Phenomenology in Literature

Introduction: Phenomenology in Literature

Phenomenology in Literature is a philosophical and interpretive approach that focuses on exploring subjective human experiences as they manifest within literary texts. This methodology delves into the intentional and consciousness-driven aspects of characters, narrators, and readers, emphasizing the nuances of perception, emotions, and interpretation.

Phenomenological analysis in literature employs principles such as intentionality, bracketing, and the reduction to uncover the essential characteristics of literary phenomena, contributing to a deeper understanding of the text’s meaning and the reader’s engagement.

Through its interdisciplinary perspective and existential exploration, phenomenology in literature offers a rich framework for comprehending the complex interplay between language, consciousness, and the portrayal of human experience in literary works.

Criticism Against Phenomenology

Criticism	Explanation	Example
Lack of Empirical Validation	Critics argue that phenomenology in literature relies heavily on subjective accounts, making empirical validation challenging.	In psychological studies, relying solely on introspection may limit the validation of therapeutic interventions.
Overemphasis on Subjectivity	Phenomenology’s focus on subjectivity may lead to a narrow perspective, overlooking external influences.	Analyzing political movements without considering socio-economic factors might limit understanding.
Limited Applicability	Some argue that phenomenology’s methods may not be suitable for empirical disciplines.	In physics research, where quantifiable experiments are vital, phenomenology may be less relevant.
Lack of Generalizability	Phenomenological findings may be hard to generalize beyond specific contexts or groups.	Insights from a study on a particular group of artists may not apply universally to all artists.
Epistemological Concerns	Critics raise concerns about circular reasoning and the subject’s role as both knower and known in phenomenology in literature.	Philosophers may question phenomenology’s ability to access objective knowledge beyond individual subjectivity.
Ethical and Political Critiques	Phenomenology is critiqued for its historical Eurocentrism and limited engagement with power dynamics and social justice issues.	Critics call for addressing historical biases and engaging with diverse perspectives.

Examples of Phenomenology in Literature (Critique)

1. The Road by Cormac McCarthy:

• Phenomenological Aspect: In the novel, the character of the father, struggling to survive in a post-apocalyptic world, experiences vivid sensory perceptions and emotional turmoil as he protects his son in a desolate landscape.
• Critique: While The Road immerses readers in the father’s intense phenomenological journey, some critics argue that the unrelenting bleakness of the narrative may overshadow other dimensions of the characters’ existence.

2. Exit West by Mohsin Hamid:

• Phenomenological Aspect: The novel follows the characters Saeed and Nadia, who must leave their war-torn homeland through magical doorways. It explores their evolving perceptions, emotions, and worldviews as they face the challenges of migration.
• Critique: While Exit West offers a unique phenomenological perspective on displacement, some readers find that the inclusion of magical realism elements can dilute the raw emotional impact of the characters’ experiences.

3. Milkman by Anna Burns:

• Phenomenological Aspect: The novel centers on the unnamed female protagonist living in a politically charged and oppressive environment. It delves into her innermost thoughts, fears, and anxieties as she navigates the complexities of her situation.
• Critique: While Milkman provides an immersive experience of the character’s subjectivity, some readers may find its dense narrative style challenging, potentially creating a disconnect from the story’s events.

4. Citizen: An American Lyric by Claudia Rankine:

• Phenomenological Aspect: This hybrid work, blending poetry and prose, examines the everyday experiences of racial microaggressions and discrimination in the United States. It delves into the emotional and psychological impact on the narrator, Claudia.
• Critique: While Citizen offers a powerful phenomenological account of racial experiences, some critics argue that its fragmented narrative style may make it challenging for readers to engage cohesively with the text.

Keywords in Phenomenology in Literature

1. Phenomenology: A philosophical approach that emphasizes the study of subjective human experiences and consciousness, aiming to understand how individuals perceive and interpret the world.
2. Intentionality: The inherent directedness of consciousness toward objects, highlighting the relationship between a subject’s awareness and the objects of that awareness.
3. Bracketing (Epoché): The method of suspending or setting aside preconceived judgments and beliefs about a phenomenon to explore it objectively and phenomenologically.
4. Reduction: The process of shifting focus from the external world to the immediate subjective experience, aimed at uncovering the essence or underlying structures of phenomena.
5. Eidetic Variation: A method used to explore the essential characteristics of a phenomenon by considering various possible variations or instances of that phenomenon.
6. Subjectivity: The unique and individual perspective, thoughts, emotions, and experiences of a conscious being.
7. Existentialism: A philosophical movement that examines the existence, freedom, choice, and authenticity of individuals, often explored through phenomenological themes in literature.
8. Hermeneutics: The study of interpretation and understanding, particularly in the context of understanding how readers or interpreters engage with texts and the role of context and perspective in interpretation.
9. Narrative Structures: The organization and arrangement of events, characters, and themes within a literary work, often analyzed from a phenomenological perspective to understand how they convey human experiences.
10. Embodiment: The concept that human consciousness and experience are closely linked to the physical body, exploring how the body influences and shapes our perceptions and interactions with the world.

Suggested Readings about Phenomenology in Literature

1. De Bolla, Peter. The Discourse of the Sublime: Readings in History, Aesthetics, and the Subject. Blackwell, 1989.
2. Gasché, Rodolphe. The Tain of the Mirror: Derrida and the Philosophy of Reflection. Harvard University Press, 1986.
3. Krell, David Farrell. Intimations of Mortality: Time, Truth, and Finitude in Heidegger’s Thinking of Being. Pennsylvania State University Press, 1986.
4. Levinas, Emmanuel. Totality and Infinity: An Essay on Exteriority. Translated by Alphonso Lingis, Duquesne University Press, 1969.
5. Llewelyn, John. The Middle Voice of Ecological Conscience: A Chiasmic Reading of Responsibility in the Neighborhood of Levinas, Heidegger, and Others. Penn State University Press, 2003.
6. Merleau-Ponty, Maurice. Phenomenology of Perception. Translated by Colin Smith, Routledge, 2012.
7. Moran, Dermot. Edmund Husserl: Founder of Phenomenology. Polity Press, 2005.
8. Nayar, Pramod K. The New Media and Cybercultures Anthology. Wiley-Blackwell, 2010.
9. Ricoeur, Paul. Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences: Essays on Language, Action, and Interpretation. Translated by John B. Thompson, Cambridge University Press, 1981.

Read more on Literary Theory Below:

• Relief Theory in Literature
• Polysystem Theory in Literature
• Pastoral Theory in Literature
• Neoclassicism in Literature
• Naturalism in Literature