“Sonnet 14: Not from the stars do I my judgement pluck” by William Shakespeare: A Critical Analysis

Introduction: “Sonnet 14: Not from the stars do I my judgement pluck” by William Shakespeare

“Sonnet 14: Not from the stars do I my judgement pluck” by William Shakespeare first appeared in 1609 in the collection “Shakespeare’s Sonnets.” This sonnet is characterized by its use of iambic pentameter, a rhyme scheme of ABAB CDCD EFEF GG, and the frequent use of metaphors and similes. The main idea of the sonnet is that true beauty and love are not determined by external factors like appearance or social status, but rather by internal qualities that are not influenced by the stars or destiny. Shakespeare argues that these qualities are the true test of love and beauty.

Text: “Sonnet 14: Not from the stars do I my judgement pluck” by William Shakespeare

Not from the stars do I my judgement pluck;
And yet methinks I have Astronomy,
But not to tell of good or evil luck,
Of plagues, of dearths, or seasons’ quality;
Nor can I fortune to brief minutes tell,
Pointing to each his thunder, rain and wind,
Or say with princes if it shall go well
By oft predict that I in heaven find:
But from thine eyes my knowledge I derive,
And, constant stars, in them I read such art
As truth and beauty shall together thrive,
If from thyself, to store thou wouldst convert;
   Or else of thee this I prognosticate:
   Thy end is truth’s and beauty’s doom and date.

Annotations: “Sonnet 14: Not from the stars do I my judgement pluck” by William Shakespeare

Line	Annotation
1. Not from the stars do I my judgement pluck;	The speaker states that they do not rely on astrology (the stars) to make their judgments or predictions.
2. And yet methinks I have Astronomy,	Although the speaker claims not to use the stars for divination, they still possess some knowledge or understanding of astronomy (science of stars).
3. But not to tell of good or evil luck,	The speaker clarifies that their understanding of the stars isn’t used for predicting fortune (good or bad luck).
4. Of plagues, of dearths, or seasons’ quality;	Nor does the speaker use the stars to predict natural disasters, famines, or weather patterns.
5. Nor can I fortune to brief minutes tell,	The speaker acknowledges that they cannot predict events moment by moment (like an astrologer would).
6. Pointing to each his thunder, rain and wind,	They can’t forecast specific weather events, like thunder, rain, or wind, either.
7. Or say with princes if it shall go well	They cannot predict the fortunes or misfortunes of kings and princes based on astrology.
8. By oft predict that I in heaven find:	The speaker rejects the idea of frequently making predictions based on celestial bodies (the stars).
9. But from thine eyes my knowledge I derive,	Instead of relying on stars, the speaker draws their knowledge from the beloved’s eyes, suggesting that their insight comes from personal connection, not astrology.
10. And, constant stars, in them I read such art	The speaker compares the beloved’s eyes to “constant stars,” seeing them as a source of truth, beauty, and wisdom.
11. As truth and beauty shall together thrive,	The speaker believes that from the beloved’s eyes, they can read a future where truth and beauty coexist harmoniously.
12. If from thyself, to store thou wouldst convert;	The speaker advises that the beloved can ensure the survival of truth and beauty by passing their qualities on (potentially referring to reproduction or a legacy).
13. Or else of thee this I prognosticate:	The speaker warns that if the beloved does not “convert” their qualities (i.e., share them), they can predict the end result.
14. Thy end is truth’s and beauty’s doom and date.	The speaker concludes that without such action, the beloved’s death will mark the demise of both truth and beauty, as the speaker believes these virtues are embodied in the beloved and would end with them.

Literary And Poetic Devices: “Sonnet 14: Not from the stars do I my judgement pluck” by William Shakespeare

Poetic Device	Definition	Explanation	Example
Alliteration	The repetition of the same consonant sound at the beginning of words.	This creates a musical effect and emphasizes certain words.	as “t” in this line: “If from thyself, to store thou wouldst convert”
Antithesis	The juxtaposition of contrasting ideas or images.	This creates a sense of balance and emphasizes the contrast between the two ideas.	“But from thine eyes my knowledge I derive, And, constant stars, in them I read such art”
Apostrophe	Addressing a person or thing that is not present.	This creates a sense of intimacy and emotion.	“O, you, fair eyes, that do possess my soul”
Hyperbole	Exaggeration for emphasis.	This creates a vivid image and emphasizes the point being made.	“Or say with princes if it shall go well”
Imagery	The use of vivid language to create mental images.	This helps the reader visualize the scene and connect emotionally with the poem.	“Pointing to each his thunder, rain and wind”
Metaphor	A comparison between two unlike things without using “like” or “as.”	This creates a vivid image and helps the reader understand the meaning of the poem.	“And, constant stars, in them I read such art”
Oxymoron	A combination of contradictory terms.	This creates a sense of surprise and emphasizes the contrast between the two terms.	“Constant stars”
Paradox	A statement that seems contradictory but is actually true.	This creates a sense of intrigue and makes the reader think about the meaning of the poem.	“Thy end is truth’s and beauty’s doom and date”
Rhyme	The repetition of similar sounds at the end of words.	This creates a musical effect and helps to structure the poem.	“Plucked” and “luck,” “Tell” and “well”
Rhyme Scheme	The pattern of rhymes in a poem.	This helps to structure the poem and create a sense of rhythm.	Sonnet 14 has an ABAB CDCD EFEF GG rhyme scheme.
Simile	A comparison between two unlike things using “like” or “as.”	This creates a vivid image and helps the reader understand the meaning of the poem.	“Not from the stars do I my judgement pluck”
Symbolism	The use of objects or images to represent something else.	This creates a deeper meaning and helps the reader understand the theme of the poem.	The eyes in the poem symbolize knowledge and understanding.
Syntax	The arrangement of words in a sentence.	This affects the rhythm and meaning of the poem.	Shakespeare uses inverted syntax in some lines, such as “Not from the stars do I my judgement pluck.”
Theme	The central idea or message of the poem.	The theme of Sonnet 14 is that true beauty and knowledge come from within, not from external factors.
Tone	The attitude of the speaker toward the subject matter.	The tone of Sonnet 14 is confident and assertive.
Volta	The turning point in a sonnet, usually occurring at the beginning of the thirteenth line.	The volta in Sonnet 14 is where the speaker shifts from discussing his lack of knowledge from the stars to his knowledge derived from the eyes of his beloved.
Word Choice	The selection of words to convey a particular meaning.	Shakespeare uses specific words to create imagery and emphasize certain ideas.	For example, he uses the word “constant” to describe the stars, emphasizing their reliability and unchanging nature.

Themes: “Sonnet 14: Not from the stars do I my judgement pluck” by William Shakespeare

Literary Theories and “Sonnet 14: Not from the stars do I my judgement pluck” by William Shakespeare

Literary Theory	Explanation in the Context of Sonnet 14	References from the Sonnet
Formalism/New Criticism	This theory focuses on the text itself, emphasizing its form, structure, and literary devices. It looks at how language, symbols, and literary elements create meaning without considering outside contexts (historical or authorial intent).	In Sonnet 14, the juxtaposition of celestial imagery with human beauty highlights the speaker’s comparison between external cosmic forces and personal, internalized sources of truth and beauty.
Psychoanalytic Criticism	This theory, based on the work of Freud, explores the psychological motivations of characters or authors, often uncovering subconscious desires or conflicts. It might examine how love and admiration are reflected in the speaker’s psyche.	The speaker’s intense focus on the beloved’s eyes could be interpreted as a subconscious projection of their desire to connect their personal fate and knowledge to the beloved’s physical traits.
New Historicism/Cultural Criticism	This theory looks at how historical context and cultural power dynamics influence a text. It might analyze how astrology was perceived in Shakespeare’s time or how the speaker’s reliance on the beloved reflects societal values of beauty and truth.	During Shakespeare’s time, astrology held significant cultural power, yet the sonnet subverts this by claiming that true knowledge comes not from the stars but from human beauty, particularly the beloved’s.

Critical Questions about “Sonnet 14: Not from the stars do I my judgement pluck” by William Shakespeare

• How does Shakespeare challenge the concept of fate and astrology in the sonnet?
• The sonnet opens with a rejection of astrology as a reliable source of knowledge: “Not from the stars do I my judgement pluck” (line 1). By distancing himself from the practice of deriving meaning from the stars, Shakespeare questions the idea that fate is written in the heavens. The speaker’s dismissal of the stars’ ability to predict “good or evil luck” (line 3) or influence the lives of “princes” (line 7) challenges the conventional belief in astrological determinism. Instead, the sonnet shifts the source of truth and knowledge to the personal realm, specifically the beloved’s eyes, suggesting that human relationships and beauty are more profound than cosmic forces in shaping one’s understanding of the world.
• What is the significance of the metaphor of the beloved’s eyes as “constant stars”?
•  The metaphor comparing the beloved’s eyes to “constant stars” (line 10) suggests that, for the speaker, the eyes are a stable, reliable source of wisdom and beauty. Unlike the unpredictable and often inscrutable movements of celestial bodies, the beloved’s eyes offer clear insight. This comparison elevates the beloved to a cosmic level, making their physical beauty and personal attributes timeless and immutable. However, this also raises questions about the speaker’s reliance on the beloved for knowledge. If the beloved is elevated to such an idealized level, does this prevent the speaker from seeing them as a flawed human, or is it a form of love that transcends such limitations?
• What role does the idea of preservation play in the sonnet, particularly in the final couplet?
• The final couplet, “Thy end is truth’s and beauty’s doom and date” (line 14), introduces a sense of urgency about the preservation of truth and beauty. The speaker suggests that the beloved has a responsibility to “convert” their beauty into something that can be stored or passed on (line 12), hinting at the idea of legacy or possibly reproduction. This raises the question of whether beauty and truth are only valuable if they are preserved for future generations. Is the speaker’s admiration contingent upon the beloved’s ability to ensure the continuation of these qualities, or is the beauty valuable in and of itself, even if it cannot be passed on?
• How does the sonnet reflect the tension between external cosmic forces and human agency?
• Throughout the sonnet, there is an ongoing tension between external cosmic forces, represented by the stars, and the internal, human source of knowledge embodied in the beloved’s eyes. While the speaker dismisses the stars as unreliable for predicting events or guiding one’s actions (lines 5–7), they place immense faith in the beloved’s eyes as a source of “truth and beauty” (line 11). This reflects a broader tension between fate (as determined by cosmic forces) and human agency (as determined by personal relationships). The sonnet seems to suggest that human agency, grounded in love and beauty, is more powerful and reliable than the impersonal forces of fate. This raises the question: does the speaker fully reject fate, or do they simply find a more reliable version of it in the beloved?

Literary Works Similar to “Sonnet 14: Not from the stars do I my judgement pluck” by William Shakespeare

Representative Quotations of “Sonnet 14: Not from the stars do I my judgement pluck” by William Shakespeare

Quotation	Context	Theoretical Perspective
“Not from the stars do I my judgement pluck;”	The opening line where the speaker rejects astrology as a source of knowledge.	Formalism – The rejection of conventional celestial authority.
“And yet methinks I have Astronomy,”	The speaker admits to possessing knowledge of astronomy, but not for making predictions.	Psychoanalytic Criticism – Suggests inner conflict about fate.
“But not to tell of good or evil luck,”	The speaker clarifies that their knowledge of the stars isn’t used to predict fortune.	New Historicism – Reflects societal skepticism about astrology.
“Nor can I fortune to brief minutes tell,”	The speaker cannot predict specific events or moments, rejecting deterministic views.	Structuralism – Demonstrates the limitations of human control.
“But from thine eyes my knowledge I derive,”	The speaker contrasts their rejection of the stars with the belief that knowledge comes from the beloved’s eyes.	Psychoanalytic Criticism – Emotional dependence on the beloved.
“And, constant stars, in them I read such art”	The speaker compares the beloved’s eyes to constant stars, a source of stable, eternal truth.	Formalism – Use of metaphor to elevate the beloved’s eyes.
“As truth and beauty shall together thrive,”	The speaker believes that truth and beauty are united and immortalized through the beloved.	Aestheticism – Emphasizes the union of beauty and truth.
“If from thyself, to store thou wouldst convert;”	The speaker urges the beloved to preserve their beauty, suggesting a legacy or reproduction to ensure truth and beauty’s survival.	New Criticism – Focus on the preservation of abstract qualities.
“Or else of thee this I prognosticate:”	The speaker offers a prophecy, shifting the tone to one of warning, about the loss of truth and beauty if they are not preserved.	Psychoanalytic Criticism – Anxiety about impermanence.
“Thy end is truth’s and beauty’s doom and date.”	The final line, where the speaker predicts that the beloved’s end will also be the end of truth and beauty, giving them ultimate importance.	New Historicism – Reflects Renaissance ideals of beauty’s ephemerality.

Suggested Readings: “Sonnet 14: Not from the stars do I my judgement pluck” by William Shakespeare

1. Andrews, Michael Cameron. “Sincerity and Subterfuge In Three Shakespearean Sonnet Groups.” Shakespeare Quarterly, vol. 33, no. 3, 1982, pp. 314–27. JSTOR, https://doi.org/10.2307/2869735. Accessed 2 Oct. 2024.
2. Beckwith, Elizabeth. “On The Chronology of Shakespeare’s Sonnets.” The Journal of English and Germanic Philology, vol. 25, no. 2, 1926, pp. 227–42. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/27702954. Accessed 2 Oct. 2024.
3. Duncan-Jones, Katherine. “Playing Fields or Killing Fields: Shakespeare’s Poems and ‘Sonnets.’” Shakespeare Quarterly, vol. 54, no. 2, 2003, pp. 127–41. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/3844171. Accessed 2 Oct. 2024.