“Presents from My Aunts in Pakistan” by Moniza Alvi: A Critical Analysis

Introduction: “Presents from My Aunts in Pakistan” by Moniza Alvi

“Presents from My Aunts in Pakistan” by Moniza Alvi first appeared in her 1993 poetry collection The Country at My Shoulder. The poem explores themes of cultural identity, displacement, and hybridity, reflecting the poet’s experience as a child of mixed heritage—half-Pakistani and half-English. Through vivid imagery of “salwar kameez / peacock-blue” and “embossed slippers, gold and black,” Alvi captures the sensory richness of Pakistani culture while simultaneously expressing her alienation from it. The speaker feels torn between two worlds: she finds the traditional clothes “alien in the sitting-room” and yearns instead for “denim and corduroy,” symbols of Western identity. The poem’s popularity stems from its honest portrayal of the diasporic struggle for belonging, a universal theme that resonates with readers navigating cross-cultural identities. The closing lines—“of no fixed nationality, / staring through fretwork / at the Shalimar Gardens”—encapsulate the enduring conflict of self-perception and cultural duality that defines Alvi’s poetic vision.

Text: “Presents from My Aunts in Pakistan” by Moniza Alvi

They sent me a salwar kameez
            peacock-blue,
                  and another
   glistening like an orange split open,
embossed slippers, gold and black
            points curling.
   Candy-striped glass bangles
            snapped, drew blood.
   Like at school, fashions changed
            in Pakistan –
the salwar bottoms were broad and stiff,
            then narrow.
My aunts chose an apple-green sari,
   silver-bordered
            for my teens.

I tried each satin-silken top –
   was alien in the sitting-room.
I could never be as lovely
            as those clothes –
   I longed
for denim and corduroy.
   My costume clung to me
            and I was aflame,
I couldn’t rise up out of its fire,
   half-English,
            unlike Aunt Jamila.

I wanted my parents’ camel-skin lamp –
   switching it on in my bedroom,
to consider the cruelty
            and the transformation
from camel to shade,
   marvel at the colours
            like stained glass.

My mother cherished her jewellery –
   Indian gold, dangling, filigree,
            But it was stolen from our car.
The presents were radiant in my wardrobe.
   My aunts requested cardigans
            from Marks and Spencers.

My salwar kameez
   didn’t impress the schoolfriend
who sat on my bed, asked to see
   my weekend clothes.
But often I admired the mirror-work,
   tried to glimpse myself
            in the miniature
glass circles, recall the story
   how the three of us
            sailed to England.
Prickly heat had me screaming on the way.
   I ended up in a cot
In my English grandmother’s dining-room,
   found myself alone,
            playing with a tin-boat.

I pictured my birthplace
   from fifties’ photographs.
            When I was older
there was conflict, a fractured land
   throbbing through newsprint.
Sometimes I saw Lahore –
            my aunts in shaded rooms,
screened from male visitors,
   sorting presents,
         wrapping them in tissue.

Or there were beggars, sweeper-girls
   and I was there –
            of no fixed nationality,
staring through fretwork
            at the Shalimar Gardens.

Annotations: “Presents from My Aunts in Pakistan” by Moniza Alvi

Stanza	Summary / Annotation	Key Literary Devices & Examples
1	The speaker receives traditional Pakistani clothes and jewelry from her aunts—“salwar kameez, peacock-blue”, “embossed slippers”, “candy-striped glass bangles.” The gifts are beautiful and exotic but cause discomfort (“bangles snapped, drew blood”), symbolizing the pain and difficulty of balancing two cultures.	Imagery: “peacock-blue,” “orange split open” (vivid sensory detail). Symbolism: Gifts represent cultural roots. Metaphor: “drew blood” — cultural tension. Alliteration: “Candy-striped glass bangles.”
2	The poet feels “alien in the sitting-room” when wearing the Pakistani clothes; they make her feel unlike others. She wishes for “denim and corduroy,” representing her English identity. The image “I was aflame” shows her discomfort and inner conflict as she struggles with being “half-English.”	Contrast: Eastern dress vs. Western clothes. Metaphor: “I was aflame” — emotional turmoil. Symbolism: “Denim and corduroy” for English modernity. Tone: Conflict and alienation.
3	She admires her parents’ “camel-skin lamp”, yet reflects on the “cruelty and the transformation from camel to shade.” This symbolizes how beauty and tradition can emerge through loss and change, reflecting her own transformation living between cultures.	Symbolism: “Camel-skin lamp” — transformation and loss. Imagery: “Colours like stained glass.” Juxtaposition: Cruelty vs. beauty. Metaphor: Cultural transformation.
4	Her mother’s cherished “Indian gold” jewelry is “stolen from our car,” symbolizing the loss of cultural heritage. The “radiant” gifts remain unused in her wardrobe, while her aunts request “cardigans from Marks and Spencers,” showing the East-West exchange and irony of mutual fascination.	Irony: Aunts desiring Western clothes. Symbolism: “Indian gold” for heritage. Personification: “The presents were radiant.” Metonymy: “Marks and Spencers” for Western consumerism.
5	Her “salwar kameez” does not impress her English schoolfriend, symbolizing cultural disconnect. She admires the “mirror-work” and tries to “glimpse” herself—an attempt to understand her fragmented identity. Recalling her childhood voyage to England and “playing with a tin-boat” shows her loneliness and cultural displacement.	Motif: “Mirror-work” — self-reflection and identity. Imagery: “Miniature glass circles.” Symbolism: Journey to England — migration and isolation. Tone: Nostalgic and introspective.
6	The poet imagines Pakistan through “fifties’ photographs” and news of “a fractured land throbbing through newsprint.” She envisions her aunts’ domestic lives—“shaded rooms, screened from male visitors”—showing her distance from that world. This portrays her sense of separation and longing for belonging.	Allusion: Political division of Pakistan. Imagery: “Shaded rooms,” “tissue wrapping.” Theme: Disconnection from homeland. Symbolism: “Fractured land” — fractured identity.
7	The final stanza contrasts poverty—“beggars, sweeper-girls”—with her detached gaze “staring through fretwork at the Shalimar Gardens.” She admits being “of no fixed nationality,” symbolizing her permanent state of cultural in-betweenness and alienation from both England and Pakistan.	Symbolism: “Shalimar Gardens” — lost cultural paradise. Metaphor: “Of no fixed nationality” — identity crisis. Contrast: Beauty vs. poverty. Ambiguity: Unresolved belonging. Tone: Melancholic and reflective.

Literary And Poetic Devices: “Presents from My Aunts in Pakistan” by Moniza Alvi

Device	Example from Poem	Full and Specific Explanation
🦚 Alliteration	“peacock-blue”	The repetition of the same initial /p/ sound in successive words produces a musical rhythm and draws attention to the luxurious imagery of the fabric. It enhances the sensuous quality of the description and reflects the aesthetic appeal of traditional attire.
🔥 Allusion	“Shalimar Gardens”	This allusion to the historic Mughal gardens in Lahore connects the speaker to her ancestral homeland, evoking Pakistan’s cultural richness and her inherited sense of belonging, even from afar.
🩸 Symbolism	“Candy-striped glass bangles / snapped, drew blood.”	The bangles symbolize both the delicate beauty and the painful constraints of cultural identity. Their breaking and the drawing of blood represent the emotional injury caused by the clash between Pakistani and British identities.
💬 Contrast	“I longed / for denim and corduroy.”	The contrast between traditional Pakistani clothing and Western casual wear highlights the poet’s cultural tension and desire to conform to the English environment, reflecting her internal struggle between heritage and modernity.
🌗 Duality	“half-English, unlike Aunt Jamila.”	This expresses the poet’s split identity — she embodies both English and Pakistani cultures but feels a full sense of belonging to neither. Aunt Jamila’s confidence in tradition emphasizes the speaker’s cultural dislocation.
✨ Imagery	“glistening like an orange split open.”	Vivid visual imagery appeals to the senses, conveying the fabric’s shimmer, warmth, and richness. It creates a sensual picture of exotic beauty and highlights the difference between her two cultural worlds.
🪞 Metaphor	“My costume clung to me / and I was aflame.”	The metaphor of being “aflame” signifies emotional turmoil and cultural discomfort. The dress represents imposed tradition, while the burning symbolizes the conflict of identity and assimilation.
🎭 Personification	“My costume clung to me.”	The clothing is personified as something that holds her tightly, suggesting how social and cultural expectations envelop and restrict her individuality.
📦 Enjambment	“My aunts chose an apple-green sari, / silver-bordered / for my teens.”	The continuation of the sentence beyond the line break mirrors the fluidity of memory and thought. It reflects the ongoing negotiation between her Pakistani past and English present.
🪙 Irony	“My mother cherished her jewellery… / But it was stolen from our car.”	The cherished jewellery — a symbol of heritage and continuity — is ironically lost, representing how migration can strip one of cultural and emotional possessions.
💔 Juxtaposition	“My aunts requested cardigans / from Marks and Spencers.”	The juxtaposition of traditional givers of Pakistani gifts and their desire for Western goods underscores the cultural exchange and irony of reversed admiration between East and West.
🧵 Metonymy	“My salwar kameez / didn’t impress the schoolfriend.”	The salwar kameez stands metonymically for her Pakistani identity. Her friend’s indifference symbolizes societal disregard for her cultural uniqueness.
🌈 Simile	“glistening like an orange split open.”	The comparison using “like” vividly enhances the texture, color, and sensual richness of the cloth, evoking the allure and intensity of her Pakistani roots.
🕊️ Tone	Entire poem	The poem’s tone shifts between nostalgia, pride, and alienation. It expresses a longing for cultural connection mixed with discomfort about not fully fitting into either world.
🧩 Motif	Repetition of clothes and gifts (e.g., “sari,” “salwar kameez,” “cardigans”)	The recurring motif of clothing symbolizes her attempt to weave together fragments of her dual identity. Each garment embodies memory, family, and cultural heritage.
🌍 Cultural Imagery	“camel-skin lamp,” “mirror-work.”	These items reflect Pakistan’s artistic craftsmanship and serve as cultural anchors for the poet’s diasporic identity, reminding her of her origin and traditions.
🔮 Metaphysical Imagery	“from camel to shade.”	This image connects physical transformation to spiritual change — from living creature to decorative lamp — suggesting the pain and beauty of transformation and cultural adaptation.
🌸 Sensory Imagery	“satin-silken top.”	Appeals to touch and sight, evoking the smooth texture and elegance of the clothing. This sensual detail captures her admiration and alienation toward traditional beauty.
🕰️ Temporal Shift	“I pictured my birthplace / from fifties’ photographs.”	The poet moves between past and present, memory and imagination. This time shift reveals her fragmented sense of identity and nostalgic yearning for a homeland she barely knows.
🚪 Theme of Identity	“of no fixed nationality.”	The central theme reflects the poet’s existential conflict. She embodies two cultures but belongs wholly to neither, representing the complexities of diasporic identity and belonging.

Themes: “Presents from My Aunts in Pakistan” by Moniza Alvi

🌸 Cultural Identity and Hybridity: In “Presents from My Aunts in Pakistan” by Moniza Alvi, the poet explores the tension of cultural identity and hybridity that arises from living between two worlds—England and Pakistan. The gifts she receives, such as “a salwar kameez, peacock-blue” and “another glistening like an orange split open,” represent the beauty and richness of her Pakistani heritage. Yet, when she tries them on, she confesses, “I was alien in the sitting-room,” expressing how out of place she feels in both cultural contexts. The “presents” in the poem’s title symbolize not only affection from her aunts but also the inherited weight of a culture she cannot fully inhabit. Her reflection, “half-English, unlike Aunt Jamila,” highlights her fractured sense of belonging—caught between two cultural identities, unable to claim either entirely. Through this conflict, Alvi captures the essence of hybridity that defines many postcolonial and diasporic experiences.

---

💎 Displacement and Alienation: In “Presents from My Aunts in Pakistan” by Moniza Alvi, the theme of displacement and alienation is central, revealing the poet’s inner struggle to reconcile her dual heritage. When she wears the “satin-silken top,” she feels consumed and uneasy: “My costume clung to me and I was aflame.” The metaphor of fire signifies her discomfort and the burning tension of identity conflict. Her “schoolfriend” remains unimpressed by her “salwar kameez,” symbolizing her exclusion within her English environment. The memory of “how the three of us sailed to England” and being “alone, playing with a tin-boat” evokes deep feelings of isolation and cultural uprooting. Alvi’s imagery of travel and solitude reflects the psychological displacement that comes from migration. The poet stands between two cultures, alienated from both, expressing the painful reality of being perpetually “in-between.”

---

🪞 Memory, Heritage, and the Search for Belonging: In “Presents from My Aunts in Pakistan” by Moniza Alvi, the poet uses memory and heritage as pathways to explore her longing for belonging and self-identity. She recalls “my aunts in shaded rooms, screened from male visitors, sorting presents,” presenting a vision of tradition that she experiences only through imagination. Her admiration for “the camel-skin lamp” reflects both wonder and sorrow—she marvels at “the colours like stained glass” while acknowledging “the cruelty and the transformation from camel to shade.” This transformation mirrors her own: shaped by two cultural forces yet fully owned by neither. When she “tried to glimpse myself in the miniature glass circles,” the mirror-work symbolizes fragmented identity and self-reflection. Through these images, Alvi portrays memory as both a bridge to her ancestral past and a reminder of the distance that separates her from it.

---

🌺 East–West Contrast and Cultural Exchange: In “Presents from My Aunts in Pakistan” by Moniza Alvi, the poet powerfully presents the contrast and exchange between Eastern and Western cultures, revealing both irony and admiration. The “radiant” Pakistani gifts remain unworn, while her aunts desire “cardigans from Marks and Spencers,” illustrating a mutual fascination between cultures. The juxtaposition of “Indian gold, dangling, filigree” with “denim and corduroy” captures the clash between tradition and modernity, luxury and simplicity. Alvi’s tone is reflective, suggesting that both East and West are trapped in cycles of imitation and idealization. The final image—“staring through fretwork at the Shalimar Gardens”—symbolizes her position as an observer, separated from her roots by invisible cultural barriers. Through this contrast, Alvi demonstrates how globalization creates cultural exchange that is at once enriching and alienating, leaving the individual suspended between admiration and estrangement.

Literary Theories and “Presents from My Aunts in Pakistan” by Moniza Alvi

Literary Theory	Application to “Presents from My Aunts in Pakistan”	Textual References and Interpretation
🌍 Postcolonial Theory	Postcolonial criticism examines identity, hybridity, and cultural displacement caused by colonial histories. In Alvi’s poem, the speaker navigates the in-between space of being “half-English,” embodying the postcolonial subject’s struggle for belonging. The poem exposes the lingering effects of colonialism on identity and cultural expression.	“half-English, unlike Aunt Jamila” — reveals hybrid identity and cultural alienation. “of no fixed nationality” — symbolizes postcolonial displacement and fractured selfhood. “My salwar kameez didn’t impress the schoolfriend” — shows cultural marginalization within Western society.
🪞 Feminist Theory	Feminist criticism interprets the poem as an exploration of female identity, tradition, and autonomy. The gifts symbolize both cultural heritage and gendered expectations. The speaker’s resistance to ornate, restrictive clothing parallels the struggle of women asserting individuality beyond traditional roles.	“My costume clung to me / and I was aflame” — the burning metaphor expresses emotional suffocation under gender and cultural expectations. “My aunts requested cardigans / from Marks and Spencers” — highlights generational women negotiating tradition and modernity. “I could never be as lovely / as those clothes” — critiques beauty standards imposed on women.
🧭 Cultural Studies Theory	Cultural Studies explores how identity is shaped through social, material, and transnational exchanges. Alvi’s poem becomes a site where Eastern and Western cultural symbols collide, reflecting consumerism, globalization, and diasporic identity formation.	“Candy-striped glass bangles snapped, drew blood” — consumer object turned symbol of identity pain. “cardigans from Marks and Spencers” — reveals cultural exchange and colonial residue in material desires. “camel-skin lamp… from camel to shade” — symbolizes commodification of culture in diasporic life.
💫 Psychoanalytic Theory	From a Freudian–Lacanian lens, the poem portrays the split self, desire for wholeness, and internal conflict between the ego (English self) and id (Pakistani heritage). The presents act as triggers for repressed memories and the tension between assimilation and authenticity.	“I was aflame” — repressed identity emerging as emotional turmoil. “I pictured my birthplace / from fifties’ photographs” — represents unconscious longing and imagined homeland. “Prickly heat had me screaming on the way” — symbolizes early trauma of migration, forming the psyche of exile.

Critical Questions about “Presents from My Aunts in Pakistan” by Moniza Alvi

---

Literary Works Similar to “Presents from My Aunts in Pakistan” by Moniza Alvi

Representative Quotations of “Presents from My Aunts in Pakistan” by Moniza Alvi

Quotation	Context and Theoretical Perspective
🌸 “They sent me a salwar kameez, peacock-blue, and another glistening like an orange split open.”	The poet introduces the vibrant cultural gifts from Pakistan, highlighting her ancestral roots. (Postcolonial theory – Cultural hybridity and material identity.)
💎 “Candy-striped glass bangles snapped, drew blood.”	The bangles, symbols of beauty and tradition, also cause pain—reflecting the discomfort of cultural inheritance. (Feminist and postcolonial perspective – The pain of assimilation and cultural conflict.)
🪞 “I was alien in the sitting-room.”	The poet feels out of place wearing her traditional clothes in an English environment. (Cultural identity theory – Otherness and diasporic alienation.)
🌺 “I longed for denim and corduroy.”	Western clothing symbolizes her yearning for belonging in English society. (Postcolonial identity – Internalized colonial influence and mimicry.)
🌻 “My costume clung to me and I was aflame.”	The metaphor of fire conveys her internal struggle between pride and discomfort in her cultural identity. (Psychological lens – Dual consciousness and identity crisis.)
🌼 “I wanted my parents’ camel-skin lamp – to consider the cruelty and the transformation from camel to shade.”	The image represents transformation, both physical and cultural, and the cost of beauty. (Symbolic interpretation – Transformation and cultural commodification.)
🌸 “My aunts requested cardigans from Marks and Spencers.”	This irony shows the East’s fascination with Western modernity while the poet admires Eastern tradition. (Globalization theory – Cross-cultural desire and cultural exchange.)
💠 “My salwar kameez didn’t impress the schoolfriend.”	The failure of her traditional clothes to be accepted exposes her social alienation in England. (Sociological reading – Cultural rejection and identity marginalization.)
🪷 “Sometimes I saw Lahore – my aunts in shaded rooms, screened from male visitors.”	The poet imagines Pakistan as distant and traditional, shaped by memory rather than experience. (Postcolonial nostalgia – Imagined homeland and cultural memory.)
🌹 “Of no fixed nationality, staring through fretwork at the Shalimar Gardens.”	The closing image captures her divided identity and permanent in-betweenness. (Diaspora studies – Hybridity, displacement, and liminality.)

Suggested Readings: “Presents from My Aunts in Pakistan” by Moniza Alvi

---