“Persephone, Falling” by Rita Dove: A Critical Analysis

One narcissus among the ordinary beautiful

flowers, one unlike all the others!  She pulled,

stooped to pull harder—

when, sprung out of the earth

on his glittering terrible

carriage, he claimed his due.

It is finished.  No one heard her.

No one!  She had strayed from the herd.

(Remember: go straight to school.

This is important, stop fooling around!

Don’t answer to strangers.  Stick

with your playmates.  Keep your eyes down.)

This is how easily the pit

opens.  This is how one foot sinks into the ground.

1. Innocence and Vulnerability

The theme of innocence is central in “Persephone, Falling,” as Persephone is depicted as a naïve and curious young girl who is easily lured by the beauty of a single narcissus flower. Lines like “One narcissus among the ordinary beautiful flowers” highlight her attraction to the extraordinary, symbolizing her untainted fascination with beauty. However, her innocent curiosity leads her into danger, as shown in “She had strayed from the herd.” This underscores the vulnerability of innocence when exposed to a world fraught with hidden perils.

2. Parental Protection and Warning

The parenthetical warnings—“(Remember: go straight to school. This is important, stop fooling around!)”—capture the theme of maternal protection and the efforts to guide children away from harm. These lines represent the universal struggle of parents trying to shield their children from the world’s dangers. Despite these well-intentioned warnings, Persephone’s fate demonstrates how such advice is often disregarded or insufficient in the face of fate, reflecting the limits of parental control.

3. Temptation and Consequences

Temptation plays a pivotal role in the narrative, as Persephone’s desire to possess the unique narcissus flower leads to her capture by Hades. The line “This is how easily the pit opens” metaphorically captures how small decisions driven by temptation can lead to significant and irreversible consequences. The flower symbolizes allure and danger, reminding readers of the seductive nature of temptation and the potential for disastrous outcomes when one gives in.

4. The Inevitability of Fate

The poem emphasizes the inevitability of fate through its narrative structure and tone. Persephone’s abduction is portrayed as unavoidable, marked by the line “It is finished.” This sense of finality suggests that her descent into the underworld was destined, regardless of the warnings or her own actions. The metaphor “This is how one foot sinks into the ground” further reinforces the theme, symbolizing how fate exerts a pull that cannot be escaped, drawing individuals toward their predestined paths.

1. How does the poem explore the concept of innocence and its loss?

The poem delves deeply into the theme of innocence, portraying Persephone as a figure lured by beauty and unaware of the dangers surrounding her. The line “One narcissus among the ordinary beautiful flowers” highlights her innocent desire to engage with the extraordinary. However, her innocence becomes her vulnerability, as shown in “She had strayed from the herd,” suggesting that her isolation and curiosity made her susceptible to Hades’ capture. The poem uses this moment to underscore how easily innocence can lead to loss, particularly when one is unaware of lurking dangers.

2. What role does maternal guidance play in the poem’s narrative?

Maternal guidance is depicted as both a protective and a futile force in the poem. The warnings—“(Remember: go straight to school. This is important, stop fooling around!)”—echo the universal parental desire to protect children from harm. Despite this guidance, Persephone’s fate unfolds, reflecting the limits of such advice against the inevitability of danger. The juxtaposition of these warnings with Persephone’s abduction suggests that while guidance provides a moral framework, it cannot shield individuals from their destinies or choices.

3. How does the poem illustrate the tension between free will and fate?

The poem presents a compelling tension between Persephone’s actions and the inevitability of her fate. Her decision to pull the narcissus flower reflects an exercise of free will, yet the line “It is finished” signals an unavoidable consequence, as if her fate had been preordained. The metaphor “This is how one foot sinks into the ground” further emphasizes this tension, showing how seemingly minor choices can lead to irreversible outcomes, blurring the line between personal agency and destiny.

4. What is the significance of the flower in the narrative?

The narcissus flower holds symbolic weight as the catalyst for Persephone’s descent into the underworld. Described as “One unlike all the others,” it represents temptation, beauty, and the allure of the unknown. Its uniqueness draws Persephone to it, symbolizing her desire to break from the mundane. However, this same attraction leads to her capture by Hades, transforming the flower into a symbol of both innocence and the dangers of temptation. The duality of the flower reflects the poem’s central themes of beauty, risk, and consequence.