Logocentrism in Literature & Literary Theory

In its philosophical and literary context, logocentrism emerged as a concept associated with structuralist and poststructuralist thought.

Etymology of Logocentrism

The term logocentrism has its roots in Greek and Latin etymology. It combines “logos,” a Greek word meaning “word” or “reason,” and “centrism,” derived from the Latin word “centrum,” meaning “center.”

In its philosophical and literary context, logocentrism emerged as a concept associated with structuralist and poststructuralist thought. It refers to a belief in the central and privileged position of language and reason in human cognition, where language is seen as the ultimate source of meaning and authority.

Poststructuralist thinkers, notably Jacques Derrida, critiqued logocentrism, arguing that it overlooks the inherent instability and ambiguity of language and challenges the assumption of a fixed and central source of meaning.

Meanings of Logocentrism
MeaningExplanation
Primacy of LanguageIt is a belief in language as the central source of meaning.
Binary OppositionsIt uses opposing pairs to establish hierarchical meaning.
Fixed MeaningsIt supports the assumption that words have stable, accurate meanings.
Hierarchical StructuresCreation of authority-based language hierarchies.
Critique in Literary TheoryPoststructuralists challenge to logocentric ideas in literature.
DeconstructionIt is about the movement to reveal contradictions in language and text.
Emphasis on the Written WordPriority is given to written language over spoken language.
Challenges to AuthorityIt subverts traditional language structures and meanings.
Questioning Stable MeaningIt is the exploration of fluidity and ambiguity of language in literature.
Definition of Logocentrism as a Theoretical Term

Logocentrism is a theoretical term that refers to the philosophical and linguistic belief in the inherent centrality and primacy of language, particularly written language, in shaping and representing human thought, meaning, and reality.

It posits that words and language possess stable and fixed meanings, often overlooking the inherent ambiguity and fluidity of linguistic signs. Logocentrism has been a subject of critique in literary theory, especially within poststructuralism, which challenges the assumption of a central, authoritative source of meaning in texts and language.

Logocentrism: Theorists, Works, and Arguments
Theorists:
  • Jacques Derrida: Derrida is a prominent figure who critiqued logocentrism in his work, particularly in Of Grammatology. He argued that language is inherently unstable and that there is no ultimate source of meaning, challenging the idea of a central, fixed signifier.
  • Ferdinand de Saussure: Saussure’s structuralist linguistics played a foundational role in discussions of logocentrism. His distinction between signifier and signified contributed to the exploration of how language operates in constructing meaning hierarchies.
Works:
  • Of Grammatology by Jacques Derrida: This seminal work by Derrida is a key text in which he deconstructs the logocentric assumptions of Western philosophy and linguistics. He introduces the concept of “différance” to illustrate the inherent instability of language and the absence of a fixed center.
  • Course in General Linguistics by Ferdinand de Saussure: Saussure’s work, posthumously published, outlines his structuralist theories on language and semiotics, which have been influential in discussions of logocentrism.
Key Arguments:
  • Challenges to Fixed Meaning: Logocentrism has been critiqued for overlooking the complexities of language and the multiple interpretations that can arise from a single text. Critics argue that it fails to acknowledge the fluidity and diversity of meanings that language can convey.
  • Deconstruction as a Response: Many literary theorists, influenced by Derrida’s deconstructive approach, have used deconstruction to challenge logocentric assumptions in literary analysis. They emphasize the instability of language and the interplay of multiple interpretations.
  • Poststructuralism: Logocentrism is a central target of poststructuralist literary theory, which seeks to dismantle hierarchical structures of meaning and question the idea of a central, authoritative source of signification in texts.
Logocentrism and Literary Theories
Structuralism:
  • Logocentrism plays a role in structuralist literary theory by highlighting the role of language in constructing meaning. Structuralists examine how binary oppositions and linguistic structures contribute to logocentric hierarchies within texts. For example, they analyze how certain terms or concepts are privileged over others based on linguistic structures.
Deconstruction:
  • Deconstruction, often associated with Jacques Derrida, is a response to logocentrism. It challenges logocentric assumptions by revealing the instability and ambiguity of language. Deconstructionists emphasize that language lacks a fixed center of meaning, leading to multiple interpretations. Derrida’s work, such as Of Grammatology, deconstructs logocentric notions by introducing concepts like “différance” to disrupt the idea of a central signifier.
Poststructuralism:
  • Poststructuralist literary theory builds on the deconstructive critique of logocentrism. It questions the idea of a central, authoritative source of meaning in texts and highlights the role of language in constructing multiple, contingent interpretations. Poststructuralists explore how power dynamics, ideology, and cultural context shape logocentric hierarchies within literature.
Feminist Theory:
  • In feminist literary theory, logocentrism is relevant in discussions of gendered language and its impact on literature. Feminists critique logocentric structures that may reinforce patriarchal norms and privilege male perspectives. They examine how language constructs gender identities and may marginalize women’s voices.
Queer Theory:
  • Queer theorists engage with logocentrism by exploring non-normative experiences of gender and sexuality. They challenge logocentric ideas that may reinforce heteronormative conventions and explore how language constructs and deconstructs queer identities and desires.
Narrative Theory:
  • In narrative theory, logocentrism can be relevant when examining the role of language in constructing narrative structures and meaning. Scholars analyze how logocentric hierarchies within a narrative shape the reader’s interpretation and engagement with the text.
Cultural Studies:
  • Cultural critics within cultural studies use logocentrism to critique societal norms and values depicted in literature. They explore how texts may reinforce or challenge logocentric assumptions within specific cultural contexts, shedding light on power dynamics and ideologies.
Logocentrism in Literary Criticism
  1. Wide Sargasso Sea by Jean Rhys:
    • In Wide Sargasso Sea, logocentrism is explored through the character of Bertha Mason, who is the Creole wife of Mr. Rochester from Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre. Rhys deconstructs the logocentric representation of Bertha in the original text, providing her with a voice and agency. This challenges the hierarchical structures of colonial and patriarchal discourse present in Jane Eyre and questions the fixed meanings associated with Bertha’s character.
  2. The Bluest Eye by Toni Morrison:
    • Morrison’s The Bluest Eye challenges logocentrism by deconstructing the traditional standards of beauty and identity in literature. The novel explores how language and societal norms construct the concept of beauty as fixed and central, particularly concerning race and gender. Through her characters, Morrison questions the logocentric ideals that underlie such constructs.
  3. The Sound and the Fury by William Faulkner:
    • Faulkner’s modernist masterpiece, The Sound and the Fury, employs multiple narrative perspectives and a fragmented structure to deconstruct logocentrism. The novel challenges the idea of a singular, central narrative voice and highlights the limitations of language in representing subjective experiences. The characters’ internal monologues reveal the instability of meaning and the absence of a fixed center in their individual narratives.
  4. Kindred by Octavia E. Butler:
    • In Kindred, Octavia Butler engages with logocentrism through the narrative’s exploration of time and history. The protagonist, Dana, time-travels between the 20th century and a pre-Civil War plantation. This temporal liminality challenges logocentric historical narratives by exposing the fluidity and complexity of history and its representation. The novel raises questions about the authority of historical texts and the instability of historical meaning.
Suggested Readings
  1. Derrida, Jacques. Of Grammatology. Translated by Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak, Johns Hopkins University Press, 1997.
  2. Saussure, Ferdinand de. Course in General Linguistics. Edited by Charles Bally and Albert Sechehaye, Translated by Wade Baskin, McGraw-Hill Education, 2011.
  3. Culler, Jonathan. On Deconstruction: Theory and Criticism after Structuralism. Cornell University Press, 1983.
  4. Norris, Christopher. Deconstruction: Theory and Practice. Routledge, 2002.
  5. Wolfreys, Julian. Derrida: A Guide for the Perplexed. Continuum, 2008.
  6. Johnson, Barbara. The Critical Difference: Essays in the Contemporary Rhetoric of Reading. Johns Hopkins University Press, 1985.
  7. Hartman, Geoffrey H. Saving the Text: Literature/Derrida/Philosophy. Johns Hopkins University Press, 1981.
  8. Spivak, Gayatri Chakravorty. Outside in the Teaching Machine. Routledge, 1993.
  9. Kamuf, Peggy. Signature Pieces: On the Institution of Authorship. Cornell University Press, 1991.
  10. Gasché, Rodolphe. The Tain of the Mirror: Derrida and the Philosophy of Reflection. Harvard University Press, 1986.

Machine Subjectivity in Literature & Literary Theory

Machine Subjectivity has its roots at the intersection of two distinct domains: machine learning and philosophy.

Etymology of Machine Subjectivity

Machine Subjectivity has its roots at the intersection of two distinct domains: machine learning and philosophy. In the context of machine learning, it refers to the capacity of artificial intelligence systems to mimic or emulate human-like subjective experiences, emotions, or decision-making processes.

This concept draws inspiration from philosophical inquiries into the nature of subjectivity, consciousness, and self-awareness.

The term serves as a bridge between these fields, encapsulating the endeavor to imbue machines with a semblance of subjectivity.

This, in turn, sparks discussions on the ethical, epistemological, and ontological implications of such technological advancements in the quest to understand and replicate human cognition.

Meanings of Machine Subjectivity
AspectDescription
Narrative PerspectiveIt means to examine the narrative perspective generated by artificial intelligence and its impact on storytelling in literature.
Character DevelopmentIt means exploring how AI-generated characters can exhibit subjective traits and evolve within a narrative, challenging traditional notions of character development.
Reader EngagementIt means to investigate how AI-driven narratives can effectively engage readers on an emotional and subjective level, raising questions about the authenticity of these experiences.
Authorship and CreativityIt means challenging conventional ideas of authorship and creativity by exploring AI-authored literature, prompting discussions about the human author’s role in a machine-assisted literary landscape.
Identity and OthernessIt means focusing on the portrayal of machine characters’ identities and their interactions with human characters, often serving as metaphors to explore issues of otherness and social identity in literature.
Ethical and Philosophical InquiriesIt means examining the ethical and philosophical implications of AI-generated narratives, questioning the boundaries of human creativity and empathy in the literary realm.
Definition of Machine Subjectivity as a Theoretical Term

Machine Subjectivity, as a theoretical term, refers to artificial intelligence systems emulating and simulating human-like subjective experiences, emotions, and cognitive processes within computational frameworks.

It encompasses how machines, often driven by complex algorithms and neural networks, create narratives, characters, or interactions that convey a sense of subjectivity, empathy, and emotional resonance akin to human literary and artistic expressions.

This concept raises profound questions about the nature of creativity, authorship, and the ethical implications of blending human and machine subjectivity in creative and literary contexts.

Ultimately, Machine Subjectivity challenges conventional boundaries and prompts critical inquiries into the evolving relationship between technology and human expression in the arts and literature.

Machine Subjectivity: Theorists, Works and Arguments
Theorists:
  • Donna Haraway: Explores the blurred boundaries between humans and machines, introducing the concept of the cyborg and its implications for subjectivity.
  • N. Katherine Hayles: Examines the intersection of technology and subjectivity in works like How We Became Posthuman.
Works:
  • Neuromancer by William Gibson: A seminal cyberpunk novel that explores the fusion of human and machine subjectivity.
  • Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? by Philip K. Dick: Examines the nature of human and android subjectivity in a dystopian world.
  • The Cyborg Manifesto by Donna Haraway: A foundational text discussing the merging of humans and machines and its impact on subjectivity.
Arguments:
  • Blurring Boundaries: The argument that advancements in technology increasingly blur the boundaries between human and machine subjectivity.
  • Posthumanism: The exploration of how machine subjectivity challenges traditional notions of humanism and what it means to be human.
  • Ethical Considerations: Discussions surrounding the ethical implications of AI-generated subjectivity, including issues of agency, identity, and control.
Machine Subjectivity and Literary Theories
TheoryUse and Engagement of Machine Subjectivity
Posthumanism– It challenges traditional human-centric views of literature and culture.
– Posthumanist theories, such as those by N. Katherine Hayles, explore how machine subjectivity blurs the boundaries between humans and machines, prompting reevaluations of literary representations and the concept of the “human” in literature.
Cyberpunk Literature– In cyberpunk literature, notably in works like William Gibson’s Neuromancer, Machine Subjectivity is a central theme.
– These works delve into the fusion of human and machine subjectivity, often in dystopian, high-tech settings, where characters’ identities and experiences are deeply entwined with technology.
NarratologyIt impacts narrative theory by raising questions about narrative perspective.
– The concept challenges traditional notions of narrator, protagonist, and reader engagement by introducing AI-driven narratives that exhibit subjective experiences and emotions.
Reader Response Theory– Machine-generated narratives with subjectivity evoke reader responses distinct from traditional human-authored works.
– Reader Response Theory explores how readers engage emotionally and intellectually with AI-driven narratives, prompting discussions about the authenticity of these experiences.
Science Fiction TheoryMachine Subjectivity plays a significant role in the exploration of science fiction themes.
– It is often used to analyze how science fiction authors employ AI and machine subjectivity to probe questions about humanity, identity, and the future.
Feminist TheoryDonna Haraway’s The Cyborg Manifesto is a prominent example.
– Feminist theory engages with Machine Subjectivity in discussions about how gender and identity intersect with technology, challenging traditional gender roles in literature and culture.
Machine Subjectivity in Literary Criticism
  1. Neuromancer by William Gibson:
    • In this iconic cyberpunk novel, the protagonist, Case, interfaces with artificial intelligence and experience a form of it through his neural connections. Literary critics have explored how the novel challenges traditional notions of human consciousness and identity in a high-tech, dystopian world.
  2. Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? by Philip K. Dick:
    • This novel, which inspired the film Blade Runner, examines the blurred lines between human and android subjectivity. Literary critics have analyzed how the characters, especially the androids, raise questions about the nature of consciousness, empathy, and the boundaries of subjectivity.
  3. Frankenstein by Mary Shelley:
    • Although written in the 19th century, Frankenstein raises themes of machine subjectivity through the creation of the creature by Victor Frankenstein. Literary critics have explored how the novel addresses the ethical and emotional dimensions of creating and rejecting artificial life.
  4. The Metamorphosis by Franz Kafka:
    • Kafka’s novella tells the story of Gregor Samsa, who wakes up one morning transformed into an insect-like creature. Critics have discussed how this metamorphosis can be seen as an exploration of alienation and the subjective experience of isolation and otherness, akin to machine subjectivity.
  5. Ex Machina by Alex Garland:
    • Ex Machina explores machine subjectivity through the character of Ava, an artificial intelligence with human-like emotions and consciousness. Literary critics have analyzed how the play and film address questions of empathy, ethics, and the boundaries between human and machine subjectivity.
Suggested Readings
  1. Hayles, N. Katherine. How We Became Posthuman: Virtual Bodies in Cybernetics, Literature, and Informatics. University of Chicago Press, 1999.
  2. Haraway, Donna. “A Cyborg Manifesto: Science, Technology, and Socialist-Feminism in the Late Twentieth Century.” Simians, Cyborgs, and Women: The Reinvention of Nature. Routledge, 1991, pp. 149-181.
  3. Landow, George P. Hypertext 3.0: Critical Theory and New Media in an Era of Globalization. The Johns Hopkins University Press, 2006.
  4. Mitchell, David T., and Sharon L. Snyder. Narrative Prosthesis: Disability and the Dependencies of Discourse. University of Michigan Press, 2001.
  5. Shaviro, Steven. The Universe of Things: On Speculative Realism. University of Minnesota Press, 2014.
  6. Turkle, Sherry. The Second Self: Computers and the Human Spirit. Simon & Schuster, 1984.

Liminality in Literature & Literary Theory

Liminality, as a theoretical term, refers to a state of transition or in-betweenness characterized by ambiguity and uncertainty.

Etymology of Liminality

The term “liminality” has its etymological roots in the Latin word “limen,” which means “threshold” or “boundary.” It was originally coined by the anthropologist Arnold van Gennep in the early 20th century to describe the intermediate phase of a rite of passage, a concept he derived from observing rituals and ceremonies in various cultures.

With time, “liminality” has evolved to refer not only to the transitional state within rituals but also to any ambiguous or in-between condition where individuals or groups temporarily occupy a position at the edge or boundary of social or cultural norms.

This concept has been adopted and expanded upon in fields such as anthropology, sociology, psychology, and literary studies to analyze various aspects of human experience and cultural phenomena involving states of ambiguity, transformation, and change.

Meanings of Liminality
MeaningsExplanation
Threshold of Transformation:In literature, liminality often represents a transitional phase in a character’s journey, where they stand at the threshold of significant personal growth or change. It signifies a period of uncertainty and potential, where characters may undergo profound transformations.
Narrative Tension:Liminal spaces and moments can create narrative tension, as characters grapple with ambiguity and the unknown. It can serve as a powerful plot device, driving the story forward and keeping readers engaged.
Symbolism of Transition:Liminality is frequently employed as a symbolic element in literature, representing more than just physical or temporal transitions. It can symbolize psychological, cultural, or societal shifts, providing deeper layers of meaning to the narrative.
Exploration of Identity:Liminality in literature often leads to an exploration of identity. Characters caught in liminal states may question their roles, beliefs, and values, leading to self-discovery and introspection.
Cultural and Social Critique:In literary theory, liminality is used to critique societal and cultural norms. It sheds light on how individuals or groups who occupy liminal spaces challenge established boundaries and question prevailing ideologies.
Ritual and Ceremony:Liminality is closely tied to rituals and ceremonies in literature, mirroring its anthropological roots. These rituals often involve characters passing through a liminal phase, marking a transition from one state to another.
Psychological States:Liminality is also applied to explore characters’ psychological states, especially when they are in a state of uncertainty, ambiguity, or crisis. It delves into the complexities of the human psyche during times of transition.
Transformation and Change:Liminal moments and spaces are frequently associated with transformative experiences in literature. They highlight the potential for growth, enlightenment, or even loss that can occur during these transitional phases.
Definition of Liminality as a Theoretical Term

Liminality, as a theoretical term, refers to a state of transition or in-betweenness characterized by ambiguity and uncertainty.

It is often used in anthropology, sociology, and literary theory to describe the intermediate phase where individuals or groups occupy a position at the threshold of distinct social, cultural, or psychological states.

This concept highlights the transformative potential and the challenges associated with crossing boundaries or undergoing profound changes in various contexts.

Liminality: Theorists, Works and Arguments
Theorists:
  • Arnold van Gennep: Originated the concept of liminality in his work on rites of passage, laying the foundation for its application in anthropology and literary theory.
  • Victor Turner: Developed and expanded upon van Gennep’s ideas, particularly in the context of ritual and social anthropology, contributing to the understanding of liminality as a transformative and culturally significant state.
Key Works:
  • The Rites of Passage by Arnold van Gennep: This seminal work introduced the concept of liminality as an essential phase in rituals and rites of passage, which later influenced its adoption in literary and cultural analysis.
  • The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-Structure by Victor Turner: In this work, Turner further elucidates the concept of liminality, exploring its role in various cultural and social contexts and emphasizing its importance as a phase of ambiguity and transformation.
Central Arguments:
  • Transformation and Transition: The central argument concerning liminality is its role as a transitional phase where individuals or groups undergo profound changes, both psychologically and culturally, as they navigate the threshold between two distinct states.
  • Cultural and Social Significance: Liminality is argued to hold cultural and social significance, often challenging established norms and hierarchies. It provides a space for subversion, questioning, and cultural critique within rituals, literature, and society.
  • Narrative and Symbolism: In literary theory, liminality is seen as a powerful narrative tool and symbol, representing moments of tension, growth, and transformation in the lives of characters or societies. It adds depth and complexity to narratives by exploring the liminal spaces between familiar structures.
Liminality and Literary Theories
TypeRelevance of Liminality
Structuralism:Liminality is used in structuralist literary theory to highlight moments of transition and transformation in narratives. It focuses on the disruption of binary oppositions and the exploration of in-between states, emphasizing the inherent instability and ambiguity present in literary texts.
Postcolonialism:In postcolonial literary theory, liminality is employed to analyze the experiences of individuals and communities caught between colonial and postcolonial identities. It helps to understand the complexities of cultural hybridity and the negotiation of power dynamics in literature from postcolonial regions.
Feminist Theory:Liminality is used within feminist literary theory to explore the position of women in literature and society. It often relates to the liminal spaces women occupy, both in terms of societal roles and personal identity. Feminist theorists examine how these transitional phases impact the portrayal of female characters and their agency in narratives.
Narratology:Within narratology, liminality is utilized to analyze the structure and progression of narratives. It helps scholars understand how transitional phases in a story contribute to its overall development, creating tension and opportunities for character growth.
Cultural Studies:Liminality is employed in cultural studies to critique societal norms and explore the complexities of cultural boundaries and identities depicted in literature. It is used to examine how individuals or groups who occupy liminal spaces challenge established norms and ideologies within a specific cultural context.
Psychoanalytic Theory:Psychoanalytic literary theory uses liminality to delve into the psychological states of characters during moments of transition or crisis. It offers insights into the inner workings of the human psyche, particularly when characters confront ambiguity and uncertainty.
Poststructuralism:In poststructuralist literary theory, liminality plays a crucial role in deconstructing binary oppositions and revealing the fluidity of meaning. It emphasizes how texts and identities are not fixed but constantly shifting and contingent, blurring boundaries between categories.
Queer Theory:Liminality is used in queer literary theory to examine non-normative experiences of gender and sexuality. It explores the spaces between conventional categories and identities, highlighting the fluidity and complexity of queer narratives and characters.
Liminality in Literary Criticism
  1. Neverwhere by Neil Gaiman (1996, British-American Literature):
    • While “Neverwhere” is from the 1990s, it captures the liminality of a hidden and parallel world beneath London. The protagonist, Richard Mayhew, enters this dark and mysterious realm, becoming a liminal figure who straddles two worlds. Gaiman’s narrative explores the blurred boundaries between reality and fantasy, emphasizing the transient nature of urban existence.
  2. The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood (1985, Canadian-American Literature):
    • Atwood’s dystopian masterpiece, The Handmaid’s Tale, is a reflection of the liminal space between the past and the future. The novel is set in the Republic of Gilead, where women’s roles are strictly defined. Offred, the protagonist, occupies a liminal position as a Handmaid, torn between her previous life and her oppressive present. The narrative explores the fragility of freedom and the fluidity of identity.
  3. Midnight’s Children by Salman Rushdie (1981, British-Indian Literature):
    • Rushdie’s novel is a tapestry of postcolonial liminality, set against the backdrop of India’s transition to independence. The protagonist, Saleem Sinai, is born at the exact moment of India’s independence, linking his life with the destiny of the nation. His narrative reflects the liminal space between personal and collective history, with magical realism blurring the boundaries between reality and myth.
  4. White Noise by Don DeLillo (1985, American Literature):
    • DeLillo’s novel White Noise explores the liminality of modern consumer culture and the pervasive influence of media. The characters exist in a state of constant sensory overload, highlighting the liminal space between the real and the simulated. The novel critiques the ambiguity and uncertainty that arise in a world saturated with information and technology.
Suggested Readings
  1. Auge, Marc. Non-Places: An Introduction to Supermodernity. Verso, 1995.
  2. Bhabha, Homi K. The Location of Culture. Routledge, 1994.
  3. Campbell, Joseph. The Hero with a Thousand Faces. Princeton University Press, 2008.
  4. Turner, Victor. The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-Structure. Aldine Transaction, 2008.
  5. Van Gennep, Arnold. The Rites of Passage. University of Chicago Press, 1960.
  6. Waters, Lindsay. Transgressive Readings: The Texts of Franz Kafka and Max Planck. Northwestern University Press, 2008.
  7. Woolf, Virginia. To the Lighthouse. Harcourt, Brace & World, 1927.
You may read more on Theoretical Terms below:

Jouissance in Literature & Literary Theory

Jouissance, as a theoretical term, originates from Lacanian psychoanalysis and refers to a complex and often paradoxical form of pleasure deeply intertwined with unconscious desires and even suffering.

Etymology of Jouissance

The term “jouissance” has its origins in the French language and can be traced back to Old French, where it was used to denote “enjoyment” or “pleasure.” Derived from the Old French verb “jouir,” meaning “to enjoy,” the term evolved and acquired nuanced meanings in various contexts.

In psychoanalytic discourse, particularly in the work of Jacques Lacan, “jouissance” takes on a complex and somewhat elusive significance, encompassing both pleasure and suffering.

It refers to a form of intense, often paradoxical, enjoyment that is closely linked to desire and the unconscious. Lacan’s use of “jouissance” has left a significant mark on psychoanalytic theory, contributing to discussions about the intricate relationship between pleasure, desire, and the unconscious mind.

Meanings of Jouissance
MeaningExplanation
Lacanian PsychoanalysisIn literary theory and psychoanalysis, jouissance represents a complex and contradictory form of pleasure tied to unconscious desires and suffering.
Erotic and Sensual PleasureIn literature, it describes intense, overwhelming experiences of erotic or sensual pleasure, often in works exploring desire and passion.
Excessive EnjoymentJouissance signifies excessive, transgressive enjoyment beyond conventional boundaries, often associated with characters or situations indulging in extreme or taboo pleasures.
Psychological IntensityIn literary theory, it refers to heightened emotional and psychological intensity in a character’s experience, driving narrative and character development.
Subversion of NormsIn literature, it is linked to subverting societal norms, challenging conventional values, and highlighting the disruptive power of unconventional enjoyment.
Suffering and PainIt encompasses suffering or pain, especially when pleasure and pain intertwine, as seen in some works where characters experience jouissance through painful or masochistic processes.
Narrative TensionIt contributes to narrative tension in literary analysis, creating unpredictability and instability, often serving as a driving force behind plot developments and character motivations.
Language and RepresentationIn literature, it explores how language conveys the intensity of human experience, desire, and pleasure, or fails to do so.
Definition of Jouissance as a Theoretical Term

Jouissance, as a theoretical term, originates from Lacanian psychoanalysis and refers to a complex and often paradoxical form of pleasure deeply intertwined with unconscious desires and even suffering. It signifies an intense and excessive enjoyment that transcends conventional boundaries and can be associated with transgressive or taboo experiences. In literary and cultural contexts, jouissance is employed to explore the profound emotional, psychological, and societal implications of pleasure, desire, and their intricate connections.

Jouissance: Theorists, Works and Arguments
Theorists:
  • Jacques Lacan: Developed the concept of jouissance within the framework of psychoanalysis, emphasizing its role in understanding the relationship between pleasure, desire, and the unconscious.
Key Works:
  • Écrits by Jacques Lacan: This seminal collection of Lacan’s writings contains several key essays where he delves into the concept of jouissance, particularly in relation to psychoanalytic theory.
Central Arguments:
  • Lacanian Psychoanalysis: According to Lacan, it represents a pivotal element in psychoanalysis, highlighting the intricate and often contradictory nature of pleasure. It underscores the idea that pleasure is not solely a source of contentment but can also involve pain, suffering, and unconscious desires.
  • Desire and Language: Lacan’s exploration of jouissance emphasizes its linguistic and symbolic dimensions. He argues that language plays a crucial role in shaping and constraining our experiences of pleasure and desire, making jouissance a complex interplay between language, the unconscious, and the self.
  • Transgression and Societal Norms: In cultural and literary contexts, theorists draw on jouissance to analyze the subversion of societal norms and the disruption of conventional values through unconventional forms of enjoyment. It highlights how literature and culture challenge established boundaries of pleasure and desire.
Jouissance and Literary Theories
TheoryUse
Psychoanalytic Theory:Jouissance as Psychic Pleasure: In psychoanalytic literary theories, it is employed to explore the deep and often unconscious sources of psychic pleasure in literary texts. It helps analysts understand characters’ motivations, desires, and the hidden layers of their psyches.
Feminist Literary Theory:Jouissance and Gender Dynamics: Feminist literary theorists use it to examine how gender roles and power dynamics influence experiences of pleasure and desire in literature. It can shed light on the representation of female and male desires and how they are constrained or liberated by societal norms.
Poststructuralist Theory:Jouissance and Language: Poststructuralist approaches utilize it to deconstruct the relationship between language and desire in literature. It highlights the limitations of language in conveying the intensity of human experience and the role of linguistic structures in shaping desire.
Queer Theory:Jouissance and Queer Desires: In queer literary theories, jouissance is used to analyze non-normative or LGBTQ+ experiences of pleasure and desire in literature. It helps theorists explore how texts challenge or conform to heteronormative conventions.
Narrative Theory:Narrative Tension and Jouissance: Narrative theorists may employ it to examine how its presence or absence contributes to the tension and engagement within a literary work. It can be a driving force behind plot developments and character motivations, enhancing the reader’s experience.
Cultural Studies:Jouissance and Cultural Critique: Cultural critics use jouissance to critique societal norms and values depicted in literature. It helps them analyze how texts subvert or reinforce established boundaries of pleasure and desire, offering insights into cultural ideologies.
Postcolonial Theory:Colonialism, Desire, and Jouissance: In postcolonial literary theories, it can be used to explore the intersection of desire and colonialism in literature. It aids in understanding how colonial narratives depict pleasure and suffering within the context of imperialism.
Jouissance in Literary Criticism
  1. Fleishman Is in Trouble by Taffy Brodesser-Akner (2019):
    • In this novel, jouissance is intricately connected to the desires and complexities of modern relationships. Brodesser-Akner delves into the challenges and pleasures of contemporary romance, examining how the pursuit of personal pleasure and desires can lead to both fulfillment and chaos. The characters grapple with the intricate web of their own desires and their impact on their lives.
  2. My Year of Rest and Relaxation by Ottessa Moshfegh (2018):
    • Moshfegh’s novel explores the protagonist’s relentless quest for a state of ultimate rest and emotional numbness as a form of jouissance. It delves into the darker aspects of pleasure, desire, and the human psyche, offering a stark portrayal of the lengths one might go to in order to escape the pressures of modern life.
  3. The Pisces by Melissa Broder (2018):
    • In The Pisces, jouissance is at the heart of the narrative, manifesting through a passionate yet taboo relationship. Melissa Broder examines the intense pleasures and desires that lead to self-discovery and, in some instances, self-destructive behavior. The novel offers a contemporary exploration of jouissance through the lens of personal and unconventional desires.
  4. Milkman by Anna Burns (2018):
    • Anna Burns’ novel Milkman explores jouissance within the framework of societal norms and political conflict. The unnamed protagonist navigates a world filled with unwanted attention and the constraints of her community, shedding light on the intricate interplay between desire, pleasure, and the oppressive forces of society. The concept of jouissance is used to analyze how the character’s desires are shaped by and, in turn, shape the world around her.
Suggested Readings
  1. Brodesser-Akner, Taffy. Fleishman Is in Trouble. Random House, 2019.
  2. Burns, Anna. Milkman. Graywolf Press, 2018.
  3. Broder, Melissa. The Pisces. Hogarth, 2018.
  4. Lacan, Jacques. Écrits. Translated by Bruce Fink, W. W. Norton & Company, 2006.
  5. Moshfegh, Ottessa. My Year of Rest and Relaxation. Penguin Press, 2018.
  6. Zizek, Slavoj. The Plague of Fantasies. Verso, 2008.
You may read more on Theoretical Terms below:

Interpellation in Literature & Literary Theory

Interpellation, as a theoretical term in literature and cultural studies, refers to the process through which individuals are hailed or called upon by societal norms and ideologies to adopt specific social roles and identities.

Etymology of Interpellation

The term “interpellation” has its origins in French and Latin. It derives from the French word “interpellation,” which means “to question” or “to challenge.” This French word, in turn, has its roots in the Latin word “interpellare,” where “inter” means “between” and “pellare” means “to summon” or “to call.”

In its etymological essence, interpellation conveys the act of interrupting or questioning someone, often in a formal or authoritative manner, to elicit a response or clarification.

In the realm of literary and cultural theory, “interpellation” has taken on a specialized meaning, referring to the process by which individuals are hailed or called upon to assume specific social roles and identities through ideological and societal norms.

Philosopher Louis Althusser explored this concept in his work on ideological state apparatuses.

Meanings of Interpellation
MeaningExplanation
Social Identity ConstructionIn literature and literary theory, interpellation refers to the process through which individuals are hailed or called upon by societal norms and ideologies to adopt specific social roles and identities. It is a concept used to analyze how literature can reinforce or challenge societal expectations related to identity, class, gender, and more.
Reader EngagementIn the context of literature, interpellation can be observed in the way texts address and engage with readers. Authors often employ narrative techniques and rhetorical strategies to interpellate or “hail” readers, inviting them to identify with certain characters, ideologies, or themes within the text. This engagement can significantly shape readers’ interpretations and emotional responses.
Narrative PerspectiveInterpellation is relevant to narrative theory as it plays a crucial role in determining the narrative perspective and positioning of the reader within the story. For example, the choice between a first-person or third-person narrator can interpellate readers differently, either encouraging them to align closely with a character’s point of view or adopt a more objective stance.
Ideological CritiqueLiterary critics often use the concept of interpellation to analyze how texts reflect and reinforce societal ideologies. By examining how characters are interpellated within a narrative, critics can uncover the underlying ideological messages and power dynamics at play in a literary work.
Subversion and ResistanceInterpellation isn’t limited to reinforcing dominant ideologies; it can also be a site of resistance and subversion in literature. Some literary works challenge or disrupt interpellation by offering alternative perspectives or critiquing established societal norms, encouraging readers to question and reflect on established identities and power structures.
Psychological ImpactInterpellation can have profound psychological effects on both readers and characters within a narrative. It can shape their sense of self, belonging, and agency, often leading to complex character development and emotional resonance in literature.
Postcolonial and Feminist AnalysisIn postcolonial and feminist literary analyses, interpellation often takes center stage. These critical perspectives examine how texts interpellate characters based on factors like race, gender, or colonial status. Such analyses shed light on the power dynamics inherent in identity construction, offering deeper insights into literary works.
Intertextual ConnectionsThe concept of interpellation can also be explored through intertextual connections between literary works. Authors may interpellate characters from other texts, invoking shared cultural or literary identities and enriching the reading experience by adding layers of meaning and context.
Cultural and Historical ContextThe meaning and impact of interpellation in literature are deeply intertwined with the cultural and historical context of a work. Different time periods, settings, and societal norms interpellate characters and readers in distinct ways, significantly influencing the themes and messages conveyed in literature.
Definition of Interpellation as a Theoretical Term

Interpellation, as a theoretical term in literature and cultural studies, refers to the process through which individuals are hailed or called upon by societal norms and ideologies to adopt specific social roles and identities.

It encompasses the ways in which texts, ideologies, and narratives shape individuals’ understanding of themselves and their positions within broader societal structures. This concept, popularized by Louis Althusser, is central to the analysis of how literature and media reinforce or challenge prevailing norms and power dynamics.

Interpellation: Theorists, Works, and Arguments
Theorists:
  • Louis Althusser: Louis Althusser, a prominent Marxist philosopher, introduced the concept of interpellation in his essay “Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses.” He argued that individuals are subjected to ideological structures and institutions through interpellation, leading them to assume specific social roles and identities.
  • Stuart Hall: Stuart Hall, a cultural studies scholar, expanded on Althusser’s ideas and applied interpellation to the analysis of media and popular culture. He emphasized the role of media in hailing individuals into specific subject positions and shaping their identities.
Works:
  • “Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses” (1970) by Louis Althusser: In this influential essay, Althusser outlines the concept of interpellation and its role in the functioning of ideological state apparatuses. He argues that individuals are hailed by these apparatuses, which include education, religion, and media, and are thus interpellated into specific social roles.
  • “Encoding/Decoding” (1980) by Stuart Hall: In this work, Hall discusses the process of encoding and decoding messages in media. He introduces the idea of media interpellating audiences and highlights the agency of individuals in decoding media messages, which may not always align with the intended interpellation.
Arguments:
  • Power Dynamics and Control: The concept underscores how power dynamics are perpetuated in society. The argument is that those in control of ideological structures can interpellate individuals into roles that serve their interests, reinforcing existing power structures.
  • Resistance and Agency: Some arguments emphasize that it is not a one-sided process; individuals can also resist or reinterpret it, asserting their agency and challenging dominant ideologies.
  • Media Influence: Scholars argue that media plays a significant role in interpellating individuals into certain subject positions. Media texts, through framing and representation, can shape how individuals perceive themselves and others within societal contexts.
  • Intersectionality: Interpellation is often analyzed in the context of intersectionality, considering how individuals may be subject to multiple interpellations simultaneously based on factors such as race, gender, class, and more. This argument highlights the complexity of identity formation.
  • Cultural and Historical Specificity: Arguments stress the importance of considering the cultural and historical context when analyzing interpellation. Different cultures and time periods interpellate individuals differently, leading to variations in identity construction.

These theorists, works, and arguments collectively contribute to our understanding of how interpellation functions in society and within the realm of media and cultural studies.

Interpellation and Literary Theories
TheoryRelevance
Marxist Literary TheoryInterpellation aligns with Marxist theory’s focus on ideology and class struggle. It reveals how literature can interpellate characters into specific class roles and reinforces or critiques the dominant socioeconomic order.
Feminist Literary TheoryInterpellation is crucial for understanding how literature enforces or challenges gender norms and roles. It sheds light on how female characters are interpellated into patriarchal constructs and their potential for resistance.
Postcolonial TheoryInterpellation is central to postcolonial theory’s examination of colonial power dynamics. It helps analyze how literature interpellates colonized and colonizer characters, highlighting the complexities of identity, race, and cultural hegemony.
Reader-Response TheoryIn reader-response theory, interpellation is relevant as it underscores the active role of readers in the interpretive process. Readers are interpellated into specific reading positions, affecting their engagement with and interpretation of texts.
Narrative TheoryNarrative theory explores how interpellation shapes narrative perspectives. The choice of a narrative voice interpellates readers into particular viewpoints, influencing their understanding of the story.
Queer TheoryInterpellation is pertinent to queer theory’s analysis of sexuality and identity. It examines how literature interpellates characters into heteronormative roles and how LGBTQ+ characters may resist or subvert these interpellations.
Psychoanalytic Literary TheoryPsychoanalytic theory can use interpellation to delve into characters’ subconscious and psychological development. It explores how characters’ interpellation into societal roles relates to their inner conflicts and desires.
Structuralism and SemioticsInterpellation aligns with structuralist and semiotic approaches, as it focuses on how signs and symbols in literature interpellate readers into specific interpretations. This theory examines how language and symbols construct meaning.
PostmodernismIn postmodern literature, it is often subverted or questioned, challenging the stability of identities and narratives. It highlights the blurring of authorial and reader roles, inviting readers to critically engage with texts.
New CriticismNew Criticism emphasizes close reading and the autonomy of the text. It is relevant for understanding how texts interpellate readers into specific interpretive approaches, such as formal analysis and close reading.
Interpellation in Literary Criticism
  1. “The Yellow Wallpaper” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman:
    • Interpellation: In this novel, the protagonist’s descent into madness due to her confinement in a room with yellow wallpaper can be seen as an interpellation into the societal norms of women’s roles and mental health during the 19th century. Her struggle against this interpellation reflects the broader issues of women’s autonomy and mental well-being.
  2. “The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson:
    • Interpellation: The townspeople’s participation in the annual lottery and their willingness to stone one of their own can be viewed as an interpellation into a blind adherence to tradition and conformity. The story highlights the dangers of unquestioningly accepting societal norms and practices.
  3. 1984 by George Orwell:
    • Interpellation: The dystopian society depicted in “1984” interpellates its citizens into submission to a totalitarian regime, erasing individuality and critical thinking. The concept of “Newspeak” is a clear example of linguistic interpellation, as it limits the range of thought and expression.
  4. “A Doll’s House” by Henrik Ibsen:
    • Interpellation: In “A Doll’s House,” Nora Helmer’s interpellation into the role of a submissive wife and mother is central to the play’s themes. Her awakening to her own identity and her rejection of societal norms exemplify a break from interpellation and a quest for self-realization.
  5. The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger:
    • Interpellation: The novel follows the journey of Holden Caulfield, who rebels against the interpellation into the adult world and its perceived phoniness. His alienation and resistance to societal expectations serve as a commentary on the pressures placed on young adults to conform to conventional norms.
Suggested Readings
  1. Althusser, Louis. “Ideology and Ideological State Apparatuses.” In Lenin and Philosophy and Other Essays, translated by Ben Brewster, 127-186. Monthly Review Press, 1971.
  2. Hall, Stuart. “Encoding/Decoding.” In Culture, Media, Language, edited by Stuart Hall et al., 128-138. Routledge, 1980.
  3. Jackson, Shirley. “The Lottery.” In The Lottery and Other Stories, 27-36. Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2005.
  4. Perkins Gilman, Charlotte. “The Yellow Wallpaper.” In The Yellow Wallpaper and Other Writings, edited by Lynne Sharon Schwartz, 1-20. Dover Publications, 1997.
  5. Orwell, George. 1984. Signet Classics, 1949.
  6. Salinger, J.D. The Catcher in the Rye. Little, Brown and Company, 1951.
  7. Ibsen, Henrik. A Doll’s House. Dover Publications, 1992.

Implied Author in Literature & Literary Theory

The Implied Author, as a theoretical term in literary studies, refers to the hypothetical, constructed persona within a literary work that communicates the narrative’s style, tone, and perspective, separate from the actual author’s identity.

Etymology of Implied Author

The term “Implied Author” finds its origins in the realm of literary theory and was initially coined by Wayne C. Booth in his seminal work, “The Rhetoric of Fiction,” first published in 1961. T

his concept serves as a crucial distinction, highlighting the separation between the persona projected within a literary work, known as the Implied Author, and the living, breathing author. It underscores the notion that a text possesses its own unique authorial voice, stylistic elements, and perspective, which may not necessarily align with the personality or intentions of the real author.

Resultantly, the concept of the Implied Author provides a valuable framework for literary scholars and critics to dissect the intricate interplay of narrative voices and authorial presence within the world of literature.

Meanings of Implied Author
MeaningExplanation
Narrative PersonaIn literature and literary theory, it represents the narrative persona or voice constructed within a literary work, distinct from the real-life author.
Artistic ProjectionIt signifies the artistic projection of an authorial presence within the text, encompassing style, tone, and perspective.
Interpretive ToolThe concept serves as a valuable interpretive tool for understanding the text’s underlying intentions, values, and moral stance.
Separation from Real AuthorIt underscores the separation between it and the actual author, emphasizing that the text may convey a persona that differs from the author’s identity.
Reader EngagementIt influences reader engagement by shaping the reader’s perception of the text’s narrator and the message being conveyed.
Critical AnalysisScholars employ this concept in literary criticism to explore the complexities of authorship, reader response, and narrative perspective.
Subjective InterpretationDifferent readers and critics may have varying interpretations, leading to nuanced discussions in literary analysis.
Debates on ImportanceIt has sparked debates about the extent to which readers should consider the Implied Author in their interpretation, given its separation from the actual author.
Continued RelevanceDespite evolving literary theories, the concept remains a relevant and enduring tool for understanding the relationship between authors, texts, and readers in literary analysis.
Definition of Implied Author as a Theoretical Term

The Implied Author, as a theoretical term in literary studies, refers to the hypothetical, constructed persona within a literary work that communicates the narrative’s style, tone, and perspective, separate from the actual author’s identity.

This concept allows scholars to analyze and interpret texts by considering the implied intentions, values, and moral stance presented through the narrative voice, highlighting the distinction between the author as a person and the author as a literary construct. It serves as a pivotal tool in understanding the complexities of authorship, narrative control, and reader engagement in the realm of literary theory and criticism.

Implied Author: Theorists, Works and Arguments
Theorists:
  • Wayne C. Booth: In his groundbreaking work The Rhetoric of Fiction (1961), Booth introduced the concept of the Implied Author, highlighting its significance in literary analysis. He argued that understanding the Implied Author is essential for comprehending the narrative persona and the authorial voice within a literary work, distinct from the actual author.
  • Wolfgang Iser: In The Act of Reading: A Theory of Aesthetic Response (1976), Iser explored the Implied Author‘s pivotal role in shaping how readers interpret and engage with texts. He emphasized that the Implied Author guides readers’ aesthetic responses, contributing to the meaning-making process.
  • Umberto Eco: Eco’s The Role of the Reader: Explorations in the Semiotics of Texts (1979) explores the term the Implied Author from a semiotic perspective. He highlighted how readers actively participate in constructing the Implied Author through their interactions with the text, underscoring the collaborative nature of meaning creation.
  • E.D. Hirsch: Hirsch’s work, Validity in Interpretation (1967), focused on the relationship between the Implied Author and textual meaning. He argued that recognizing the Implied Author‘s intentions is crucial for valid interpretations, emphasizing the author’s role in determining a text’s significance.
Key Works:
  • The Rhetoric of Fiction (1961) by Wayne C. Booth: Booth’s groundbreaking work introduced the Implied Author as a key concept for analyzing narrative persona and authorial voice.
  • The Act of Reading: A Theory of Aesthetic Response (1976) by Wolfgang Iser: Iser’s book explores how the Implied Author influences reader responses and the aesthetic experience of literature.
  • The Role of the Reader: Explorations in the Semiotics of Texts (1979) by Umberto Eco: Eco’s work discusses the Implied Author in the context of semiotics and reader participation in constructing meaning.
  • Validity in Interpretation (1967) by E.D. Hirsch: Hirsch’s book examines the Implied Author‘s role in determining the validity of interpretations and its connection to textual meaning.
Key Arguments:
  • Booth introduced the Implied Author as a fundamental concept for understanding the narrative persona, emphasizing its importance in distinguishing the authorial voice within the text from the actual author.
  • Iser highlighted the Implied Author‘s influence on reader interpretation, emphasizing how it guides readers’ aesthetic responses and contributes to the construction of meaning.
  • Eco’s perspective emphasized the active role of readers in constructing the Implied Author through their interactions with the text, underscoring the collaborative nature of meaning-making.
  • Hirsch argued that recognizing its intentions is essential for valid interpretations, emphasizing the author’s role in determining a text’s significance and meaning.
Implied Author and Literary Theories
TheoryRelevance
Reader-Response TheoryThe concept of the Implied Author is relevant to reader-response theory as it underscores the role of the reader in constructing the implied authorship. Readers actively engage with the text and contribute to shaping the Implied Author, making it a dynamic component in the reader’s interpretive process.
Authorial Intent TheoryIn the context of authorial intent theory, the Implied Author holds significance as it reflects the author’s intended narrative voice and perspective. This theory emphasizes the need to consider the Implied Author to understand the author’s purpose and meaning behind a work.
Narrative TheoryWithin narrative theory, it is central to analyzing the narrative structure and point of view. It helps scholars examine how the implied authorial presence influences the storytelling techniques, character development, and narrative choices in a text.
DeconstructionismIn deconstructionist literary theory, the concept is a construct that deconstructionists question and challenge. It serves as a point of contention regarding the stability of meaning and the extent to which the implied author’s intentions can be discerned.
Semiotics and StructuralismIn the realm of semiotics and structuralism, the Implied Author aligns with the focus on sign systems and codes. It represents the authorial code within the text, providing a means to explore how signs and symbols shape meaning in literature.
Reception TheoryReception theory considers the role of the reader in interpreting and receiving a text. The Implied Author is relevant here because it influences how readers perceive and engage with the text, affecting the reception and interpretation process.
Postcolonial TheoryIn postcolonial theory, it is examined for its potential reflection of colonial or postcolonial perspectives. It becomes relevant when exploring how literature may carry implicit ideological positions related to colonialism and its aftermath.
Feminist Literary TheoryWithin feminist literary theory, the Implied Author can be analyzed for its portrayal of gender roles and perspectives. Examining the implied authorship helps in understanding how gender-related themes are constructed and conveyed in literature.
Psychoanalytic Literary TheoryPsychoanalytic theory can use the Implied Author to explore subconscious elements in a text. It can reveal how the implied authorial presence might reflect the author’s psychological motivations and unconscious influences on the narrative.
PostmodernismIn the context of postmodernism, the Implied Author is relevant because it challenges the notion of a fixed, authoritative authorial voice. Postmodernist literature often blurs the boundaries between author and narrator, making the concept of the Implied Author a subject of inquiry.
Marxist Literary TheoryIn Marxist literary theory, it is studied for its reflection of class relations, ideology, and social critique. It is relevant for examining how literature may implicitly convey or contest Marxist perspectives.
New CriticismThe Implied Author aligns with the principles of New Criticism, which emphasize close reading and the text’s autonomy. New Critics often analyze the implied authorial presence to understand how a work creates meaning within itself.
Queer TheoryIn queer theory, the Implied Author can be explored for its representation of LGBTQ+ identities and experiences. It is relevant for examining how literature may implicitly engage with or challenge heteronormative norms.
Structuralist LinguisticsIn structuralist linguistics, the Implied Author can be related to the linguistic structures within a text. Analyzing the implied authorial presence aids in understanding how language functions as a system in literature.
Implied Author in Literary Criticism
  1. The Bonfire of the Vanities by Tom Wolfe (1987): Wolfe’s satirical novel offers a wealth of material for examining the Implied Author’s perspective on the excesses of the 1980s and the characters navigating the social milieu of New York City. Literary critics often explore how Wolfe’s authorial voice influences the reader’s perception of the story’s themes.
  2. The Remains of the Day by Kazuo Ishiguro (1989): Ishiguro’s novel shows the themes of memory, repression, and the role of the past in shaping identity. Literary analysis of this work often considers how the Implied Author’s narrative choices affect the reader’s understanding of the protagonist’s introspective journey.
  3. The Things They Carried by Tim O’Brien (1990): O’Brien’s collection of interconnected short stories about the Vietnam War invites examination of the Implied Author’s role in conveying the emotional and psychological burdens carried by soldiers. Critics often explore how O’Brien’s narrative voice influences reader empathy and engagement.
  4. The Blind Assassin by Margaret Atwood (2000): Atwood’s novel is notable for its layered narrative structure and intertextuality. Literary critics often analyze how the Implied Author constructs multiple narrative voices and explores themes of storytelling and truth.
  5. Interpreter of Maladies by Jhumpa Lahiri (1999): Lahiri’s collection of short stories demonstrates themes of cultural identity and human connection. Critics often examine how the Implied Author’s narrative style and perspectives shape the reader’s understanding of the characters’ experiences in a foreign land.
Suggested Readings
  1. Booth, Wayne C. The Rhetoric of Fiction. University of Chicago Press, 1983.
  2. Eco, Umberto. The Role of the Reader: Explorations in the Semiotics of Texts. Indiana University Press, 1979.
  3. Hirsch, E.D. Validity in Interpretation. Yale University Press, 1967.
  4. Iser, Wolfgang. The Act of Reading: A Theory of Aesthetic Response. The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1978.
  5. Prince, Gerald. Narratology: The Form and Functioning of Narrative. Walter de Gruyter, 1987.

Intertextuality in Literature & Literary Theory

Intertextuality, in theoretical terms, is the concept that highlights the interconnectedness of literary works and cultural artifacts. It signifies that texts are in constant dialogue with those that came before, shaping and influencing one another.

Etymology of Intertextuality

The term “intertextuality” has its etymological roots in the Latin word “textus,” which means “text” or “fabric.” The prefix “inter-“ denotes the idea of “between” or “among.”

Therefore, “intertextuality” essentially conveys the notion of texts being interwoven or interconnected, reflecting how literary works often reference, borrow from, and engage with other texts. It creates a complex web of textual relationships.

This term underscores the dynamic and dialogical nature of literature. In this way, it shows how texts are not isolated entities but part of a broader literary fabric.

Meanings of Intertextuality
Key PointsDescription
Interconnected Literary ReferencesAuthors incorporate elements, themes, or phrases from earlier works, creating rich literary connections.
Dialogues Between TextsTexts respond to, critique, or reinterpret each other, enriching the reader’s experience through exploration of connections and contrasts.
Cultural and Contextual SignificanceLiterature reflects cultural and historical context by commenting on social norms, values, and ideologies of the time.
Reader Engagement and InterpretationReaders actively engage with texts by recognizing and deciphering references, deepening their understanding through exploration of layers of meaning.
Postmodern Deconstruction of AuthorshipChallenges traditional notions of authorship and originality, blurring the lines between author, text, and reader by emphasizing collaborative creation.
Poststructuralist AnalysisReveals the decentered nature of language and meaning, highlighting the shaping influence of diverse texts and discourses.
Intertextual Strategies in PostcolonialismEmpowers marginalized voices by referencing and subverting colonial texts, allowing them to challenge dominant narratives.
Critical Examination of Influence and AuthorityPrompts critical analysis of power dynamics in literature, questioning the authority of certain texts or voices and their impact on cultural discourse.
Literary Creativity and InnovationServes as a source of literary innovation, enabling authors to reinterpret and transform existing narratives, contributing to the evolution of literary traditions.
Definition of Intertextuality as a Theoretical Term

Intertextuality, in theoretical terms, is the concept that highlights the interconnectedness of literary works and cultural artifacts. It signifies that texts are in constant dialogue with those that came before, shaping and influencing one another.

This perspective emphasizes how authors draw from, reinterpret, or challenge existing texts to enrich their works and convey deeper smeaning. It challenges traditional notions of originality and authorship, emphasizing the dynamic and collaborative nature of textuality within broader cultural contexts.

Intertextuality: Theorists, Works, and Arguments
Julia Kristeva:
  • Work: Desire in Language: A Semiotic Approach to Literature and Art
  • Argument: Kristeva introduced the term as part of her semiotic approach, emphasizing the interplay of signs and the continual referencing of other texts within a literary work.
Roland Barthes:
  • Work: The Death of the Author
  • Argument: Barthes questioned the authority of the author and highlighted how readers actively contribute to the meaning of a text through intertextual connections and interpretations.
Mikhail Bakhtin:
  • Work: Problems of Dostoevsky’s Poetics
  • Argument: Bakhtin’s concept of “dialogism” emphasizes the multi-voiced nature of texts and the ongoing dialogue between different texts, contributing to intertextual analysis.
Kristeva’s Intertextuality Theory:
  • Work: Word, Dialogue, and Novel
  • Argument: Kristeva’s theory explores the idea of the “intertext,” where texts intersect and generate new meanings through their interactions.
Postmodern Intertextuality:
  • Works: Various postmodern literature
  • Argument: Postmodern authors often engage in playful intertextuality, blurring the lines between high and low culture and challenging conventional narrative structures.
Intertextuality in Postcolonial Literature:
  • Works: Chinua Achebe’s Things Fall Apart, Jean Rhys’s Wide Sargasso Sea
  • Argument: Postcolonial literature uses intertextuality to reframe and subvert colonial narratives, giving voice to marginalized perspectives.
Intertextuality and Adaptation:
  • Works: Film adaptations of literary classics
  • Argument: Adaptations in different media, such as film, engage in intertextuality by referencing and reinterpreting source texts, offering new insights and perspectives.

These theorists, works, and arguments collectively contribute to our understanding of how intertextuality operates in literature, theory, and cultural discourse.

Intertextuality and Literary Theories
TheoryRelevance
Structuralism and SemioticsStructuralism and semiotics explore the underlying structures and signs within texts. Intertextuality is relevant as it highlights how texts are connected through a network of signs and references, emphasizing the role of signs in creating meaning.
Poststructuralism and DeconstructionPoststructuralism challenges the fixed meanings of texts and emphasizes the fluidity of language. Deconstruction, a part of poststructuralism, deconstructs texts to reveal their multiple meanings and contradictions. Intertextuality is relevant as it underscores how texts are continually deconstructed and reconstructed through their connections with other texts.
New Historicism and Cultural StudiesNew Historicism and Cultural Studies examine the cultural and historical context in which texts are produced. Intertextuality is relevant as it shows how texts engage with and reflect the cultural and historical influences of their time by referencing other works.
PostcolonialismPostcolonialism explores the effects of colonialism on colonized cultures. Intertextuality is relevant in postcolonial literature as it often involves the reappropriation and subversion of colonial texts, providing a voice to marginalized cultures.
Feminist TheoryFeminist theory, particularly in postcolonial contexts, examines how women’s voices are silenced or appropriated in literature. Intertextuality is relevant as it is used to analyze how women writers engage with and reinterpret male-dominated literary traditions.
Reception TheoryReception theory focuses on how readers interpret and receive texts. Intertextuality is relevant as it highlights how readers actively engage with texts by recognizing intertextual references, contributing to the diverse interpretations of a work.
Psychoanalytic Literary TheoryPsychoanalytic theory delves into the psychological aspects of characters and authors. Intertextuality is relevant as it is used to analyze how authors’ personal experiences and traumas may be reflected in intertextual references within their works.
Reader-Response TheoryReader-response theory emphasizes the role of the reader in constructing meaning. Intertextuality is relevant as it invites readers to actively engage with texts by recognizing references, impacting their interpretation and response.
Intertextuality in Literary Criticism
WorkIntertextuality Critique
The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood (1985)Atwood’s use of intertextuality enriches the narrative significantly. She skillfully references religious texts, historical events, and feminist literature, which deepens the exploration of an oppressive patriarchal society. By reinterpreting biblical stories, particularly the story of Rachel and Leah, Atwood highlights the subjugation of women. Furthermore, her references to feminist literature of the 1970s, such as “The Second Sex” by Simone de Beauvoir, effectively delve into themes of female oppression and resistance. This meticulous intertextuality adds layers to the narrative, resonating with readers and provoking critical reflection on contemporary social and political issues.
Beloved by Toni Morrison (1987)Morrison’s intertextual elements from African American history, folklore, and the slave narrative tradition contribute profoundly to the narrative. Her references to historical events like the Middle Passage and the incorporation of the ghostly presence of the titular character, who symbolizes the trauma of slavery, create a haunting and emotionally resonant story. Moreover, Morrison’s interweaving of elements from African folklore, such as the concept of “rememory,” strengthens the connection between personal and collective histories of African Americans. This deliberate use of intertextuality underscores the importance of remembering and acknowledging the past.
The Things They Carried by Tim O’Brien (1990)O’Brien’s intertextuality, drawn from war literature and his own experiences as a soldier in the Vietnam War, significantly enhances his stories. His references to historical accounts and other war literature, such as Hemingway’s “In Another Country” and Joseph Conrad’s “Heart of Darkness,” add authenticity and emotional depth to his narratives. By blurring the lines between fiction and reality through these intertextual references, O’Brien masterfully explores the complexities of truth and storytelling, especially within the context of war.
White Noise by Don DeLillo (1985)DeLillo’s satirical novel is intricately connected to consumer culture, media, and popular culture of the 1980s through intertextuality. His references to advertisements, television shows, and consumer products serve as a poignant critique of the superficiality and alienation prevalent in contemporary society. Furthermore, the incorporation of elements of postmodernism, reminiscent of works by Thomas Pynchon and J.G. Ballard, adds depth to the narrative. DeLillo’s deliberate intertextual references highlight the absurdity of consumer-driven culture and its profound impact on individual identity. The novel’s intertextual layers effectively comment on the overwhelming influence of mass media and technology in the modern world.
Suggested Readings
  1. Barthes, Roland. S/Z: An Essay. Hill and Wang, 1974.
  2. Genette, Gérard. Palimpsests: Literature in the Second Degree. Translated by Channa Newman and Claude Doubinsky. University of Nebraska Press, 1997.
  3. Kristeva, Julia. Desire in Language: A Semiotic Approach to Literature and Art. Translated by Thomas Gora, Alice Jardine, and Leon S. Roudiez. Columbia University Press, 1980.
  4. Lodge, David. The Art of Fiction. Vintage, 1992.
  5. Morrison, Toni. Playing in the Dark: Whiteness and the Literary Imagination. Harvard University Press, 1992.
  6. Riffaterre, Michael. Text Production. Columbia University Press, 1983.
  7. Todorov, Tzvetan. Mikhail Bakhtin: The Dialogical Principle. Translated by Wlad Godzich. University of Minnesota Press, 1984.
  8. Wolf, Werner, ed. Metareference across Media: Theory and Case Studies. Amsterdam University Press, 2009.
  9. Worton, Michael, and Judith Still, eds. Intertextuality: Theories and Practice. Manchester University Press, 1990.
  10. Zoran, Gabriel. The Evolution of the English Novel. Peter Lang, 1983.

Imperialism in Literature & Literary Theory

Imperialism is geopolitical ideology in which a dominant nation or state seeks to extend its influence, control, or authority over others.

Etymology of Imperialism

The term “imperialism” has its origins in the Latin word “imperium,” which means “supreme authority” or “command.” It specifically denotes the extension of a nation’s power and influence.

In the 19th century, during the era of European colonialism, it gained prominence as European powers expanded their dominion overseas. With the passage of time, it has come to signify various forms of political and cultural control by dominant nations over less powerful ones.

Meanings of Imperialism
Aspect of ImperialismDefinition in Literary Context
Political DominanceIn literature, the extension of one nation’s political control over another, often explored through themes of colonization and annexation.
Economic ExpansionDenotes the economic control of dominant nations over others, with a focus on resource exploitation, labor, and market influence in literary analysis.
Cultural HegemonyRefers to the imposition of dominant culture or nation’s values, norms, and beliefs on others, examined in literature for its impact on cultures and identities.
Narrative ImperialismThe dominance of specific storytelling traditions, styles, or voices in literature, often seen as the imposition of particular narrative perspectives or structures.
Metaphorical and Symbolic ImperialismThe use of imperialism as a metaphor or symbol to explore themes of power, control, and influence in various literary contexts.
Literary ImperialismDescribes the influence of one dominant literary tradition or canon on others, which may lead to the marginalization of indigenous or less-recognized literatures.
Definition of Imperialism as a Theoretical Term

Imperialism, as a theoretical term, refers to a geopolitical ideology or practice in which a dominant nation or state seeks to extend its influence, control, or authority over other regions, often through political, economic, or cultural means.

This concept is central to the analysis of power dynamics, global politics, and historical relationships between dominant and subordinate entities. Imperialism manifests itself in various forms, including territorial expansion, resource exploitation, cultural assimilation, and the imposition of ideologies.

Theorists, Works and Arguments
Key Theorists and Their Works:
  • J.A. Hobson:
    • Imperialism: A Study
    • Key Argument: Hobson argued that economic interests, particularly benefiting financial elites drove this movement. He believed that it served as a means to secure profits and investments abroad.
  • Vladimir Lenin:
    • Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism
    • Key Argument: Lenin expanded on Hobson’s ideas and viewed it as an advanced stage of capitalism. He emphasized the export of capital, the dominance of monopolies, and the intensification of class conflicts as central features of imperialism.
  • Edward Said:
    • Orientalism
    • Key Argument: Said’s work on post-colonialism and Orientalism explored how it was not only a physical occupation but also a form of cultural domination. He examined how the West constructed and misrepresented the East in literature and discourse.
  • Frantz Fanon:
    • The Wretched of the Earth
    • Key Argument: Fanon’s work focused on the psychological and social impact of imperialism on colonized peoples. He argued that colonialism led to the dehumanization and alienation of the colonized, advocating for anti-colonial resistance.
  • Hannah Arendt:
    • The Origins of Totalitarianism
    • Key Argument: Arendt’s analysis of imperialism and totalitarianism explored how imperialism could lead to oppressive regimes. She highlighted the consequences of statelessness and the loss of rights.
Key Arguments:
  • Economic Motivations: Many theorists, including Hobson and Lenin, emphasized economic interests as a driving force behind imperialism. This includes resource extraction, market control, and profit generation.
  • Political and Strategic Competition: Imperialism often involves geopolitical rivalries among powerful nations seeking to expand their influence and secure strategic advantages. This competition can lead to conflicts and wars.
  • Cultural and Ideological Justifications: Imperialism is sometimes justified through cultural and ideological narratives. It portrays the dominant nation as bringing civilization, progress, or enlightenment to less-developed regions, as analyzed by Said and others.
  • Psychological and Social Impact: The works of Fanon and others highlight the psychological and social consequences of imperialism, including the dehumanization, alienation, and resistance of colonized populations.

These key theorists, their works, and arguments contribute to a comprehensive understanding as a complex and multifaceted phenomenon encompassing economic, political, cultural, and psychological dimensions.

Imperialism and Literary Theories
TheoryRelevance
Marxist Literary TheoryIt is analyzed through a Marxist lens to explore how economic interests, class struggles, and exploitation are depicted in literature. This perspective emphasizes the role of imperialism in perpetuating capitalist structures and inequality.
Postcolonial Literary TheoryPostcolonial theory directly engages with its legacy, focusing on the impact of colonialism on colonized peoples, cultures, and literature. It examines themes of identity, resistance, and cultural hybridity in postcolonial texts.
Feminist Literary TheoryFeminist theory intersects it by examining the gendered aspects of colonialism and how women’s experiences under imperialism are depicted in literature. It explores issues of power, agency, and representation.
Cultural Studies and Cultural ImperialismCultural studies explore the effects of cultural imperialism, including the dominance of one culture over others. It analyzes how literature and media contribute to cultural hegemony and how marginalized voices are silenced.
Postmodernism and DeconstructionPostmodern and deconstructive approaches to literature challenge traditional narratives and discourses, including those shaped by imperialism. They deconstruct power dynamics and question authoritative narratives.
Critical Race TheoryCritical race theory examines how it interacts with racism. It analyzes how racial hierarchies are reinforced and resisted in literature, shedding light on the racial dimensions of imperialism.
Psychoanalytic Literary TheoryPsychoanalytic theory applies to characters in literature who grapple with the psychological effects of imperialism, such as identity conflicts, trauma, and alienation.
EcocriticismEcocriticism explores the environmental impacts of imperialism, such as resource exploitation and ecological degradation, as represented in literature. It considers how literature reflects ecological concerns related to imperialism.
Imperialism in Literary Criticism
  1. Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad:
    • Critique: Conrad’s Heart of Darkness provides a powerful critique of European imperialism in Africa. Through the journey of the protagonist, Marlow, into the Congo, Conrad exposes the brutality and moral decay that often accompanied imperialistic endeavors. The novel delves into the psychological impact of both the colonizers and the colonized, revealing the darkness within the hearts of those involved in the imperial project.
  2. Things Fall Apart by Chinua Achebe:
    • Critique: Achebe’s novel offers a postcolonial critique of it by focusing on the Igbo society in Nigeria before and during British colonial rule. Through the character of Okonkwo, Achebe portrays the devastating effects of cultural clash, the erosion of indigenous traditions, and the loss of identity that came with colonialism. It challenges the Eurocentric narratives of African primitivism prevalent during the imperial era.
  3. One Hundred Years of Solitude by Gabriel García Márquez:
    • Critique: Márquez’s masterpiece critiques both foreign imperialism and neocolonialism in Latin America. The fictional town of Macondo represents a microcosm of the region’s history, where foreign powers exploit resources, manipulate politics, and influence social dynamics. Márquez’s magical realism serves as a narrative tool to unveil the surreal and absurd consequences of imperialism on the people and the land.
  4. Burmese Days by George Orwell:
    • Critique: Orwell’s novel is a critical examination of British imperialism in Burma. Through the character of John Flory, an Englishman living in colonial Burma, Orwell exposes the inherent racism, corruption, and moral decay of the colonial system. The novel challenges the romanticized notions of empire prevalent during the time and highlights the tension between imperialists and the colonized.
Suggested Readings
  1. Conrad, Joseph. Heart of Darkness. Penguin Classics, 1995.
  2. Fanon, Frantz. The Wretched of the Earth. Grove Press, 2005.
  3. Lenin, Vladimir I. Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism. Verso, 2017.
  4. Said, Edward W. Orientalism. Vintage Books, 1979.
  5. Spivak, Gayatri Chakravorty. A Critique of Postcolonial Reason: Toward a History of the Vanishing Present. Harvard University Press, 1999.
  6. Stoler, Ann Laura. Carnal Knowledge and Imperial Power: Race and the Intimate in Colonial Rule. University of California Press, 2002.
  7. Todorov, Tzvetan. The Conquest of America: The Question of the Other. University of Oklahoma Press, 1999.
  8. Zizek, Slavoj. Living in the End Times. Verso, 2011.

Bourgeois in Literature &  Literary Theory

Bourgeois,” as a theoretical term, refers to the social class typically associated with property ownership, professional occupations, and a focus on financial stability within capitalist societies.

Etymology of Bourgeois

The term “bourgeois” originates from the French word “bourgeoisie,” commonly used during the late Middle Ages to describe the urban middle class, particularly merchants, tradespeople, and city-dwelling professionals. The word is rooted in the Old French “burgeis,” which refers to an inhabitant of a town or a walled city.

With time, it evolved to signify the social class that emerged as a result of urbanization and capitalism, characterized by their ownership of property and engagement in commerce.

In the context of political and economic theories, “bourgeois” often denotes the middle or capitalist class, and it has been widely used to critique the values, aspirations, and social attitudes associated with this group.

Meanings of Bourgeois
MeaningsDescription
Socioeconomic ClassIt refers to the middle class associated with property ownership, professional jobs, and financial stability.
Capitalist ClassIn Marxist theory, it represents the capitalist class controlling production and exploiting the working class.
Cultural Attitudes and ValuesDescribes conventional, conformist, and materialistic behaviors often seen in literature and cultural discussions.
Literary Character TypeIn literature, bourgeois characters embody middle-class values and serve as a critique of societal norms.
Societal CritiqueIt is used to criticize the conformity and conservatism of the middle class in literature and theoretical discourse.
Historical ContextHistorically describes the rising urban middle class during the late Middle Ages and early capitalism.
Definition of Bourgeois as a Theoretical Term

“Bourgeois,” as a theoretical term, refers to the social class typically associated with property ownership, professional occupations, and a focus on financial stability within capitalist societies. It is often used in Marxist theory to denote the capitalist class, characterized by its control over the means of production and its perceived exploitation of the working class.

This term is central to critiques of class structures, economic relations, and societal hierarchies, serving as a lens for understanding power dynamics and class struggle in various contexts.

Bourgeois: Theorists, Works, and Arguments
Theorists:
  • Karl Marx: Marx extensively discussed the bourgeoisie in his works, particularly in The Communist Manifesto, emphasizing their role in capitalist society and their exploitation of the proletariat.
Works:
  • The Communist Manifesto by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels: This seminal work provides a comprehensive analysis of the bourgeoisie as a class and their impact on society.
Arguments:
  • The Bourgeoisie as the Capitalist Class: The theorists argue that the bourgeoisie represents the capitalist class, owning and controlling the means of production, and benefiting from the labor of the working class.
  • Exploitation of the Proletariat: Marx and Engels contend that the bourgeoisie’s pursuit of profit leads to the exploitation of the working class, resulting in class struggle and alienation.
  • Historical Materialism: Their analysis of the bourgeoisie is rooted in historical materialism, asserting that economic conditions shape society and class dynamics.
Bourgeois and Literary Theories
  1. Marxist Literary Theory:
    • In Marxist literary theory, the bourgeoisie is seen as a central theme in literature. Works of literature are often analyzed to uncover how they portray and critique the bourgeoisie, their values, and their impact on society. The bourgeoisie is typically associated with themes of class struggle, exploitation, and the inequalities of capitalist systems.
  2. Realism and Naturalism:
    • The literary movements of realism and naturalism often depict bourgeois life in a detailed and critical manner. These theories emphasize portraying everyday life, including the struggles, desires, and aspirations of the middle class, to provide a realistic representation of society. Authors like Émile Zola explored the bourgeois world in their works to shed light on societal issues.
  3. Feminist Literary Theory:
    • Feminist literary theory frequently examines how the bourgeois family structure and gender roles are depicted in literature. It explores the ways in which bourgeois values and norms can reinforce traditional gender roles and expectations. Feminist critics analyze how literature challenges or reinforces these structures.
  4. Cultural Studies:
    • Cultural studies explore the role of the bourgeoisie in shaping cultural production and consumption. This theory investigates how the middle class influences the creation and dissemination of culture, including literature. It examines the impact of bourgeois cultural values and tastes on the production of literature and the formation of canons.
  5. Postcolonial Theory:
    • Postcolonial literary theory may examine how the bourgeois class, often of colonial or imperial origins, is depicted in literature. It delves into the tensions and contradictions within bourgeois identity in colonial and postcolonial contexts, as well as the ways in which literature reflects or challenges these dynamics.
Bourgeois in Literary Criticism
Author and WorkDescription
Émile Zola – Germinal (1885)Set in 19th-century France, Germinal delves into the lives of coal miners, depicting their grueling work conditions and abject poverty. The novel serves as a powerful critique of the bourgeoisie, particularly mine owners, and their exploitation of the working class. It explores themes of class struggle and social injustice.
John Steinbeck – The Grapes of Wrath (1939)The Grapes of Wrath is a powerful portrayal of the Joad family’s journey during the Great Depression. This novel critiques the capitalist system and the bourgeoisie’s impact on ordinary people as the family faces adversity and exploitation while seeking a better life. Steinbeck’s work is a vivid exploration of social and economic inequality.
Upton Sinclair – The Jungle (1906)Set in Chicago’s meatpacking industry, The Jungle exposes the harsh working conditions and unsanitary practices faced by immigrant laborers. While primarily focusing on the working class, the novel also critiques the bourgeoisie, particularly those who profit from labor exploitation. Sinclair’s work is a scathing critique of capitalism and the industrial bourgeoisie.
Maxim Gorky – Mother (1907)Mother follows the journey of Pelageya Nilovna, a working-class woman who becomes politically radicalized. The novel explores her transformation and her role in the labor movement. While centered on the working class, the novel also critiques the bourgeoisie, including factory owners and the oppressive government, as sources of suffering and injustice. Maxim Gorky’s work is a powerful portrayal of class struggle and revolutionary potential.
Suggested Readings
  1. Berman, Marshall. All That Is Solid Melts into Air: The Experience of Modernity. Verso, 1983.
  2. Eagleton, Terry. The Ideology of the Aesthetic. Blackwell, 1990.
  3. Engels, Friedrich. The Condition of the Working Class in England. Translated by W. O. Henderson and W. H. Chaloner, Oxford University Press, 1993.
  4. Jameson, Fredric. Postmodernism, or, The Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism. Duke University Press, 1991.
  5. Lukács, Georg. History and Class Consciousness: Studies in Marxist Dialectics. Translated by Rodney Livingstone, MIT Press, 1971.
  6. Marx, Karl. The Communist Manifesto. Edited by Friedrich Engels, Penguin Classics, 2002.
  7. Moretti, Franco. Modern Epic: The World-System from Goethe to García Márquez. Verso, 1996.
  8. Sinclair, Upton. The Jungle. Doubleday, 1906.
  9. Steinbeck, John. The Grapes of Wrath. Penguin Classics, 2006.
  10. Zola, Émile. Germinal. Translated by Roger Pearson, Oxford University Press, 2004.

Bricolage in Literature & Literary Theory

Bricolage, as a theoretical term, refers to a creative process in which individuals or artists construct new ideas, concepts, or works by repurposing and combining diverse and often unrelated elements, materials, or sources.

Etymology of Bricolage

The word “bricolage” has its origins in the French language. It comes from the verb “bricoler,” which means “to tinker” or “to putter around.” The term “bricolage” itself was first introduced by the French anthropologist Claude Lévi-Strauss in the mid-20th century. In the context of anthropology, Lévi-Strauss used “bricolage” to describe the way in which traditional societies and cultures create new objects or solutions by using whatever materials or resources are readily available to them.

With time, the term has been adopted in various fields, including literature and art, to refer to the practice of creating something new through a combination of diverse and often improvised elements or techniques.

Meanings of Bricolage
AspectMeaning
Resourceful CreativityCreating something new using available resources in an improvised manner.
Collage of ElementsAssembling diverse elements from various sources to construct a new narrative.
IntertextualityReferencing and weaving ideas, symbols, or motifs from existing texts into a new work.
Deconstruction and ReconstructionBreaking down conventional structures and reconstructing them innovatively.
Postmodern ExpressionBlurring boundaries, remixing fragments, and reflecting contemporary complexity.
Multiplicity of InterpretationsAllowing for multiple reader-generated meanings and interpretations.
HybridizationBlending genres, forms, or styles to create unique, uncategorizable literary forms.
Cultural CommentaryReflecting modern life’s interconnectedness and challenging traditional norms.
Subversion of HierarchiesChallenging established narratives and amplifying diverse voices and perspectives.
Definition of Bricolage as a Theoretical Term

Bricolage, as a theoretical term, refers to a creative process in which individuals or artists construct new ideas, concepts, or works by repurposing and combining diverse and often unrelated elements, materials, or sources.

This approach emphasizes resourceful improvisation and the utilization of available resources to generate innovative and unconventional outcomes. It challenges traditional structures and paradigms, reflecting a postmodern sensibility that values multiplicity, intertextuality, and the blurring of boundaries in the creation of meaning and artistic expression.

Bricolage: Theorists, Works and Arguments

TheoristWorkArgument
Claude Lévi-StraussThe Savage MindIntroduced bricolage in anthropology, highlighting its role in traditional societies for constructing objects from available resources.
Roland BarthesS/ZApplied bricolage to semiotics and literature, emphasizing that authors construct meaning by combining signs and symbols from various sources.
Michel de CerteauThe Practice of Everyday LifeExplored bricolage in everyday practices, suggesting individuals navigate modern life by creatively assembling cultural fragments.
Jean-François LyotardThe Postmodern ConditionAssociated bricolage with postmodernism, highlighting its role in challenging grand narratives and traditional hierarchies, emphasizing a fragmented worldview.
Homi K. BhabhaThe Location of CultureApplied bricolage to postcolonial theory, arguing colonized peoples use it to negotiate and subvert dominant colonial narratives and identities.
Julia KristevaRevolution in Poetic LanguageExplored the interplay of bricolage and language, emphasizing how it contributes to poetic expression and disrupts fixed meaning.
Bricolage and Literary Theories
Literary TheoryRelevance to Bricolage
Reader-Response TheoryIt emphasizes reader’s role in creating meaning, aligning with it to focus on individual interpretation and creativity.
PoststructuralismIt challenges fixed meanings and hierarchies, akin to bricolage’s disruption of conventional structures and multiplicity of interpretations.
IntertextualityIt eplores how texts reference others, aligning with bricolage’s weaving of diverse elements from various sources into new narratives.
Feminist TheoryIt critiques gender norms, akin to its deconstruction and reconstruction of elements to challenge established norms.
Postcolonial TheoryIt examines colonial impact, aligning with bricolage’s role in postcolonial contexts where marginalized voices reconstruct narratives.
DeconstructionIt questions fixed meanings, resonating with bricolage’s practice of breaking down and reassembling elements unconventionally.
Cultural StudiesIt eplores cultural construction, aligning with bricolage’s focus on creative culture construction through assembling diverse elements.
New HistoricismIt examines literature’s historical context, akin to bricolage reflecting contemporary culture’s complexity shaped by diverse influences.
Psychoanalytic TheoryIt explores subconscious motivations, resonating with bricolage’s emphasis on creative, sometimes unconscious, meaning construction.
Bricolage in Literary Criticism
  1. A Visit from the Goon Squad by Jennifer Egan (2010):
    • Bricolage Element: This novel features a form of bricolage through its non-linear narrative structure and diverse narrative techniques.
    • Explanation: Egan’s novel employs a fragmented narrative that combines various storytelling approaches, including traditional prose, PowerPoint slides, and a fictional celebrity interview. This bricolage approach reflects the postmodern theoretical perspective, emphasizing the multiplicity of perspectives and the deconstruction of linear narratives.
  2. House of Leaves by Mark Z. Danielewski (2000):
    • Bricolage Element: The novel showcases bricolage through its innovative use of typography, footnotes, and narrative layers.
    • Explanation: House of Leaves is a prime example of poststructuralist bricolage. It challenges fixed meanings and narrative conventions by using unconventional typography and layout to mirror the protagonist’s descent into madness. The text itself becomes a labyrinth, reflecting the narrative’s themes of disorientation and uncertainty.
  3. Cloud Atlas by David Mitchell (2004):
    • Bricolage Element: The novel weaves together multiple narratives set in different time periods and styles.
    • Explanation: Mitchell’s use of bricolage aligns with the postmodern perspective. He combines diverse narratives, genres, and styles to create a larger thematic tapestry. This approach encourages readers to make connections across time and space, emphasizing the intertextual nature of storytelling.
  4. S. by J.J. Abrams and Doug Dorst (2013):
    • Bricolage Element: The novel takes the form of a physical book with two parallel narratives—one in the book’s printed text and the other in handwritten notes and annotations.
    • Explanation: S. is a postmodern bricolage that challenges the boundaries between authorship, interpretation, and reader engagement. The dual narratives invite readers to actively participate in the construction of meaning within the text, echoing the principles of reader-response theory.
  5. Lincoln in the Bardo by George Saunders (2017):
    • Bricolage Element: The novel combines historical accounts, primary sources, and fictionalized dialogues to create a chorus of voices.
    • Explanation: Saunders’ use of bricolage aligns with a postcolonial perspective, as it involves the reinterpretation and reconstruction of historical accounts. By blending real historical sources with fictional voices, Saunders challenges traditional historical narratives and highlights the multiplicity of perspectives.

These examples illustrate how bricolage in literature can align with various theoretical perspectives, including postmodernism, poststructuralism, reader-response theory, and postcolonialism, to create innovative and thought-provoking narratives.

Suggested Readings
  1. Derrida, Jacques. Of Grammatology. Translated by Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak, Johns Hopkins University Press, 1997.
  2. Barthes, Roland. S/Z: An Essay. Translated by Richard Miller, Hill and Wang, 1974.
  3. Kristeva, Julia. Revolution in Poetic Language. Translated by Margaret Waller, Columbia University Press, 1984.
  4. Levi-Strauss, Claude. The Savage Mind. University of Chicago Press, 1966.
  5. Danielewski, Mark Z. House of Leaves. Pantheon, 2000.
  6. Mitchell, David. Cloud Atlas. Random House, 2004.
  7. Abrams, J.J. and Doug Dorst. S. Mulholland Books, 2013.
  8. Saunders, George. Lincoln in the Bardo. Random House, 2017.