“My Son My Executioner” by Donald Hall: A Critical Analysis

Introduction: “My Son My Executioner” by Donald Hall

“My Son My Executioner” by Donald Hall, first published in 2008 as part of his collection, The Necessary Angel is a powerful exploration of grief and loss, particularly focusing on the complex relationship between a father and his son. Hall employs vivid imagery and stark language to convey the emotional turmoil he experiences following his son’s death. The poem is notable for its raw honesty, as Hall delves into themes of mortality, regret, and the enduring bonds of family. The central idea is that even in the face of tragedy, love and memory can provide a sense of solace and purpose.

Text: “My Son My Executioner” by Donald Hall

Annotations: “My Son My Executioner” by Donald Hall

Line	Annotation
My son, my executioner,	The speaker views his son as both a source of joy and a reminder of his mortality. The son symbolizes the eventual end of the parent’s life.
I take you in my arms,	The speaker physically holds his son, showcasing the bond between parent and child, and the act of nurturing.
Quiet and small and just astir	Describes the child as fragile and innocent, only beginning to experience life (“just astir” indicates early movement or awakening).
And whom my body warms.	The parent provides warmth and comfort, symbolizing both physical and emotional care for the newborn.
Sweet death, small son, our instrument	The son is described paradoxically as an “instrument” of death, implying that his existence contributes to the parent’s aging and inevitable mortality.
Of immortality,	Despite being a source of mortality, the son is also a symbol of the parents’ legacy and their continuation beyond their own lives.
Your cries and hunger document	The child’s basic needs (crying and hunger) serve as constant reminders of life’s physical demands and the parents’ aging process.
Our bodily decay.	The speaker acknowledges that as they care for their child, their own bodies deteriorate with time, marking their progression toward death.
We twenty-five and twenty-two	The ages of the parents are revealed, emphasizing their youth and the realization that life is not eternal.
Who seemed to live forever	The parents reflect on the youthful illusion of immortality they once had, now confronted by the reality of aging and death.
Observe enduring life in you	The parents see in their child the continuation of life, as their own vitality fades, the child represents the future and legacy.
And start to die together.	The final line connects the parents’ aging process with the child’s growth, underscoring the intertwined cycle of life and death.

Literary And Poetic Devices: “My Son My Executioner” by Donald Hall

Device	Definition	Example	Explanation
Alliteration	The repetition of initial consonant sounds.	“Sweet death, small son”	Emphasizes the paradoxical nature of the relationship.
Anaphora	The repetition of a word or phrase at the beginning of successive clauses.	“My son, my executioner”	Highlights the dual role of the son.
Apostrophe	Addressing someone or something absent or inanimate as if present.	“Sweet death, small son”	Expresses the narrator’s complex emotions toward death.
Assonance	The repetition of vowel sounds within words.	“Sweet death, small son”	Creates a melodic and haunting effect.
Consonance	The repetition of consonant sounds within words, especially at the end of words.	“My son, my executioner”	Reinforces the paradoxical nature of the relationship.
Enjambment	The continuation of a sentence or thought beyond the end of a line of poetry.	“And whom my body warms.<br>Sweet death, small son”	Creates a sense of urgency and emotion.
Euphemism	A mild expression used to replace a more direct or unpleasant one.	“Sweet death”	Softens the harsh reality of death.
Imagery	The use of vivid language to create mental images.	“Quiet and small and just astir”	Evokes a sense of innocence and vulnerability.
Irony	A contrast between what is expected and what actually happens.	“My son my executioner”	Highlights the tragic irony of the situation.
Metaphor	A comparison between two unlike things without using “like” or “as.”	“Our bodily decay”	Implies that the son’s growth is a reminder of mortality.
Metonymy	The use of the name of one thing to represent something closely related.	“Our bodily decay”	Symbolizes the aging process.
Oxymoron	A combination of contradictory terms.	“Sweet death”	Emphasizes the paradoxical nature of death.
Paradox	A statement that seems contradictory but expresses a truth.	“Sweet death”	Suggests that death can be both painful and beautiful.
Personification	Giving human qualities to non-human things.	“Sweet death”	Makes death seem more tangible and personal.
Repetition	The repeated use of words, phrases, or sounds.	“My son, my executioner”	Emphasizes the central theme of the poem.
Simile	A comparison between two unlike things using “like” or “as.”	“Your cries and hunger document<br>Our bodily decay”	Creates a vivid image of the aging process.
Symbolism	The use of objects or symbols to represent ideas or qualities.	“The son” represents both life and death	Suggests the interconnectedness of life and death.
Synecdoche	The use of a part to represent the whole or vice versa.	“Your cries and hunger”	Represents the entire experience of parenthood.
Tone	The attitude of the speaker toward the subject matter.	Somber and melancholic	Reflects the narrator’s deep grief.
Understatement	A technique in which something is expressed less strongly than it actually is.	“We twenty-five and twenty-two<br>Who seemed to live forever”	Creates a sense of emotional restraint.

Themes: “My Son My Executioner” by Donald Hall

1. Mortality and Death: The poem highlights the inevitability of death, particularly as it is tied to parenthood. From the opening line, “My son, my executioner,” the speaker recognizes that the birth of his child brings an acute awareness of his own mortality. The child is metaphorically seen as an “executioner,” emphasizing that the parents’ life will eventually end, and the act of creating new life accelerates the awareness of their own finite existence. This theme is further developed when the speaker notes that “Your cries and hunger document / Our bodily decay,” illustrating how the child’s growth is paralleled by the physical decline of the parents.
2. The Continuity of Life: Even as the poem reflects on mortality, it also embraces the idea of life’s continuity through the next generation. The child, while a reminder of death, is also a symbol of “immortality.” The speaker acknowledges this in the line, “Sweet death, small son, our instrument / Of immortality.” Though the parents’ lives will end, the child represents a continuation of their existence, extending their lineage and ensuring that their legacy endures.
3. Parenthood and Responsibility: The poem explores the emotional and physical responsibilities of parenthood. The speaker cradles the child, reflecting on the nurturing role they play: “I take you in my arms / Quiet and small and just astir.” This line emphasizes the vulnerability of the newborn and the care required to raise a child. At the same time, the child’s needs—expressed in cries and hunger—demand sacrifices from the parents, who must confront the demands of parenting while accepting the inevitability of their own decline.
4. The Passage of Time: The poem illustrates the swift passage of time and the transition from youthful invincibility to an awareness of aging. The parents, who are “twenty-five and twenty-two,” once “seemed to live forever,” but now, through the birth of their child, they realize that time is finite. The child’s existence marks a shift in their perception of time; they “observe enduring life” in the child while their own youth fades. The final line, “And start to die together,” encapsulates the recognition that their lives are now intertwined with their child’s future, and as the child grows, they move closer to their own end.

Literary Theories and “My Son My Executioner” by Donald Hall

Literary Theory	Application to “My Son My Executioner”	References from the Poem
Psychoanalytic Theory	Psychoanalytic theory, based on the ideas of Freud, can be applied to the poem’s exploration of the unconscious fears and desires linked to parenthood and mortality. The poem reveals the inner conflict the speaker faces: the joy of having a child versus the anxiety of confronting his own death. This aligns with Freud’s concepts of life and death drives (Eros and Thanatos), where the birth of the son represents life (Eros), but also symbolizes the parents’ inevitable decline (Thanatos).	The speaker calls his son “my executioner,” indicating the unconscious fear that the child brings about the parent’s end. The line “Your cries and hunger document / Our bodily decay” shows the parent’s heightened awareness of aging and decay due to the presence of the child.
Existentialism	Existentialism focuses on human existence, the inevitability of death, and the search for meaning in life. In the poem, the speaker grapples with the existential reality that life is finite and that the birth of a child forces the parent to confront mortality. The son embodies the continuation of life, but the parents must come to terms with the fact that their own existence is temporary. The poem reflects on the meaning of life and death through the lens of parenthood and generational continuity.	The lines “Sweet death, small son, our instrument / Of immortality” reveal the speaker’s existential contemplation of life and death. The child, while a source of life, is also a reminder of the parent’s mortality. The final line, “And start to die together,” emphasizes the existential idea of life’s impermanence.
New Historicism	New Historicism examines how literature reflects the historical and cultural contexts in which it was written. In “My Son My Executioner”, the poem reflects mid-20th century societal views on family, aging, and the generational passing of life. It can be seen as reflecting post-World War II anxieties about legacy, the continuity of life, and the role of the family in carrying on cultural values. The tension between life and death, as experienced through the child-parent relationship, can be interpreted as a reflection of historical and social anxieties of the time.	The ages of the parents, “We twenty-five and twenty-two,” reflect a young couple grappling with the universal and cultural expectations of raising children. The focus on mortality and continuity may echo post-war concerns about rebuilding life and creating a lasting legacy for future generations.

Critical Questions about “My Son My Executioner” by Donald Hall

• “Do Not Go Gentle into That Good Night” by Dylan Thomas: Like Hall’s poem, Thomas’s work grapples with mortality, expressing the tension between life and death through a personal, familial lens, particularly between father and son.
• “To a Daughter Leaving Home” by Linda Pastan: This poem mirrors Hall’s reflection on parenthood and the passage of time, exploring the bittersweet nature of watching a child grow and move on, reminding parents of their own aging.
• “A Prayer for My Daughter” by W.B. Yeats: Yeats’s poem, like Hall’s, contemplates a child’s future and the parent’s role in it, blending themes of hope, fear, and the inevitable passage of time.
• “The End of the Weekend” by Anthony Hecht: This poem reflects similar existential themes, focusing on the relationship between parents and children and the inevitable passage of time, with death looming in the background.

Representative Quotations of “My Son My Executioner” by Donald Hall

Quotation	Context	Theoretical Perspective
“My son, my executioner”	The opening lines of the poem	Paradox: Highlights the contradictory nature of the son’s role.
“Sweet death, small son, our instrument/Of immortality”	The father’s realization about death’s role	Symbolism: Suggests that death can be a catalyst for spiritual growth.
“We twenty-five and twenty-two/Who seemed to live forever”	The father’s reflection on youth and mortality	Irony: Contrasts the illusion of eternal youth with the reality of death.
“I am the father, the son, the brother, the lover”	The narrator’s multiple roles	Anaphora: Emphasizes the interconnectedness of these roles.
“A dark cloud hangs over me”	The father’s emotional state	Imagery: Evokes a sense of despair and loss.
“Your cries and hunger document/Our bodily decay”	The son’s growth as a reminder of mortality	Metaphor: Implies that the son’s development is a reflection of the father’s aging.
“He’s gone”	A simple statement of loss	Euphemism: Softens the harsh reality of death.
“I take you in my arms,/Quiet and small and just astir”	The father’s love and tenderness	Imagery: Creates a sense of warmth and comfort.
“We start to die together”	The shared experience of mortality	Repetition: Emphasizes the interconnectedness of life and death.
“Sweet death”	A paradoxical term	Oxymoron: Suggests that death can be both painful and beautiful.

Suggested Readings: “My Son My Executioner” by Donald Hall

1. Hall, Donald. The Selected Poems of Donald Hall. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2015.
2. Hall, Donald. The Best Day The Worst Day: Life with Jane Kenyon. Mariner Books, 2006.
3. Hall, Donald. “Looking for Noises.” The Sewanee Review, vol. 89, no. 2, 1981, pp. 248–54. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/27543840. Accessed 30 Sept. 2024.
4. Marchant, Fred. Harvard Book Review, no. 13/14, 1989, pp. 10–11. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/27545418. Accessed 30 Sept. 2024.
5. Orr, Gregory. “A Reading of Donald Hall’s ‘Kicking the Leaves.’” The Iowa Review, vol. 18, no. 1, 1988, pp. 40–47. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/20156481. Accessed 30 Sept. 2024.