson
    Explores themes of female isolation and male dominance, reflecting the struggles of women trapped in societal roles while yearning for independence.
  3. “Siren Song” by Margaret Atwood
    Reimagines the myth of the Sirens, emphasizing the manipulative power of the female voice and critiquing male-centric perceptions of femininity.
  4. “Demeter” by Carol Ann Duffy
    Another poem from The World’s Wife, it revisits a mythological narrative from a maternal perspective, highlighting themes of loss, renewal, and female resilience.
Representative Quotations of “Eurydice” by Carol Ann Duffy
QuotationContextTheoretical Perspective
“I was dead and down in the Underworld, a shade, a shadow of my former self.”Eurydice introduces herself, emphasizing her detachment from life and her reduced state in death.Feminist Theory: Highlights the erasure of female identity.
“A place where language stopped, a black full stop, a black hole.”Describes the Underworld as a silent, peaceful escape from life’s constraints.Psychoanalytic Theory: Reflects a subconscious desire for freedom.
“I’d rather speak for myself than be Dearest, Beloved, Dark Lady, White Goddess.”Rejects traditional roles imposed by male poets and reclaims her voice.Feminist Theory: Critiques patriarchal artistic traditions.
“The Gods are like publishers, usually male.”Satirizes the dominance of men in decision-making in both myth and modern literary fields.Marxist Theory: Examines power dynamics in creative industries.
“He mustn’t look back or turn round… but already the light had saddened from purple to grey.”Depicts the moment of Orpheus’s failure to resist looking back, symbolizing Eurydice’s liberation.Postmodernism: Challenges the reliability of the original myth.
“Bollocks. (I’d done all the typing myself, I should know.)”Humorously undermines Orpheus’s artistic claims, asserting her contribution to his work.Feminist Theory: Subverts male authority over creative output.
“Forget what you’ve read. It happened like this.”Directly challenges the traditional version of the Orpheus and Eurydice myth.Postmodernism: Encourages alternative narratives.
“The dead are so talented. The living walk by the edge of a vast lake.”Reflects on the wisdom of the dead versus the ignorance of the living.Existentialism: Explores the profundity of silence and death.
“Orpheus, your poem’s a masterpiece. I’d love to hear it again…”Eurydice manipulates Orpheus into looking back by appealing to his vanity.Psychoanalytic Theory: Reveals Eurydice’s agency through psychological manipulation.
“I did everything in my power to make him look back.”Confesses her active role in securing her independence by orchestrating Orpheus’s failure.Feminist Theory: Asserts female autonomy and control over fate.
Suggested Readings: “Eurydice” by Carol Ann Duffy
  1. Scannell, Vernon. Ambit, no. 159, 2000, pp. 69–70. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/44342000. Accessed 15 Nov. 2024.
  2. DIMARCO, DANETTE. “Exposing Nude Art: Carol Ann Duffy’s Response to Robert Browning.” Mosaic: An Interdisciplinary Critical Journal, vol. 31, no. 3, 1998, pp. 25–39. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/44029809. Accessed 15 Nov. 2024.
  3. Yorke, Liz. “British Lesbian Poetics: A Brief Exploration.” Feminist Review, no. 62, 1999, pp. 78–90. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/1395648. Accessed 15 Nov. 2024.
  4. Nori, Beatrice. “Dreadful Dolls: Female Power in Carol Ann Duffy.” Linguæ &-Rivista di lingue e culture moderne 19.2 (2021): 71-85.

“Marriage A-la-Mode” by John Dryden: A Critical Analysis

“Marriage A-la-Mode” by John Dryden first appeared in 1673 as part of a collection of Restoration comedies that reflected the complexities and ironies of court life.

"Marriage A-la-Mode" by John Dryden: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “Marriage A-la-Mode” by John Dryden

“Marriage A-la-Mode” by John Dryden first appeared in 1673 as part of a collection of Restoration comedies that reflected the complexities and ironies of court life. This play is known for its dual plot structure, interweaving a heroic romance with a satirical comedy of manners. The main themes revolve around the social expectations of marriage, fidelity, and the power dynamics between the sexes. Through its sharp wit, clever dialogue, and exaggerated characters, Dryden presents a critique of the aristocracy’s frivolity and moral ambiguity, making it a notable work for its humor and social commentary. The play’s popularity stems from its reflection of Restoration society’s attitudes toward marriage and relationships, as well as its innovative approach to mixing genres, which provided audiences with both entertainment and a lens into the hypocrisies of their own world.

Text: “Marriage A-la-Mode” by John Dryden

Why should a foolish marriage vow,

Which long ago was made,

Oblige us to each other now

When passion is decay’d?

We lov’d, and we lov’d, as long as we could,

Till our love was lov’d out in us both:

But our marriage is dead, when the pleasure is fled:

‘Twas pleasure first made it an oath.

If I have pleasures for a friend,

And farther love in store,

What wrong has he whose joys did end,

And who could give no more?

‘Tis a madness that he should be jealous of me,

Or that I should bar him of another:

For all we can gain is to give our selves pain,

When neither can hinder the other.

Annotations: “Marriage A-la-Mode” by John Dryden
LineAnnotation
“Why should a foolish marriage vow,”The speaker questions the validity and purpose of the marriage vow, calling it “foolish” and implying that it may lack enduring significance.
“Which long ago was made,”The vow was made in the past, suggesting it may no longer hold relevance in the present. This reflects a sense of temporal distance and change over time.
“Oblige us to each other now”The speaker challenges whether they should still be bound by this vow despite changing circumstances, particularly the loss of love or passion.
“When passion is decay’d?”The idea of “decay’d passion” suggests that love or desire has faded, hinting at the transient nature of romantic or passionate love in relationships.
“We lov’d, and we lov’d, as long as we could,”A reflective acknowledgment that the couple did experience love sincerely, but only “as long as we could,” indicating a natural end to this emotional connection.
“Till our love was lov’d out in us both:”This line suggests that their love has been exhausted or depleted; they have given all they could, and now it is gone. The phrase “lov’d out” conveys a sense of emotional fatigue or fulfillment of love’s potential.
“But our marriage is dead, when the pleasure is fled:”Here, the speaker states that the essence or vitality of their marriage depended on pleasure, and with its absence, the marriage has lost its meaning or “died.”
“‘Twas pleasure first made it an oath.”The speaker attributes the marriage vow or “oath” to pleasure, suggesting that the commitment was based on physical or sensual enjoyment rather than deeper emotional or spiritual bonds.
“If I have pleasures for a friend,”This line implies that the speaker finds pleasure outside of marriage, perhaps through companionship or friendship, indicating an alternative source of fulfillment.
“And farther love in store,”The speaker hints at potential romantic interests or passions beyond the marriage, indicating a willingness or readiness to explore love anew.
“What wrong has he whose joys did end,”The speaker questions whether there is any wrongdoing in seeking pleasure elsewhere, especially if the other party (the spouse) no longer finds joy in the relationship.
“And who could give no more?”This line suggests that the spouse is also unable to offer further emotional or passionate engagement, framing the search for external pleasures as reasonable.
“‘Tis a madness that he should be jealous of me,”The speaker asserts that jealousy from the spouse would be irrational or “mad,” as the mutual love between them has dissipated.
“Or that I should bar him of another:”The speaker also believes it would be wrong to prevent the spouse from pursuing other relationships, suggesting a mutual freedom in seeking new connections.
“For all we can gain is to give ourselves pain,”The speaker recognizes that clinging to a dead marriage would only result in pain and suffering for both parties, implying that letting go would be more beneficial.
“When neither can hinder the other.”This concluding line emphasizes a sense of individual freedom; neither partner has the right or ability to restrain the other, highlighting a perspective of mutual independence in the face of emotional change.
Literary And Poetic Devices: “Marriage A-la-Mode” by John Dryden
DeviceExampleExplanation
Allusion“marriage vow”Refers to the traditional marriage vows, invoking societal expectations and the sanctity associated with marriage.
Antithesis“We lov’d, and we lov’d, as long as we could”Contrasts the love they had with its eventual depletion, highlighting the finite nature of their emotions.
Apostrophe“Why should a foolish marriage vow”The speaker directly addresses the concept of the “marriage vow” as if questioning it, personifying the vow as something that can respond.
Assonance“pleasures for a friend”Repetition of the “e” sound adds a melodic quality to the line, emphasizing the speaker’s alternative pursuits of pleasure.
Caesura“But our marriage is dead, when the pleasure is fled:”The comma creates a natural pause, reinforcing the finality and reflective tone of the statement.
Conceit“Till our love was lov’d out in us both”This line uses a conceit, or an extended metaphor, to describe love as something that can be exhausted or “used up.”
Connotation“decay’d”The word “decay’d” has connotations of death and deterioration, emphasizing the end of passion and love in the relationship.
End-stopping“Which long ago was made,”The punctuation at the end of this line reinforces the finality and distance of the vow made in the past.
Epiphora“as long as we could” / “in us both”The repetition of the endings emphasizes the mutual and temporal limits of their love.
Hyperbole“all we can gain is to give ourselves pain”Exaggeration is used here to emphasize that trying to maintain the marriage only causes suffering.
Irony“foolish marriage vow”Referring to a sacred vow as “foolish” introduces irony, challenging traditional views of marriage.
Juxtaposition“pleasure” and “oath”Juxtaposing “pleasure” with “oath” underscores the conflict between temporary desires and permanent commitments.
Metaphor“our marriage is dead”Compares the marriage to something that is alive and has now “died,” symbolizing the end of emotional connection.
Metonymy“pleasures for a friend”“Pleasures” represents romantic or sensual fulfillment, indirectly referring to extramarital interests.
Paradox“lov’d out in us both”This line contains a paradox, as love is often seen as boundless, but here it is portrayed as exhaustible.
Personification“our marriage is dead”Marriage is personified as something that can “die,” attributing human qualities to an abstract concept.
Repetition“We lov’d, and we lov’d”Repeating “we lov’d” emphasizes the sincerity and depth of feeling, while also hinting at its inevitable decline.
Rhetorical Question“Why should a foolish marriage vow, / Which long ago was made, / Oblige us to each other now”The speaker uses a rhetorical question to question the lasting obligation of marriage vows, encouraging readers to consider the purpose of marital bonds.
Simile“Till our love was lov’d out in us both” (implied comparison)Though not a direct simile, it suggests love as something that can be used up like a resource, comparing it to a finite substance.
Themes: “Marriage A-la-Mode” by John Dryden
  1. The Transience of Love and Passion: In “Marriage A-la-Mode,” Dryden explores the impermanence of romantic love, suggesting that passion is fleeting and ultimately fades. The speaker reflects, “We lov’d, and we lov’d, as long as we could, / Till our love was lov’d out in us both,” indicating that their initial attraction and affection were genuine but could not be sustained indefinitely. This theme reflects a more skeptical and realistic view of love, positing that emotional connections, no matter how strong initially, often wane over time. The decay of passion is further emphasized with the line, “When passion is decay’d,” suggesting that love, much like other aspects of life, is subject to the effects of time and can deteriorate, leaving the marriage hollow once the pleasure is gone.
  2. Critique of Marriage as a Social Institution: Dryden’s poem criticizes the institution of marriage as being based on outdated and often unrealistic expectations. The speaker questions the binding nature of the marriage vow, calling it a “foolish marriage vow, / Which long ago was made.” This language challenges traditional views on marriage, suggesting that a vow made under the influence of passion should not necessarily enforce lifelong commitment. The poem conveys a sense of disillusionment with the concept of marriage, as the speaker implies that the societal obligation to remain married becomes burdensome when love has faded. By juxtaposing pleasure with obligation, Dryden critiques marriage as a socially imposed contract that may not suit the changing nature of human emotions.
  3. The Pursuit of Personal Freedom: The speaker in “Marriage A-la-Mode” advocates for individual freedom within relationships, especially when love has waned. The line “If I have pleasures for a friend, / And farther love in store” indicates the speaker’s desire to seek new sources of happiness outside the confines of marriage. The speaker questions, “What wrong has he whose joys did end, / And who could give no more?” suggesting that both partners have the right to pursue personal satisfaction without being bound by past promises. This pursuit of freedom highlights Dryden’s progressive stance on relationships, implying that people should be free to explore love and joy beyond a single partnership, especially if the relationship no longer fulfills them.
  4. Jealousy and Possessiveness in Relationships: Dryden also examines the irrationality of jealousy and possessiveness within marriage, particularly when love has diminished. The speaker calls it “a madness that he should be jealous of me,” arguing that jealousy is unreasonable when both partners have lost affection for one another. This theme highlights the idea that possessiveness is unnecessary and even harmful when the emotional foundation of a relationship has eroded. Instead, Dryden’s speaker advocates for a mutual understanding of freedom: “Or that I should bar him of another,” suggesting that restricting one another’s pursuits in love only leads to unnecessary pain. This perspective challenges traditional ideas of loyalty and fidelity, proposing a more open and understanding approach to relationships.
Literary Theories and “Marriage A-la-Mode” by John Dryden
Literary TheoryExplanation in Context of “Marriage A-la-Mode”References from the Poem
Feminist TheoryFeminist theory examines gender roles and the societal expectations placed on women, especially within marriage. In “Marriage A-la-Mode”, Dryden critiques marriage as an institution that can impose restrictive roles on both men and women, limiting individual freedom and agency. The speaker’s desire for autonomy and lack of jealousy suggest a challenge to traditional marital expectations and the concept of exclusive possession in marriage, especially regarding women’s roles and their right to personal freedom.“‘Tis a madness that he should be jealous of me, / Or that I should bar him of another,” highlights a rejection of traditional possessiveness in marriage, proposing mutual independence instead.
Psychoanalytic TheoryPsychoanalytic theory explores subconscious desires, motivations, and the conflict between social duty and personal desire. The speaker’s struggle in “Marriage A-la-Mode” to reconcile his feelings of decayed passion with the marriage vow illustrates a deep inner conflict. His desire for external pleasures reveals a subconscious resistance to societal expectations of fidelity, as well as a search for satisfaction that the marriage can no longer provide. This theory can explain the speaker’s disillusionment with conventional marital expectations and his drive toward self-fulfillment.“Why should a foolish marriage vow, / Which long ago was made, / Oblige us to each other now / When passion is decay’d?” reflects the speaker’s internal conflict between the vow and his own fading desires.
Marxist TheoryMarxist theory focuses on societal structures, class relations, and the critique of ideology, particularly the ways institutions can maintain social order. In “Marriage A-la-Mode,” marriage is viewed as a social contract rather than a relationship based on enduring love, suggesting it serves as a tool to enforce conformity and control. The speaker’s dismissal of the vow as “foolish” indicates a rejection of the institution as outdated and incompatible with individual needs, challenging the idea that marriage should serve as an instrument of social stability.“But our marriage is dead, when the pleasure is fled: / ‘Twas pleasure first made it an oath” critiques marriage as a social institution bound by pleasure rather than meaningful bonds, questioning its long-term societal value.
Critical Questions about “Marriage A-la-Mode” by John Dryden
  • What is Dryden’s critique of the institution of marriage, and how does he present this critique through the speaker’s perspective?
  • In “Marriage A-la-Mode,”Dryden questions the societal expectations surrounding marriage, particularly the idea of an unbreakable marital bond. The speaker expresses disillusionment with the marriage vow, describing it as a “foolish marriage vow, / Which long ago was made.” This line suggests a disconnect between the vow’s initial meaning and its present significance, raising questions about the relevance of lifelong promises in a relationship where passion has decayed. By portraying marriage as an outdated commitment that persists despite the loss of love, Dryden critiques the rigid social institution that may trap individuals in unfulfilling relationships, ultimately questioning the value of marriage as an enduring contract.
  • How does the speaker’s perspective on jealousy challenge traditional notions of fidelity and loyalty in marriage?
  • The speaker’s dismissal of jealousy as “a madness” that would “bar him of another” reflects a radical view on fidelity, advocating for mutual freedom within marriage rather than possessive loyalty. This perspective challenges traditional marital expectations, where loyalty and exclusivity are foundational to the commitment. Dryden presents jealousy as an unnecessary source of “pain” when love has faded, suggesting that personal satisfaction should take precedence over societal standards of fidelity. By questioning the importance of exclusivity, Dryden invites readers to consider whether marriage should be redefined in a way that acknowledges individual desires and autonomy, especially in relationships where mutual affection no longer exists.
  • What role does personal freedom play in the speaker’s understanding of love and commitment?
  • Personal freedom is central to the speaker’s view on relationships, as he believes that both partners should have the autonomy to seek pleasure beyond marriage. This idea is highlighted in the line, “If I have pleasures for a friend, / And farther love in store,” indicating that the speaker sees love and companionship as dynamic, evolving needs that may not be fully satisfied within the bounds of a single relationship. The speaker’s emphasis on personal fulfillment over traditional commitment suggests a redefinition of love, one that values individual happiness over rigid marital expectations. Dryden uses this perspective to question the relevance of lifelong marriage in a society where desires and needs are ever-changing.
  • How does Dryden use the decay of passion to explore the theme of emotional exhaustion in relationships?
  • In “Marriage A-la-Mode,” Dryden explores the concept of love as something that can be “lov’d out in us both,” suggesting that emotional and physical desire can be exhausted over time. The speaker’s acknowledgment that “passion is decay’d” raises the question of whether it is realistic to expect love to remain constant in a marriage. This focus on the decay of passion emphasizes the idea that romantic relationships may have a natural lifespan, with love potentially “dying” as desire fades. Through this, Dryden examines the weariness that can result from forcing a relationship to endure past its natural end, critiquing societal expectations that compel individuals to maintain marital bonds despite emotional exhaustion and loss of connection.
Literary Works Similar to “Marriage A-la-Mode” by John Dryden
  • “The Scrutiny” by Richard Lovelace: Similar in its exploration of fleeting love and the desire for freedom outside of monogamy, this poem questions the notion of exclusive commitment, much like Dryden’s critique of marriage.
  • To His Coy Mistress” by Andrew Marvell: This poem shares Dryden’s theme of passion’s impermanence, urging a lover to seize the moment and suggesting that love and desire are temporal and bound to fade.
  • “Song: Go, Lovely Rose” by Edmund Waller: Waller’s poem also reflects on the transience of beauty and passion, echoing Dryden’s view on the decay of romantic attraction over time.
  • “A Song (Ask Me No More)” by Thomas Carew: Carew’s poem conveys the disillusionment that often follows initial passion, much like Dryden’s portrayal of love’s eventual exhaustion in marriage.
  • “The Broken Heart” by John Donne: Donne’s poem examines the pain and finality of love’s end, similar to Dryden’s reflection on how passion can fade and leave an emotional void within relationships.
Representative Quotations of “Marriage A-la-Mode” by John Dryden
QuotationContextTheoretical Perspective
“Why should a foolish marriage vow, / Which long ago was made,”The speaker questions the relevance of a vow made in the past, highlighting a sense of disillusionment.Marxist Theory – Critiques marriage as a social institution that binds individuals to outdated promises.
“Oblige us to each other now / When passion is decay’d?”The speaker argues that marriage obligations should not continue once love and desire have faded.Psychoanalytic Theory – Examines the inner conflict between social duty and personal desire.
“We lov’d, and we lov’d, as long as we could”Acknowledges that the initial love was genuine but ultimately had limits, emphasizing the transience of passion.New Historicism – Reflects Restoration society’s changing attitudes toward marriage and love as fluid concepts.
“Till our love was lov’d out in us both:”Suggests that love has been exhausted or used up, presenting love as finite.Existentialism – Views love as an experience that, like any emotion, has a limited lifespan.
“But our marriage is dead, when the pleasure is fled:”The speaker equates the end of pleasure with the “death” of marriage, redefining its essence.Feminist Theory – Critiques the conventional view of marriage by proposing that fulfillment is essential to its validity.
“‘Twas pleasure first made it an oath.”Suggests that the marriage vow was made under the influence of pleasure rather than deeper commitment.Marxist Theory – Implies that social contracts like marriage are based on temporary emotions, questioning their long-term societal role.
“If I have pleasures for a friend, / And farther love in store”The speaker hints at seeking love and companionship beyond marriage, advocating for individual freedom.Liberal Humanism – Emphasizes the importance of personal fulfillment over traditional societal expectations.
“What wrong has he whose joys did end, / And who could give no more?”Questions whether it is wrong to seek happiness elsewhere once the joy in marriage has faded.Ethical Relativism – Suggests that moral judgments about fidelity are subjective and dependent on individual circumstances.
“‘Tis a madness that he should be jealous of me”The speaker dismisses jealousy as irrational once love has decayed, promoting mutual independence.Feminist Theory – Challenges possessiveness in relationships and traditional notions of marital fidelity.
“For all we can gain is to give ourselves pain, / When neither can hinder the other.”The speaker highlights that staying in a loveless marriage only causes pain, advocating for autonomy.Existentialism – Emphasizes freedom and personal responsibility over societal expectations in relationships.
Suggested Readings: “Marriage A-la-Mode” by John Dryden
  1. Kalitzki, Judith. “Versions of Truth: Marriage à La Mode.” Restoration: Studies in English Literary Culture, 1660-1700, vol. 4, no. 2, 1980, pp. 65–70. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/43292320. Accessed 10 Nov. 2024.
  2. McKeon, Michael. “MARXIST CRITICISM AND ‘MARRIAGE A LA MODE.'” The Eighteenth Century, vol. 24, no. 2, 1983, pp. 141–62. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/41467289. Accessed 10 Nov. 2024.
  3. Milhous, Judith. Theatre Journal, vol. 35, no. 3, 1983, pp. 416–18. JSTOR, https://doi.org/10.2307/3207225. Accessed 10 Nov. 2024.
  4. Denman, Jason. “‘Too Hasty to Stay’: Erotic and Political Timing in ‘Marriage à La Mode.'” Restoration: Studies in English Literary Culture, 1660-1700, vol. 32, no. 2, 2008, pp. 1–23. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/43293813. Accessed 10 Nov. 2024.

“Housewife” by Anne Sexton: A Critical Analysis

“Housewife” by Anne Sexton, first appeared in 1962 in her poetry collection All My Pretty Ones, captures Sexton’s unique perspective on the role of women, especially as homemakers, during the mid-20th century.

"Housewife" by Anne Sexton: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “Housewife” by Anne Sexton

“Housewife” by Anne Sexton, first appeared in 1962 in her poetry collection All My Pretty Ones, captures Sexton’s unique perspective on the role of women, especially as homemakers, during the mid-20th century, offering a critique of societal expectations placed on women. With striking imagery, she presents the house as both a haven and a trap, suggesting that the house “eats” the woman, symbolizing how traditional roles can consume personal identity. This piece became popular for its bold portrayal of feminist ideas and its candid exploration of the inner lives of women, resonating with readers during the feminist movements of the 1960s and 70s. Sexton’s fearless engagement with topics like gender roles, domesticity, and mental health has made Housewife a lasting work that continues to evoke critical conversations on women’s autonomy and societal constraints.

Text: “Housewife” by Anne Sexton

Some women marry houses.
It’s another kind of skin; it has a heart,
a mouth, a liver and bowel movements.
The walls are permanent and pink.
See how she sits on her knees all day,
faithfully washing herself down.
Men enter by force, drawn back like Jonah
into their fleshy mothers.
A woman is her mother.
That’s the main thing.

Annotations: “Housewife” by Anne Sexton
LineAnnotation
“Some women marry houses.”The opening line introduces a metaphor where the woman marries her home, indicating a profound attachment or an imposed identity intertwined with domesticity. “Marrying houses” symbolizes how some women are confined within domestic roles, treating the house as if it were a life partner.
“It’s another kind of skin;”This line suggests that the house becomes an extension of the woman herself, like a second skin. It implies how deeply personal and consuming this relationship with the domestic space is, as though the woman’s own identity is enmeshed in her surroundings.
“it has a heart, a mouth, a liver and bowel movements.”By describing the house with organs, Sexton personifies it, illustrating it as a living, breathing entity. This creates an image of the house as a body, reflecting the woman’s life and implying that the house “consumes” her energy, life, and labor.
“The walls are permanent and pink.”Here, the walls symbolize stability but also restriction. “Permanent” suggests an inescapable quality, while “pink” hints at traditional femininity or stereotypical feminine aesthetics, highlighting gendered expectations of women’s spaces.
“See how she sits on her knees all day,”This line portrays the woman in a position of servitude and ritualistic care, almost as if she’s worshipping or submitting to the house. The image of kneeling is evocative of submission, sacrifice, or duty, emphasizing her dedication to the home.
“faithfully washing herself down.”Washing “herself” down can symbolize the blurring of identity between the woman and the house. By cleaning the house, she metaphorically cleans herself, emphasizing that her self-worth is bound to the maintenance of the domestic space.
“Men enter by force, drawn back like Jonah”This line introduces men into the poem, describing them as entering the home forcefully, possibly alluding to a sense of dominance or control. The comparison to Jonah suggests they are “swallowed” or return to a motherly space, with the house as a stand-in for the maternal body.
“into their fleshy mothers.”This imagery likens the house to a motherly figure, echoing the maternal role many women are expected to fulfill in the household. It also indicates that the home represents safety and nurturing, although this may be confining for women.
“A woman is her mother.”This line reinforces the cycle of generational roles and expectations, suggesting that a woman’s identity is inherited or defined by her role as a mother and caretaker. It emphasizes how societal norms expect women to mirror their mothers’ lives.
“That’s the main thing.”The concluding line drives home the poem’s critical message: that women’s identities are often reduced to their maternal and domestic roles. It implies resignation, as if these roles are ultimately inescapable, reflecting the internalized expectations of gender norms.
Literary And Poetic Devices: “Housewife” by Anne Sexton
DeviceExampleExplanation
Allusion“Jonah”Refers to the Biblical story of Jonah, who was swallowed by a whale. Here, it suggests men are “swallowed” by the home, paralleling their return to a motherly space.
Analogy“Some women marry houses.”Compares women’s relationship to their homes to marriage, emphasizing the deep, consuming bond and the confinement in traditional domestic roles.
Assonance“walls are permanent and pink”The repetition of the “a” sound in “walls” and “are” creates a soft, melodic quality, which contrasts with the permanence and constraint implied by the words.
Caesura“That’s the main thing.”A pause at the end of this line serves as a final, conclusive thought, creating an abrupt stop to emphasize the inevitability of women becoming like their mothers.
Consonance“Marry houses”The repetition of the “s” sound in “marry” and “houses” softens the phrase, ironically making the confinement sound gentle, though it represents restriction.
Enjambment“See how she sits on her knees all day,”This line flows into the next without punctuation, emphasizing the continuous, unending labor and dedication the woman has toward the house.
Extended MetaphorThe house as a living bodySexton extends the house metaphor by giving it human organs, portraying it as a living entity that absorbs the woman’s energy, thus consuming her identity.
Hyperbole“sits on her knees all day”Exaggerates the time spent by the woman cleaning, implying a relentless, almost sacrificial dedication to domestic labor.
Imagery“walls are permanent and pink”Evokes a visual image of confinement with the “permanent walls” and stereotypical femininity with “pink,” reinforcing traditional roles imposed on women.
Irony“faithfully washing herself down”The irony lies in the fact that she’s not actually washing herself but the house, yet she sees it as an extension of herself, showcasing her blurred identity.
Metaphor“marry houses”The phrase compares the woman’s role in the home to marriage, highlighting the deep, binding nature of her relationship with domestic life.
Metonymy“walls”The walls represent the entire house, and metaphorically, the constraints of domestic life that surround the woman.
Paradox“A woman is her mother.”This line suggests that despite being an individual, a woman’s identity is inextricably tied to her role, echoing her mother’s life, creating a cycle of identity loss.
Personification“it has a heart, a mouth, a liver and bowel movements”Giving the house bodily organs personifies it, suggesting it’s a living entity that consumes the woman’s labor and life force.
Repetition“a heart, a mouth, a liver”The list of organs emphasizes the house as a body, stressing the completeness of the woman’s absorption into her role as homemaker.
Simile“like Jonah”Compares men entering the home to Jonah being swallowed by a whale, emphasizing their return to a nurturing but engulfing maternal space.
Symbolism“pink”The color pink symbolizes traditional femininity and reinforces stereotypical gender roles, suggesting that the woman’s space is decorated with societal expectations.
Synecdoche“walls”The walls represent the entire home, illustrating how the woman’s identity and her physical space are inseparably linked.
ThemeDomestic confinement, identity lossThe theme highlights the limited, consuming nature of domestic life for women, who often lose their identity to their roles as caretakers and homemakers.
ToneResigned, criticalThe poem’s tone is reflective yet critical, as it underscores the inevitability and restrictiveness of traditional domestic roles for women.
Themes: “Housewife” by Anne Sexton
  1. Domestic Confinement and Identity Loss: The theme of domestic confinement is vividly portrayed through the metaphor of women “marrying houses.” This line suggests that women’s identities are inextricably bound to the domestic sphere, so much so that their sense of self merges with the home itself. Sexton emphasizes this loss of individuality by describing the house as having “a heart, a mouth, a liver and bowel movements,” signifying that the house is a living entity that consumes the woman’s labor and identity. The metaphor of the house becoming an “extension of skin” underscores how the domestic space engulfs her, blending the boundaries between the woman’s identity and her role as a homemaker.
  2. Generational Expectations and Maternal Legacy: Sexton touches upon the theme of inherited roles and societal expectations for women, particularly in the line, “A woman is her mother. That’s the main thing.” This line speaks to the cycle of generational expectations, suggesting that women are often expected to replicate the lives of their mothers, bound to the same domestic roles and responsibilities. By stating “the main thing,” Sexton implies an almost inescapable fate for women to assume their mothers’ identities, highlighting the societal pressure for women to conform to traditional roles within the household.
  3. Gendered Spaces and Traditional Femininity: The description of the “walls [that] are permanent and pink” symbolizes how domestic spaces are traditionally gendered, marked by societal expectations of femininity. The color “pink” alludes to stereotypical representations of femininity, suggesting that the woman’s space is defined and even constrained by traditional gender roles. The permanence of the walls hints at the rigidity of these roles, emphasizing how deeply entrenched and inescapable they are for many women. The line reinforces how society shapes the environment of the domestic space to embody femininity, contributing to the overall sense of confinement in the woman’s life.
  4. Power Dynamics and Male Authority: In Housewife, Sexton explores the theme of male dominance within the domestic sphere, especially in the line, “Men enter by force, drawn back like Jonah into their fleshy mothers.” This imagery depicts men as forcefully entering the home, which symbolizes a sense of male authority and control over the domestic space. The reference to “Jonah” suggests that men view the home as a nurturing, motherly space they return to for comfort, yet their entrance is marked by force, implying an imbalance of power and control. This line reflects how men may take for granted the nurturing role of women, highlighting the one-sided expectations of domestic roles and the imbalance in household dynamics.
Literary Theories and “Housewife” by Anne Sexton
Literary TheoryApplication to Housewife by Anne SextonReferences from the Poem
Feminist TheoryHousewife can be analyzed through a feminist lens to highlight the societal expectations placed on women, especially regarding their roles in the domestic sphere. Feminist critics would argue that the poem critiques the ways women are confined to homemaking and lose their identities within these roles. This perspective underscores Sexton’s portrayal of the home as a place of confinement rather than fulfillment.The line “Some women marry houses” emphasizes how women are expected to devote themselves entirely to the home, likening this commitment to a marriage. Additionally, “A woman is her mother” reflects the cyclical and generational constraints placed on women, where they inherit and replicate their mothers’ roles, showcasing a lack of autonomy.
Psychoanalytic TheoryThrough a psychoanalytic lens, Housewife can be viewed as a reflection of the woman’s internal conflict and unconscious struggle with her role. The house symbolizes the “id” or suppressed desires, consuming the woman’s sense of self. This analysis might suggest that the woman’s obsessive care for the house reflects her repressed identity and feelings of self-neglect, which are channeled into her domestic tasks.The description of the house as having “a heart, a mouth, a liver and bowel movements” suggests that the house is a living entity, almost like a surrogate body for the woman, signifying her projection of self onto her surroundings. Her “faithful” cleaning could indicate an attempt to satisfy an unconscious need for control or purpose, reinforcing the internalization of her assigned role.
Marxist TheoryFrom a Marxist perspective, Housewife can be interpreted as a critique of how domestic labor is undervalued in a capitalist society. The poem highlights how women’s unpaid labor in the home supports patriarchal structures, as the woman’s role in maintaining the household facilitates the male’s return to a nurturing space without reciprocation. Marxist critics might view the woman’s confinement to the home as a form of exploitation that benefits the larger social and economic system.The line “Men enter by force” implies a sense of entitlement men have within the domestic sphere, highlighting the imbalance of power. Additionally, “walls are permanent and pink” suggests the rigid, gendered roles imposed by society, indicating that the woman’s labor and identity are confined to this socially constructed space, which serves the needs of others.
Critical Questions about “Housewife” by Anne Sexton
  • How does Sexton portray the relationship between women and domestic spaces in “Housewife?
  • Sexton portrays the relationship between women and domestic spaces as one of entrapment and identity erosion. By describing how “Some women marry houses,” she suggests that women’s identities become subsumed by their domestic roles, as if their lives are dedicated to serving their homes. The house becomes “another kind of skin,” symbolizing the extent to which a woman’s personal identity is merged with her domestic space, almost as if the house becomes an extension of her own body. This metaphor emphasizes that the home is not just a place but a confining identity, showing the often inescapable nature of traditional domestic roles for women. Through this portrayal, Sexton raises questions about how societal expectations can limit and define women’s lives within the home.
  • In what ways does the poem critique generational cycles of domestic roles for women?
  • “Housewife” critiques the generational cycle of domestic roles by suggesting that women are destined to follow in their mothers’ footsteps, bound by tradition and societal norms. The line “A woman is her mother” underscores this theme, as it implies that women are expected to inherit their mothers’ roles without question. Sexton’s use of the phrase “That’s the main thing” gives a sense of inevitability, as if this inheritance is unavoidable and central to a woman’s identity. By depicting this cycle, Sexton challenges the reader to question the fairness of these roles and consider the limited choices that have historically defined women’s lives, thereby critiquing the lack of autonomy women often have in escaping these generational expectations.
  • How does Sexton address themes of power and control within the household in the poem?
  • Sexton addresses themes of power and control by exploring the dynamic between men and women in the domestic space, particularly highlighting the unequal authority that men hold over the household. The line “Men enter by force, drawn back like Jonah into their fleshy mothers” reveals a power imbalance; while men come and go freely, women remain tethered to the home. The imagery of “force” suggests an imposition of male authority, while comparing men to Jonah swallowed by a whale hints at their entitlement to the nurturing space without equal responsibility. Sexton’s choice of words illustrates the societal expectation that women maintain and sustain the home, while men are merely visitors. This critique of domestic power dynamics reveals how women’s roles in the household often limit their agency and control.
  • What is the significance of the poem’s tone, and how does it affect the reader’s interpretation of the domestic role?
  • The tone of “Housewife”is reflective yet critical, tinged with irony as it underscores the confining nature of traditional domestic roles. Phrases like “faithfully washing herself down” illustrate the woman’s near-religious dedication to her home, yet there’s a sense of irony in that she is not literally “washing herself” but the house. This ironic tone highlights the absurdity of women devoting themselves so entirely to a role that offers little personal fulfillment or recognition. The tone is further intensified by the closing line, “That’s the main thing,” which reads as resigned and final, as though there is no escape from these expectations. This tone shapes the reader’s interpretation, encouraging a critical view of the domestic role as an identity that consumes rather than liberates, challenging the reader to consider the hidden costs of traditional gender roles.
Literary Works Similar to “Housewife” by Anne Sexton
  1. “The Applicant” by Sylvia Plath
    Similar to Housewife, this poem critiques the traditional roles and expectations placed on women, particularly within marriage and domesticity, highlighting how women are often reduced to their utility.
  2. “Aunt Jennifer’s Tigers” by Adrienne Rich
    This poem explores the theme of female confinement within marriage, where Aunt Jennifer’s domestic life restricts her freedom, much like the woman in Housewife is confined by her role within the home.
  3. “What’s That Smell in the Kitchen?” by Marge Piercy
    Piercy’s poem reflects a woman’s frustration with domestic expectations and the burdens of household responsibilities, resonating with Sexton’s exploration of a woman’s identity consumed by domestic roles.
  4. “Her Kind” by Anne Sexton
    In this poem, Sexton also examines themes of female identity and societal expectations, particularly the roles that society imposes on women, paralleling the sense of entrapment seen in Housewife.
  5. “To the Ladies” by Mary, Lady Chudleigh
    This 18th-century poem critiques marriage as an institution that restricts women, echoing Sexton’s portrayal of domestic life as a consuming force that can diminish a woman’s sense of self.
Representative Quotations of “Housewife” by Anne Sexton
QuotationContextTheoretical Perspective
“Some women marry houses.”Opens the poem with a metaphor comparing women’s commitment to the home as akin to marriage.Feminist Theory: Highlights the expectation for women to become bound to domestic roles.
“It’s another kind of skin;”Suggests that the house becomes an extension of the woman’s identity, enveloping her personal self.Psychoanalytic Theory: Indicates the merging of identity with environment, a form of self-erasure.
“it has a heart, a mouth, a liver and bowel movements.”Personifies the house, suggesting it consumes life as a living being does.Marxist Theory: Reflects how unpaid domestic labor sustains others but drains the woman’s identity.
“The walls are permanent and pink.”Emphasizes the rigidity of domestic life and the gendered expectations symbolized by the color pink.Gender Theory: Explores how spaces are gendered and how femininity is prescribed in domestic roles.
“See how she sits on her knees all day,”Implies that the woman is in a constant state of servitude and submission within the home.Feminist Theory: Portrays the submissive role women are expected to take on within the household.
“faithfully washing herself down.”Ironically describes the woman as cleansing herself, though it’s actually the house she cleans.Irony: Highlights the self-sacrifice involved in maintaining the home, losing personal identity.
“Men enter by force”Describes men as coming into the home authoritatively, suggesting a dominance over the domestic sphere.Power Dynamics Theory: Examines the imbalance of authority between men and women in the household.
“drawn back like Jonah into their fleshy mothers.”Compares men to Jonah, suggesting the house is like a maternal space.Psychoanalytic Theory: Explores maternal archetypes and the house as a space of nurturing yet entrapment.
“A woman is her mother.”Asserts that a woman’s identity is shaped by her mother’s role, often continuing generational patterns.Social Expectation Theory: Highlights the cycle of traditional roles passed from mother to daughter.
“That’s the main thing.”A resigned ending, emphasizing the inevitability of these roles for women.Structuralism: Indicates the role of societal structures in defining and limiting women’s identities.
Suggested Readings: “Housewife” by Anne Sexton
  1. Middlebrook, Diane Wood. “Housewife into Poet: The Apprenticeship of Anne Sexton.” The New England Quarterly, vol. 56, no. 4, 1983, pp. 483–503. JSTOR, https://doi.org/10.2307/365101. Accessed 13 Nov. 2024.
  2. HOFFMAN, NANCY YANES, and JEFFREY L. LANT. “Two Perspectives on Anne Sexton.” Southwest Review, vol. 64, no. 3, 1979, pp. 209–19. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/43468286. Accessed 13 Nov. 2024.
  3. Salvio, Paula M. “LOSS, MEMORY, AND THE WORK OF LEARNING: Lessons from the Teaching Life of Anne Sexton.” Personal Effects, edited by DEBORAH H. HOLDSTEIN and DAVID BLEICH, University Press of Colorado, 2001, pp. 93–118. JSTOR, https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctt46nx6f.7. Accessed 13 Nov. 2024.
  4. Mizejewski, Linda. “Sappho to Sexton: Woman Uncontained.” College English, vol. 35, no. 3, 1973, pp. 340–45. JSTOR, https://doi.org/10.2307/374996. Accessed 13 Nov. 2024.

“A Song (Ask Me No More)” by Thomas Carew: A Critical Analysis

“A Song (Ask Me No More)” by Thomas Carew first appeared in 1640 as part of Poems, Songs, and Sonnets, a collection that was published posthumously.

"A Song (Ask Me No More)" by Thomas Carew: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “A Song (Ask Me No More)” by Thomas Carew

“A Song (Ask Me No More)” by Thomas Carew first appeared in 1640 as part of Poems, Songs, and Sonnets, a collection that was published posthumously. This lyric poem captures the essence of early 17th-century Cavalier poetry, known for its graceful exploration of love, beauty, and fleeting pleasures. The main ideas revolve around a plea to end questioning about love’s mysteries and transience, invoking the beauty of the natural world to symbolize the ephemeral nature of passion. The poem is celebrated for its delicate and refined language, reflecting Carew’s admiration for love’s idealized form while acknowledging its inevitable end. The work’s popularity stems from its elegant expression and the universal theme of impermanence in relationships, resonating with readers who appreciate both the beauty and sorrow of love’s fleeting nature. Carew’s lyrical style and skillful use of metaphor further cement the poem’s enduring appeal.

Text: “A Song (Ask Me No More)” by Thomas Carew

Ask me no more where Jove bestows,

When June is past, the fading rose;

For in your beauty’s orient deep

These flowers, as in their causes, sleep.

Ask me no more whither do stray

The golden atoms of the day;

For in pure love heaven did prepare

Those powders to enrich your hair.

Ask me no more whither doth haste

The nightingale, when May is past;

For in your sweet dividing throat

She winters, and keeps warm her note.

Ask me no more where those stars ‘light,

That downwards fall in dead of night;

For in your eyes they sit, and there

Fixed become, as in their sphere.

Ask me no more if east or west

The phoenix builds her spicy nest;

For unto you at last she flies,

And in your fragrant bosom dies.

Annotations: “A Song (Ask Me No More)” by Thomas Carew
LineAnnotation
Ask me no more where Jove bestows,Jove, or Jupiter, is the king of the gods in Roman mythology; Carew invokes his authority, suggesting mystery.
When June is past, the fading rose;June symbolizes peak beauty; the rose represents transient beauty and the inevitability of decline.
For in your beauty’s orient deep“Orient” refers to the east, symbolizing something precious; the speaker equates the beloved’s beauty with this.
These flowers, as in their causes, sleep.The rose’s beauty is metaphorically preserved in the beloved, suggesting an eternal quality within them.
Ask me no more whither do strayThe poet asks the beloved not to question where things go, emphasizing the unknowable.
The golden atoms of the day;“Golden atoms” symbolize sunlight or time, hinting at the divine nature of beauty and the passage of time.
For in pure love heaven did prepareHeaven and love are united here, suggesting that the beloved’s beauty was divinely crafted.
Those powders to enrich your hair.Sunlight (golden atoms) is poetically re-imagined as the glow or shine in the beloved’s hair.
Ask me no more whither doth hasteThis line refers to the questioning of where natural phenomena go, hinting at fleeting beauty and mystery.
The nightingale, when May is past;The nightingale is associated with spring and love; its absence symbolizes the end of a season of beauty.
For in your sweet dividing throatThe throat of the beloved is compared to the nightingale’s refuge, carrying her melody and warmth.
She winters, and keeps warm her note.The nightingale finds a home in the beloved’s voice, suggesting her voice’s warmth and soothing quality.
Ask me no more where those stars ‘light,The poet again redirects questioning, this time about falling stars, a mystery of the natural world.
That downwards fall in dead of night;Falling stars are symbols of fleeting beauty and wishes; here they represent brief, beautiful phenomena.
For in your eyes they sit, and thereThe beloved’s eyes are metaphorically the destination of falling stars, adding to their celestial quality.
Fixed become, as in their sphere.Stars are “fixed” in the beloved’s eyes, suggesting permanence and an idealized vision of beauty.
Ask me no more if east or westThe poet refers to the phoenix’s elusive resting place, as in myth, it is never certain where it settles.
The phoenix builds her spicy nest;The phoenix’s “spicy nest” symbolizes rebirth and regeneration, associated with aromatic woods like myrrh.
For unto you at last she flies,The beloved becomes the final destination of the phoenix, representing unique and eternal beauty.
And in your fragrant bosom dies.The beloved’s heart is where the phoenix dies and is reborn, embodying immortality through love and beauty.
Literary And Poetic Devices: “A Song (Ask Me No More)” by Thomas Carew
DeviceExampleExplanation
Alliteration“fading flower”Repetition of the initial “f” sound enhances the musicality and flow of the line.
Allusion“Jove” and “phoenix”References to mythology (Jove as a god, phoenix as a symbol of rebirth) add depth and resonance.
Apostrophe“Ask me no more”The speaker directly addresses an absent person (the beloved), creating an intimate tone.
Assonance“orient deep”Repetition of the “e” sound adds to the lyrical quality of the poem.
Caesura“Ask me no more where Jove bestows,”The comma creates a pause, adding emphasis to the speaker’s request for no further questions.
ConceitThe beloved’s eyes as “stars”An extended metaphor compares the beloved’s eyes to stars, emphasizing their beauty and constancy.
End Rhyme“bestows” / “rose”; “night” / “light”Rhyme at the end of lines enhances the structure and musicality of the poem.
Enjambment“For in your beauty’s orient deep / These flowers”The line runs onto the next, creating a sense of continuation and flow in the imagery.
EpistropheRepetition of “Ask me no more” at stanza beginningsRepetition at the beginning of each stanza emphasizes the speaker’s reluctance to answer further.
Hyperbole“Fixed become, as in their sphere.”Exaggeration of the beloved’s eyes as the eternal home of stars, emphasizing their celestial beauty.
Imagery“golden atoms of the day”Vivid description appeals to the senses, portraying sunlight as tiny, precious particles.
IronyThe phoenix “in your fragrant bosom dies”Irony lies in the idea of death within beauty, suggesting a paradox of rebirth and mortality in love.
Metaphor“These flowers, as in their causes, sleep.”The rose symbolizes transient beauty, which metaphorically “sleeps” within the beloved’s beauty.
Metonymy“Your beauty’s orient deep”“Orient” is used to symbolize the precious quality of the beloved’s beauty.
Personification“flowers…sleep”Flowers are given the human ability to “sleep,” indicating their rest in the beloved’s beauty.
Refrain“Ask me no more”This phrase is repeated, emphasizing the poem’s central plea for no further questioning.
Simile“Fixed become, as in their sphere.”The beloved’s eyes are compared to stars fixed in the sky, emphasizing permanence and clarity.
Symbolism“rose,” “nightingale,” “phoenix”Symbols of beauty, love, and rebirth, respectively, enrich the poem’s meditation on beauty and mortality.
Synecdoche“powders to enrich your hair”“Powders” represent the sunlight in a part-to-whole relationship, suggesting that light enhances beauty.
Transferred Epithet“sweet dividing throat”The adjective “sweet” applies to the nightingale’s song rather than the throat itself, intensifying imagery.
Themes: “A Song (Ask Me No More)” by Thomas Carew
  1. Transience of Beauty and Nature: The poem underscores the fleeting nature of beauty through references to the changing seasons and natural phenomena. For instance, Carew mentions “the fading rose” after June has passed, symbolizing how beauty, much like the rose, is temporary and inevitably fades with time. Similarly, the poet refers to the nightingale, which departs once May is over, highlighting that beauty and joy are bound to cycles and seasons, unable to remain forever. This theme reflects a common Renaissance poetic meditation on beauty’s impermanence.
  2. Idealization of the Beloved: Throughout the poem, Carew elevates the beloved to a near-mythical status, attributing celestial and divine qualities to her beauty. For example, he describes her eyes as the resting place of falling stars, suggesting that her beauty has an eternal and almost otherworldly quality, as if the stars have found their true home in her gaze. By comparing her to divine figures and natural wonders, Carew places the beloved beyond ordinary human beauty, representing an idealized form of perfection.
  3. Mystery and the Unknowable: The repeated line, “Ask me no more,” serves to create an aura of mystery, suggesting that some aspects of beauty, love, and life are beyond human understanding. Carew refuses to explain where the “golden atoms of the day” go or where the phoenix flies, indicating that certain phenomena, particularly those related to beauty and love, are shrouded in mystery. This theme suggests that not everything in life needs to be explained; sometimes, it is enough to admire beauty without probing its origins or nature.
  4. Union of Love and Nature: Carew intricately connects the beloved’s beauty to elements of nature, such as flowers, sunlight, and mythical creatures like the phoenix. For instance, he notes that the powders of “golden atoms” (symbolizing sunlight) enrich her hair, as if nature itself contributes to her loveliness. In doing so, he blurs the line between human beauty and natural wonders, showing that the beloved’s allure is a part of the natural world’s beauty. This theme reflects a Renaissance idea of harmony between human love and nature, where the beloved is seen as a natural, sublime creation deserving of reverence.
Literary Theories and “A Song (Ask Me No More)” by Thomas Carew
Literary TheoryExplanationReferences from the Poem
FormalismFormalism focuses on analyzing the poem’s structure, language, and use of poetic devices without considering the author’s biography or historical context.Carew’s use of rhetorical repetition (“Ask me no more”) and vivid imagery, like “fading rose” and “golden atoms of the day,” enhances the poem’s lyrical quality and theme of beauty.
Mythological CriticismThis theory examines the role of myths, symbols, and archetypes in the poem, exploring how they create universal meanings and connect with shared human experience.References to “Jove,” the “nightingale,” and the “phoenix” invoke mythological and natural symbols, representing eternal beauty, rebirth, and divinity in the beloved’s qualities.
RomanticismRomanticism emphasizes the beauty of nature, emotional depth, and the idealization of love and the beloved, often seeing beauty as an eternal truth.The beloved’s beauty is idealized as eternal, with metaphors like the beloved’s eyes as stars and her presence as a home for natural beauty (“These flowers… sleep” within her beauty).
Critical Questions about “A Song (Ask Me No More)” by Thomas Carew
  • How does Carew’s use of natural imagery shape the reader’s perception of the beloved’s beauty?
  • Carew repeatedly employs natural imagery, such as “the fading rose,” “golden atoms of the day,” and “the nightingale,” to illustrate the beloved’s beauty in relation to the natural world. These images create a dual perception of her beauty as both transient, like the rose that fades after June, and enduring, as it becomes the final resting place of elements like the stars. This question probes how nature’s ephemerality and constancy in Carew’s imagery enhance our understanding of his idealized vision of the beloved and whether it implies a connection to something eternal within her beauty.
  • What is the significance of the repeated refrain, “Ask me no more,” and how does it influence the tone of the poem?
  • The refrain, “Ask me no more,” serves as both a plea and a command, setting a contemplative and somewhat wistful tone. It suggests that some mysteries, particularly those surrounding beauty and love, are beyond explanation and should be accepted rather than questioned. Each stanza introduces a rhetorical question only to have the speaker deflect it, preserving an air of mystery around the beloved. This question encourages analysis of how the refrain might reflect Carew’s view on the limitations of language and understanding when describing beauty and whether it implies reverence or frustration.
  • How does Carew’s idealization of the beloved reflect broader themes of Renaissance poetry, particularly in the context of love and beauty?
  • Renaissance poets frequently celebrated idealized love, blending divine, mythological, and natural elements to exalt the beloved. Carew’s description of his beloved as embodying “the golden atoms of the day” or as the final home of the “phoenix” elevates her to a celestial level, emphasizing an unattainable, almost divine form of beauty. This question invites readers to consider how Carew’s poem fits within Renaissance traditions, exploring how he employs idealization and mythological allusions to elevate human beauty and emotion to the sublime and whether this idealization implies a separation between idealized and real-world love.
  • In what ways does the poem explore the theme of mystery in relation to beauty, and what might this suggest about Carew’s perspective on love?
  • Carew’s poem emphasizes the unknowable aspects of beauty through repeated questions and refusals to answer, suggesting that beauty, like certain natural phenomena, is shrouded in mystery. By stating, “Ask me no more,” the speaker implies that beauty’s true nature transcends human understanding. This question leads to a deeper exploration of whether Carew’s focus on the enigmatic qualities of beauty reflects a perspective that true love and beauty are beyond reason and intellect, existing as sacred or mystical experiences that cannot be fully grasped, only appreciated.
Literary Works Similar to “A Song (Ask Me No More)” by Thomas Carew
  1. “To His Coy Mistress” by Andrew Marvell
    This poem shares themes of fleeting beauty and the passage of time, urging the beloved to seize the moment as beauty and life are transient.
  2. “Shall I Compare Thee to a Summer’s Day?” by William Shakespeare
    Like Carew, Shakespeare idealizes the beloved’s beauty, using natural imagery to immortalize her in poetic form and contrast her with the transience of nature.
  3. “Song: To Celia” by Ben Jonson
    Jonson’s poem, similar in tone, elevates the beloved with divine and mystical comparisons, creating an idealized portrayal of love and beauty.
  4. “The Good-Morrow” by John Donne
    Donne explores an intimate and idealized vision of love, describing it in elevated and transcendent terms, akin to Carew’s idealization of the beloved.
  5. “A Red, Red Rose” by Robert Burns
    Burns, like Carew, uses rich natural imagery to convey intense admiration and devotion to the beloved, comparing her beauty to elements of nature.
Representative Quotations of “A Song (Ask Me No More)” by Thomas Carew
QuotationContextTheoretical Perspective
“Ask me no more where Jove bestows”The speaker begins by asking the beloved to cease questioning, setting a contemplative and mysterious tone.Formalism: Focuses on the refrain as a stylistic device enhancing tone.
“When June is past, the fading rose”The rose, a symbol of beauty, fades after its peak, illustrating the impermanence of beauty.Romanticism: Emphasizes nature as symbolic of beauty’s transience.
“For in your beauty’s orient deep”The speaker locates beauty in the beloved, equating it to something precious and rare like the Orient.Aestheticism: Highlights the beauty ideal as precious and exotic.
“Ask me no more whither do stray / The golden atoms of the day”The speaker alludes to sunlight as “golden atoms,” associating it with divinity and mystery.Mythological Criticism: Light as a divine element that enriches beauty.
“For in pure love heaven did prepare / Those powders to enrich your hair.”Suggests that the beloved’s beauty is a divine creation, destined to be admired.Transcendentalism: Links beauty to a divine and universal origin.
“Ask me no more whither doth haste / The nightingale”Refers to the nightingale, symbolic of song and love, which appears to reside in the beloved.Symbolism: Uses the nightingale to symbolize love and beauty’s warmth.
“For in your sweet dividing throat / She winters, and keeps warm her note.”The beloved’s voice becomes a refuge for the nightingale, blending nature with human beauty.Romanticism: Idealizes nature as intertwined with the beloved’s beauty.
“Ask me no more where those stars ‘light”Stars falling from the sky represent beauty’s mystical, elusive quality that finds a resting place in the beloved.Existentialism: Beauty is mysterious, finding meaning in human love.
“For in your eyes they sit, and there / Fixed become, as in their sphere.”Stars are metaphorically “fixed” in the beloved’s eyes, suggesting an eternal quality.Formalism: Uses metaphor to convey idealized, immutable beauty.
“Ask me no more if east or west / The phoenix builds her spicy nest”Refers to the phoenix, a mythical creature symbolizing rebirth, which ultimately seeks refuge in the beloved.Mythological Criticism: Uses the phoenix to convey rebirth in love.
Suggested Readings: “A Song (Ask Me No More)” by Thomas Carew
  1. Powell, C. L. “New Material on Thomas Carew.” The Modern Language Review, vol. 11, no. 3, 1916, pp. 285–97. JSTOR, https://doi.org/10.2307/3713526. Accessed 13 Nov. 2024.
  2. PARKER, MICHAEL P. “‘All Are Not Born (Sir) to the Bay’: ‘Fack’ Suckling, ‘Tom’ Carew, and the Making of a Poet.” English Literary Renaissance, vol. 12, no. 3, 1982, pp. 341–68. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/43447085. Accessed 13 Nov. 2024.
  3. Carew, Thomas. “Thomas Carew.” Poetry of World Literature (2024): 35.
  4. Hannaford, Renée. “‘Express’d by Mee’: Carew on Donne and Jonson.” Studies in Philology, vol. 84, no. 1, 1987, pp. 61–79. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/4174258. Accessed 13 Nov. 2024.

“Marks” by Linda Pastan: A Critical Analysis

“Marks” by Linda Pastan, first appeared in her 1978 poetry collection, The Five Stages of Grief, yet impactful poem explores themes of domestic life, self-worth, and societal expectations.

"Marks" by Linda Pastan: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “Marks” by Linda Pastan

Marks” by Linda Pastan, first appeared in her 1978 poetry collection, The Five Stages of Grief, yet impactful poem explores themes of domestic life, self-worth, and societal expectations, examining how a wife and mother’s worth is often measured through a series of “grades” assigned by her family members. Each family member, from her husband to her children, evaluates her in various roles—cooking, mothering, and being a spouse. The poem resonates because it captures the often-unspoken exhaustion and frustration felt by many women who juggle multiple roles and are judged, sometimes unfairly, on their “performance” in each. Pastan’s use of school grading as a metaphor to express emotional fatigue and the pressures of domestic expectations has made the poem widely relatable and popular, offering insight into the complexities of identity and personal validation within family dynamics.

Text: “Marks” by Linda Pastan

My husband gives me an A
for last night’s supper,
an incomplete for my ironing,
a B plus in bed.
My son says I am average,
an average mother, but if
I put my mind to it
I could improve.
My daughter believes
in Pass/Fail and tells me
I pass. Wait ’til they learn
I’m dropping out.

Annotations: “Marks” by Linda Pastan
LineAnnotation
“My husband gives me an A”The speaker introduces the metaphor of grading, where her performance as a wife and mother is assessed. This “A” implies approval and satisfaction in her role of providing a meal.
“for last night’s supper,”Specific praise for preparing a meal, suggesting that her household contributions are quantified, with each task evaluated independently.
“an incomplete for my ironing,”The “incomplete” grade implies criticism or a sense of failure. Ironing is a traditional domestic chore, highlighting an unmet expectation or perceived inadequacy.
“a B plus in bed.”This line implies that her sexual performance is also evaluated. The “B plus” suggests mild satisfaction but an implicit standard that she hasn’t completely met.
“My son says I am average,”Her son assesses her as “average,” which can be hurtful. This reflects a lack of appreciation for her efforts and a casual, dismissive evaluation of her as a mother.
“an average mother, but if”Repetition of “average” emphasizes the mediocrity assigned to her, underscoring that her efforts, in her son’s eyes, don’t stand out.
“I put my mind to it”The son implies that her role as a mother could be improved, suggesting that her shortcomings are a matter of effort or motivation, which may feel dismissive or unsympathetic.
“I could improve.”The phrase echoes societal expectations for constant improvement, implying that her current efforts are insufficient, fueling her sense of being undervalued.
“My daughter believes”Her daughter’s viewpoint is introduced, showing that each family member has a unique way of “grading” her contributions and role within the household.
“in Pass/Fail and tells me”The daughter’s “Pass/Fail” approach is simpler and less critical, indicating that she views her mother’s efforts as either acceptable or not, without nuanced grading.
“I pass.”“Pass” suggests acceptance, though it’s hardly a strong affirmation. This conveys a bare minimum of approval, further underscoring the mother’s feelings of being judged.
“Wait ’til they learn”A shift in tone occurs here, with the speaker expressing a sense of impending action or rebellion, hinting at her dissatisfaction with being constantly evaluated.
“I’m dropping out.”This line concludes the poem with a powerful assertion. “Dropping out” symbolizes her rejection of the roles and expectations imposed upon her, choosing self-liberation over judgment.
Literary And Poetic Devices: “Marks” by Linda Pastan
DeviceExampleExplanation
Alliteration“My mind”Repetition of the “m” sound in “My mind” creates a rhythm and emphasis on the speaker’s reflection on her roles.
Ambiguity“I pass”“Pass” can mean success, but it also implies merely meeting the minimum standard, highlighting a sense of underappreciation.
Anaphora“an average… an average mother”Repetition of “an average” emphasizes the son’s dismissive view of her, heightening the emotional impact of feeling unappreciated.
Anthropomorphism“believes in Pass/Fail”Giving the grading system (“Pass/Fail”) a personality through the daughter’s belief as if it were a system of faith or ideology.
Antithesis“Pass/Fail” vs. “A, B plus, incomplete”Contrasting grading systems illustrate varying perspectives on her worth, with the daughter’s binary view opposing her husband’s more complex system.
Apostrophe“Wait ’til they learn”Addressing “they” directly when they are not present emphasizes her internal monologue and decision to “drop out.”
Connotation“dropping out”“Dropping out” usually refers to quitting school, but here it signifies rejecting her family roles, with connotations of rebellion and liberation.
Contrast“A for supper” vs. “incomplete for ironing”Highlights her fluctuating value in different tasks, showing the arbitrary and fragmented nature of her family’s judgments.
DefamiliarizationGrading her roles as a wife and motherBy using academic grading for household tasks, the poem invites readers to view domestic life in an unusual, critical perspective.
Diction“average,” “incomplete,” “dropping out”Words like “average” and “incomplete” carry negative tones, while “dropping out” evokes a strong statement of rejection.
Double Entendre“dropping out”The phrase suggests both quitting her family roles and abandoning societal expectations, adding layers of meaning.
Enjambment“My son says I am average, / an average mother”The line break emphasizes the phrase “an average mother,” isolating it for greater impact and drawing attention to the son’s indifference.
Extended MetaphorGrading system applied to domestic rolesThe whole poem uses grading as a metaphor for family evaluation of a woman’s domestic contributions, critiquing how society values her efforts.
Hyperbole“Wait ’til they learn”This line exaggerates her family’s possible shock at her “dropping out,” emphasizing her growing frustration with her domestic roles.
Imagery“last night’s supper,” “ironing”Concrete images evoke familiar domestic scenes, helping readers visualize the tasks she is graded on.
IronyReceiving grades in domestic rolesIt’s ironic that domestic tasks, often undervalued, are graded like academic subjects, highlighting the absurdity of judging personal relationships by performance.
JuxtapositionHusband’s grading vs. daughter’s Pass/FailPlacing these grading methods side by side underscores different attitudes within the family, illustrating varied perspectives on her worth.
MetaphorGrading as a metaphor for judgmentThe grades represent the family’s evaluation of her as a wife and mother, serving as a metaphor for how her roles are quantified and judged.
Personification“My son says I am average”The family members act as judges, assigning her value in each role, almost personifying their evaluations as if they have authoritative power over her self-worth.
ToneMix of resignation and defianceThe speaker’s tone shifts from passive acceptance to assertive rejection (“dropping out”), reflecting her growing dissatisfaction with constant judgment.
Themes: “Marks” by Linda Pastan
  1. Judgment and Evaluation: The central theme in “Marks” is the constant judgment the speaker faces within her family, where her roles as a wife and mother are scrutinized as though they were academic performances. Each family member evaluates her contributions, as seen in lines like “My husband gives me an A for last night’s supper” and “a B plus in bed.” These “grades” symbolize how the speaker’s family views her contributions in quantifiable, transactional terms, reducing her complex roles to simplistic evaluations. This judgment leads her to feel objectified, as though her worth depends on meeting others’ standards, emphasizing the theme of external validation and its impact on self-worth.
  2. Domestic Expectations and Gender Roles: The poem critiques traditional expectations placed upon women in domestic spaces, where their value is often tied to fulfilling household tasks and caregiving roles. Lines like “an incomplete for my ironing” illustrate these domestic expectations, reflecting how her family notices and critiques every domestic detail. The poem thus reveals the pressure women face to excel in household duties, which are often thankless and invisible until unmet. This theme explores the broader societal expectations placed on women in family settings, underscoring the persistent pressure to maintain a “perfect” home.
  3. The Search for Identity and Self-Worth: The speaker’s frustration with her family’s evaluations reveals her struggle for identity beyond her family-defined roles. Her son’s remark, “My son says I am average,” dismisses her as merely sufficient, intensifying her desire to assert her self-worth outside of familial judgments. By the end, she decides, “Wait ’til they learn I’m dropping out,” expressing a wish to detach herself from these roles to preserve her identity. This statement represents a turning point where she no longer sees herself as just a mother or wife judged by others but as an individual deserving of self-worth beyond these limiting labels.
  4. Rebellion and Liberation: The poem’s conclusion hints at the speaker’s desire for freedom from her family’s constant grading system. The line “Wait ’til they learn I’m dropping out” suggests a rebellion against the expectations her family imposes on her. This decision to “drop out” symbolizes a rejection of the roles she’s confined to, highlighting her need for liberation from the household duties that define her. This theme illustrates the courage it takes to break away from confining social roles, portraying the speaker’s journey toward self-empowerment and autonomy.
Literary Theories and “Marks” by Linda Pastan
Literary TheoryApplication to “Marks”References from the Poem
Feminist TheoryExamines how societal expectations place women in restrictive roles, often valuing them solely by their domestic and caregiving abilities. “Marks” critiques the traditional gender roles that confine the speaker to her roles as a wife and mother.“My husband gives me an A for last night’s supper” and “an incomplete for my ironing” reflect the family’s judgment of her domestic roles.
Marxist TheoryAnalyzes class structures and the value placed on labor, including unpaid domestic labor, highlighting how the speaker’s work is quantified and graded without real recognition or compensation, akin to a worker in a capitalist system.The family’s grading of her domestic tasks, such as “a B plus in bed” and “an incomplete for my ironing,” treats her labor as transactional.
Psychoanalytic TheoryFocuses on the speaker’s inner conflict between her role in the family and her need for individual identity. Her decision to “drop out” can be seen as a reaction to the repressed dissatisfaction and desire for self-worth beyond her family’s approval.“Wait ’til they learn I’m dropping out” indicates her subconscious drive toward autonomy and rejection of family-imposed evaluations.
Critical Questions about “Marks” by Linda Pastan
  • How does the grading metaphor in “Marks” comment on the societal expectations placed upon women in domestic roles?
  • The grading metaphor in “Marks” powerfully critiques societal expectations that measure a woman’s worth by her performance in domestic roles. Pastan uses language typically associated with school—”A,” “B plus,” “incomplete,” “Pass/Fail”—to illustrate how the speaker’s family treats her work as quantifiable and subject to assessment. This metaphor reflects the reductive way society often evaluates women’s domestic labor, emphasizing how their identities are frequently confined to being “good” or “bad” mothers, wives, and homemakers. By grading her household tasks, her family mirrors a broader societal attitude that undervalues and scrutinizes women’s unpaid labor within the home.
  • What does the speaker’s tone reveal about her feelings toward the family’s judgments?
  • The speaker’s tone in “Marks” shifts from resigned acceptance to assertive defiance, revealing a complex mix of frustration and empowerment. Initially, her tone seems passive, as she lists the grades she receives from her family members without apparent resistance, such as “an incomplete for my ironing” or “a B plus in bed.” However, the final lines, “Wait ’til they learn I’m dropping out,” indicate a tone of rebellion and self-assertion. This shift suggests that she feels both exhausted by the continuous evaluations and ready to take control of her identity outside her family’s judgments, underscoring a desire for liberation from restrictive roles.
  • How does the poem explore the theme of self-worth in relation to familial roles?
  • In “Marks,” Pastan explores the theme of self-worth by depicting a woman who is constantly evaluated based on her familial roles, leaving her personal identity and self-worth tied to these external assessments. The line “My son says I am average” reflects her sense of inadequacy as a mother, while the daughter’s “Pass/Fail” approach further reduces her worth to a simplistic evaluation. These assessments suggest that her value is dependent on how well she meets her family’s needs, not on her own sense of self. By the end, her declaration of “dropping out” signifies a critical moment of self-recognition and a choice to seek validation outside her roles, reflecting a shift toward intrinsic self-worth.
  • What is the significance of the poem’s closing line, “Wait ’til they learn I’m dropping out”?
  • The closing line, “Wait ’til they learn I’m dropping out,” is a significant assertion of agency and autonomy. After enduring a series of evaluations from her husband, son, and daughter, the speaker’s decision to “drop out” suggests a rejection of the roles and expectations imposed on her. This act of “dropping out” implies that she no longer wishes to participate in a system that constantly grades and devalues her efforts. The line encapsulates her desire to reclaim control over her life, signaling a move toward self-liberation and a refusal to be defined solely by the judgments of others. This ending serves as both a statement of empowerment and a critique of the way family roles can confine individual identity.
Literary Works Similar to “Marks” by Linda Pastan
  1. “Daystar” by Rita Dove
    This poem examines a woman’s need for personal space and identity beyond her domestic duties, much like Pastan’s speaker who feels confined by familial expectations.
  2. “The Applicant” by Sylvia Plath
    Through biting satire, this poem critiques societal expectations for women, particularly in marriage, echoing Pastan’s examination of gender roles and the pressures placed on women.
  3. “To a Daughter Leaving Home” by Linda Pastan
    Also by Pastan, this poem explores motherhood and the bittersweet emotions of watching a child grow independent, highlighting familial relationships and identity similar to “Marks.”
  4. “Housewife” by Anne Sexton
    This poem critiques traditional female roles, portraying the housewife as an object tied to her home, resonating with the feeling of entrapment and judgment seen in “Marks.”
Representative Quotations of “Marks” by Linda Pastan
QuotationContextTheoretical Perspective
“My husband gives me an A / for last night’s supper”Context: The speaker reflects on being “graded” by her family on her performance as a wife and mother, likening household roles to academic tasks.Feminist Critique: Examines societal expectations and patriarchal “grading” of women in domestic spaces.
“an incomplete for my ironing”Context: Ironing, a typical household chore, is presented as a task left unfinished, one for which the speaker is also evaluated.Social Criticism: Highlights how women’s domestic labor is undervalued and trivialized in daily life.
“a B plus in bed”Context: The speaker shares her husband’s judgment of her sexual performance, revealing the reduction of intimacy to a graded task.Sexual Objectification: Explores how intimate relationships can be reduced to metrics and evaluations.
“My son says I am average, / an average mother”Context: The speaker notes her son’s blunt assessment, which implies a lack of exceptionalism and underscores the family’s judgmental perspective.Generational Expectations: Reflects on the intergenerational transmission of normative roles and judgments.
“My daughter believes / in Pass/Fail and tells me / I pass”Context: The daughter’s pass/fail assessment suggests a simpler standard, though still in keeping with the theme of familial judgment.Binary Value Systems: Indicates that value judgments often ignore complexity, reducing roles to binaries.
“Wait ’til they learn / I’m dropping out.”Context: The speaker concludes with a powerful declaration of rebellion, revealing her desire to reject these imposed standards.Agency and Resistance: Represents the speaker’s resistance to societal expectations, reclaiming autonomy.
Suggested Readings: “Marks” by Linda Pastan
  1. Battersby, James L., and James Phelan. “Meaning as Concept and Extension: Some Problems.” Critical Inquiry, vol. 12, no. 3, 1986, pp. 605–15. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/1343546. Accessed 10 Nov. 2024.
  2. ROMADHONA, MINTAMI. THE PORTRAYAL OF WOMEN UNDER PATRIARCHAL SYSTEM IN LINDA PASTAN’S POEMS. Diss. UNIVERSITAS AIRLANGGA, 2012.
  3. PASTAN, LINDA. “The Five Stages of Grief.” Chicago Review, vol. 42, no. 3/4, 1996, pp. 194–96. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/40783779. Accessed 10 Nov. 2024.
  4. PASTAN, LINDA. “LINDA PASTAN.” Contemporary Poetry: A Retrospective from the “Quarterly Review of Literature,” edited by T. Weiss and Renée Weiss, Princeton University Press, 1974, pp. 495–96. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt13x0t26.168. Accessed 10 Nov. 2024.
  5. Pastan, Linda. “The Seven Deadly Sins.” Poetry, vol. 146, no. 1, 1985, pp. 19–21. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/20600251. Accessed 10 Nov. 2024.

“Mad Girl’s Love Song” by Sylvia Plath: A Critical Analysis

“Mad Girl’s Love Song” by Sylvia Plath first appeared in 1953 in Mademoiselle magazine, marking one of her early forays into published poetry.

"Mad Girl's Love Song" by Sylvia Plath: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “Mad Girl’s Love Song” by Sylvia Plath

“Mad Girl’s Love Song” by Sylvia Plath first appeared in 1953 in Mademoiselle magazine, marking one of her early forays into published poetry. This villanelle captures Plath’s powerful expression of unrequited love, emotional despair, and inner turmoil through hauntingly vivid language and repetitive structure. The poem’s refrain, “I shut my eyes and all the world drops dead,” echoes Plath’s intense psychological depth, as she explores themes of love, disillusionment, and the blurred line between reality and imagination. Its popularity can be attributed to the raw honesty of Plath’s introspection, which resonates with readers who have experienced the ache of loss and unfulfilled desire. The poem’s unique fusion of lyricism with emotional vulnerability has cemented it as one of Plath’s iconic works, celebrated for its exploration of mental anguish and the struggle between yearning for connection and the suffocating pull of isolation.

Text: “Mad Girl’s Love Song” by Sylvia Plath

“I shut my eyes and all the world drops dead;
I lift my lids and all is born again.
(I think I made you up inside my head.)

The stars go waltzing out in blue and red,
And arbitrary blackness gallops in:
I shut my eyes and all the world drops dead.

I dreamed that you bewitched me into bed
And sung me moon-struck, kissed me quite insane.
(I think I made you up inside my head.)

God topples from the sky, hell’s fires fade:
Exit seraphim and Satan’s men:
I shut my eyes and all the world drops dead.

I fancied you’d return the way you said,
But I grow old and I forget your name.
(I think I made you up inside my head.)

I should have loved a thunderbird instead;
At least when spring comes they roar back again.
I shut my eyes and all the world drops dead.
(I think I made you up inside my head.)”

Annotations: “Mad Girl’s Love Song” by Sylvia Plath
LineAnnotation
“I shut my eyes and all the world drops dead;”This line expresses a sense of control or withdrawal, as if by closing her eyes, the speaker can make reality vanish. It indicates a desire to escape or dissociate from the pain associated with the world.
“I lift my lids and all is born again.”Here, the speaker reverses the previous act by reopening her eyes, symbolizing how reality and pain come flooding back. It reflects a cycle of seeking solace through escape but inevitably facing reality again.
“(I think I made you up inside my head.)”This refrain suggests doubt and introspection, questioning whether the love or person she addresses was real or a figment of her imagination. This line conveys themes of mental instability and unreliable memory.
“The stars go waltzing out in blue and red,”The stars symbolize beauty and celestial harmony but are described as “waltzing” away, indicating a loss of wonder or stability. “Blue and red” may evoke vivid emotions or a sense of dissonance in what should be harmonious.
“And arbitrary blackness gallops in:”The “arbitrary blackness” suggests overwhelming darkness or despair that enters without reason or warning, reflecting feelings of depression. The word “gallops” implies force and speed, indicating how quickly this despair takes over.
“I shut my eyes and all the world drops dead.”Repeated from the first line, this refrain emphasizes the cyclical nature of her retreat from reality. It reiterates her attempt to withdraw from a world that causes her distress.
“I dreamed that you bewitched me into bed”The speaker recalls a dream or fantasy in which she was enchanted or seduced. “Bewitched” suggests an otherworldly or spellbinding influence, indicating how deeply the imagined lover has captivated her.
“And sung me moon-struck, kissed me quite insane.”“Moon-struck” and “kissed me quite insane” intensify the fantasy, reflecting both enchantment and madness. The imagery implies that love (or longing for it) has unbalanced her mind, leading to confusion and obsession.
“(I think I made you up inside my head.)”The refrain returns, reinforcing the idea that her intense emotions may be based on illusion. This line creates an internal conflict between desire and doubt about the existence of her lover or the authenticity of her feelings.
“God topples from the sky, hell’s fires fade:”In a dramatic image, divine and infernal forces disappear, symbolizing disillusionment with cosmic order or faith. This line conveys an existential void where both heaven and hell lose their meaning in the face of her emotional anguish.
“Exit seraphim and Satan’s men:”Angels (seraphim) and devils are dismissed, suggesting a collapse of spiritual or moral frameworks. The world becomes empty and devoid of the supernatural or moral guidance, reflecting her deep despair and nihilism.
“I shut my eyes and all the world drops dead.”This repetition underscores her attempt to control or negate painful reality through imagination or withdrawal, but it only offers a temporary escape.
“I fancied you’d return the way you said,”This line reveals her longing and hope that the lover would keep their promises and return to her. “Fancied” suggests it was a hopeful yet ultimately unrealistic expectation, indicating her disappointment.
“But I grow old and I forget your name.”The speaker acknowledges the passage of time and a fading memory of the lover. It suggests the impermanence of both her fantasy and emotional pain, as she resigns to forgetfulness and the erosion of passion.
“(I think I made you up inside my head.)”Repeating the refrain once again, she resigns to the notion that her lover may never have existed outside her mind. This line captures her internal conflict between memory, fantasy, and reality.
“I should have loved a thunderbird instead;”This line expresses regret for not choosing something enduring and reliable (“thunderbird” as a mythical creature or a bird that returns with the seasons). She contrasts this with the unreliable love she feels she imagined.
“At least when spring comes they roar back again.”Unlike her imaginary lover, thunderbirds or actual birds are reliable, cyclically returning with the seasons. This highlights her yearning for stability and constancy in love, which she finds lacking in her imagined relationship.
“I shut my eyes and all the world drops dead.”This closing repetition emphasizes her desire to escape, reiterating the poem’s cycle of fantasy and disillusionment. It underscores the poem’s theme of withdrawal as her only solace from a painful, unfulfilled love.
“(I think I made you up inside my head.)”The final line reaffirms her realization that her idealized lover is a mere fantasy. This closure suggests an acceptance of her solitary, introspective world, where her imagined love is her own creation rather than a shared reality.
Literary And Poetic Devices: “Mad Girl’s Love Song” by Sylvia Plath
DeviceExampleExplanation
Alliteration“world drops dead”The repetition of the “d” sound emphasizes finality and creates a rhythmic impact, enhancing the sense of an ending or cessation.
Anaphora“I shut my eyes… I lift my lids…”The repetition of “I” at the beginning of lines highlights the speaker’s personal perspective and emphasizes her actions and internal reflections.
Apostrophe“I dreamed that you bewitched me…”The speaker addresses an absent or imagined lover directly, creating intimacy and reflecting the intensity of her feelings, even in the lover’s absence.
Assonance“blue and red”The repetition of the “u” sound in “blue” and “red” links these contrasting colors, symbolizing emotional highs and lows, and enhances the musicality of the line.
Caesura“I grow old and I forget your name.”The pause after “I grow old” creates a reflective tone, allowing the reader to dwell on the passage of time and the fading of memory.
Consonance“God topples from the sky”The repetition of the “s” sound creates a soft, almost hissing effect, adding to the poem’s melancholic, resigned mood.
Enjambment“I shut my eyes and all the world drops dead; / I lift my lids…”Enjambment here drives the reader forward, mirroring the poem’s sense of continuous introspection and emotional fluctuation.
Epizeuxis“drops dead, drops dead”The repetition of “drops dead” reinforces the impact of the action, suggesting a cyclical, overwhelming sense of loss and withdrawal.
Hyperbole“I dreamed that you bewitched me into bed”The idea of being “bewitched” into bed is exaggerated, suggesting the overwhelming and magical pull of her imagined lover.
Imagery“The stars go waltzing out in blue and red”Vivid imagery of stars “waltzing” in colors evokes a dreamlike and surreal quality, illustrating her emotional intensity and blurred reality.
Irony“I think I made you up inside my head.”There’s irony in her realization that her intense emotions may be directed toward an illusion, as she questions the existence of the lover she longs for.
Juxtaposition“God topples… hell’s fires fade”Heaven and hell are placed side by side to emphasize the speaker’s sense of collapse in her worldview, where both good and evil lose meaning.
Metaphor“I should have loved a thunderbird instead”Comparing love to a “thunderbird” suggests a desire for something powerful, reliable, and recurring, unlike her imagined, fleeting lover.
Paradox“I lift my lids and all is born again.”The contradiction lies in closing one’s eyes to “kill” the world, yet lifting them brings it back, representing the paradox of perception and emotional cycles.
Personification“arbitrary blackness gallops in”Blackness is given the human quality of “galloping,” which creates a more vivid sense of an overwhelming force of despair that overtakes her.
Refrain“I shut my eyes and all the world drops dead.”This recurring line reflects the poem’s central theme of withdrawal and emotional isolation, reinforcing the speaker’s cycle of detachment from reality.
Simile“kissed me quite insane”Comparing the kiss to an action that makes her “insane” emphasizes the intensity and irrationality of her feelings, highlighting the overwhelming nature of her love.
Symbolism“stars”Stars symbolize beauty, hope, and stability, which “waltz out,” indicating the loss of these ideals in her emotional world.
ToneThroughout the poemThe tone is melancholic and introspective, reflecting themes of disillusionment, mental anguish, and the struggle between fantasy and reality.
Villanelle FormEntire poemThe structured form of the villanelle, with its repeated lines and strict rhyme scheme, mirrors the cyclical and obsessive nature of the speaker’s thoughts.
Themes: “Mad Girl’s Love Song” by Sylvia Plath
  1. Isolation and Despair: The poem conveys an overwhelming sense of isolation and despair, as the speaker retreats from a painful reality into her own mind. This is evident in the refrain, “I shut my eyes and all the world drops dead,” where closing her eyes becomes a means to escape. The repetition of this line throughout the poem emphasizes her cyclical and inescapable loneliness, where her only relief is the temporary cessation of awareness, suggesting a deep internalized anguish.
  2. Fantasy and Reality: Plath explores the tension between fantasy and reality, where the speaker grapples with whether her lover was real or merely imagined. The line “I think I made you up inside my head” reflects this internal struggle, questioning the validity of her memories and emotions. This repeated doubt blurs the boundary between her desires and the real world, underscoring her reliance on fantasy to cope with disappointment and unfulfilled love.
  3. Unrequited Love: Unrequited love is central to the speaker’s suffering, as she recalls her longing and disappointment. Lines like “I fancied you’d return the way you said” show her desire for reciprocation that never materializes. The longing for a lover who does not return intensifies her feelings of rejection and self-doubt, leading her to question whether the love she felt was real or purely a product of her imagination.
  4. Disillusionment with Faith and Meaning: The poem also expresses disillusionment with faith and the search for meaning, as symbols of both heaven and hell fade in her despair. In the lines, “God topples from the sky, hell’s fires fade,” both divine and infernal powers are dismissed, suggesting a collapse of traditional structures of meaning in the face of her emotional turmoil. This spiritual disillusionment reflects a nihilistic view, where the extremes of heaven and hell lose relevance, and only her solitary thoughts remain.
Literary Theories and “Mad Girl’s Love Song” by Sylvia Plath
Literary TheoryApplication to “Mad Girl’s Love Song”References from the PoemExplanation
Psychoanalytic TheoryFocuses on the speaker’s inner conflict, isolation, and mental anguish.“I shut my eyes and all the world drops dead.”The refrain suggests a desire to escape reality, aligning with psychoanalytic concepts of repression and the subconscious. The poem reflects the speaker’s inner struggle with loneliness, desire, and fantasy.
Feminist TheoryExamines the speaker’s emotional dependency and struggle with autonomy.“I dreamed that you bewitched me into bed”This line reflects a woman’s vulnerability to male influence, often viewed critically in feminist analysis as highlighting power dynamics, dependency, and gendered expectations of love and desire.
ExistentialismExplores themes of isolation, disillusionment, and meaninglessness.“God topples from the sky, hell’s fires fade”The collapse of divine figures reflects an existential void, where traditional sources of meaning (like religion) hold no relevance in the speaker’s emotional world, highlighting her search for meaning in a bleak reality.
Critical Questions about “Mad Girl’s Love Song” by Sylvia Plath
  • How does the speaker’s isolation influence her perception of reality and fantasy?
  • The speaker’s intense isolation blurs the boundary between reality and fantasy, leading her to question the existence of her lover. This is evident in the repeated line, “I think I made you up inside my head,” suggesting an internal struggle to distinguish between imagined love and real experience. Her isolation is both a refuge and a prison, allowing her to create an idealized version of her lover while fueling doubts about whether he was ever real. This question invites analysis of how loneliness can distort perceptions and lead to a dependency on fantasy as a coping mechanism.
  • In what ways does Plath’s use of repetition affect the reader’s understanding of the speaker’s mental state?
  • Repetition in the poem, particularly in the refrain “I shut my eyes and all the world drops dead,” creates a cyclical and inescapable sense of despair. This constant repetition mirrors obsessive thought patterns, hinting at the speaker’s inability to move beyond her pain and doubt. It also emphasizes her mental entrapment, where attempts at escape only bring her back to the same state of hopelessness. This raises questions about the nature of her mental anguish, highlighting how repetition can illustrate cyclical thought in depression and unresolved longing.
  • How does the speaker’s relationship with faith and spirituality evolve in the poem?
  • Initially, the speaker appears to hold some form of reverence or belief, but as her despair deepens, she dismisses traditional symbols of faith. In the line, “God topples from the sky, hell’s fires fade,” she envisions a world where both divine and infernal powers are meaningless, revealing a disillusionment with spiritual systems that once may have provided guidance or comfort. This shift points to an existential crisis where faith in established beliefs collapses under the weight of personal suffering. The question invites discussion on how despair can lead individuals to abandon belief systems that no longer resonate with their experiences.
  • What role does gender play in the speaker’s experience of love and longing?
  • The line “I dreamed that you bewitched me into bed” suggests a passive role for the speaker, as if she were under the control or spell of her lover. This portrayal reflects traditional, gendered expectations where women are positioned as emotionally dependent or at the mercy of their romantic desires. The poem’s exploration of unrequited love through this lens questions societal expectations of feminine vulnerability and dependency in relationships. This question encourages an analysis of how the speaker’s gendered experience shapes her identity and intensifies her suffering, as she navigates feelings of both yearning and helplessness.
Literary Works Similar to “Mad Girl’s Love Song” by Sylvia Plath
  1. “One Art” by Elizabeth Bishop – Like Plath’s poem, Bishop’s work explores loss and the emotional difficulty of letting go, using a structured form (villanelle) to convey recurring sorrow and resilience.
  2. “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock” by T.S. Eliot – Eliot’s poem delves into themes of isolation, self-doubt, and unfulfilled longing, mirroring Plath’s introspective tone and exploration of internal conflict.
  3. “Daddy” by Sylvia Plath – This poem also reflects Plath’s intense emotional struggles and complex relationships, as well as a blend of love and resentment, similar to the conflicted feelings in “Mad Girl’s Love Song”.
  4. “When You Are Old” by W.B. Yeats – Yeats’ poem deals with unrequited love and the haunting memories of a lost relationship, paralleling Plath’s theme of longing and fading connection.
  5. “Remember” by Christina Rossetti – Rossetti’s meditation on love, memory, and the pain of separation reflects the themes of loss and yearning found in Plath’s poem, evoking a similar tone of introspective sorrow.
Representative Quotations of “Mad Girl’s Love Song” by Sylvia Plath
QuotationContextTheoretical Perspective
“I shut my eyes and all the world drops dead.”Repeated refrain where the speaker retreats into herself, attempting to escape reality.Psychoanalytic Theory – Reflects the use of withdrawal as a coping mechanism to escape painful emotions, indicating repression and avoidance.
“I lift my lids and all is born again.”A momentary return to reality when the speaker reopens her eyes, symbolizing the cycle of despair.Existentialism – Highlights the inescapable cycle of human experience, where attempts to avoid reality only lead back to the same suffering.
“(I think I made you up inside my head.)”Refrain showing doubt about whether the lover ever existed outside her mind.Postmodernism – Raises questions of subjective reality and the reliability of memory, blurring lines between fantasy and reality.
“The stars go waltzing out in blue and red.”Imagery describing the night sky, portraying a surreal, dreamlike atmosphere.Romanticism – Emphasizes the emotional response to nature, using vivid imagery to reflect the speaker’s inner emotional turbulence.
“And arbitrary blackness gallops in.”A sudden onset of darkness, personified as it overtakes her mind.Psychoanalytic Theory – Represents intrusive, uncontrollable thoughts associated with mental anguish, likened to Freud’s concept of the Id.
“I dreamed that you bewitched me into bed.”Describes a fantasy where she is enchanted or controlled by her lover.Feminist Theory – Reflects traditional gender dynamics and vulnerability, with the woman being passively affected by male influence.
“God topples from the sky, hell’s fires fade.”Depiction of a breakdown in faith, with spiritual symbols losing significance.Existentialism – The collapse of religious symbols points to a nihilistic void, where meaning is elusive in the speaker’s despair.
“Exit seraphim and Satan’s men.”Angels and devils both depart, leaving an empty spiritual landscape.Postmodernism – Suggests a collapse of traditional binaries (good/evil), reflecting postmodern disillusionment with clear moral structures.
“I fancied you’d return the way you said.”Hints at unfulfilled promises and the speaker’s disillusionment.Feminist Theory – Highlights the theme of female vulnerability in love, with the speaker hoping for reciprocation that never comes.
“I should have loved a thunderbird instead.”The speaker regrets not choosing a more stable and reliable object of affection.Existentialism – Reveals the speaker’s search for meaning and reliability in love, suggesting a longing for permanence in an impermanent world.
Suggested Readings: “Mad Girl’s Love Song” by Sylvia Plath
  1. Greenberg, Arielle, and Becca Klaver. “Mad Girls’ Love Songs: Two Women Poets—A Professor and Graduate Student—Discuss Sylvia Plath, Angst, and the Poetics of Female Adolescence.” College Literature, vol. 36, no. 4, 2009, pp. 179–207. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/20642061. Accessed 9 Nov. 2024.
  2. Johnson, Greg. “The Many Lives of Sylvia Plath.” The Georgia Review, vol. 67, no. 2, 2013, pp. 351–57. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/43491064. Accessed 9 Nov. 2024.
  3. “Front Matter.” The Georgia Review, vol. 67, no. 2, 2013. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/43491048. Accessed 9 Nov. 2024.
  4. Ellingsen, Eric. “The Long Poem of Walking.” World Literature Today, vol. 85, no. 1, 2011, pp. 41–45. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/41060334. Accessed 9 Nov. 2024.
  5.  

“Mac Flecknoe” by John Dryden: A Critical Analysis

“Mac Flecknoe” by John Dryden, first appeared in 1682 as part of a collection of Dryden’s satirical works, is primarily a satire targeting the poet Thomas Shadwel.

"Mac Flecknoe" by John Dryden: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “Mac Flecknoe” by John Dryden

“Mac Flecknoe” by John Dryden, first appeared in 1682 as part of a collection of Dryden’s satirical works, is primarily a satire targeting the poet Thomas Shadwell, whom Dryden saw as lacking literary talent and taste. The poem’s title character, Richard Flecknoe, is a notoriously inept poet who, in the narrative, bequeaths his “throne” of literary mediocrity to Shadwell, thereby symbolizing Shadwell’s perceived shortcomings as a writer. The piece explores themes of incompetence, literary degeneration, and the decline of artistic standards, using elaborate irony and allusions to classical literature to elevate its satire. Its popularity lies in Dryden’s sharp wit, intricate wordplay, and his skillful use of the mock-epic form, which frames Shadwell’s literary mediocrity in an exaggeratedly grand style, making “Mac Flecknoe” a classic example of Restoration satire and a key work in Dryden’s critique of literary and cultural decay.

Text: “Mac Flecknoe” by John Dryden

A Satire upon the True-blue Protestant Poet T.S.

All human things are subject to decay,

And, when Fate summons, monarchs must obey:

This Flecknoe found, who, like Augustus, young

Was call’d to empire, and had govern’d long:

In prose and verse, was own’d, without dispute

Through all the realms of Non-sense, absolute.

This aged prince now flourishing in peace,

And blest with issue of a large increase,

Worn out with business, did at length debate

To settle the succession of the State:

And pond’ring which of all his sons was fit

To reign, and wage immortal war with wit;

Cry’d, ’tis resolv’d; for nature pleads that he

Should only rule, who most resembles me:

Shadwell alone my perfect image bears,

Mature in dullness from his tender years.

Shadwell alone, of all my sons, is he

Who stands confirm’d in full stupidity.

The rest to some faint meaning make pretence,

But Shadwell never deviates into sense.

Some beams of wit on other souls may fall,

Strike through and make a lucid interval;

But Shadwell’s genuine night admits no ray,

His rising fogs prevail upon the day:

Besides his goodly fabric fills the eye,

And seems design’d for thoughtless majesty:

Thoughtless as monarch oaks, that shade the plain,

And, spread in solemn state, supinely reign.

Heywood and Shirley were but types of thee,

Thou last great prophet of tautology:

Even I, a dunce of more renown than they,

Was sent before but to prepare thy way;

And coarsely clad in Norwich drugget came

To teach the nations in thy greater name.

My warbling lute, the lute I whilom strung

When to King John of Portugal I sung,

Was but the prelude to that glorious day,

When thou on silver Thames did’st cut thy way,

With well tim’d oars before the royal barge,

Swell’d with the pride of thy celestial charge;

And big with hymn, commander of an host,

The like was ne’er in Epsom blankets toss’d.

Methinks I see the new Arion sail,

The lute still trembling underneath thy nail.

At thy well sharpen’d thumb from shore to shore

The treble squeaks for fear, the basses roar:

Echoes from Pissing-Alley, Shadwell call,

And Shadwell they resound from Aston Hall.

About thy boat the little fishes throng,

As at the morning toast, that floats along.

Sometimes as prince of thy harmonious band

Thou wield’st thy papers in thy threshing hand.

St. Andre’s feet ne’er kept more equal time,

Not ev’n the feet of thy own Psyche’s rhyme:

Though they in number as in sense excel;

So just, so like tautology they fell,

That, pale with envy, Singleton forswore

The lute and sword which he in triumph bore

And vow’d he ne’er would act Villerius more.

Here stopt the good old sire; and wept for joy

In silent raptures of the hopeful boy.

All arguments, but most his plays, persuade,

That for anointed dullness he was made.

Close to the walls which fair Augusta bind,

(The fair Augusta much to fears inclin’d)

An ancient fabric, rais’d t’inform the sight,

There stood of yore, and Barbican it hight:

A watch tower once; but now, so fate ordains,

Of all the pile an empty name remains.

From its old ruins brothel-houses rise,

Scenes of lewd loves, and of polluted joys.

Where their vast courts, the mother-strumpets keep,

And, undisturb’d by watch, in silence sleep.

Near these a nursery erects its head,

Where queens are form’d, and future heroes bred;

Where unfledg’d actors learn to laugh and cry,

Where infant punks their tender voices try,

And little Maximins the gods defy.

Great Fletcher never treads in buskins here,

Nor greater Jonson dares in socks appear;

But gentle Simkin just reception finds

Amidst this monument of vanish’d minds:

Pure clinches, the suburbian muse affords;

And Panton waging harmless war with words.

Here Flecknoe, as a place to fame well known,

Ambitiously design’d his Shadwell’s throne.

For ancient Decker prophesi’d long since,

That in this pile should reign a mighty prince,

Born for a scourge of wit, and flail of sense:

To whom true dullness should some Psyches owe,

But worlds of Misers from his pen should flow;

Humorists and hypocrites it should produce,

Whole Raymond families, and tribes of Bruce.

Now Empress Fame had publisht the renown,

Of Shadwell’s coronation through the town.

Rous’d by report of fame, the nations meet,

From near Bun-Hill, and distant Watling-street.

No Persian carpets spread th’imperial way,

But scatter’d limbs of mangled poets lay:

From dusty shops neglected authors come,

Martyrs of pies, and reliques of the bum.

Much Heywood, Shirley, Ogleby there lay,

But loads of Shadwell almost chok’d the way.

Bilk’d stationers for yeoman stood prepar’d,

And Herringman was Captain of the Guard.

The hoary prince in majesty appear’d,

High on a throne of his own labours rear’d.

At his right hand our young Ascanius sat

Rome’s other hope, and pillar of the state.

His brows thick fogs, instead of glories, grace,

And lambent dullness play’d around his face.

As Hannibal did to the altars come,

Sworn by his sire a mortal foe to Rome;

So Shadwell swore, nor should his vow be vain,

That he till death true dullness would maintain;

And in his father’s right, and realm’s defence,

Ne’er to have peace with wit, nor truce with sense.

The king himself the sacred unction made,

As king by office, and as priest by trade:

In his sinister hand, instead of ball,

He plac’d a mighty mug of potent ale;

Love’s kingdom to his right he did convey,

At once his sceptre and his rule of sway;

Whose righteous lore the prince had practis’d young,

And from whose loins recorded Psyche sprung,

His temples last with poppies were o’er spread,

That nodding seem’d to consecrate his head:

Just at that point of time, if fame not lie,

On his left hand twelve reverend owls did fly.

So Romulus, ’tis sung, by Tiber’s brook,

Presage of sway from twice six vultures took.

Th’admiring throng loud acclamations make,

And omens of his future empire take.

The sire then shook the honours of his head,

And from his brows damps of oblivion shed

Full on the filial dullness: long he stood,

Repelling from his breast the raging god;

At length burst out in this prophetic mood:

Heavens bless my son, from Ireland let him reign

To far Barbadoes on the Western main;

Of his dominion may no end be known,

And greater than his father’s be his throne.

Beyond love’s kingdom let him stretch his pen;

He paus’d, and all the people cry’d Amen.

Then thus, continu’d he, my son advance

Still in new impudence, new ignorance.

Success let other teach, learn thou from me

Pangs without birth, and fruitless industry.

Let Virtuosos in five years be writ;

Yet not one thought accuse thy toil of wit.

Let gentle George in triumph tread the stage,

Make Dorimant betray, and Loveit rage;

Let Cully, Cockwood, Fopling, charm the pit,

And in their folly show the writer’s wit.

Yet still thy fools shall stand in thy defence,

And justify their author’s want of sense.

Let ’em be all by thy own model made

Of dullness, and desire no foreign aid:

That they to future ages may be known,

Not copies drawn, but issue of thy own.

Nay let thy men of wit too be the same,

All full of thee, and differing but in name;

But let no alien Sedley interpose

To lard with wit thy hungry Epsom prose.

And when false flowers of rhetoric thou would’st cull,

Trust Nature, do not labour to be dull;

But write thy best, and top; and in each line,

Sir Formal’s oratory will be thine.

Sir Formal, though unsought, attends thy quill,

And does thy Northern Dedications fill.

Nor let false friends seduce thy mind to fame,

By arrogating Jonson’s hostile name.

Let Father Flecknoe fire thy mind with praise,

And Uncle Ogleby thy envy raise.

Thou art my blood, where Jonson has no part;

What share have we in Nature or in Art?

Where did his wit on learning fix a brand,

And rail at arts he did not understand?

Where made he love in Prince Nicander’s vein,

Or swept the dust in Psyche’s humble strain?

Where sold he bargains, whip-stitch, kiss my arse,

Promis’d a play and dwindled to a farce?

When did his muse from Fletcher scenes purloin,

As thou whole Eth’ridge dost transfuse to thine?

But so transfus’d as oil on waters flow,

His always floats above, thine sinks below.

This is thy province, this thy wondrous way,

New humours to invent for each new play:

This is that boasted bias of thy mind,

By which one way, to dullness, ’tis inclin’d,

Which makes thy writings lean on one side still,

And in all changes that way bends thy will.

Nor let thy mountain belly make pretence

Of likeness; thine’s a tympany of sense.

A tun of man in thy large bulk is writ,

But sure thou ‘rt but a kilderkin of wit.

Like mine thy gentle numbers feebly creep,

Thy Tragic Muse gives smiles, thy Comic sleep.

With whate’er gall thou sett’st thy self to write,

Thy inoffensive satires never bite.

In thy felonious heart, though venom lies,

It does but touch thy Irish pen, and dies.

Thy genius calls thee not to purchase fame

In keen iambics, but mild anagram:

Leave writing plays, and choose for thy command

Some peaceful province in acrostic land.

There thou may’st wings display and altars raise,

And torture one poor word ten thousand ways.

Or if thou would’st thy diff’rent talents suit,

Set thy own songs, and sing them to thy lute.

He said, but his last words were scarcely heard,

For Bruce and Longvil had a trap prepar’d,

And down they sent the yet declaiming bard.

Sinking he left his drugget robe behind,

Born upwards by a subterranean wind.

The mantle fell to the young prophet’s part,

With double portion of his father’s art.

Annotations: “Mac Flecknoe” by John Dryden
PassageAnnotation
“All human things are subject to decay, / And, when Fate summons, monarchs must obey:”Opening lines; Dryden alludes to the inevitability of decline and mortality, setting the scene for Flecknoe’s “succession” to Shadwell.
“This Flecknoe found, who, like Augustus, young / Was call’d to empire, and had govern’d long:”Flecknoe is mockingly compared to Emperor Augustus, suggesting his rule over the “realm of Nonsense” as one of misguided talent.
“Shadwell alone my perfect image bears, / Mature in dullness from his tender years.”Dryden sarcastically praises Shadwell, implying he has excelled in “dullness” since youth, unlike others who occasionally achieve wit.
“Some beams of wit on other souls may fall, / Strike through and make a lucid interval;”Dryden notes that others may have brief flashes of intelligence, but Shadwell remains perpetually and proudly dull.
“Besides his goodly fabric fills the eye, / And seems design’d for thoughtless majesty:”Shadwell’s physical appearance is grand, suited to a “majestic” role devoid of thought or wit.
“Thoughtless as monarch oaks, that shade the plain, / And, spread in solemn state, supinely reign.”Shadwell is compared to an oak tree, grand in appearance but inert and unthinking, reinforcing his portrayal as an unworthy leader.
“Heywood and Shirley were but types of thee, / Thou last great prophet of tautology:”Dryden mockingly names Shadwell as the “prophet of tautology,” implying his writing is redundant and devoid of meaning, unlike Heywood and Shirley who are lesser examples.
“Echoes from Pissing-Alley, Shadwell call, / And Shadwell they resound from Aston Hall.”Dryden references Pissing-Alley, a lowly area, to emphasize the wide reach of Shadwell’s lack of literary merit.
“Sometimes as prince of thy harmonious band / Thou wield’st thy papers in thy threshing hand.”Shadwell’s poetry is mocked as “threshing,” an agricultural metaphor suggesting crude, unrefined work.
“Here Flecknoe, as a place to fame well known, / Ambitiously design’d his Shadwell’s throne.”Flecknoe decides on a notorious, decaying location for Shadwell’s “coronation,” further underscoring the futility and lack of grandeur in Shadwell’s inheritance.
“An ancient fabric, rais’d t’inform the sight, / There stood of yore, and Barbican it hight:”Dryden references the Barbican, an old, decayed building symbolizing the ruinous legacy Shadwell is inheriting.
“Of all the pile an empty name remains. / From its old ruins brothel-houses rise,”Dryden uses the decayed building of Barbican as a metaphor for Shadwell’s literary inheritance – something once meaningful now in ruin and used for lowly purposes.
“Much Heywood, Shirley, Ogleby there lay, / But loads of Shadwell almost chok’d the way.”The path to Shadwell’s coronation is strewn with the works of lesser poets, including Heywood and Shirley, indicating the lowly position of these writers.
“Shadwell swore, nor should his vow be vain, / That he till death true dullness would maintain;”Shadwell takes a satirical oath to maintain “true dullness,” emphasizing Dryden’s contempt for Shadwell’s commitment to mediocrity.
“In his sinister hand, instead of ball, / He plac’d a mighty mug of potent ale;”The regal symbols are mocked; instead of a scepter, Shadwell holds ale, further undercutting his supposed “coronation.”
“Beyond love’s kingdom let him stretch his pen; / He paus’d, and all the people cry’d Amen.”Flecknoe’s wish for Shadwell’s “rule” to extend as far as possible is ironic, as it implies spreading his mediocrity further.
“Pangs without birth, and fruitless industry. / Let Virtuosos in five years be writ;”Dryden mocks Shadwell’s unproductive efforts, suggesting he works hard but produces nothing of value or originality.
“Success let other teach, learn thou from me / Pangs without birth, and fruitless industry.”Dryden satirically encourages Shadwell to embrace failure and unproductive effort rather than strive for literary success.
“Let gentle George in triumph tread the stage, / Make Dorimant betray, and Loveit rage;”Characters from popular plays of the time are mentioned, perhaps implying Shadwell’s characters will never achieve similar fame.
“Nor let thy mountain belly make pretence / Of likeness; thine’s a tympany of sense.”Dryden mocks Shadwell’s physical appearance and suggests his “bulk” is not matched by substance in wit or sense.
“Thy Tragic Muse gives smiles, thy Comic sleep.”Dryden criticizes Shadwell’s lack of skill in both tragedy and comedy, implying his works fail to evoke the intended emotional responses.
“Leave writing plays, and choose for thy command / Some peaceful province in acrostic land.”Dryden sarcastically advises Shadwell to abandon playwriting for simpler, non-dramatic forms like acrostics, suited to his limited abilities.
“Set thy own songs, and sing them to thy lute.”Another mock suggestion; Dryden implies Shadwell should focus on minor art forms, suggesting his talent isn’t suited to larger, respected genres.
“Sinking he left his drugget robe behind, / Born upwards by a subterranean wind.”In the final lines, Dryden completes Shadwell’s “coronation” into the realm of dullness, with a supernatural, yet ironic, elevation.
Literary And Poetic Devices: “Mac Flecknoe” by John Dryden
DeviceExampleExplanation
Alliteration” And, when Fate summons, monarchs must obey”Repetition of consonant sounds (e.g., monarchs and must) to create rhythm and emphasize phrases.
Allusion“like Augustus, young / Was call’d to empire”Reference to Emperor Augustus, ironically comparing Flecknoe’s rule of “nonsense” to the grandeur of Augustus.
Apostrophe“Heavens bless my son”Direct address to an absent or abstract entity (the heavens) to invoke blessings, often in a mock-serious tone.
Bathos“A tun of man in thy large bulk is writ, / But sure thou ‘rt but a kilderkin of wit.”A sudden drop from the serious or lofty to the trivial or ridiculous, enhancing the satire.
Classical Reference“Methinks I see the new Arion sail”Reference to the Greek poet and musician Arion, ironically associating Shadwell’s poetry with classical heroism.
Double Entendre“mighty mug of potent ale”Suggests both Shadwell’s dullness and his fondness for ale, mocking his lack of sophistication.
Extended Metaphor“Throne of Non-sense”The poem sustains the metaphor of monarchy, with Shadwell as the inheritor of Flecknoe’s “throne” of mediocrity.
Heroic Couplet“All human things are subject to decay, / And, when Fate summons, monarchs must obey:”Two rhymed lines of iambic pentameter used throughout the poem to provide a formal structure, which contrasts with the satirical tone.
Hyperbole“Of his dominion may no end be known”Exaggeration to emphasize Shadwell’s rule over dullness, mocking his ambition to rule over a “kingdom” of mediocrity.
Imagery“Echoes from Pissing-Alley, Shadwell call”Vivid imagery that conveys the lowliness of Shadwell’s influence, adding to the satirical effect.
Irony“Thou last great prophet of tautology”Dryden ironically calls Shadwell a “great prophet,” though he actually mocks his redundancy and lack of creativity.
Metaphor“mountain belly”Shadwell’s large physique is used as a metaphor for his bloated and unoriginal literary output.
Mock-Epic“As Hannibal did to the altars come, / Sworn by his sire a mortal foe to Rome”The mock-epic style elevates trivial subjects (Shadwell’s dullness) with heroic language, highlighting the satire.
Parody“Nor greater Jonson dares in socks appear”Dryden parodies Shadwell’s imitation of great dramatists like Jonson to highlight Shadwell’s inferior talent.
Personification“lambent dullness play’d around his face”Dullness is personified as if it has a tangible presence around Shadwell, reinforcing his mediocrity.
Sarcasm“Gentle George in triumph tread the stage”Dryden uses sarcasm by calling Shadwell “gentle,” when he actually intends to ridicule his incompetence.
Simile“Thoughtless as monarch oaks, that shade the plain”Comparison using “as” to highlight Shadwell’s immobility and lack of purpose, like a tree.
Symbolism“mighty mug of potent ale”The mug symbolizes Shadwell’s coarse tastes and lack of refinement, mocking his fitness as a “monarch.”
Synecdoche“Let gentle George in triumph tread the stage”The “stage” represents Shadwell’s entire career, reducing his efforts to a single setting of mockery.
Tautology“Thou last great prophet of tautology”Intentional use of redundant phrases to mock Shadwell’s repetitive and uncreative writing style.
Themes: “Mac Flecknoe” by John Dryden
  1. The Decline of Literary Standards: One of the primary themes in “Mac Flecknoe” is the degeneration of literary quality, particularly as represented by the character of Shadwell. Dryden portrays Shadwell as the epitome of dullness and mediocrity, symbolizing the decline in taste and talent in contemporary literature. The passage, “Shadwell alone my perfect image bears, / Mature in dullness from his tender years,” emphasizes Shadwell’s unvarying lack of wit, suggesting that he has consistently embodied literary failure. This theme reflects Dryden’s criticism of a cultural environment that, in his view, promotes uninspired and derivative work.
  2. Mock Heroism and Parody: Dryden employs the style and structure of epic poetry, traditionally used to exalt heroes, to mock and parody Shadwell’s literary ineptitude. Through this mock-heroic form, Dryden uses grandiose language and epic conventions to elevate the trivial subject of Shadwell’s coronation as the “king of dullness.” For instance, “Methinks I see the new Arion sail,” references the classical figure Arion but applies it ironically to Shadwell, whose artistic talent is nonexistent. This parody serves to ridicule Shadwell and satirize the misuse of epic forms for unworthy subjects.
  3. Inheritance and Succession of Dullness: The poem centers on the idea of Shadwell as the natural successor to Flecknoe’s “throne” of dullness, representing a satirical take on the theme of succession. The lines “This aged prince now flourishing in peace, / And blest with issue of a large increase,” suggest that Flecknoe’s lineage is one of literary ineptitude, and Shadwell is deemed the “worthy” heir. Dryden uses this theme to mock the notion of inherited genius, implying instead that Shadwell has inherited only his father’s incompetence and lack of creativity, making him a fitting ruler of a kingdom where mediocrity is the standard.
  4. The Futility of Ambition in the Absence of Talent: Another key theme is the mockery of ambition unaccompanied by genuine skill. Dryden satirizes Shadwell’s aspirations to literary fame and success, underscoring the futility of ambition without the talent to back it up. In the poem, Flecknoe advises Shadwell, “Learn thou from me / Pangs without birth, and fruitless industry,” portraying Shadwell’s literary efforts as fundamentally unproductive. This theme highlights Dryden’s disdain for writers who pursue literary renown without the requisite ability, emphasizing that ambition alone cannot create art or lasting value.
Literary Theories and “Mac Flecknoe” by John Dryden
Literary TheoryExplanationApplication in “Mac Flecknoe”
New HistoricismThis theory examines literature in the context of the historical and cultural circumstances of its creation, exploring how texts reflect or respond to their time.“Mac Flecknoe” reflects Restoration England’s literary culture and its decline, as Dryden critiques the era’s literary standards. The line “Shadwell alone my perfect image bears” alludes to how Dryden perceived the cultural shift towards mediocrity and derivative works, positioning Shadwell as emblematic of this decline.
Satire and Parody TheorySatire as a literary device involves ridiculing subjects, often using exaggeration or irony, to criticize individuals or social norms. Parody specifically imitates genres or styles for comedic effect.Dryden employs both satire and parody to mock Thomas Shadwell, presenting him as the “king of dullness.” By ironically crowning Shadwell in a mock-heroic tone—”High on a throne of his own labours rear’d”—Dryden parodies epic traditions to criticize Shadwell’s perceived lack of talent.
Biographical CriticismThis theory connects an author’s personal experiences, relationships, and social context with their literary work, highlighting how these factors shape a text’s themes and tone.Dryden’s personal rivalry with Shadwell shapes “Mac Flecknoe”‘s tone and content. His disdain for Shadwell’s style is evident in lines like “The rest to some faint meaning make pretence, / But Shadwell never deviates into sense,” which directly attacks Shadwell’s intellectual capabilities, revealing Dryden’s personal animosity.
Critical Questions about “Mac Flecknoe” by John Dryden
  • How does Dryden use the mock-heroic form to enhance his satire in “Mac Flecknoe”?
  • Dryden’s use of the mock-heroic form amplifies his satire by juxtaposing epic conventions with a trivial subject—Shadwell’s incompetence. Traditionally, the heroic form is reserved for grand narratives about noble characters, but Dryden subverts this to elevate Shadwell’s mediocrity to epic proportions, creating a comedic effect. In lines like “Methinks I see the new Arion sail,” Dryden compares Shadwell to the mythical Arion, a revered poet and musician, to highlight Shadwell’s lack of comparable talent. This contrast between form and subject underscores the absurdity of Shadwell’s pretensions and highlights Dryden’s disdain for his literary rival, ultimately making Shadwell’s lack of skill appear even more glaring.
  • What role does the theme of succession play in Dryden’s critique of Shadwell’s literary abilities?
  • Succession, a key theme in “Mac Flecknoe,” is used to critique Shadwell by casting him as the rightful heir to a kingdom of “nonsense.” Dryden frames Flecknoe’s abdication as a parody of royal succession, but instead of bequeathing a legacy of greatness, Flecknoe bestows his “throne” of dullness on Shadwell. When Flecknoe declares, “Shadwell alone my perfect image bears,” he cynically praises Shadwell for embodying all the qualities of mediocrity. By presenting Shadwell as a successor, Dryden mocks his literary legacy, implying that Shadwell’s “inheritance” will only further the decline of literary quality, perpetuating a lineage of untalented writers.
  • How does Dryden use imagery to convey his disdain for Shadwell’s work?
  • Dryden’s disdain for Shadwell is palpable through his use of unflattering imagery that reduces Shadwell’s literary achievements to absurd and crude comparisons. In lines like “Echoes from Pissing-Alley, Shadwell call,” Dryden conjures a lowly image of Shadwell’s work as something emanating from a sordid, derelict alley. By placing Shadwell in such ignoble surroundings, Dryden emphasizes the vulgarity and lack of refinement in Shadwell’s literary output. Additionally, the image of Shadwell’s “mighty mug of potent ale” during his coronation ridicules any notion of grandeur, associating Shadwell with coarseness and a lack of intellectual sophistication. This imagery not only mocks Shadwell but also critiques the literary culture Dryden believed Shadwell represented.
  • In what ways does Dryden’s personal rivalry with Shadwell shape the tone and content of “Mac Flecknoe”?
  • The tone and content of “Mac Flecknoe” are heavily influenced by Dryden’s personal animosity toward Shadwell, transforming the poem into a pointed attack rather than a detached critique. Dryden’s language is laced with scorn, as he continually demeans Shadwell’s intelligence and literary skills, calling him the “last great prophet of tautology.” Such phrases suggest that Dryden viewed Shadwell’s work not only as devoid of wit but as an offense to true artistry. This personal rivalry adds a layer of intensity to the satire, as Dryden doesn’t merely dismiss Shadwell’s work; he actively seeks to degrade his reputation. This personal vendetta sharpens the poem’s tone, making it a passionate, if scornful, critique rather than an impartial observation.
Literary Works Similar to “Mac Flecknoe” by John Dryden
  1. “The Dunciad” by Alexander Pope – Similar to Mac Flecknoe, this satirical poem mocks mediocrity and poor taste in literature, targeting those Pope deemed culturally degenerate.
  2. “Absalom and Achitophel” by John Dryden – Another of Dryden’s satires, it uses biblical allegory to critique political figures, employing the same mock-heroic style seen in Mac Flecknoe.
  3. “Hudibras” by Samuel Butler – This satirical poem critiques hypocrisy and pretension in society, using humor and exaggerated characters similar to Dryden’s approach to ridiculing Shadwell.
  4. “The Rolliad” (Anonymous) – A satire on British politics and literature, this poem, like Mac Flecknoe, uses parody and ridicule to expose what the authors saw as cultural and intellectual decline.
  5. “Don Juan” by Lord Byron – Though more narrative, Byron’s poem shares Mac Flecknoe‘s satirical tone and mock-heroic style to critique societal norms and the pretensions of individuals.
Representative Quotations of “Mac Flecknoe” by John Dryden
QuotationContextTheoretical Perspective
“All human things are subject to decay, / And, when Fate summons, monarchs must obey:”Opening lines, setting a somber, universal truth in a mock-heroic tone as a prelude to Flecknoe’s abdication.Satire Theory – Highlights the inevitability of decay to mock Shadwell’s mediocrity by elevating it to an “epic” level of decline.
“Shadwell alone my perfect image bears, / Mature in dullness from his tender years.”Flecknoe names Shadwell as his successor, sarcastically praising his lack of wit and intellectual growth.Biographical Criticism – Reflects Dryden’s personal disdain for Shadwell’s literary style, targeting him directly.
“Some beams of wit on other souls may fall, / Strike through and make a lucid interval;”Dryden contrasts Shadwell with other poets, implying Shadwell lacks even momentary inspiration.New Historicism – Dryden critiques contemporary literary culture by implying that even the lowest writers occasionally achieve some wit.
“But Shadwell never deviates into sense.”Dryden’s pointed insult at Shadwell’s unchanging dullness and inability to produce meaningful work.Satire and Parody Theory – Exemplifies Dryden’s direct ridicule through exaggerated insult, enhancing the satirical tone.
“Besides his goodly fabric fills the eye, / And seems design’d for thoughtless majesty:”Describes Shadwell’s physical appearance as suited to a king, mockingly associating grandeur with shallowness.New Criticism – Uses irony to subvert the traditional association of majesty with wisdom, implying Shadwell’s superficiality.
“Thou last great prophet of tautology:”Dryden mocks Shadwell’s redundant writing style, calling him a prophet of unnecessary repetition.Formalism – Highlights Shadwell’s lack of creativity by focusing on his repetitive structure and content.
“Echoes from Pissing-Alley, Shadwell call, / And Shadwell they resound from Aston Hall.”Dryden’s use of lowly imagery to depict the widespread influence of Shadwell’s “dullness” in society.Cultural Criticism – Dryden criticizes the spread of poor taste, symbolized by Shadwell, across different social strata.
“The hoary prince in majesty appear’d, / High on a throne of his own labours rear’d.”Flecknoe seated on his “throne,” made from his body of work, elevates Shadwell’s mediocrity with irony.Mock-Epic Theory – Uses the epic throne imagery to ridicule Shadwell’s literary incompetence as if it were majestic.
“Methinks I see the new Arion sail, / The lute still trembling underneath thy nail.”Ironically compares Shadwell to Arion, a mythological figure of poetic excellence, for comedic effect.Intertextuality – Draws from mythological references to satirically juxtapose Shadwell with a great poet, underscoring his flaws.
“Pangs without birth, and fruitless industry.”Flecknoe’s advice to Shadwell to pursue pointless endeavors, reinforcing his ineptitude.Psychoanalytic Criticism – Represents Shadwell’s creative impotence, suggesting an inability to achieve meaningful expression.
Suggested Readings: “Mac Flecknoe” by John Dryden
  1. West, Michael. “Some Neglected Continental Analogues for Dryden’s Mac Flecknoe.” Studies in English Literature, 1500-1900, vol. 13, no. 3, 1973, pp. 437–49. JSTOR, https://doi.org/10.2307/449998. Accessed 9 Nov. 2024.
  2. Wilkinson, John. “A Note on Language in Dryden’s ‘Mac Flecknoe.'” Restoration: Studies in English Literary Culture, 1660-1700, vol. 4, no. 1, 1980, pp. 9–10. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/43292457. Accessed 9 Nov. 2024.
  3. Dearing, Vinton A. “Dryden’s ‘Mac Flecknoe’: The Case for Authorial Revision.” Studies in Bibliography, vol. 7, 1955, pp. 85–102. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/40372123. Accessed 9 Nov. 2024.
  4. Castrop, Helmut. “Dryden and Flecknoe: A Link.” The Review of English Studies, vol. 23, no. 92, 1972, pp. 455–58. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/514093. Accessed 9 Nov. 2024.
  5. Pritchard, William H. “Dryden Rules.” The Hudson Review, vol. 58, no. 4, 2006, pp. 541–67. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/20464480. Accessed 9 Nov. 2024.
  6. McKeithan, D. M. “The Occasion of Macflecknoe.” PMLA, vol. 47, no. 3, 1932, pp. 766–71. JSTOR, https://doi.org/10.2307/457952. Accessed 9 Nov. 2024.

“Love After Love” by Derek Walcott: A Critical Analysis

“Love After Love” by Derek Walcott, first appeared in his 1976 poetry collection Sea Grapes, is widely celebrated for its powerful themes of self-discovery and self-reconciliation, offering readers a contemplative journey towards self-love.

"Love After Love" by Derek Walcott: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “Love After Love” by Derek Walcott

“Love After Love” by Derek Walcott, first appeared in his 1976 poetry collection Sea Grapes, is widely celebrated for its powerful themes of self-discovery and self-reconciliation, offering readers a contemplative journey towards self-love. In simple yet profound language, Walcott encourages the reader to embrace and rediscover their own identity, especially after times of hardship or loss. The poem’s popularity lies in its universal message of healing and self-acceptance, resonating with audiences who find solace in its gentle invitation to “feast on your life.” Walcott’s words remind readers of the importance of self-compassion and the joy in reuniting with the “stranger” within, a message that has continued to impact readers across generations.

Text: “Love After Love” by Derek Walcott

The time will come
when, with elation
you will greet yourself arriving
at your own door, in your own mirror
and each will smile at the other’s welcome,

and say, sit here. Eat.
You will love again the stranger who was your self.
Give wine. Give bread. Give back your heart
to itself, to the stranger who has loved you

all your life, whom you ignored
for another, who knows you by heart.
Take down the love letters from the bookshelf,

the photographs, the desperate notes,
peel your own image from the mirror.
Sit. Feast on your life.

Annotations: “Love After Love” by Derek Walcott
LineAnnotation
The time will comeThe line suggests a future moment of personal significance, foreshadowing a period of healing, self-recognition, or inner awakening.
when, with elation“Elation” implies intense joy or relief, indicating that this encounter with oneself will be uplifting and transformative.
you will greet yourself arrivingThis line evokes the image of meeting oneself as a stranger or friend, symbolizing the journey to self-recognition and self-acceptance.
at your own door, in your own mirrorThe imagery of “door” and “mirror” suggests an intimate, personal space where one encounters their true self, free from others’ influences.
and each will smile at the other’s welcome,There’s a sense of mutual acceptance and harmony as one reconciles with their own identity, marking a moment of self-approval.
and say, sit here. Eat.This invitation to “sit” and “eat” symbolizes self-care and nurturing, urging the reader to honor their own needs and desires.
You will love again the stranger who was your self.This powerful line reflects on the concept of self-alienation, suggesting that one will rediscover affection for the part of themselves they had forgotten.
Give wine. Give bread.“Wine” and “bread” are symbols of sustenance and celebration, representing a ritual of communion and nourishment, often used in spiritual or self-reflective contexts.
Give back your heartThe line calls for an emotional reclaiming, encouraging the reader to reconnect with their own heart and passions, without external influences.
to itself, to the stranger who has loved youThis part personifies the “stranger” within as a caring presence, reminding the reader that their true self has always been present and supportive.
all your life, whom you ignoredWalcott addresses self-neglect, the way one may prioritize others over their own needs and identity, leading to a loss of self.
for another, who knows you by heart.The “stranger” represents the inner self that truly understands and loves the individual deeply, despite being overlooked.
Take down the love letters from the bookshelf,This line suggests revisiting past memories or expressions of love, urging one to reconnect with their history and emotions stored away.
the photographs, the desperate notes,By mentioning “photographs” and “desperate notes,” Walcott references tangible memories, which hold pieces of one’s identity and experiences.
peel your own image from the mirror.This metaphor represents shedding external layers or perceptions to reveal the authentic self beneath, an act of self-liberation.
Sit. Feast on your life.The final line is an invitation to celebrate oneself fully, to appreciate one’s life experiences, and to find contentment within.
Literary And Poetic Devices: “Love After Love” by Derek Walcott
DeviceExampleExplanation
Alliteration“will welcome,” “say, sit,” “love letters”Repeated consonant sounds create a rhythmic quality, emphasizing certain phrases and lending a soothing tone to the poem.
Anaphora“Give wine. Give bread. Give back your heart”The repetition of “Give” at the start of lines emphasizes generosity toward oneself, underscoring the idea of self-nurturing and acceptance.
Apostrophe“You will love again the stranger who was your self.”Directly addressing the reader as “you” creates intimacy, making the poem’s message feel personal and encouraging self-reflection.
Assonance“stranger” and “was your”The repeated vowel sound “a” in “stranger” and “was your” creates a gentle flow, enhancing the contemplative tone of the poem.
Caesura“sit here. Eat.”The period creates a pause mid-line, which emphasizes the invitation to “sit” and “eat,” reinforcing the importance of slowing down to care for oneself.
Consonance“at your own door, in your own mirror”The repeated “r” sound in “your,” “door,” and “mirror” ties the phrases together, creating a rhythmic unity that reinforces the idea of self-reflection.
Enjambment“The time will come / when, with elation”The line break without punctuation leads smoothly into the next line, which mirrors the continuous flow of self-discovery and reconnection described in the poem.
Epiphany“You will love again the stranger who was your self.”The line captures a moment of realization, where the speaker understands the importance of self-love, marking a revelation or epiphany for the reader.
Imagery“take down the love letters from the bookshelf”Creates a vivid visual image that evokes memories and nostalgia, encouraging the reader to reflect on their past relationships with themselves.
Irony“the stranger who was your self”The use of “stranger” to describe oneself is ironic, suggesting that while one should know themselves best, they have become unfamiliar with their own identity.
Metaphor“peel your own image from the mirror”“Peel” implies removing layers to uncover the true self, suggesting that self-identity is hidden beneath external facades or societal expectations.
MotifFood and drink references: “wine,” “bread,” “feast”These symbols of nourishment and communion create a motif of self-care and celebration, emphasizing the importance of cherishing oneself.
Paradox“the stranger who was your self”Describing oneself as both “stranger” and “self” is paradoxical, highlighting the disconnection one can feel from their inner identity and the need for reconciliation.
Personification“the stranger who has loved you”The inner self is personified as a caring, loving entity that has been present throughout, underscoring the enduring nature of self-love even when neglected.
Repetition“Give wine. Give bread. Give back your heart.”Repetition of “Give” emphasizes generosity and ritual, suggesting that self-love is an act of kindness that requires deliberate action and repeated effort.
Simile“you will greet yourself arriving / at your own door”While not a direct simile, the poem evokes a feeling akin to greeting someone else, suggesting that self-reconnection is like meeting an old friend.
Symbolism“wine,” “bread,” “mirror,” “love letters”Each item symbolizes different aspects of self-identity (wine and bread as sustenance, mirror as reflection, love letters as memories), enhancing the poem’s meaning.
ToneGentle and reflectiveThe tone is calm and nurturing, encouraging the reader to approach self-reflection with compassion and patience, which aligns with the theme of self-love.
ThemeSelf-love and reconciliationThe poem’s overarching theme is the importance of self-love, guiding readers to reconnect with and embrace their own identities after a period of self-neglect.
Visual Imagery“Sit. Feast on your life.”Conjures an image of celebration and abundance, encouraging the reader to indulge in the richness of their own life experiences and achievements.
Themes: “Love After Love” by Derek Walcott
  1. Self-Reconciliation and Acceptance: A central theme of “Love After Love” is the journey of reconciling with oneself and embracing self-acceptance. Walcott encourages the reader to “greet yourself arriving / at your own door, in your own mirror,” an image that suggests meeting oneself as if for the first time. This idea of returning to one’s true identity after periods of self-neglect is at the heart of the poem, highlighting the importance of self-compassion and reconciliation. By calling on readers to “peel your own image from the mirror,” Walcott suggests that self-acceptance requires shedding superficial layers to connect deeply with the authentic self within.
  2. Rediscovery of Self-Love: Walcott’s poem emphasizes the rediscovery of self-love, especially after losing oneself in relationships or the expectations of others. The line “You will love again the stranger who was your self” speaks to the idea of self-love being rediscovered after a time of alienation from one’s true identity. Walcott paints self-love as a nurturing, almost celebratory process, urging readers to “Give wine. Give bread.” Through these images of nourishment, he suggests that self-love is essential sustenance, a kind of spiritual food that one must learn to give themselves.
  3. Healing and Inner Peace: The poem suggests that true healing lies in reconnecting with oneself and attaining inner peace. Phrases like “you will greet yourself” and “each will smile at the other’s welcome” evoke a peaceful reunion, implying that finding inner peace is not only possible but necessary. This healing process is not just about forgiveness but a joyful reunion with one’s true self. Walcott’s gentle invitation to “Sit. Feast on your life” at the poem’s conclusion reinforces the idea that healing involves embracing and celebrating one’s life experiences, no matter how difficult.
  4. Letting Go of Past Attachments: “Love After Love” also touches on the theme of releasing the past and moving forward with self-awareness. The lines “Take down the love letters from the bookshelf, / the photographs, the desperate notes” encourage the reader to let go of past memories and attachments that may be holding them back from fully embracing themselves. By advising readers to “peel your own image from the mirror,” Walcott suggests a metaphorical shedding of the past, allowing one’s true self to emerge unburdened by previous relationships or regrets. This release from the past enables a new beginning, rooted in a clearer understanding of self.
Literary Theories and “Love After Love” by Derek Walcott
Literary TheoryApplication to “Love After Love”References from the Poem
Psychoanalytic TheoryThis theory, particularly Jungian concepts of self and individuation, is relevant as the poem emphasizes self-reconciliation and meeting one’s inner “stranger.” The journey to reclaim the “stranger who was your self” aligns with Jung’s idea of the shadow self, where aspects of one’s identity that have been repressed or neglected are reintegrated into consciousness.“You will love again the stranger who was your self” and “Give back your heart to itself, to the stranger who has loved you” suggest reconnecting with a forgotten or repressed self, highlighting a psychoanalytic exploration of the subconscious.
Existentialist TheoryExistentialism’s focus on authenticity, self-identity, and the search for personal meaning is echoed in the poem’s emphasis on self-reliance and acceptance. Walcott’s message encourages embracing one’s own life as a meaningful, self-defined existence, urging readers to live genuinely rather than seeking fulfillment from external sources.“Sit. Feast on your life” represents an existential call to embrace one’s experiences fully and find meaning within oneself, rather than through external attachments or others’ expectations.
Postcolonial TheoryThrough a postcolonial lens, the poem’s message of rediscovering and celebrating one’s identity can be interpreted as a reclamation of self, often necessary in postcolonial contexts where identity has been shaped or suppressed by colonial influences. Walcott’s Jamaican heritage and his broader works often explore identity and selfhood in relation to cultural recovery, which resonates in this poem.“Take down the love letters from the bookshelf” and “peel your own image from the mirror” suggest shedding past influences or imposed identities, symbolizing a return to a truer, possibly decolonized self.
Critical Questions about “Love After Love” by Derek Walcott
  • How does the poem challenge conventional ideas of self-worth and self-love?
  • “Love After Love” redefines self-love as an inward journey rather than something dependent on others’ validation. Instead of seeking love externally, Walcott encourages readers to embrace self-compassion, urging them to “give back your heart / to itself, to the stranger who has loved you.” This line suggests that self-worth is inherent, rooted in recognizing and valuing oneself despite past tendencies to “ignore” the self in favor of others. By framing self-love as something to “feast on,” Walcott implies that true fulfillment is internal, a radical challenge to traditional views that associate worth with external relationships or societal approval.
  • What role does memory play in the process of self-recovery presented in the poem?
  • Memory is depicted as both a foundation for identity and something that must be selectively let go in the journey toward self-recovery. Walcott writes, “Take down the love letters from the bookshelf, / the photographs, the desperate notes,” symbolizing memories that once defined the self or attached it to others. This invitation to revisit and then set aside memories suggests that while the past shapes us, it should not constrain our present identity. By acknowledging these past “desperate notes” and letting them go, the reader is encouraged to reclaim their life independently, free from the hold of past attachments.
  • In what way does the poem’s structure enhance its message about self-reflection and self-discovery?
  • The poem’s free verse structure and use of enjambment create a fluid, contemplative rhythm that mirrors the ongoing nature of self-reflection and discovery. Lines such as “The time will come / when, with elation / you will greet yourself arriving” flow smoothly into one another, symbolizing the continuous journey of self-acceptance. This lack of rigid structure reflects the personal and unstructured nature of self-discovery, highlighting that healing and self-love are processes without strict boundaries or linear paths. The pauses in the poem, such as “sit here. Eat,” serve as moments of introspection, encouraging the reader to pause and reflect on their own journey.
  • How does the poem explore the theme of identity and its connection to solitude?
  • The poem presents solitude not as isolation but as an essential condition for reconnecting with one’s identity. The imagery of “greet yourself arriving / at your own door, in your own mirror” reflects an encounter with oneself that requires solitude, a step away from external distractions or dependencies. Walcott’s lines “Sit. Feast on your life” suggest that one’s identity and fulfillment are to be discovered individually, within the space of one’s own experience. In exploring identity through solitude, Walcott implies that true understanding and acceptance of oneself come from within, not from relationships or society, presenting solitude as a form of self-respect and self-awareness.
Literary Works Similar to “Love After Love” by Derek Walcott
  1. “Wild Geese” by Mary Oliver – This poem, like Walcott’s, encourages self-compassion and emphasizes the importance of accepting one’s imperfections and living authentically.
  2. “The Journey” by Mary Oliver – Oliver’s poem mirrors Walcott’s theme of self-discovery and courage, as it explores the need to break away from others’ expectations and reclaim one’s own life.
  3. “Phenomenal Woman” by Maya Angelou – Angelou’s work celebrates self-love and inner beauty, resonating with Walcott’s emphasis on valuing oneself without external validation.
  4. “Invictus” by William Ernest Henley – Henley’s poem, like Walcott’s, focuses on inner strength and resilience, inspiring readers to overcome adversity and embrace their own power.
  5. “I Am Not Yours” by Sara Teasdale – Teasdale’s poem reflects themes of independence and self-possession, resonating with Walcott’s focus on reclaiming one’s heart and identity from external attachments.
Representative Quotations
QuotationContextTheoretical Perspective
“The time will come”Opening line that introduces the promise of future self-reconciliation.Existentialism – Emphasizes a crucial moment of self-discovery and the inevitability of personal growth.
“you will greet yourself arriving”Suggests a transformative encounter with one’s own self, an act of self-recognition.Psychoanalytic Theory – Symbolizes a confrontation with the inner self, akin to Jung’s concept of individuation.
“at your own door, in your own mirror”Implies that this self-encounter takes place in an intimate space, both physical and metaphorical.Phenomenology – The “door” and “mirror” are symbols of self-perception and self-experience.
“and each will smile at the other’s welcome”Depicts mutual acceptance and peace between one’s external and inner self.Humanistic Theory – Suggests self-acceptance as a path toward personal fulfillment and wholeness.
“You will love again the stranger who was your self.”Reflects on rediscovering the inner self, once lost or ignored.Psychoanalytic Theory – The “stranger” represents the shadow self, a concept rooted in Jungian psychology.
“Give wine. Give bread.”An invitation to nurture oneself with spiritual and emotional sustenance.Symbolism – Uses bread and wine as symbols of self-nourishment, similar to spiritual rituals of communion.
“Give back your heart to itself”Suggests reclaiming one’s love and attention, often given to others, back for oneself.Existentialism – Emphasizes autonomy and self-possession, central to existentialist views of self-identity.
“Take down the love letters from the bookshelf”Calls to revisit memories or attachments that shaped identity, before letting them go.Psychoanalytic Theory – Reflects the process of unpacking repressed emotions and past attachments.
“peel your own image from the mirror.”Implies removing layers of external influence to reveal the authentic self.Postcolonial Theory – Suggests shedding imposed identities or perceptions created by external expectations.
“Sit. Feast on your life.”The poem’s closing line, urging readers to fully embrace and celebrate their own life experiences.Humanistic Theory – Celebrates self-actualization, encouraging fulfillment and appreciation of one’s own life.
Suggested Readings: “Love After Love” by Derek Walcott
  1. Balakian, Peter. “The Poetry of Derek Walcott.” Poetry, vol. 148, no. 3, 1986, pp. 169–77. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/20600767. Accessed 9 Nov. 2024.
  2. Mitchell, Michael. Journal of Indentureship and Its Legacies, vol. 1, no. 1, 2021, pp. 188–95. JSTOR, https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.13169/jofstudindentleg.1.1.0188. Accessed 9 Nov. 2024.
  3. MASON, DAVID. “The Fame of Derek Walcott.” The Hudson Review, vol. 67, no. 3, 2014, pp. 505–13. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/43488922. Accessed 9 Nov. 2024.
  4. Mayer, Pamela S. “Introduction.” Journal of Aesthetic Education, vol. 30, no. 4, 1996, pp. 1–4. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/3333176. Accessed 9 Nov. 2024.