Percy Bysshe Shelley As a Literary Theorist

Introduction: Percy Bysshe Shelley As a Literary Theorist

Table of Contents

Percy Bysshe Shelley as a literary theorist represents one of the most intellectually audacious and philosophically visionary figures of the Romantic era. Born on August 4, 1792, at Field Place, Horsham, Sussex, and drowned tragically on July 8, 1822, off the coast of Italy, Shelley’s short life embodied a synthesis of poetic idealism and critical radicalism. Educated first at Sion House Academy and Eton College, where he was ridiculed for his unorthodox ideas, Shelley entered University College, Oxford, in 1810 but was expelled the following year for co-authoring The Necessity of Atheism (1811), an act that established his lifelong reputation for intellectual rebellion. His early experiences of exclusion and his engagement with Enlightenment rationalism shaped both his poetic imagination and critical consciousness. As Harold Bloom observes, “Shelley transmembers every other genre into the realm of lyric,” defining the Sublime as that which “persuades us to give up easier pleasures for more difficult ones”. This vision of transcendence through imaginative struggle informed his literary theory, most clearly articulated in A Defence of Poetry (1821), where he argues that “poets are the unacknowledged legislators of the world.” Shelley saw poetry not merely as an art but as an instrument of moral and social reform, maintaining that imagination is “the great instrument of moral good.” His major critical and poetic works—Queen Mab (1813), Alastor (1816), Prometheus Unbound (1820), and A Defence of Poetry—reflect his faith in the transformative power of the imagination, the inevitability of human perfectibility, and the fusion of aesthetic beauty with political idealism. As Donovan and Duffy note, Shelley’s oeuvre “reinterprets the European poetic tradition with a bold originality and philosophical depth unmatched in his age”. Thus, as both poet and theorist, Shelley united vision and intellect, creating a body of work that continues to challenge, inspire, and “kindle us to a perpetual sense of more life” (Bloom, xii).

Major Works and Main Ideas of Percy Bysshe Shelley As a Literary Theorist

1. A Defence of Poetry (1821): The Foundation of Shelley’s Poetic Philosophy

Shelley’s most significant theoretical work, written in response to Thomas Love Peacock’s Four Ages of Poetry, positions poetry as the moral and imaginative essence of civilization.

He declares that “poetry is the record of the best and happiest moments of the happiest and best minds” and that “poets are the unacknowledged legislators of the world” (A Defence of Poetry, qtd. in Donovan & Duffy 43–44).
Shelley argues that poetry’s moral value lies not in doctrine but in its ability to stimulate imagination and empathy. As Harold Bloom notes, for Shelley, “Imagination is the great instrument of moral good. The secret of morals is love”.
He rejects didacticism: “Moral reasoning does not act upon the cause, it only analyses the effect”, insisting that the poet must “create rather than preach” (Defence, qtd. in Bloom 184).

His philosophical lineage extends to Plato, Aristotle, and Sidney, emphasizing that poetry “purges from our inward sight the film of familiarity … and creates anew the universe”.

2. Queen Mab (1813): The Revolutionary Vision

Shelley’s early philosophical poem espouses atheism, pacifism, and utopian socialism, combining poetic prophecy with political critique.
The poem attacks monarchy, institutional religion, and economic exploitation—embodying Shelley’s belief that imagination and moral idealism can inspire reform.

Its radical tone anticipates the Defence’s conviction that poets are agents of human perfectibility and ethical transformation.

3. Alastor; or, The Spirit of Solitude (1816): The Poet’s Quest for the Ideal

Alastor portrays the alienation of the visionary who seeks absolute beauty but rejects human fellowship.

This work reveals Shelley’s developing idea that poetic imagination must reconcile transcendence with sympathy—a theme later refined in Prometheus Unbound.
The solitary poet’s failure illustrates what Shelley calls the “desire of the moth for the star,” symbolizing humanity’s perpetual striving toward the ideal.

4. Prometheus Unbound (1820): Imagination as Liberation

A lyrical drama representing the overthrow of tyranny and the triumph of love and forgiveness.

Shelley reimagines the Promethean myth as a symbol of spiritual and political emancipation.
He identifies the poetic imagination as “a creative power … which forms those forms that are common to universal nature and existence” (Defence, qtd. in Bloom 174).
The drama envisions the transformation of human consciousness: “To suffer woes which Hope thinks infinite; / To forgive wrongs darker than death or night”—affirming the poet’s role as moral redeemer.

5. Hellas (1822) and The Revolt of Islam (1818): The Poetics of Revolution

Both works engage with liberty and the cyclical nature of oppression and renewal.
In Hellas, Shelley contrasts tyranny with prophetic vision, proclaiming: “The world’s great age begins anew.”

The Revolt of Islam extends his conviction that moral reform begins with imaginative sympathy rather than coercion—a reflection of his Defence’s assertion that “love is a going out of our own nature”.

6. Adonais (1821): The Poetic Imagination as Immortality

Written on Keats’s death, Adonais fuses elegy with metaphysics, suggesting that artistic vision transcends mortality: “He is made one with Nature: there is heard / His voice in all her music.”
The poem exemplifies Shelley’s theoretical belief that poetry “redeems from decay the visitations of the divinity in man” (Defence, qtd. in Bloom 174).

7. Central Ideas in Shelley’s Literary Theory

Imagination as Moral Faculty: “A man, therefore, to be greatly good must imagine intensely and comprehensively” (Bloom 184).
Love as Ethical Principle: “The secret of morals is love” (Bloom 184).
Poetry as Social Renewal: “It creates anew the universe” (Donovan & Duffy 36).

Poet as Prophet and Legislator: “Poets are the unacknowledged legislators of the world” (Donovan & Duffy 43–44).
Art as Moral Imagination, Not Doctrine: “The poet has no right to be content to analyse what he ought indirectly to create” (Bloom 184).

Theoretical Terms/Concepts of Percy Bysshe Shelley As a Literary Theorist

Theoretical Term / Concept	Explanation	Example / Quotation
Imagination	For Shelley, imagination is the supreme creative faculty that unites reason, emotion, and perception; it is the “great instrument of moral good” and the source of human sympathy and creativity. It allows individuals to transcend the limitations of experience and envision moral perfection.	“Imagination is the great instrument of moral good. The secret of morals is love” (A Defence of Poetry, qtd. in Bloom 185).
Love	Shelley identifies love as the foundation of moral and poetic insight—“a going out of our own nature.” It is through love that humans achieve empathy and unity with others.	“Love is a going out of our own nature, and an identification of ourselves with the beautiful which exists in thought, action, or person not our own” (Defence, qtd. in Bloom 185).
Inspiration	Poetry originates from moments of divine illumination or inspiration—visitations from a “diviner nature.” The poet’s task is to capture these fleeting insights and transform them into enduring art.	“The province of the poet is to arrest these apparitions… and so to ‘redeem from decay the visitations of the divinity in man’” (Defence, qtd. in Bloom 174).
Poetry as Creation	Shelley sees poetry as an active process of creation rather than mere representation. The poet creates forms that embody eternal truths of life and nature.	“A poem is the very image of life expressed in its eternal truth” (Defence, qtd. in Bloom 173).
Poetry as Revelation	Poetry is a revelation of divine or ideal truth—it unveils the hidden unity and beauty within life.	“Poetry… is the revelation of those eternal ideas which lie behind the many-coloured, ever-shifting veil that we call reality or life” (Defence, qtd. in Bloom 173).
Unity of the Ideal and the Real	Shelley emphasizes that all expressions of beauty and goodness—whether in art, nature, or human action—are manifestations of one divine principle.	“All… goodness and beauty is its partial manifestation… the splendour of nature, the love of lovers… the truths deformed by superstitious religion—all are equally operations of the hidden power” (Bloom 173).
Poet as Legislator	The poet’s social role is visionary and moral; poets shape human thought and progress through imaginative empathy rather than political power.	“Poets are the unacknowledged legislators of the world” (A Defence of Poetry, qtd. in Donovan & Duffy 43–44).
Moral Imagination	Shelley argues that poetry cultivates moral sensitivity and ethical judgment by expanding the reader’s imaginative capacity, not by preaching doctrine.	“The poet has no right to be content to analyse what he ought indirectly to create” (Defence, qtd. in Bloom 185).
Language as Creative Medium	Shelley places language at the pinnacle of artistic media because it is produced by imagination and capable of infinite expression.	“Language… is the most direct and plastic vehicle of art, produced by imagination instead of being simply encountered by it” (Bloom 176).
Art and Society (“Spirit of the Age”)	Shelley conceives poets as both products and creators of their historical context. They reshape “the spirit of the age” through creative renewal of meaning and emotion.	“Artists are said to be ‘in one sense, the creators, and, in another, the creations, of their age’” (Defence, qtd. in Donovan & Duffy 49–50).

Application of Ideas of Percy Bysshe Shelley As a Literary Theorist to Literary Works

#	Contemporary Work	Shelley-Idea Applied	Explanation of Application
1	The Overstory (by Richard Powers, 2018)	Imagination as moral faculty	The novel uses botanical and arboreal imagery to stimulate a sense of connectedness and ecological responsibility—parallel to Shelley’s claim that imagination is “the great instrument of moral good.”
2	Girl, Woman, Other (by Bernardine Evaristo, 2019)	Poetry/Art as social renewal; poet as unacknowledged legislator	The novel uses multiple voices and forms to challenge social norms about gender, identity and race—reflecting Shelley’s idea that “poets are the unacknowledged legislators of the world.”
3	Klara and the Sun (by Kazuo Ishiguro, 2021)	Unity of ideal & real; imagination revealing hidden truth	This speculative novel invites readers to imagine consciousness, love and machine-life—linking to Shelley’s belief that poetry “is the revelation of those eternal ideas which lie behind … reality.”
4	Piranesi (by Susanna Clarke, 2020)	Inspiration & transcendence; language as creative medium	The work’s labyrinthine structure and poetic language evoke a transcendent vision of being and place—akin to Shelley’s emphasis that the poet “creates anew the universe” through imaginative language.

Representation Quotations of Percy Bysshe Shelley As a Literary Theorist

No.	Quotation (Shelley)	Explanation (Critical Context)	Source
1	“Poetry is the record of the best and happiest moments of the happiest and best minds.”	Shelley defines poetry as the highest expression of human consciousness, preserving ideal moments of perception and moral clarity — not mere emotion, but refined intellect in its noblest state.	A Defence of Poetry, qtd. in Donovan & Duffy 43.
2	“Poets are the unacknowledged legislators of the world.”	Perhaps his most famous critical claim — Shelley positions poets as moral and social reformers whose imaginative influence shapes civilization more profoundly than political lawgivers.	A Defence of Poetry, qtd. in Donovan & Duffy 44.
3	“Imagination is the great instrument of moral good.”	Shelley establishes imagination as a moral faculty; it allows empathy, sympathy, and ethical understanding — linking aesthetics and ethics inseparably.	Defence, qtd. in Bloom 185.
4	“The secret of morals is love.”	This critical statement expands his aesthetic theory into moral philosophy: love and imagination are twin forces in the creation of humane values and poetic insight.	Defence, qtd. in Bloom 185.
5	“Poetry lifts the veil from the hidden beauty of the world, and makes familiar objects be as if they were not familiar.”	Shelley articulates the Romantic theory of defamiliarization — poetry renews perception by reawakening the sense of wonder dulled by habit.	Defence, qtd. in Donovan & Duffy 38.
6	“A poem is the very image of life expressed in its eternal truth.”	Shelley emphasizes mimesis as revelation — poetry is not imitation but a recreation of life’s essential patterns and truths.	Defence, qtd. in Bloom 173.
7	“Poetry turns all things to loveliness; it exalts the beauty of that which is most beautiful.”	He defines poetry as a transformative art, elevating existence by fusing perception with imaginative vision — central to his Romantic idealism.	Defence, qtd. in Donovan & Duffy 37.
8	“The great secret of morals is love; or a going out of our own nature, and an identification of ourselves with the beautiful.”	This statement extends his concept of aesthetic empathy — the ability to inhabit another’s consciousness, forming the ethical foundation of art.	Defence, qtd. in Bloom 185.
9	“Poetry strengthens that faculty which is the organ of the moral nature of man, in the same manner as exercise strengthens a limb.”	Shelley’s proto-psychological insight: art trains and extends human empathy through imaginative “exercise,” shaping both intellect and conscience.	Defence, qtd. in Bloom 185.
10	“Poets are not only the authors of language and of music, of the dance, and architecture, and statuary, and painting; they are the institutors of laws and the founders of civil society.”	Shelley broadens the scope of poetry to encompass all creative acts — linking the origins of civilization, law, and art to the same imaginative impulse.	Defence, qtd. in Donovan & Duffy 41.

Criticism of Ideas of Percy Bysshe Shelley As a Literary Theorist

1. Excessive Idealism and Utopianism

Critics argue that Shelley’s A Defence of Poetry is excessively idealistic, portraying poetry as an almost divine instrument of social change.

Shelley’s belief that poets are “the unacknowledged legislators of the world” is often viewed as naïve and impractical, neglecting material and political realities.
Matthew Arnold called Shelley a “beautiful but ineffectual angel, beating in the void his luminous wings in vain,” highlighting the impracticality of his visionary optimism.
His idealism, while inspiring, often disconnects poetic imagination from tangible reform.

2. Neglect of Form and Aesthetic Technique

Critics like T. S. Eliot and F. R. Leavis accused Shelley of emphasizing emotion and philosophy over artistic discipline.
Eliot remarked that Shelley’s poetry “lacks concentration” and that his imagination “dissolves rather than unites,” suggesting a deficiency in formal control.
This critique implies that Shelley’s theory of poetry prioritizes abstract idealism over craftsmanship, structure, and precision of language.

3. Abstract and Metaphysical Obscurity

Shelley’s theoretical writings are often dense, abstract, and metaphysical, leading some critics to find them conceptually obscure.
His Platonic and transcendental vocabulary (“eternal ideas,” “divine imagination,” “moral good”) can seem philosophically inflated and detached from concrete literary criticism.
Even sympathetic interpreters like Harold Bloom note that Shelley’s theory “risks self-annihilation in its pursuit of transcendence” (Shelley’s Mythmaking, 1971).

4. Overemphasis on the Poet’s Moral Superiority

Shelley’s conception of the poet as a moral and visionary legislator has been criticized as elitist and self-glorifying.
Critics argue that he endows the poet with quasi-religious authority, implying moral superiority over other human faculties.
In modern democratic and post-structuralist perspectives, such a stance appears hierarchical and exclusionary, inconsistent with Shelley’s own egalitarian ideals.

5. Ambiguity Between Art and Politics

Shelley’s attempt to unite aesthetic beauty with political radicalism leads to conceptual contradictions.
While advocating artistic autonomy, he simultaneously demands moral and social utility from poetry.
This tension between art for art’s sake and art for reform’s sake creates ambiguity in his theoretical framework.

Critics like Paul Foot (in Red Shelley, 1980) celebrate this tension, while others find it inconsistent with pure aesthetic theory.

6. Psychological Idealism vs. Historical Realism

Shelley’s emphasis on imagination as the engine of moral progress ignores historical, social, and psychological constraints on human behavior.
Marxist critics regard his view of poetry as ahistorical, grounded in individual moral transformation rather than collective social change.

Raymond Williams, for instance, noted that Shelley’s cultural theory lacks “a sense of class mediation and historical process.”

7. Vagueness in Defining “Imagination”

Though central to his theory, Shelley’s definition of imagination remains fluid — oscillating between divine inspiration, moral intuition, and cognitive synthesis.
Critics point out that this conceptual vagueness undermines the theoretical precision of his aesthetic system.

Compared to Coleridge’s analytic framework (Biographia Literaria), Shelley’s imagination seems more visionary than systematic.

8. Overgeneralization of Poetry’s Function

Shelley extends the term “poetry” to encompass all forms of creative human expression (law, art, architecture, language), diluting its specificity as a literary form.
This universalization makes his theory rhetorically powerful but analytically diffuse, turning poetry into a metaphor for all cultural creation rather than a distinct art.

9. Incompatibility with Modernist and Postmodern Thought

Modernist critics reject Shelley’s faith in moral progress and universal beauty, viewing such ideals as incompatible with modern fragmentation and irony.
Postmodern theorists further critique his essentialism — his belief in timeless truths and moral universals — as incompatible with the linguistic and cultural relativism of later theory.

10. Limited Engagement with Reader and Language

Shelley’s theory focuses on the poet’s role and imagination but pays little attention to reader response or linguistic construction.

Later theories (New Criticism, Reader-Response, Structuralism) found his model too author-centered, neglecting textual autonomy and interpretive plurality.

M	T	W	T	F	S	S
					1	2
3	4	5	6	7	8	9
10	11	12	13	14	15	16
17	18	19	20	21	22	23
24	25	26	27	28	29	30