"Michael" by William Wordsworth: A Critical Analysis

Introduction: “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Table of Contents

“Michael” by William Wordsworth first appeared in 1800 as part of the second edition of Lyrical Ballads, a collection co-authored with Samuel Taylor Coleridge that helped inaugurate the Romantic movement in English literature. This pastoral narrative poem, subtitled “A Pastoral Poem,” explores themes of rural life, familial love, and the destructive impact of economic pressures on traditional communities. The poem’s portrayal of Michael, an aged shepherd, and his deep bond with his land and family resonates with Wordsworth’s ideals of simplicity and the sanctity of the natural world. Its vivid imagery and emotional depth make it a cornerstone of Romantic poetry and a popular choice for anthologies and classrooms, as it exemplifies Wordsworth’s poetic philosophy of finding the sublime in everyday life and the rural experience.

Text: “Michael” by William Wordsworth

If from the public way you turn your steps

Up the tumultuous brook of Green-head Ghyll,
You will suppose that with an upright path
Your feet must struggle; in such bold ascent

The pastoral mountains front you, face to face.
But, courage! for around that boisterous brook
The mountains have all opened out themselves,

And made a hidden valley of their own.
No habitation can be seen; but they
Who journey thither find themselves alone

With a few sheep, with rocks and stones, and kites
That overhead are sailing in the sky.
It is in truth an utter solitude;

Nor should I have made mention of this Dell
But for one object which you might pass by,
Might see and notice not. Beside the brook

Appears a straggling heap of unhewn stones!
And to that simple object appertains
A story–unenriched with strange events,

Yet not unfit, I deem, for the fireside,
Or for the summer shade. It was the first
Of those domestic tales that spake to me

Of Shepherds, dwellers in the valleys, men
Whom I already loved;–not verily
For their own sakes, but for the fields and hills

Where was their occupation and abode.
And hence this Tale, while I was yet a Boy
Careless of books, yet having felt the power

Of Nature, by the gentle agency
Of natural objects, led me on to feel
For passions that were not my own, and think

(At random and imperfectly indeed)
On man, the heart of man, and human life.
Therefore, although it be a history

Homely and rude, I will relate the same
For the delight of a few natural hearts;
And, with yet fonder feeling, for the sake

Of youthful Poets, who among these hills
Will be my second self when I am gone.
Upon the forest-side in Grasmere Vale

There dwelt a Shepherd, Michael was his name;
An old man, stout of heart, and strong of limb.
His bodily frame had been from youth to age

Of an unusual strength: his mind was keen,
Intense, and frugal, apt for all affairs,
And in his shepherd’s calling he was prompt

And watchful more than ordinary men.
Hence had he learned the meaning of all winds,
Of blasts of every tone; and oftentimes,

When others heeded not, he heard the South
Make subterraneous music, like the noise
Of bagpipers on distant Highland hills.

The Shepherd, at such warning, of his flock
Bethought him, and he to himself would say,
“The winds are now devising work for me!”

nd, truly, at all times, the storm, that drives
The traveller to a shelter, summoned him
Up to the mountains: he had been alone

Amid the heart of many thousand mists,
That came to him, and left him, on the heights.
So lived he till his eightieth year was past.

And grossly that man errs, who should suppose
That the green valleys, and the streams and rocks,
Were things indifferent to the Shepherd’s thoughts.

Fields, where with cheerful spirits he had breathed
The common air; hills, which with vigorous step
He had so often climbed; which had impressed

So many incidents upon his mind
Of hardship, skill or courage, joy or fear;
Which, like a book, preserved the memory

Of the dumb animals, whom he had saved,
Had fed or sheltered, linking to such acts
The certainty of honourable gain;

Those fields, those hills–what could they less? had laid
Strong hold on his affections, were to him
A pleasurable feeling of blind love,

The pleasure which there is in life itself .
His days had not been passed in singleness.
His Helpmate was a comely matron, old–

Though younger than himself full twenty years.
She was a woman of a stirring life,
Whose heart was in her house: two wheels she had

Of antique form; this large, for spinning wool;
That small, for flax; and, if one wheel had rest,
It was because the other was at work.

The Pair had but one inmate in their house,
An only Child, who had been born to them
When Michael, telling o’er his years, began

To deem that he was old,–in shepherd’s phrase,
With one foot in the grave. This only Son,
With two brave sheep-dogs tried in many a storm,

The one of an inestimable worth,
Made all their household. I may truly say,
That they were as a proverb in the vale

For endless industry. When day was gone,
And from their occupations out of doors
The Son and Father were come home, even then,

Their labour did not cease; unless when all
Turned to the cleanly supper-board, and there,
Each with a mess of pottage and skimmed milk,

Sat round the basket piled with oaten cakes,
And their plain home-made cheese. Yet when the meal
Was ended, Luke (for so the Son was named)

And his old Father both betook themselves
To such convenient work as might employ
Their hands by the fireside; perhaps to card

Wool for the Housewife’s spindle, or repair
Some injury done to sickle, flail, or scythe,
Or other implement of house or field.

Down from the ceiling, by the chimney’s edge,
That in our ancient uncouth country style
With huge and black projection overbrowed

Large space beneath, as duly as the light
Of day grew dim the Housewife hung a lamp,
An aged utensil, which had performed

Service beyond all others of its kind.
Early at evening did it burn–and late,
Surviving comrade of uncounted hours,

Which, going by from year to year, had found,
And left the couple neither gay perhaps
Nor cheerful, yet with objects and with hopes,

Living a life of eager industry.
And now, when Luke had reached his eighteenth year,
There by the light of this old lamp they sate,

Father and Son, while far into the night
The Housewife plied her own peculiar work,
Making the cottage through the silent hours

Murmur as with the sound of summer flies.
This light was famous in its neighbourhood,
And was a public symbol of the life

That thrifty Pair had lived. For, as it chanced,
Their cottage on a plot of rising ground
Stood single, with large prospect, north and south,

High into Easedale, up to Dunmail-Raise,
And westward to the village near the lake;
And from this constant light, so regular

And so far seen, the House itself, by all
Who dwelt within the limits of the vale,
Both old and young, was named The Evening Star.

Thus living on through such a length of years,
The Shepherd, if he loved himself, must needs
Have loved his Helpmate; but to Michael’s heart

This son of his old age was yet more dear–
Less from instinctive tenderness, the same
Fond spirit that blindly works in the blood of all–

Than that a child, more than all other gifts
That earth can offer to declining man,
Brings hope with it, and forward-looking thoughts,

And stirrings of inquietude, when they
By tendency of nature needs must fail.
Exceeding was the love he bare to him,

His heart and his heart’s joy! For oftentimes
Old Michael, while he was a babe in arms,
Had done him female service, not alone

For pastime and delight, as is the use
Of fathers, but with patient mind enforced
To acts of tenderness; and he had rocked
His cradle, as with a woman’s gentle hand.
And, in a later time, ere yet the Boy
Had put on boy’s attire, did Michael love,
Albeit of a stern unbending mind,
To have the Young-one in his sight, when he
Wrought in the field, or on his shepherd’s stool
Sate with a fettered sheep before him stretched
Under the large old oak, that near his door
Stood single, and, from matchless depth of shade,
Chosen for the Shearer’s covert from the sun,
Thence in our rustic dialect was called
The Clipping Tree, a name which yet it bears.
There, while they two were sitting in the shade,
With others round them, earnest all and blithe,
Would Michael exercise his heart with looks
Of fond correction and reproof bestowed
Upon the Child, if he disturbed the sheep
By catching at their legs, or with his shouts
Scared them, while they lay still beneath the shears.
And when by Heaven’s good grace the boy grew up
A healthy Lad, and carried in his cheek
Two steady roses that were five years old;
Then Michael from a winter coppice cut
With his own hand a sapling, which he hooped
With iron, making it throughout in all
Due requisites a perfect shepherd’s staff,
And gave it to the Boy; wherewith equipt
He as a watchman oftentimes was placed
At gate or gap, to stem or turn the flock;
And, to his office prematurely called,
There stood the urchin, as you will divine,
Something between a hindrance and a help,
And for this cause not always, I believe,
Receiving from his Father hire of praise;
Though nought was left undone which staff, or voice,
Or looks, or threatening gestures, could perform.
But soon as Luke, full ten years old, could stand
Against the mountain blasts; and to the heights,
Not fearing toil, nor length of weary ways,
He with his Father daily went, and they
Were as companions, why should I relate
That objects which the Shepherd loved before
Were dearer now? that from the Boy there came
Feelings and emanations–things which were
Light to the sun and music to the wind;
And that the old Man’s heart seemed born again?
Thus in his Father’s sight the Boy grew up:
And now, when he had reached his eighteenth year,
He was his comfort and his daily hope.
While in this sort the simple household lived
From day to day, to Michael’s ear there came
Distressful tidings. Long before the time
Of which I speak, the Shepherd had been bound
In surety for his brother’s son, a man
Of an industrious life, and ample means;
But unforeseen misfortunes suddenly
Had prest upon him; and old Michael now
Was summoned to discharge the forfeiture,
A grievous penalty, but little less
Than half his substance. This unlooked-for claim
At the first hearing, for a moment took
More hope out of his life than he supposed
That any old man ever could have lost.
As soon as he had armed himself with strength
To look his trouble in the face, it seemed
The Shepherd’s sole resource to sell at once
A portion of his patrimonial fields.
Such was his first resolve; he thought again,
And his heart failed him. “Isabel,” said he,
Two evenings after he had heard the news,
“I have been toiling more than seventy years,
And in the open sunshine of God’s love
Have we all lived; yet, if these fields of ours
Should pass into a stranger’s hand, I think
That I could not lie quiet in my grave.
Our lot is a hard lot; the sun himself
Has scarcely been more diligent than I;
And I have lived to be a fool at last
To my own family. An evil man
That was, and made an evil choice, if he
Were false to us; and, if he were not false,
There are ten thousand to whom loss like this
Had been no sorrow. I forgive him;–but
‘Twere better to be dumb than to talk thus.
“When I began, my purpose was to speak
Of remedies and of a cheerful hope.
Our Luke shall leave us, Isabel; the land
Shall not go from us, and it shall be free;
He shall possess it, free as is the wind
That passes over it. We have, thou know’st,
Another kinsman–he will be our friend
In this distress. He is a prosperous man,
Thriving in trade and Luke to him shall go,
And with his kinsman’s help and his own thrift
He quickly will repair this loss, and then
He may return to us. If here he stay,
What can be done? Where every one is poor,
What can be gained?”
At this the old Man paused,
And Isabel sat silent, for her mind
Was busy, looking back into past times.
There’s Richard Bateman, thought she to herself,
He was a parish-boy–at the church-door
They made a gathering for him, shillings, pence,
And halfpennies, wherewith the neighbours bought
A basket, which they filled with pedlar’s wares;
And, with this basket on his arm, the lad
Went up to London, found a master there,
Who, out of many, chose the trusty boy
To go and overlook his merchandise
Beyond the seas; where he grew wondrous rich,
And left estates and monies to the poor,
And, at his birth-place, built a chapel floored
With marble, which he sent from foreign lands.
These thoughts, and many others of like sort,
Passed quickly through the mind of Isabel,
And her face brightened. The old Man was glad,
And thus resumed:–“Well, Isabel! this scheme
These two days has been meat and drink to me.
Far more than we have lost is left us yet.
We have enough–I wish indeed that I
Were younger;–but this hope is a good hope.
Make ready Luke’s best garments, of the best
Buy for him more, and let us send him forth
To-morrow, or the next day, or to-night:
–If he could go, the boy should go to-night.”
Here Michael ceased, and to the fields went forth
With a light heart. The Housewife for five days
Was restless morn and night, and all day long
Wrought on with her best fingers to prepare.
Things needful for the journey of her Son.
But Isabel was glad when Sunday came
To stop her in her work: for, when she lay
By Michael’s side, she through the last two nights
Heard him, how he was troubled in his sleep:
And when they rose at morning she could see
That all his hopes were gone. That day at noon
She said to Luke, while they two by themselves
Were sitting at the door, “Thou must not go:
We have no other Child but thee to lose,
None to remember–do not go away,
For if thou leave thy Father he will die.”
The Youth made answer with a jocund voice;
And Isabel, when she had told her fears,
Recovered heart. That evening her best fare
Did she bring forth, and all together sat
Like happy people round a Christmas fire.
With daylight Isabel resumed her work;
And all the ensuing week the house appeared
As cheerful as a grove in Spring: at length
The expected letter from their kinsman came,
With kind assurances that he would do
His utmost for the welfare of the Boy;
To which requests were added, that forthwith
He might be sent to him. Ten times or more
The letter was read over, Isabel
Went forth to show it to the neighbours round;
Nor was there at that time on English land
A prouder heart than Luke’s. When Isabel
Had to her house returned, the old man said,
“He shall depart to-morrow.” To this word
The Housewife answered, talking much of things
Which, if at such short notice he should go,
Would surely be forgotten. But at length
She gave consent, and Michael was at ease.
Near the tumultuous brook of Green-head Ghyll,
In that deep valley, Michael had designed
To build a Sheep-fold; and, before he heard
The tidings of his melancholy loss,
For this same purpose he had gathered up
A heap of stones, which by the streamlet’s edge
Lay thrown together, ready for the work.
With Luke that evening thitherward he walked:
And soon as they had reached the place he stopped,
And thus the old Man spake to him:–“My Son,
To-morrow thou wilt leave me: with full heart
I look upon thee, for thou art the same
That wert a promise to me ere thy birth,
And all thy life hast been my daily joy.
I will relate to thee some little part
Of our two histories; ’twill do thee good
When thou art from me, even if I should touch
On things thou canst not know of.–After thou
First cam’st into the world–as oft befalls
To new-born infants–thou didst sleep away
Two days, and blessings from thy Father’s tongue
Then fell upon thee. Day by day passed on,
And still I loved thee with increasing love.
Never to living ear came sweeter sounds
Than when I heard thee by our own fireside
First uttering, without words, a natural tune;
While thou, a feeding babe, didst in thy joy
Sing at thy Mother’s breast. Month followed month,
And in the open fields my life was passed,
And on the mountains; else I think that thou
Hadst been brought up upon thy Father’s knees.
But we were playmates, Luke: among these hills,
As well thou knowest, in us the old and young
Have played together, nor with me didst thou
Lack any pleasure which a boy can know.”
Luke had a manly heart; but at these words
He sobbed aloud. The old Man grasped his hand,
And said, “Nay, do not take it so–I see
That these are things of which I need not speak.
–Even to the utmost I have been to thee
A kind and a good Father: and herein
I but repay a gift which I myself
Received at others’ hands; for, though now old
Beyond the common life of man, I still
Remember them who loved me in my youth.
Both of them sleep together: here they lived,
As all their Forefathers had done; and, when
At length their time was come, they were not loth
To give their bodies to the family mould.
I wished that thou should’st live the life they lived:
But, ’tis a long time to look back, my Son,
And see so little gain from threescore years.
These fields were burthened when they came to me;
Till I was forty years of age, not more
Than half of my inheritance was mine.
I toiled and toiled; God blessed me in my work,
And till these three weeks past the land was free.
–It looks as if it never could endure
Another Master. Heaven forgive me, Luke,
If I judge ill for thee, but it seems good
That thou should’st go.”
At this the old Man paused;
Then, pointing to the stones near which they stood,
Thus, after a short silence, he resumed:
“This was a work for us; and now, my Son,
It is a work for me. But, lay one stone–
Here, lay it for me, Luke, with thine own hands.
Nay, Boy, be of good hope;–we both may live
To see a better day. At eighty-four
I still am strong and hale;–do thou thy part;
I will do mine.–I will begin again
With many tasks that were resigned to thee:
Up to the heights, and in among the storms,
Will I without thee go again, and do
All works which I was wont to do alone,
Before I knew thy face.–Heaven bless thee, Boy!
Thy heart these two weeks has been beating fast
With many hopes; it should be so–yes–yes–
knew that thou could’st never have a wish
To leave me, Luke: thou hast been bound to me
Only by links of love: when thou art gone,
What will be left to us!–But, I forget
My purposes. Lay now the corner-stone,
As I requested; and hereafter, Luke,
When thou art gone away, should evil men
Be thy companions, think of me, my Son,
And of this moment; hither turn thy thoughts,
And God will strengthen thee: amid all fear
And all temptation, Luke, I pray that thou
May’st bear in mind the life thy Fathers lived,
Who, being innocent, did for that cause
Bestir them in good deeds. Now, fare thee well–
When thou return’st, thou in this place wilt see
A work which is not here: a covenant
‘Twill be between us; but, whatever fate
Befall thee, I shall love thee to the last,
And bear thy memory with me to the grave.”
The Shepherd ended here; and Luke stooped down,
And, as his Father had requested, laid
The first stone of the Sheep-fold. At the sight
The old Man’s grief broke from him; to his heart
He pressed his Son, he kissed him and wept;
And to the house together they returned.
–Hushed was that House in peace, or seeming peace,
Ere the night fell:–with morrow’s dawn the Boy
Began his journey, and, when he had reached
The public way, he put on a bold face;
And all the neighbours, as he passed their doors,
Came forth with wishes and with farewell prayers,
That followed him till he was out of sight.
A good report did from their Kinsman come,
Of Luke and his well-doing; and the Boy
Wrote loving letters, full of wondrous news,
Which, as the Housewife phrased it, were throughout
“The prettiest letters that were ever seen.”
Both parents read them with rejoicing hearts.
So, many months passed on: and once again
The Shepherd went about his daily work
With confident and cheerful thoughts; and now
Sometimes when he could find a leisure hour
He to that valley took his way, and there
Wrought at the Sheep-fold. Meantime Luke began
To slacken in his duty; and, at length,
He in the dissolute city gave himself
To evil courses: ignominy and shame
Fell on him, so that he was driven at last
To seek a hiding-place beyond the seas.
There is a comfort in the strength of love;
‘Twill make a thing endurable, which else
Would overset the brain, or break the heart:
I have conversed with more than one who well
Remember the old Man, and what he was
Years after he had heard this heavy news.
His bodily frame had been from youth to age
Of an unusual strength. Among the rocks
He went, and still looked up to sun and cloud,
And listened to the wind; and, as before,
Performed all kinds of labour for his sheep,
And for the land, his small inheritance.
And to that hollow dell from time to time
Did he repair, to build the Fold of which
His flock had need. ‘Tis not forgotten yet
The pity which was then in every heart
For the old Man–and ’tis believed by all
That many and many a day he thither went,
And never lifted up a single stone.
There, by the Sheep-fold, sometimes was he seen
Sitting alone, or with his faithful Dog,
Then old, beside him, lying at his feet.
The length of full seven years, from time to time,
He at the building of this Sheep-fold wrought,
And left the work unfinished when he died.
Three years, or little more, did Isabel
Survive her Husband: at her death the estate
Was sold, and went into a stranger’s hand.
The Cottage which was named The Evening Star
Is gone–the ploughshare has been through the ground
On which it stood; great changes have been wrought
In all the neighbourhood:–yet the oak is left
That grew beside their door; and the remains
Of the unfinished Sheep-fold may be seen
Beside the boisterous brook of Green-head Ghyll.

Annotations: “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Lines	Annotation
1-10	The poem begins with an invitation to leave the public way and ascend the rugged Green-head Ghyll. The imagery of the “tumultuous brook” and “pastoral mountains” creates a vivid natural setting. This opening establishes solitude and a sense of separation from the bustling world, setting the stage for a contemplative tale.
11-20	The speaker describes the isolated valley, where only a few sheep and wildlife reside. The “utter solitude” mirrors the simplicity and tranquility of rural life. The mention of a “straggling heap of unhewn stones” foreshadows the story of the Sheep-fold and its symbolic significance.
21-30	The speaker introduces his inspiration, reflecting on how domestic tales of shepherds taught him empathy and a connection to human life through nature. This section highlights Wordsworth’s Romantic ideals, valuing nature as a teacher of emotions and morality.
31-40	The narrative transitions to the shepherd Michael, who lives in Grasmere Vale. Michael’s strength, keen mind, and close connection with nature and his flock establish him as a figure of resilience and pastoral wisdom.
41-50	Michael’s understanding of the natural world is emphasized, particularly his ability to interpret the winds. This connection underscores the theme of harmony between humans and nature, a recurring idea in Wordsworth’s work.
51-60	Michael’s life of solitude and endurance is portrayed as heroic. His daily tasks and connection to the rugged landscape emphasize the dignity and fulfillment found in pastoral labor.
61-70	The emotional attachment Michael feels for his land is explored. The fields and hills serve as a “book” preserving his life’s memories, tying personal history to the landscape. Wordsworth emphasizes the deep bonds between people and their environment.
71-80	The introduction of Isabel, Michael’s wife, brings a domestic dimension. Her industrious nature and the description of her spinning wheels highlight the couple’s hardworking and self-sufficient lifestyle.
81-90	Luke, their only child, is introduced. The late birth of the son reinforces his significance to the aging couple. The family dynamic is established as close-knit and rooted in mutual reliance.
91-100	The family’s routine is described in detail, emphasizing their industriousness and the harmony in their simple life. This portrayal aligns with Wordsworth’s celebration of ordinary rural lives.
101-110	The domestic setting becomes symbolic, with the “light of the old lamp” representing stability and continuity. The family’s evenings of communal labor demonstrate unity and purpose.
111-120	The lamp becomes a neighborhood symbol, earning the house the name “The Evening Star.” This detail connects the family to the wider community while maintaining their distinctiveness.
121-130	Michael’s profound love for Luke is explored. His son represents hope and renewal, offering a stark contrast to the couple’s aging and the challenges they face.
131-140	The relationship between Michael and Luke deepens. The old shepherd’s past experiences as a father reveal tenderness and emotional growth, further humanizing his character.
141-150	Michael’s attachment to Luke is both practical and emotional, as he sees his son as a continuation of his legacy. This reflects themes of generational connection and familial love.
151-160	The narrative shifts to a moment of hardship. Michael’s financial troubles, stemming from a bond for a relative, introduce conflict, highlighting the precariousness of rural life.
161-170	The couple debates the future of their land. Michael’s anguish over the possibility of losing the family’s patrimony underscores the symbolic importance of the land in their lives.
171-180	Michael resolves to send Luke away to preserve the land, a decision that reflects his selflessness and enduring hope. This moment marks a turning point in the narrative.
181-190	The preparations for Luke’s departure are detailed, illustrating Isabel’s care and Michael’s stoic determination. This reinforces the emotional gravity of the decision.
191-200	Michael and Luke share a poignant moment at the site of the unfinished Sheep-fold. Michael’s instructions to Luke imbue the place with symbolic meaning, tying it to family legacy and moral strength.
201-210	The scene at the Sheep-fold becomes a covenant between father and son. Michael’s words reflect his hopes and fears, blending personal and universal themes of love, loss, and perseverance.
211-220	Luke departs, and the neighbors’ farewells emphasize the community’s respect for the family. The narrative shifts to Luke’s journey and initial success, offering a brief sense of hope.
221-230	Luke’s downfall in the city introduces tragedy. His failure contrasts with his idyllic upbringing, reflecting Wordsworth’s critique of urban life’s corrupting influences.
231-240	Michael’s life after Luke’s departure is marked by quiet endurance. His continued visits to the Sheep-fold symbolize his unwavering love and connection to his son.
241-250	The poem concludes with a sense of irrevocable change. The sale of the family’s land and the disappearance of the cottage mark the end of an era, leaving only faint traces of the family’s legacy.
251-260	The community’s memory of Michael reflects a collective sense of loss and respect. The unfinished Sheep-fold stands as a poignant reminder of his steadfastness and the challenges he endured.
261-270	The narrative shifts to Michael’s solitary visits to the Sheep-fold. His inability to complete it symbolizes his grief and the unfulfilled promise of his son’s return. The unfinished work also serves as a metaphor for incompleteness in life.
271-280	The faithful companionship of Michael’s dog reflects his enduring bond with the natural world and his reliance on steadfast connections amid loss. This element reinforces Wordsworth’s Romantic ideal of nature as a source of solace.
281-290	Michael’s perseverance in the face of tragedy illustrates his resilience and fortitude. His dedication to the land and the Sheep-fold embodies themes of legacy and enduring love.
291-300	Isabel’s death adds another layer of sorrow to the tale. The sale of the estate marks the ultimate dissolution of the family’s connection to the land, emphasizing the impermanence of human efforts against larger societal and economic forces.
301-310	The destruction of the family cottage and the ploughing of the land symbolize irreversible change and the passing of an older way of life. These events underscore the vulnerability of rural traditions in the face of modernization.
311-320	The surviving oak tree beside the former cottage serves as a poignant emblem of endurance and continuity. Despite the family’s absence, the tree remains a living testament to their history and resilience.
321-330	The final lines focus on the remnants of the Sheep-fold, blending melancholy with hope. The image of the unfinished structure becomes a powerful symbol of human aspiration, struggle, and the enduring spirit of remembrance.
331-340	The Sheep-fold, which Michael and Luke had planned to complete together, becomes a haunting representation of their shared dreams and unfulfilled promises. It highlights the emotional weight of family legacies and personal connections.
341-350	Michael’s repeated visits to the Sheep-fold after Luke’s departure show his unyielding hope and sense of duty, even in the absence of his son. This act of revisiting reflects his struggle to reconcile love, memory, and loss.
351-360	The unfinished state of the Sheep-fold parallels the incompleteness in Michael’s life caused by Luke’s failure and departure. It reinforces the poem’s tragic tone while celebrating Michael’s unwavering commitment to his values.
361-370	Wordsworth contrasts the transient nature of human accomplishments with the permanence of nature. The Sheep-fold, though incomplete, endures as a silent witness to Michael’s perseverance and the family’s struggles.
371-380	The sale of the land and the eventual disappearance of the family cottage symbolize the erosion of traditional rural lifestyles under economic and social pressures. Wordsworth critiques the forces that displace simple, harmonious lives.
381-390	The oak tree by the cottage remains a powerful symbol of resilience and memory. It stands as a living marker of the past, juxtaposed against the impermanence of human constructs like the Sheep-fold and the cottage.
391-400	The closing lines reflect a melancholic yet accepting tone. Wordsworth acknowledges the inevitability of change while preserving the emotional resonance of Michael’s story. The unfinished Sheep-fold, though a testament to grief, also symbolizes the persistence of love and memory.
401-410	The poem concludes by inviting readers to contemplate the broader implications of Michael’s life. His legacy, though materially diminished, remains intact in the natural world and in the hearts of those who remember him.
411-420	Wordsworth’s portrayal of Michael’s unwavering connection to his family and land serves as a call to value simplicity, emotional depth, and harmony with nature, qualities often lost in the face of modernity and materialism.
421-430	The narrative leaves readers with a vivid sense of place, memory, and loss. The imagery of the unfinished Sheep-fold and the enduring oak ties together themes of resilience and the enduring impact of personal histories.

Final Reflections:

Wordsworth’s Michael is a poignant exploration of the intersections between human relationships, nature, and the challenges of rural life. Through its rich symbolism and vivid imagery, the poem conveys universal themes of love, loss, and the enduring power of memory. It serves as a Romantic critique of industrialization and modernity, celebrating the pastoral ideal and the dignity of simple, laborious lives. This comprehensive annotation underscores how the poem, while seemingly simple in its narrative, is layered with emotional and philosophical depth, making it a timeless work of Romantic literature.

Literary And Poetic Devices: “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Device	Details (Definition, Example with Line Number, and Explanation)
Alliteration	Definition: Repetition of consonant sounds at the beginning of nearby words. Example: “Green-head Ghyll” (Line 2); “boisterous brook” (Line 6) Explanation: The repetition of “G” and “B” sounds creates a musical quality and enhances the natural, pastoral imagery.
Allusion	Definition: Reference to a person, place, or event outside the text. Example: “With two brave sheep-dogs tried in many a storm” (Line 91) Explanation: The image of the sheep-dogs recalls pastoral traditions and biblical shepherd imagery, reinforcing the rural setting.
Ambiguity	Definition: A word, phrase, or statement with multiple meanings. Example: “The Evening Star” (Line 137) Explanation: The name of the cottage has literal and symbolic meanings: it references a guiding light and symbolizes constancy in Michael’s life.
Anaphora	Definition: Repetition of words or phrases at the beginning of lines or clauses. Example: “And their plain home-made cheese. Yet when the meal / Was ended…” (Lines 101-98) Explanation: The repetition of “And” at the beginning emphasizes the routine, simple life of Michael and his family.
Apostrophe	Definition: Addressing an absent person, idea, or object as if it were present. Example: “But, lay one stone—Here, lay it for me, Luke, with thine own hands.” (Line 388) Explanation: Michael’s direct address to his son reflects deep emotion and the symbolic weight of their family bond.
Assonance	Definition: Repetition of vowel sounds in nearby words. Example: “The Shepherd, at such warning, of his flock” (Line 53) Explanation: The repetition of the “e” sound in “shepherd” and “warning” adds a lyrical quality to the description.
Caesura	Definition: A pause within a line of poetry, often marked by punctuation. Example: “That wert a promise to me ere thy birth,” (Line 335) Explanation: The pause after “me” emphasizes the gravity of the father’s emotions and reflections on his son.
Connotation	Definition: The implied or emotional meaning of a word beyond its literal definition. Example: “The heart of man, and human life.” (Line 33) Explanation: “Heart” suggests both the physical and emotional centers, deepening the contemplative tone of the narrative.
Consonance	Definition: Repetition of consonant sounds, especially at the end of words. Example: “With looks of fond correction and reproof bestowed” (Line 173) Explanation: The repeated “d” and “f” sounds unify the line and enhance its rhythm.
Diction	Definition: Choice of words to convey tone and meaning. Example: “Hushed was that House in peace, or seeming peace,” (Line 426) Explanation: Words like “hushed” and “seeming peace” create a somber and reflective tone.
Enjambment	Definition: The continuation of a sentence or clause across a line break. Example: “A grievous penalty, but little less / Than half his substance.” (Lines 215-216) Explanation: The thought flows beyond the line break, reflecting the overwhelming nature of Michael’s financial loss.
Epiphany	Definition: A sudden realization or insight. Example: “I wished that thou should’st live the life they lived:” (Line 372) Explanation: Michael’s reflection reveals his realization about the generational connection and continuity of life.
Foreshadowing	Definition: Hints about what will happen later in the narrative. Example: “Yet when they rose at morning she could see / That all his hopes were gone.” (Lines 292-293) Explanation: This moment foreshadows the eventual tragic trajectory of Luke’s journey and the family’s hardships.
Imagery	Definition: Descriptive language appealing to the senses. Example: “Amid the heart of many thousand mists, / That came to him, and left him, on the heights.” (Lines 59-60) Explanation: The vivid imagery captures the solitary and sublime experience of the shepherd’s life in nature.
Irony	Definition: A contrast between expectations and reality. Example: “To evil courses: ignominy and shame / Fell on him, so that he was driven at last” (Lines 446-448) Explanation: It is ironic that Luke, raised with love and hope, succumbs to a life of shame, contrary to his father’s expectations.
Metaphor	Definition: A direct comparison between two unlike things without using “like” or “as.” Example: “And all thy life hast been my daily joy.” (Line 336) Explanation: Michael metaphorically describes his son as his “daily joy,” emphasizing his emotional reliance on him.
Mood	Definition: The emotional atmosphere of a literary work. Example: “With a light heart. The Housewife for five days / Was restless morn and night” (Lines 285-286) Explanation: The mood shifts from hopeful anticipation to anxious preparation, reflecting the emotional journey of the family.
Personification	Definition: Giving human characteristics to non-human things. Example: “The winds are now devising work for me!” (Line 55) Explanation: The winds are personified as if they are planning tasks for Michael, emphasizing his connection with nature.
Repetition	Definition: Reuse of words or phrases for emphasis. Example: “He at the building of this Sheep-fold wrought, / And left the work unfinished when he died.” (Lines 473-474) Explanation: The repetition emphasizes the incomplete nature of Michael’s project and its symbolic connection to his unfulfilled hopes.
Symbolism	Definition: Use of symbols to signify ideas and qualities beyond their literal meaning. Example: “Lay now the corner-stone, As I requested;” (Line 405) Explanation: The cornerstone symbolizes the foundation of family values, legacy, and hope, as well as the bond between Michael and his son.

Themes: “Michael” by William Wordsworth

1. Human Connection with Nature: Wordsworth’s “Michael” exemplifies the profound relationship between humans and nature, a hallmark of Romantic poetry. Michael, the shepherd, is depicted as deeply rooted in his environment, embodying an idealized harmony with the natural world. The poem emphasizes his sensitivity to natural phenomena, such as his ability to interpret “the meaning of all winds” and hear the “subterraneous music” of the south wind (Lines 48, 51). These details highlight his intimate connection with the pastoral setting. The natural landscape—the “fields,” “hills,” and “mountains”—serves as a living repository of his experiences and emotions, as seen in the lines: “Those fields, those hills…laid strong hold on his affections” (Lines 74-75). This relationship transcends physical presence; nature is a source of solace and identity for Michael, reflecting constancy and permanence even as human life is marked by impermanence and struggle. Wordsworth’s portrayal of Michael’s connection to nature underscores the Romantic belief in the healing and grounding power of the natural world.

2. Family and Generational Bonds: The theme of family and its intergenerational ties lies at the heart of “Michael.” The poem portrays Michael as a devoted father whose life is deeply intertwined with that of his son, Luke. Wordsworth explores the strength of this bond, as Michael expresses that Luke has been his “daily joy” throughout his life (Line 336). This affection is mirrored in the symbolic act of laying the cornerstone for the sheepfold, an unfinished structure that Michael hopes will represent their shared legacy: “Lay now the corner-stone…with thine own hands” (Line 388). The sheepfold becomes a powerful metaphor for Michael’s dreams of continuity and stability for his family. However, Luke’s departure and subsequent moral failure disrupt this vision, leaving the sheepfold incomplete. The poem poignantly depicts how the dissolution of familial bonds can fracture not only personal lives but also the broader moral and cultural fabric of rural life.

3. The Tragic Impact of Economic Hardship: Economic hardship and its devastating effects are central to the narrative of “Michael.” The shepherd’s financial troubles arise when he acts as a guarantor for his nephew, leading to a forfeiture that threatens his family’s land: “A grievous penalty, but little less / Than half his substance” (Lines 215-216). This unexpected burden forces Michael to make the heartbreaking decision to send Luke away to a prosperous kinsman in hopes of recovering their financial stability. The tragedy lies in how this decision disrupts the pastoral idyll, fracturing the familial and moral unity that defines Michael’s life. Luke’s eventual downfall into “evil courses: ignominy and shame” (Line 446) further illustrates the long-reaching consequences of economic strain. Wordsworth critiques the impact of external economic pressures on rural life, presenting Michael as a victim of forces beyond his control and highlighting the fragility of traditional ways of life in the face of financial adversity.

4. Loss and Resilience: “Michael” is a deeply moving exploration of loss and resilience, portraying how individuals confront and endure profound personal tragedies. Michael experiences multiple forms of loss: the departure of his son, the moral failure of Luke, and the eventual dissolution of his dreams. Despite these hardships, Michael continues to persevere, symbolized by his tireless effort to complete the sheepfold: “He at the building of this Sheep-fold wrought, / And left the work unfinished when he died” (Lines 473-474). The unfinished sheepfold becomes a poignant symbol of both his unfulfilled aspirations and his unwavering commitment to his family’s legacy. Even in his later years, Michael remains connected to the land and nature, performing labor and finding solace in the enduring landscape around him. Wordsworth presents Michael as an emblem of resilience, showing how individuals can derive strength from their love for family and the constancy of nature, even when faced with irrevocable loss.

Literary Theories and “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Literary Theory	Explanation	References from the Poem
Romanticism	This theory emphasizes the connection between humans and nature, individual emotion, and the sublime. Wordsworth, as a key Romantic poet, showcases the pastoral life, harmony with nature, and deep personal feelings in Michael.	Michael’s intimate knowledge of the natural world, such as “the meaning of all winds” (Line 48) and his connection to the “fields” and “hills” that “laid strong hold on his affections” (Lines 74-75).
Ecocriticism	Focuses on the relationship between literature and the natural environment. Ecocriticism in Michael examines how Wordsworth portrays nature as a nurturing force and an essential part of human identity.	The depiction of Green-head Ghyll and its surroundings: “The pastoral mountains front you, face to face” (Line 5) and “the mountains have all opened out themselves” to create a “hidden valley” (Lines 7-8).
Marxist Criticism	Examines class struggles, economic hardship, and their impact on individuals and families. In Michael, economic pressures force Luke to leave, disrupting the pastoral ideal and rural family stability.	Michael’s financial crisis caused by his nephew’s debt: “A grievous penalty, but little less / Than half his substance” (Lines 215-216), and the resulting strain on the family dynamic.
Psychoanalytic Criticism	Focuses on the psychological depth of characters and their emotional struggles. Michael explores the father-son bond, loss, and resilience, revealing Michael’s internal conflict and profound grief.	Michael’s reflection on his love for Luke: “And all thy life hast been my daily joy” (Line 336) and his emotional response when laying the cornerstone: “He kissed him and wept” (Line 423).

Critical Questions about “Michael” by William Wordsworth

1. How does Wordsworth portray the relationship between humans and nature in “Michael”?

Wordsworth’s portrayal of the human-nature relationship in “Michael” reflects the Romantic ideal of harmony between the two. Michael’s life as a shepherd is inextricably linked to the natural landscape, which serves as both his livelihood and his spiritual refuge. He is deeply attuned to the natural world, having “learned the meaning of all winds” (Line 48) and finding solace in the pastoral mountains, which “front you, face to face” (Line 5). These mountains and valleys are not passive settings but active participants in Michael’s life, embodying memory and emotion. The “fields, those hills” that “laid strong hold on his affections” (Lines 74-75) symbolize his deep connection to the land, which provides him with identity and purpose. Nature is presented as a source of constancy and solace amidst the disruptions of human life, highlighting the Romantic belief in its restorative power.

2. What role does economic hardship play in the poem, and how does it affect Michael and his family?

Economic hardship serves as the catalyst for the central tragedy of “Michael,” illustrating its destructive impact on rural life and familial stability. Michael’s financial troubles arise when he acts as a guarantor for his nephew, leading to a devastating forfeiture: “A grievous penalty, but little less / Than half his substance” (Lines 215-216). This unforeseen burden forces Michael to send Luke away to a prosperous kinsman in hopes of restoring their finances. The economic pressures disrupt the idyllic harmony of their pastoral life, severing the father-son bond and leaving Michael to cope with both material and emotional loss. Luke’s subsequent moral downfall—succumbing to “evil courses: ignominy and shame” (Lines 446-447)—underscores the far-reaching consequences of financial strain. Through Michael’s plight, Wordsworth critiques the vulnerability of rural families to economic forces beyond their control.

3. How does the sheepfold function as a symbol in the poem?

The sheepfold in “Michael” serves as a powerful symbol of legacy, familial continuity, and unfulfilled hope. Michael’s intention to build the sheepfold with Luke represents his desire to create a tangible marker of their bond and shared labor: “Lay now the corner-stone…with thine own hands” (Line 388). However, the sheepfold remains incomplete, mirroring the disruption of Michael’s dreams for his family due to Luke’s departure and eventual moral failure. When Michael continues to work on the sheepfold alone, even as an old man, it becomes a testament to his perseverance and resilience: “He at the building of this Sheep-fold wrought, / And left the work unfinished when he died” (Lines 473-474). The unfinished sheepfold thus symbolizes the enduring love and effort Michael invests in his family, even in the face of irrevocable loss.

4. What is the significance of Michael’s emotional struggles and how do they shape the narrative?

Michael’s emotional struggles are central to the poem, driving its tragic and reflective tone. His love for Luke is profound, as he declares, “And all thy life hast been my daily joy” (Line 336). However, this love becomes a source of immense pain when economic necessity forces him to send Luke away, disrupting the life he had envisioned. Michael’s anguish is poignantly expressed when he lays the cornerstone of the sheepfold, a moment filled with symbolic and emotional weight: “He kissed him and wept” (Line 423). These struggles reveal Michael’s humanity and resilience, as he continues to labor and maintain his connection to the land despite his sorrow. Through Michael’s emotional journey, Wordsworth explores themes of love, loss, and endurance, portraying him as a figure of quiet heroism who finds strength in his unwavering commitment to family and nature.

Literary Works Similar to “Michael” by William Wordsworth

“The Solitary Reaper” by William Wordsworth
Similar for its focus on rural life and the emotional depth of individuals connected to nature.
“Resolution and Independence” by William Wordsworth
Shares themes of resilience and human connection to the natural world, reflecting on the challenges faced by humble, solitary figures.
“The Deserted Village” by Oliver Goldsmith
Explores the decline of rural communities and the impact of economic and social changes on traditional ways of life.
“Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard” by Thomas Gray
Contemplates the lives of humble, rural individuals and their unnoticed yet meaningful contributions to society.
“The Shepherd’s Tree” by John Clare
Portrays the life of a shepherd and his intimate bond with nature, emphasizing the simplicity and struggles of pastoral existence.

Representative Quotations of “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Quotation	Context	Theoretical Perspective
“Green-head Ghyll” (Line 2)	Describes the setting of the poem, a secluded valley in the countryside.	Ecocriticism: Highlights the role of nature as a living, defining element of the narrative.
“The pastoral mountains front you, face to face” (Line 5)	Portrays the grandeur of the natural setting and its overwhelming presence.	Romanticism: Depicts the sublime and the emotional impact of nature.
“The winds are now devising work for me!” (Line 55)	Michael personifies the winds as he predicts labor inspired by nature’s challenges.	Ecocriticism: Reflects the harmony between human labor and natural forces.
“Those fields, those hills—what could they less?” (Line 74)	Reflects Michael’s emotional attachment to the land where he has lived and worked.	Marxist Criticism: Suggests the economic and emotional investment in rural labor.
“A grievous penalty, but little less / Than half his substance” (Lines 215-216)	Describes the financial loss Michael faces due to acting as surety for his nephew.	Marxist Criticism: Highlights the vulnerability of rural families to economic forces.
“The House itself…was named The Evening Star” (Lines 137-138)	Refers to Michael’s cottage, symbolizing stability and guidance in the community.	Symbolism: The Evening Star symbolizes hope and permanence in Michael’s life.
“He shall possess it, free as is the wind” (Line 246)	Michael speaks of Luke inheriting the land, expressing his hope for familial continuity.	Psychoanalytic Criticism: Reflects Michael’s deep emotional attachment to his legacy.
“Lay now the corner-stone, As I requested;” (Line 405)	Michael asks Luke to place the cornerstone of the sheepfold, symbolizing shared labor and legacy.	Symbolism: The cornerstone represents familial bonds and hope for continuity.
“And all thy life hast been my daily joy” (Line 336)	Michael expresses his deep love for Luke, emphasizing their close relationship.	Psychoanalytic Criticism: Explores the emotional depth of parental love and attachment.
“The Shepherd ended here; and Luke stooped down, / And…laid the first stone of the Sheep-fold” (Lines 420-421)	Marks the symbolic act of starting the sheepfold, a shared dream of Michael and Luke.	Symbolism: Represents the transmission of values and the connection between generations.
“He at the building of this Sheep-fold wrought, / And left the work unfinished when he died” (Lines 473-474)	Michael’s labor on the sheepfold remains incomplete, symbolizing his unfulfilled dreams.	Romanticism: Highlights the poignancy of human effort and the inevitability of loss.
“The heart of man, and human life.” (Line 33)	Reflects on the universal themes of human emotion and experience.	Humanism: Focuses on the complexity and depth of human existence.
“Amid the heart of many thousand mists” (Line 59)	Describes Michael’s experience in the solitary and sublime natural world.	Romanticism: Emphasizes the beauty and emotional power of the natural landscape.
“Nor should I have made mention of this Dell” (Line 14)	Introduces the secluded valley where the story unfolds, highlighting its uniqueness.	Ecocriticism: Focuses on the significance of place in shaping human experience.
“What will be left to us!” (Line 404)	Michael laments the potential loss of his son and the disruption of his life’s work.	Psychoanalytic Criticism: Reveals the emotional vulnerability and fear of loss.
“To evil courses: ignominy and shame” (Line 446)	Describes Luke’s moral downfall after leaving his family and the pastoral setting.	Marxist Criticism: Suggests the corrupting influence of urban life and economic pressures.
“The Cottage which was named The Evening Star / Is gone” (Lines 478-479)	Describes the disappearance of Michael’s home after his death, symbolizing the end of an era.	Historical Criticism: Reflects the changing socio-economic realities of rural England.
“Yet with objects and with hopes, / Living a life of eager industry” (Lines 121-122)	Describes Michael’s industrious and hopeful nature despite challenges.	Romanticism: Celebrates human resilience and the dignity of labor.
“Great changes have been wrought / In all the neighbourhood” (Lines 480-481)	Reflects on the transformation of the rural landscape, emphasizing loss and change.	Ecocriticism: Highlights the impact of modernization on rural life and natural environments.
“There is a comfort in the strength of love” (Line 450)	Suggests the enduring power of love to provide solace amidst hardship.	Humanism: Emphasizes love as a universal, sustaining force in human life.

“Michael” by William Wordsworth: A Critical Analysis

Introduction: “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Text: “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Annotations: “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Literary And Poetic Devices: “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Themes: “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Critical Questions about “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Literary Works Similar to “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Representative Quotations of “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Suggested Readings: “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Introduction: “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Text: “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Annotations: “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Literary And Poetic Devices: “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Themes: “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Critical Questions about “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Literary Works Similar to “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Representative Quotations of “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Suggested Readings: “Michael” by William Wordsworth

Related posts:

Leave a Reply Cancel reply