Rhetorical Analysis of McDonald’s Filet-o-Fish

Rhetorical analysis of McDonald’s Filet-o-Fish delves into the persuasive strategies employed in McDonald’s Filet-O-Fish marketing, examining the use of language, imagery, and appeals to analyze how the fast-food giant strategically communicates its message to the target audience.

Introduction: Rhetorical Analysis of McDonald’s Filet-o-Fish

Rhetorical analysis of McDonald’s Filet-o-Fish delves into the persuasive strategies employed in McDonald’s Filet-O-Fish marketing, examining the use of language, imagery, and appeals to analyze how the fast-food giant strategically communicates its message to the target audience. Marketers shrewdly leverage various cartoon characters for their new products, employing these characters with new props in advertisements. These cartoon characters subtly convey messages targeted at both the young and adults, promoting a neutral stance that communicates a taste surpassing gender or cultural specificities. This approach led to the introduction of a new character—a pirate. The pirate character is portrayed wearing a tea shirt with red and white lines, a black or greyish-black hat, a beard, a blindfold on his left eye, his left hand in his pocket, and a hook in his right hand carrying the featured burger, the focal point of the advertisement. The pirate character is also depicted carrying a dagger with a yellow hilt. The neutrality of the cartoon extends not only across gender and cultural levels but also proves enticing and captivating for children. The unique look of the pirate, particularly with his somewhat twisted mustaches and distinctive speaking style, adds to its appeal.

Rather than simply displaying the burger with a standard announcement, the advertisement incorporates the slogan “Pirates would give their arm for one,” where “one” refers to the Filet-o-Fish. This slogan effectively conveys the burger’s taste, clarifying the significance of the hook in the pirate’s right hand, which is used to carry the burger. The props, including the yellow hilt of the dagger, are intentionally selected to convey the burger’s taste through the pirate character. Simultaneously, the text aligns its meanings with the product, creating a cohesive and effective messaging strategy for the advertisement.

Image and Rhetorical Analysis of McDonald’s Filet-o-Fish

Text alone may not always suffice to make a convincing argument, as it is often complemented by images or pictures. Text, in conjunction with visuals, carries both connotative and denotative meanings. In the instance of the text “Pirates would give their arm for one,” the connotative interpretation suggests a generalization—implying that every pirate would willingly sacrifice a limb for the Filet-o-Fish, the signified “one” in this context. The connotation extends to the taste of the burger, as the willingness of a pirate to give up a body part implies a remarkable quality in the food item. The denotative meaning, on the other hand, straightforwardly communicates that a pirate is prepared to sacrifice a limb for a burger.

The inclusion of the logo and slogan in the bottom right corner of the image serves a dual purpose. Firstly, it adds a layer of logos to the argument, indicating that the advertisement is from a reputable and credible company. Secondly, it establishes a clear relationship and association between the text and the image, enhancing the overall ethos. The text and the pirate image complement each other, reinforcing the credibility of the message. However, the effectiveness of these elements can be compromised in the absence of color contrast and a distinctive font style. These visual aspects play a crucial role in capturing the viewer’s attention and ensuring that the message is conveyed with maximum impact.

Rhetorical Strategies and Rhetorical Analysis of McDonald’s Filet-o-Fish

The use of a combination of serif and non-serif fonts, along with a contrasting color scheme for the fonts against the background, has further enhanced the credibility of the brand, making the argument of the advertisement more effective. Design plays a crucial role in establishing a brand’s credibility, encompassing factors such as font style and color scheme. In this advertisement, the specially designed font style, aligned with the image, adds a distinctive touch. Not only does it heighten the contrast, but it also makes this contrast effective by using a light black color against the background of the greenish-blue sky and dark greenish-blue sea.

This color scheme significantly amplifies the visual appeal of the burger the pirate is carrying. The colors of the plank on which the pirate is standing, as well as the hilt of the sword, stand out prominently against the greenish-blue background. Within this context, the peculiar image of the pirate standing on the long plank seemingly appearing out of nowhere aligns with the uniqueness the brand aims to convey for this product.

Conclusion of Rhetorical Analysis of McDonald’s Filet-o-Fish

In short, the advertisement has been successful in reaching its targeted customers due to having full and perfect props, the best use of a color scheme, text, and fonts. The addition of the logo at the bottom right corner has further strengthened its argument. It is expected, as usual, that McDonald’s will come up with some unique product and a distinctive advertisement scheme. This advertisement has proven it through the use of different props, characters, and design techniques to enhance the rhetorical appeal of the advertisement. The major purpose of all this visual rhetorical argument is that it is important to stay in business when, all of a sudden, a new product emerges and prevails in the market. It seems McDonald’s has achieved its purpose.

Works Cited: Rhetorical Analysis of McDonald’s Filet-o-Fish
  1. “Pirates Would Give Their Arm for One.” Blogpost. n. d. http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-DuRhvPaXxaI/TX-UBKp_dII/AAAAAAAABQE/Dhxofjii3dQ/s1600/pirate-advertising-illustration-mcdonalds-filet-o-fish.jpg. Accessed on 11 Oct. 2017.
Three Relevant Questions about Rhetorical Analysis of McDonald’s Filet-o-Fish
  1. How does McDonald’s employ rhetorical strategies in its marketing and advertising of the Filet-o-Fish to appeal to specific target audiences, considering factors such as cultural diversity and regional preferences?
  2. In the context of a rhetorical analysis, how does McDonald’s use visual elements, such as images and design, to enhance the appeal of the Filet-o-Fish and convey a persuasive message to consumers?
  3. What linguistic and persuasive techniques are employed in McDonald’s promotional materials for the Filet-o-Fish, and how do these strategies contribute to shaping consumer perceptions and influencing their choices in the fast-food market?

“The Snake” by Stephen Crane: Man’s Eternal Foe

Man is at war with the natural world but has also friends. Stephan Crane’s story The Snake shows an enemy the snake and a friend the dog. 

Outlines:
A-Introduction: “The Snake”

Man is at war with the natural world but has also friends. Stephan Crane’s poem The Snake shows an enemy the snake and a friend the dog. 

Thesis Statement: In fact, Stephen Crane explores man’s relation with enteral foe, his eternal fear and eternal friendship with the dog.

Instructions about How to Start, Introduction:
  • Begin with a compelling introduction: The poem by Stephen Crane, which sets the stage for exploring the complex relationship between man and the natural world.
  • Provide a brief summary of the story, highlighting the central characters— the snake as an adversary and the dog as a companion, emphasizing their contrasting roles in the narrative.
  • Introduce the thesis statement that encapsulates the core theme of the analysis: “In fact, it explores man’s relationship with an eternal foe, delving into his perpetual fear and enduring friendship with the dog.”
  • Ensure clarity and coherence in expressing the main idea, making it evident that the analysis will focus on the exploration of man’s intricate connection with both the snake as an enemy and the dog as a friend.
  • Use concise language and maintain a formal tone throughout the introduction, providing a roadmap for the reader to understand the forthcoming examination of the nuanced dynamics presented in Crane’s story.
B-Body: “The Snake”
  • Body Paragraph-1

It is not only a foe, but also a metaphor of evil deeds. The story has Biblical interpretation and it illustrates this very well.

  • Body Paragraph-2

This enteral enmity has filled eternal fear in both the creatures. It shows that “The man and the snake confronted each other” (2) and both have only “hatred and fear” (2) in their eyes.

  • Body Paragraph-3

This is also a natural concept of friendship or man’s friend with do throws a contrast on it. Loyalty of dog has put it in awkward position.

Instructions for B-Body
  • Body Paragraph-1:
    • Emphasize that it is not merely a physical adversary but serves as a metaphor for evil deeds, drawing parallels with biblical interpretations. Discuss how snake in the poem is a symbol representing more than a mere creature; it embodies deeper, metaphorical implications.
  • Body Paragraph-2:
    • Examine the perpetual enmity between man and snake, highlighting the eternal fear that this relationship instills in both parties. Quote a key passage from the story, such as “The man and the snake confronted each other” (2), and explore how this confrontation is characterized by mutual “hatred and fear” (2), shedding light on the profound emotions evoked in this encounter.
  • Body Paragraph-3:
    • Explore the natural concept of friendship presented in the story, particularly the loyalty exhibited by the dog. Draw a clear contrast between the loyalty of the dog and the awkward position in which it places snake. Analyze how the dynamic of friendship between man and dog influences the perception of snake, creating a layered narrative that delves into the complexities of relationships in “The Snake.”
C-Conclusion

The story has biblical interpretations in that it has both enteral friend as well as eternal enemy of human being which are the snake and the dog. It shows danger while dog shows loyalty and love.

Instructions for Writing Conclusion
  • Summarize the overarching theme of the story, highlighting its biblical interpretations that depict both eternal friendship and eternal enmity in the form of the snake and the dog.
  • Reiterate the symbolic significance of the snake as a representation of danger and the dog as a symbol of loyalty and love.
  • Emphasize how Stephen Crane skillfully weaves these elements into the narrative, creating a story that not only explores the complexities of human-animal relationships but also carries profound allegorical undertones.
Works Cited:
  1. Crane, Stephen. The Snake. 2000. 04 February 2014 <http://www.online-literature.com/crane/2557/>.
  2. Darwin, Charles. On the Origin of Species. New York: The Bantam, 1999.
Three Relevant Questions about
  1. How does the snake in Stephen Crane’s “The Snake” serve as a metaphor for deeper, symbolic meanings, particularly in the context of biblical interpretations?
  2. What emotions and dynamics are portrayed in the confrontation between the man and the snake, as expressed through the narrative’s description of their mutual “hatred and fear”? How does this confrontation contribute to the overall theme of eternal enmity in the story?
  3. In what ways does the contrast between the loyalty and love exhibited by the dog and the danger symbolized by the snake contribute to the narrative’s exploration of the dualities in human-animal relationships?

Technology and Human Culture

Technology, in simple terms, refers to innovative discoveries or inventions that facilitate human activities in various areas causing fusion of technology and human culture.

Introduction: Technology and Human Culture

Technology, in simple terms, refers to innovative discoveries or inventions that facilitate human activities in various areas causing fusion of technology and human culture. It emerges in response to the fundamental need for improvement. However, this advancement can also pose challenges for human beings, initiating a cycle of continuous invention of technological devices and subsequent problem-solving. As Amanda Cravens pointed out, there exists a dynamic relationship between human culture, technology, and the surrounding environment (Cravens, 2003).

In her article titled “The Dynamic Relationship Between Technology and Culture,” Cravens argues that “All technologies are shaped by their particular culture,” emphasizing the influence of geography and the physical environment on technology (Cravens, 2003). In essence, she suggests that the physical environment gives rise to human needs, prompting the development of technologies. When these technologies create problems, it leads to the creation of more technologies. Cravens provides the example of the irrigation system in the Middle East, illustrating how it gave rise to the need for more technologies, transforming the culture in the process (Cravens, 2003). This implies a mutual dependence between technology and culture, as they continually shape and influence each other in a transformative manner.

Example: Technology and Human Culture

Similarly, Charlie Gilkey has argued, drawing from historical examples, that “The technology that powered the industrial revolution created the industrial society,” and this transformation gave rise to a culture of mass production, subsequently influencing broader cultural aspects such as music genres like jazz and the emergence of social phenomena like chatting in chat rooms (Gilkey, 2015). Gilkey suggests that as soon as technology becomes integrated into our culture, it has the power to alter the very cultural values that initially shaped it. He emphasizes the idea that there is an awareness that technology is, in a sense, creating itself. According to him, significant technological changes bring about substantial social changes, giving rise to major technologies (Gilkey, 2016).

In essence, Gilkey is conveying that technology has the capability to shape and change human beings and their culture. This transformed culture, in turn, generates new needs for innovative technologies. Moreover, it sparks a heightened awareness of these transformations, creating an entirely new cultural milieu that fuels further technological innovations.

Conclusion: Technology and Human Culture

In short, the intricate relationship between culture and technology is characterized by a mutual dependence and constant influence on one another. When one undergoes a transformation, it inevitably triggers changes in the other, initiating an ongoing cycle of reciprocal influence. The dynamic interplay between culture and technology is such that alterations in one variable invariably lead to corresponding adjustments in the other.

It is accurate to assert that both culture and technology are intricately connected through human interaction, forming a symbiotic relationship. Human beings, in their interactions with their environment, play a pivotal role in shaping both cultural values and technological advancements. The evolving nature of culture and technology is a testament to the continuous interplay between these two elements, where each serves as a catalyst for change in the other. In essence, to affirm that both culture and technology impact human interaction with their environment is not only accurate but underscores the profound interconnectedness of these fundamental aspects of human existence. This interdependence creates a dynamic and ever-evolving landscape where cultural transformations spark technological innovations, and vice versa, fostering a perpetual cycle of influence and adaptation.

References: Technology and Human Culture
  1. Cravens, A. (February 22, 2003). “The Dynamic Relationship Between Technology and Culture.” Swarth More. Retrieved on February 10, 2019 from http://fubini.swarthmore.edu/~ENVS2/S2003/Amanda/Paper2technologyculture.htm
  2. Gilkey, C. (April 21, 20150. “Technology and Culture Influence Each Other.” Productive Flourishing. Retrieved on February 10, 2019 from https://www.productiveflourishing.com/technology-and-culture-influence-each-other/
Relevant Questions
  1. How does the intertwining of technology and human culture contribute to the evolution of societal norms and values?
  2. In what manner does technological innovation shape the cultural identity of communities and individuals in the modern era?
  3. To what extent does the reciprocal relationship between technology and human culture foster or challenge inclusivity and diversity in global societies?

New Future in Old Man’s War

Throughout human history, the power of human imagination has been a driving force in shaping the future, exemplified vividly by visionaries like John Scalzi, who presents a new future in Old Man’s War.

Introduction: New Future in Old Man’s War

Throughout human history, the power of human imagination has been a driving force in shaping the future, exemplified vividly by visionaries like John Scalzi, who presents a new future in Old Man’s War. From ancient tales of flying carpets to the most advanced modes of communication, fictional stories and fables have been instrumental in sparking innovation and progress. Long before the creation of transformative technologies such as television, telephones, and engines, these were nothing more than figments of human imagination, awaiting realization.

Even during the era of Leonardo da Vinci, who conceptualized many ideas that bordered on science fiction in his own time, the visionary creations of the mind have pushed the boundaries of what is possible. Today, our lives are inseparable from the existence of airplanes, mobile phones, and computers—innovations that were once only fantastical musings. Science fiction acts as a catalyst, inspiring people to envision new possibilities and providing solutions to the challenges they encounter in their lives.

As a potent tool, science fiction not only stimulates creativity but also serves as a platform for exploring and resolving societal dilemmas. Each new science fiction narrative opens windows of opportunity for future innovators and scientists, offering a glimpse into potential advancements that could shape the trajectory of human progress. In essence, the imaginative realms of science fiction have proven to be fertile ground for cultivating innovative ideas that, over time, have transformed from mere dreams into the indispensable realities of our everyday lives.

Imagination and New Future in Old Man’s War

For instance, John Scalzi’s science fiction masterpiece, ‘Old Man’s War,’ significantly expands our imaginations with its portrayal of the groundbreaking use of nanotechnology. This book is poised to become an invaluable source of inspiration for budding thinkers and young minds eager to explore the limitless possibilities of the future. Within its narrative, ‘Old Man’s War’ introduces The Colonial Defense Forces, which leverage nanotechnology to address a myriad of challenges, serving as a testament to the transformative potential of this technology.

The novel vividly illustrates the utilization of nanotechnology in weapons and healthcare, pushing the boundaries of our current understanding. Scalzi’s depiction suggests a future where nanotechnology may revolutionize various aspects of our lives in ways we can scarcely imagine today. In the world of ‘Old Man’s War,’ nanobots exhibit incredible precision in performing delicate surgeries, aiding humans in regenerating new limbs. Notably, nanotechnology gives rise to ‘smartblood,’ an innovative concept that enhances human capabilities and physical strength, effectively transforming ordinary individuals into superhumans.

The profound implications of ‘Old Man’s War’ have the power to instill a sense of hope in the hearts and minds of the new generation. As readers delve into the narrative, they are presented with a vision of the future where nanotechnology transcends its current limitations, opening up possibilities for advancements that could redefine the human experience. Scalzi’s work serves not only as a gripping tale but also as a catalyst for stimulating curiosity and innovation, encouraging the exploration of new frontiers in science and technology.

Future and New Future in Old Man’s War

Certainly, the evolution of human progress has shown that predicting the future remains an elusive endeavor. Throughout past centuries, human imagination has been a powerful catalyst for the creation of new machines, tools, and gadgets. The industrial revolution, a transformative period in history, gave rise to incredible inventions that swiftly integrated into our daily lives. Machines and gadgets, once unimaginable, became tangible realities within a few short decades, reshaping the way we live.

In the present era, characterized by an explosion of knowledge and technological advancements, humanity finds itself pushing the boundaries of its capabilities. The conquest of deadly diseases and the remarkable strides in modern medicine have significantly enhanced our physical well-being and increased life expectancy. As we stand on the precipice of the future, the collective gaze of society is fixed on the prospect of transforming an ordinary individual into a superhuman.

Major corporations, including industry giants like Google, are heavily investing in endeavors aimed at augmenting human physical capacities. This emerging trend suggests a trajectory where, in the future, we may witness the application of nanotechnology to revolutionize and enhance our lives even further. The pursuit of making technological strides to improve the human condition appears to be an ongoing journey, marked by relentless innovation and a commitment to shaping a future that surpasses our current understanding of what is possible.

References: New Future in Old Man’s War
  1. The G. (2015, September 22). What’s Next for the Old Man’s War Universe? TOR. Retrieved March 16, 2019, from https://www.tor.com/2015/09/22/whats-next-for-the-old-mans-war-universe/
  2. Luciani, M. (2013, February 15). Old Man’s War by John Scalzi. NETMASSIMO. Retrieved March 16, 2019, from http://english.netmassimo.com/2013/02/15/old-mans-war-by-john-scalzi/
Relevant Questions about New Future in Old Man’s War
  1. How does John Scalzi’s “Old Man’s War” envision a new future through its portrayal of nanotechnology, and what implications does this have for the evolution of human capabilities in the narrative?
  2. In “Old Man’s War,” how does the use of nanotechnology by The Colonial Defense Forces impact both warfare and healthcare, and what broader reflections on the future of technology and its ethical considerations does the narrative provoke?
  3. Considering the influence of “Old Man’s War” in sparking imagination and inspiring new thinkers, what specific elements of the novel’s portrayal of nanotechnology hold the potential to shape discussions around the integration of advanced technologies in our future, both in the realm of science fiction and in real-world applications?

Narratological Lens on Seven Little Australians

This extract, analyzed through Meike Bal’s narratological lens on Seven Little Australians, has been excerpted from the novel’s tenth chapter, titled “Bunty in the Light of a Hero.”

Introduction:Narratological Lens on Seven Little Australians

This extract, analyzed through Meike Bal’s narratological lens on Seven Little Australians, has been excerpted from the novel’s tenth chapter, titled “Bunty in the Light of a Hero.” When applying the theoretical terms articulated by Bal in her book to this two-page extract, it becomes evident that stories are a “structured whole composed of signs.” These signs convey various shades, perspectives, interpretations, and aspects to different audiences and readers.

Upon analyzing this extract in the light of Bal’s views using narratological strategies, it reveals the complexity of the fabula elements, encompassing events, actors, time, location, as well as descriptions, dialogues, and perspectives, all orchestrated through the narrator and focalizer.

Fabula and Narratological Lens on Seven Little Australians

If this extract is regarded as a complete fabula with given events, it demonstrates a logical and chronological order (Bal 6). The third-person omniscient narrator portrays the characters Bunty and Judy in the loft. Bunty is already concealed there when Meg arrives, playing truant from school. Both agents (06) carry out this action in the location of the “loft,” as indicated by the third-person or external narrator.

While the duration and exact timing of the act are not specified, the third-person narrator suggests that, being in the loft, it is likely daytime with some darkness. The second actor, Judy, informs Bunty that they are meeting in the “loft” and that she will remain there “for a time,” though the duration is not explicitly mentioned. Therefore, the location is clearly identified as the loft at home, situated beyond other rooms where both characters are hiding. This setting implies that both are children using the loft as a refuge from the authority of the elders, and it is positioned somewhere within the house. Though locations such as Lawson, Springwood, and Katoomba are referenced, they merely serve as points of reference, indicating that the characters are far away from these locations while situated in the loft.

Event and Narratological Lens on Seven Little Australians

Judy queries the other character, Bunty, about her escape from a school located at a considerable distance. This inquiry further underscores the specific location as the “loft,” situated within the house building. The unfolding events in this place begin with Bunty hiding in the loft and contemplating other animate objects. The second event involves Judy’s arrival, followed by their conversation as the third event, and finally, the fourth event entails Bunty departing to fetch something for Judy to eat.

Apart from these two characters actively participating in the events, there are others who are absent physically but exert influence through their impact on both children. The first impact is subtle, evidenced by the sound Bunty makes after being frightened by something like a rat. The second involves clear names he exclaims, such as “Meg – oh! Father—Esther.” Another character, Miss Burtons, referred to by Judy, appears to be a teacher, suggesting that she might discover Judy’s truancy upon her return to school.

While Bunty exhibits a somewhat mischievous and playful nature, engaging in a game of hide and seek despite being frightened, Judy, too, demonstrates a degree of audacity. She confesses to playing truant from school and requests Bunty to bring her something to eat, indicating distinct and individualized characteristics for both characters.

Description and Narratological Lens on Seven Little Australians

As far as the description of the text is concerned, it has been applied by the external third person narrator as pointed out with “He.” It is his perspective about the characters that the readers would have. He makes the character to show the naughty, clever, terrifying or fearful side of their character and it is he who describes their traits with specific images. He states about Bunty when opening the text “He fancied…” which is an exact wording for a naughty boy and also states the location of the place as “second loft” and where it is located. This external narrator also makes the boy to say “Shoo” by which the narrator means the readers to understand that the boy is fearful of something and then makes the boy think that it is “rat” where the objective is clear that it is intended to show the reader. The argument here is to show how two naughty and clever children can plan to move away from the adult and authoritative world to hide their activities.

Narrator and Focalizer and Narratological Lens on Seven Little Australians

Whereas the narrator and the focalizer are concerned, they, too, have played an important role. The text uses the narrator and focalizer both at the same time as the third person narrator is also the focalizer. The main task of the narrator here in this passage is to describe and show how actors act and move the act forward. However, the focalizer, though, he is the same makes the readers think about the specific vision that he wants to show which is that children often play truant and that the readers should understand the specific perspective of the children. As both the perspectives are interspersed with dialogues, it becomes clear that focalizer and narrator shift the text to dialogue when it becomes necessary to show action of the agents/characters and are involved again when they want to show the specific perspective and aspect to the readers. This constant shift moves the text from one event of another building logic and chronology in the text to make it credible. In this way, the narrator /focalizer builds characters by first giving a vision to the readers what character is going to appear and then announcing through the dialogue of the character how he is going to act and how it is going to impact the act or the event. For example, third person narrator / focalizer here announces constantly within the text how Judy arrives and how she surprises Bunty when he is hiding in the loft as when she puts her hand “over his mouth.” The narrator could have stated that she has put her hand on her shoulders, but the focalizer wants to build readers’ vision that it is a moment of surprise and that Bunty could shriek out loud.

Conclusion: Narratological Lens on Seven Little Australians

By employing description followed by dialogue, the third-person narrator constructs the characters and then narrates events, progressing them chronologically to formulate a visual representation through focalization. This allows readers to perceive clever and mischievous children within a household, concealed in a loft, where they believe they can outsmart the adult world. This foreshadows potential challenges for these playful children. In the final description, the narrator captures Bunty’s emotions, hinting that he would go to fetch something to eat. This foreshadowing engages readers in anticipation, a result of the gradual progression of events.

Works Cited: Narratological Lens on Seven Little Australians
  1. Bal, Mieke. A Mieke Bal Reader. University of Chicago Press, 2006.
  2. Turner, Ethel. Seven Little Australians. National Library Australia, 2005.
Relevant Questions about Narratological Lens on Seven Little Australians
  1. How does the narratological lens, as applied to “Seven Little Australians,” enhance our understanding of the narrative structure, focalization, and the relationship between the narrator and characters?
  2. In the context of Meike Bal’s narratological framework, how does the narrative strategy in “Seven Little Australians” contribute to the construction of characters and events, and what impact does it have on the reader’s engagement with the story?
  3. Can the narratological analysis of “Seven Little Australians” shed light on the significance of the chosen narrative perspective, the representation of time and space, and the use of focalization in conveying the complexities of the plot and character development?

Future And Science Fiction

There is nothing more complicated and beautiful in the universe than the human brain which makes future and science fiction relevant.

Introduction: Future And Science Fiction

There is nothing more complicated and beautiful in the universe than the human brain which makes future and science fiction relevant. The human brain is the source of creation in the world. Our imaginations have no boundaries or limitations; we can think of the wildest concepts. Humans have been contemplating impossible things and sharing their dreams with each other. Such imaginations create a world beyond humans. This imagination has a profound impact on human actions. People always dream of creating things that could only be imagined in dreams. Some people are dreamers, and others are doers. Dreamers guide us to take actions, and doers achieve those dreams. This is the simple story of human civilization and innovation. These dreamers weave the fabric of stories, and the doers create new worlds by following the paths shown by those dreamers.

Inspiration: Future and Science Fiction

Exactly, that is why science fiction writers have always served as a profound source of inspiration for millions of people around the world. Many innovations that we now take for granted were once nothing but the wildest dreams in the minds of these visionary writers. These writers, essentially dreamers, play a crucial role in guiding scientists and innovators toward turning their fantastical ideas into reality. One notable example is the science fiction book titled ‘Old Man’s War,’ penned by American writer John Scalzi.

This captivating narrative envisions a world where old individuals regain their youth, and nanobots perform intricate surgeries on human bodies. In this imagined future, smart blood replaces natural blood in human veins. Communication has reached unprecedented speeds, facilitated by neural implants known as BrainPals, directly integrated into human brains. Through BrainPals, humans not only communicate amongst themselves but also engage in conversations with extraterrestrial beings from different parts of the universe.

The weaponry portrayed in the book has evolved to such an extent that it can dynamically adapt its shape according to the task at hand. The introduction of the Skip Drive has revolutionized transportation, enabling people to traverse the vast expanse of the universe without any delays. This captivating tale illustrates how the dreams of science fiction writers can shape our imaginations and, in turn, influence the path of scientific and technological advancements.

Conclusion: Future and Science Fiction

The depictions of advanced technologies and futuristic scenarios in ‘Old Man’s War’ may indeed appear ‘impossible’ within the scope of our current knowledge and technology. However, this apparent impossibility is not unfamiliar in the narrative of human history. Consider the era when people wrote about flying machines in science fiction. During the Victorian era, some of the foremost scientists in Europe and America staunchly believed, based on the prevailing knowledge and technology of their time, that creating a flying machine was an insurmountable challenge. Despite their skepticism, it was only a matter of time before the Wright brothers successfully invented the airplane in 1903. Today, the airplane is an integral part of our lives, demonstrating how seemingly impossible feats can become an indispensable reality with advancements in science and technology.

The evolution of human innovation and technological progress, as showcased in the contrast between the skepticism of the past and the realities of the present, underscores the dynamic nature of human achievement. The ‘impossible’ dreams envisioned by science fiction writers often serve as catalysts for pushing the boundaries of what is conceivable. While the narratives in ‘Old Man’s War’ may currently exceed our technological grasp, history has shown that our understanding and capabilities continually evolve, and what once seemed impossible may become an integral part of our future reality.

References: Future and Science Fiction
  1. Somers. J (2016, November 28). 7 Things You Might Not Know About John Scalzi’s Old Man’s War. Barnes and Nobel. Retrieved March 16, 2019, from https://www.barnesandnoble.com/blog/sci-fi-fantasy/7-things-you-might-not-know-about-john-scalzis-old-mans-war/
  2. Itzkoff, D (2006, December 24). Wars of the Worlds. New York Times. Retrieved March 16, 2019, from https://www.nytimes.com/2006/12/24/books/review/Itzkoff.t.html
Relevant Questions: Future and Science Fiction
  1. How has science fiction literature influenced technological advancements and innovations in the real world?
  2. What role does the exploration of futuristic scenarios in science fiction play in shaping societal attitudes towards emerging technologies?
  3. In what ways does the portrayal of the future in science fiction reflect or challenge contemporary social, political, and ethical concerns?

Critical Response to Digital Amnesia

This critical response to Digital Amnesia shows how archives are going to help future generations in exploring knowledge.Starting with the preservation of our memories, books, and other documents, “constantly being recorded for future references,” the documentary, “Digital Amnesia,” presents a solution wherein nearly all human knowledge ever recorded on Earth is being archived on digital media for future generations (Digital Amnesia).

Introduction: Critical Response to Digital Amnesia

This critical response to Digital Amnesia shows how archives are going to help future generations in exploring knowledge.Starting with the preservation of our memories, books, and other documents, “constantly being recorded for future references,” the documentary, “Digital Amnesia,” presents a solution wherein nearly all human knowledge ever recorded on Earth is being archived on digital media for future generations (Digital Amnesia). However, there is a challenge associated with this digitization—many robust hard drives and tools have a limited lifespan and eventually become obsolete. Alongside this challenge, the documentary introduces extensive solutions in the form of online books, websites, and cloud storage on the internet. The future of physical books and documents in the era of fast-track digitization may seem bleak, but simultaneously, digitization represents the future of knowledge for generations to come.

Knowledge in Critical Response to Digital Amnesia

When we consider the fate of physical knowledge treasures, it becomes evident that their relevance is diminishing in the face of the widespread availability of books and documents online. A poignant example is the government’s reluctance to support the Royal Topic Institute for document storage, showcasing a disheartening disregard for preserving tangible records (Digital Amnesia). Nevertheless, amidst such challenges, Brewster Kahle stands out as a beacon of hope with his ongoing efforts in digitization, as demonstrated in his archive. His commitment to the swift digitization of valuable knowledge serves as a promising contrast to governmental hesitations, highlighting the potential for digital preservation to bridge the gap left by traditional means.

Despite the challenges faced by ventures like Dennis Wingho’s struggles in preserving myriad NASA tapes, digitization emerges as a vital force for the future of knowledge. Dr. Ismail Serageldin’s initiative to transform the library of Alexandria into a knowledge hub represents a commendable effort to safeguard physical knowledge. While hurdles persist in various preservation endeavors, the overarching theme is that digitization is poised to be a transformative boon, ensuring that knowledge transcends physical limitations and remains accessible for generations to come (Digital Amnesia).

Risks of Digital Construction in Critical Response to Digital Amnesia

Despite the potential risks associated with digital destruction, individuals like Jason Scott and his dedicated archive team have achieved remarkable feats in preserving vast amounts of web pages, making them globally accessible. Their efforts not only combat the transient nature of digital information but also democratize access to a wealth of online content. Another champion of knowledge preservation is Alexander Rose of the Long Now, who has undertaken an arduous mission to safeguard materials that represent a comprehensive archive of human history. With a dedicated team engaged in scanning and preserving manuscripts and documents, Rose’s commitment reflects a profound understanding of the importance of cultural heritage.

The incorporation of innovative approaches, such as Rose’s peculiar time machine or clock, in “Digital Amnesia” symbolizes a creative solution to the challenges of digital preservation. The deliberate pacing of this unique time device mirrors the meticulous and deliberate approach required for the rapid preservation of digital data. Furthermore, the optimistic portrayal of Kahle’s statue room serves as a symbol of hope for those tirelessly engaged in the preservation of human knowledge. It stands as a testament to the ongoing endeavors of preservationists, emphasizing the importance of their work in ensuring that the treasure trove of human knowledge endures for the benefit of future generations.

Conclusion: Critical Response to Digital Amnesia

In short, “Digital Amnesia” elicits a critical response that reflects the complex interplay between the advancement of digital technologies and the preservation of human knowledge. While concerns about the transience of digital data and the potential risks of its destruction linger, the documentary spotlights unsung heroes like Jason Scott and Alexander Rose, who defy these challenges by tirelessly archiving and safeguarding valuable information. The juxtaposition of their efforts against the backdrop of governmental hesitations and funding refusals emphasizes the urgent need for a collective commitment to digital preservation.

The innovative strategies showcased, such as Alexander Rose’s unique time machine, underscore the importance of creative solutions in tackling the multifaceted issues surrounding knowledge retention. The documentary prompts viewers to reflect on the delicate balance between embracing digital advancements and ensuring the enduring accessibility of our collective history. As we witness the digital transformation of libraries and archives, “Digital Amnesia” serves as a wake-up call, urging society to collectively engage in the thoughtful curation and preservation of our evolving digital heritage. Ultimately, the critical response to the documentary underscores the significance of proactive measures and collaborative efforts in securing the longevity of human knowledge in the face of the ever-evolving digital landscape.

Works Cited: Critical Response to Digital Amnesia

Digital Amnesia. Dir. Bregtje van der Haak, Top Documentaries, 2014. https://topdocumentaryfilms.com/digital-amnesia/ Accessed 28 Mar. 20122.

Relevant Questions about Critical Response to Digital Amnesia
  1. How does the documentary “Digital Amnesia” by Bregtje van der Haak explore the societal implications of the digital age, particularly in terms of memory and the potential consequences of relying heavily on digital technologies for information storage?
  2. In response to “Digital Amnesia,” how have viewers and critics assessed the effectiveness of the documentary in raising awareness about the challenges posed by our increasing reliance on digital tools and the potential loss of collective memory? What specific aspects of the documentary’s presentation and argumentation have been particularly noteworthy?
  3. How has the critical reception to “Digital Amnesia” contributed to discussions surrounding digital literacy, data privacy, and the need for a balanced approach to technology use in the modern era? Have there been notable debates or shifts in public perception as a result of the issues highlighted in the documentary?

Confirmation Bias in Literature & Literary Theory

Confirmation bias is a cognitive phenomenon where individuals tend to favor information that reinforces their existing beliefs while avoiding or downplaying contradictory evidence.

Confirmation Bias: Etymology, Meanings, and Concept
Etymology/Term:

Confirmation bias, a term prevalent in psychology and cognitive science, describes the tendency of individuals to favor information that confirms their pre-existing beliefs or hypotheses. The term originated from the concept of selectively reinforcing one’s existing views, thereby “confirming” what one already believes.

Meanings and Concept:
  • Selective Perception: Individuals actively seek, interpret, and remember information that aligns with their existing beliefs, while disregarding or downplaying conflicting evidence.
  • Cognitive Shortcut: It serves as a mental shortcut or heuristic, allowing people to process information efficiently by relying on their pre-existing beliefs rather than critically evaluating each piece of evidence.
  • Influence on Decision-Making: It plays a significant role in decision-making, potentially leading to flawed judgments, reinforcing stereotypes, and hindering the acceptance of new information that challenges established beliefs.
  • Psychological Comfort: It offers a sense of psychological comfort by validating existing opinions, contributing to the maintenance of a person’s cognitive and emotional equilibrium.
  • Impact on Objectivity: The bias can distort objectivity, impeding the ability to assess situations impartially and fostering a closed-minded approach to information.

Understanding it is crucial in various fields, from psychology and sociology to decision science, as it sheds light on the ways individuals process information, make decisions, and navigate their cognitive landscapes.

Confirmation Bias: Definition of a Theoretical Term

Confirmation bias is a cognitive phenomenon where individuals tend to favor information that reinforces their existing beliefs while avoiding or downplaying contradictory evidence. This bias can lead to selective perception, where people actively seek and interpret information in a way that aligns with their preconceived notions. It has significant implications for decision-making, potentially distorting objectivity and hindering the acceptance of diverse perspectives or conflicting data.

Confirmation Bias: Theorists, Works and Argument
Theorists:
  • Leon Festinger: In his theory of cognitive dissonance, Festinger highlighted bias as a mechanism to reduce discomfort by seeking information that aligns with existing beliefs.
  • Peter Wason: Known for his work on the psychology of reasoning, Wason’s research on bias explored how individuals tend to selectively process information to confirm their hypotheses.
  • Raymond Nickerson: Contributed extensively to the study of cognitive biases, including bias, emphasizing its role in shaping decision-making and information processing.
Key Works:
  1. A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance by Leon Festinger (1957): Festinger’s seminal work introduces bias as a component of cognitive dissonance theory, illustrating how individuals strive to maintain consistency in their beliefs.
  2. Reasoning and the Explanation of Actions by Peter Wason (1968): Wason’s research in this work explores bias within the context of reasoning, shedding light on the mechanisms behind biased information processing.
  3. Confirmation Bias: A Ubiquitous Phenomenon in Many Guises by Raymond Nickerson (1998): Nickerson’s comprehensive review delves into various manifestations of bias across different domains, emphasizing its pervasive nature.
Argument:

Confirmation bias, as explored by these theorists, is rooted in the human tendency to seek information that aligns with pre-existing beliefs while avoiding contradictory evidence. Festinger’s cognitive dissonance theory suggests that individuals are motivated to maintain internal consistency, leading to biased information processing. Wason and Nickerson contribute insights into the cognitive mechanisms and contexts that drive confirmation bias, highlighting its ubiquitous presence in decision-making and reasoning processes.

Major Characteristics of Confirmation Bias:
  1. Selective Perception: Individuals tend to actively seek, perceive, and remember information that confirms their existing beliefs while ignoring or downplaying contradictory evidence.
  2. Cognitive Shortcut: It serves as a mental shortcut, allowing individuals to process information efficiently by relying on their pre-existing beliefs rather than critically evaluating each piece of evidence.
  3. Influence on Decision-Making: It significantly affects decision-making processes, leading to biased judgments, reinforcing stereotypes, and hindering the acceptance of new information that challenges established beliefs.
  4. Psychological Comfort: It provides a sense of psychological comfort by validating existing opinions, contributing to the maintenance of a person’s cognitive and emotional equilibrium.
  5. Impact on Objectivity: The bias can distort objectivity, impeding the ability to assess situations impartially and fostering a closed-minded approach to information.
Literary Examples:
  1. “To Kill a Mockingbird” by Harper Lee: It is evident in the racial prejudices of the characters, such as the biased perceptions of Tom Robinson’s guilt due to ingrained societal beliefs.
  2. “1984” by George Orwell: It is reflected in the citizens’ acceptance of the Party’s propaganda, as they selectively perceive information that aligns with the regime’s narrative while disregarding dissenting views.
  3. “The Crucible” by Arthur Miller: It is portrayed in the Salem witch trials, where characters selectively interpret events to confirm their preconceived notions about witchcraft and religious purity.
  4. “Fahrenheit 451” by Ray Bradbury: The novel explores confirmation bias through the suppression of dissenting ideas, as individuals willingly conform to a society that reinforces their existing beliefs and rejects opposing viewpoints.
  5. “The Lord of the Flies” by William Golding: It is evident in the group dynamics, where characters succumb to preconceived notions about each other, leading to conflict and violence based on biased perceptions.
Confirmation Bias: Relevance in Literary Theories
Literary TheoryRelevance to Confirmation Bias
Psychoanalytic Theory:Examines how confirmation bias can be rooted in the unconscious mind, influencing characters’ perceptions and actions based on repressed desires, fears, or unresolved conflicts.
Marxist Criticism:Analyzes how confirmation bias can perpetuate social hierarchies and reinforce class distinctions, influencing characters’ perceptions of power dynamics and justifying existing societal structures.
Feminist Criticism:Explores how confirmation bias may contribute to the perpetuation of gender stereotypes and the marginalization of certain voices, impacting characters’ attitudes towards gender roles and relationships.
Postcolonialism:Investigates how confirmation bias can shape characters’ perceptions of the “other,” reinforcing colonial ideologies and influencing narratives that perpetuate stereotypes about colonized or marginalized groups.
Reader-Response Theory:Examines how readers’ confirmation biases may influence their interpretations of a text, affecting their understanding of characters, themes, and the overall meaning of the narrative.

Confirmation bias is relevant across various literary theories, impacting characters’ perspectives, narrative dynamics, and reader interpretations. Each theory provides a unique lens through which to analyze how confirmation bias operates within literary works and their broader cultural contexts.

Confirmation Bias: Application in Critiques
  1. To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee:
    • Analysis: In the novel, the confirmation bias is evident in the prejudiced attitudes of characters, particularly during Tom Robinson’s trial. Characters selectively perceive evidence that aligns with their racial biases, confirming their existing beliefs about the racial hierarchy in the society depicted.
  2. 1984 by George Orwell:
    • Analysis: Orwell’s novel explores confirmation bias through the citizens’ acceptance of the Party’s propaganda. The characters selectively perceive information that aligns with the regime’s narrative, confirming their loyalty to the Party and disregarding dissenting views as misinformation.
  3. The Crucible by Arthur Miller:
    • Analysis: Miller’s play delves into confirmation bias during the Salem witch trials, where characters selectively interpret events to confirm their preconceived notions about witchcraft. The confirmation bias leads to a collective hysteria based on biased perceptions and societal pressures.
  4. Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury:
    • Analysis: Bradbury’s novel explores confirmation bias in a dystopian society where individuals willingly conform to a regime that reinforces their existing beliefs. The characters selectively perceive information that aligns with the government’s narrative, confirming their conformity to a censored and controlled worldview.

In each of these literary works, bias becomes a thematic element, shaping characters’ perceptions, influencing societal dynamics, and contributing to the conflicts depicted in the narratives. The critique of these works can involve an analysis of how confirmation bias operates within the context of the story, affecting character development and overarching themes.

Confirmation Bias: Relevant Terms
Theoretical TermBrief Literary Critique Relevance
1. Cognitive Dissonance:Explores characters’ internal conflicts.
2. Herd Mentality:Influences societal pressures and character dynamics.
3. Selective Exposure:Shapes characters’ perspectives and plot developments.
4. In-Group Bias:Affects character alliances and conflicts.
5. Illusory Correlation:Impacts character judgments based on false connections.
6. Groupthink:Drives collective decision-making and plot developments.
7. Stereotyping:Influences character interactions and societal representations.
8. Authority Bias:Shapes characters’ obedience and narrative power dynamics.
9. False Consensus Effect:Influences character perceptions in social dynamics.
10. Belief Perseverance:Contributes to characters clinging to initial beliefs.
Confirmation Bias: Suggested Readings
  1. Festinger, Leon. A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance. Stanford UP, 1957.
  2. Gilovich, Thomas, Dale Griffin, and Daniel Kahneman, editors. Heuristics and Biases: The Psychology of Intuitive Judgment. Cambridge UP, 2002.
  3. Nickerson, Raymond S. Confirmation Bias: A Ubiquitous Phenomenon in Many Guises. Review of General Psychology, vol. 2, no. 2, 1998, pp. 175–220.
  4. Sunstein, Cass R., and Reid Hastie. Wiser: Getting Beyond Groupthink to Make Groups Smarter. Harvard UP, 2015.
  5. Tavris, Carol, and Elliot Aronson. Mistakes Were Made (But Not by Me): Why We Justify Foolish Beliefs, Bad Decisions, and Hurtful Acts. Mariner Books, 2008.
  6. Thaler, Richard H., and Cass R. Sunstein. Nudge: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth, and Happiness. Penguin Books, 2009.
  7. West, Richard F., and T. D. Brown. Theory of Addiction. Wiley, 2013.

Anti-intentionalism in Literature & Literary Theory

Anti-intentionalism is a theoretical term that challenges the notion that the author’s intentions are essential for understanding the meaning of a work of art or literature.

Introduction: Anti-intentionalism

Anti-intentionalism is a philosophical position that challenges the idea that the meaning or interpretation of a work of art or literature is dependent on the author’s intentions. Instead, anti-intentionalists argue that the meaning of a work of art or literature is independent of the author’s intentions and can be derived solely from the work itself and the way it is received by its audience.

This position emerged in the mid-twentieth century as a response to the dominant view that the author’s intentions were crucial for determining the meaning of a work. Anti-intentionalism has been influential in literary theory, art criticism, and aesthetics, and has led to debates about the nature of interpretation, the role of the author, and the relationship between art and society.

Etymology and Meanings of Anti-intentionalism

The term “anti-intentionalism” derives from the prefix “anti-“ which connotes opposition or contradiction, and the word “intentionalism,” which denotes the belief that the author’s intentions constitute a crucial element for the comprehension of a work of art or literature.

The roots of anti-intentionalism is traced back to the works of literary theorists such as W.K. Wimsatt and Monroe Beardsley, who, in their seminal essay “The Intentional Fallacy,” posited the argument that the author’s intentions should not be regarded when interpreting a literary text.

This perspective challenged the prevailing New Criticism approach that privileged authorial intention. Since then, anti-intentionalism has emerged as a significant school of thought in literary theory, influencing the manner in which scholars approach the study of literature and other forms of art.

Meanings of Anti-intentionalism
AspectMeanings
Rejection of Authorial IntentAuthorial intentions are not the primary source of a text’s meaning; they may be inaccessible or irrelevant.
Focus on Reader ResponseMeaning is constructed through diverse reader perspectives and interactions with the text, not authorial intent.
Text-Centered AnalysisMeaning is derived from the text itself, focusing on its features, language, and structure, rather than authorial biography.
Openness to Multiple InterpretationsRecognizes the existence of multiple valid interpretations due to diverse reader backgrounds and contexts.
Historical and Cultural ContextConsiders the text’s historical and cultural context but doesn’t limit meaning to the author’s specific context or intent.
Challenges Authorial AuthorityQuestions the author’s ultimate authority over a work’s meaning, promoting a more inclusive approach to interpretation.
Definition of Anti-intentionalism as a Theoretical Term

Anti-intentionalism is a theoretical term that challenges the notion that the author’s intentions are essential for understanding the meaning of a work of art or literature. According to this perspective, the meaning of a work is determined by its inherent qualities and how it is perceived by the audience, rather than the author’s intentions. Anti-intentionalism has played a significant role in literary theory, art criticism, and aesthetics, leading to debates about the nature of interpretation and the relationship between art and society.

Anti-Intentionalism: Theorists, Works and Arguments
Theorists:
  • Roland Barthes:
    • Notable Work: “Death of the Author”
    • Argument: Barthes argues that the author’s intentions are irrelevant and that the focus should shift to the reader’s interpretation. He advocates for the idea that texts are created by readers as they engage with the text, rather than being dictated by the author’s intent.
  • Wolfgang Iser:
    • Notable Work: “The Act of Reading: A Theory of Aesthetic Response”
    • Argument: Iser emphasizes the role of the reader in shaping a text’s meaning. He suggests that the text’s gaps and ambiguities invite readers to actively participate in constructing meaning.
  • Hans Robert Jauss:
    • Notable Work: “Literary History as a Challenge to Literary Theory”
    • Argument: Jauss proposes that the meaning of a text evolves over time as it encounters new readers and cultural contexts. He underscores the dynamic nature of interpretation and the influence of historical and cultural factors.
Notable Works:
  • “Death of the Author” by Roland Barthes:
    • Argument: Barthes challenges the traditional authority of the author in determining a text’s meaning and argues that the text should be detached from the author’s intentions. He promotes the idea that readers should play a central role in interpretation.
  • “The Act of Reading: A Theory of Aesthetic Response” by Wolfgang Iser:
    • Argument: Iser explores the concept of the implied reader, suggesting that the text invites readers to fill in gaps and actively participate in shaping the meaning. He contends that meaning is co-created by the text and the reader.
  • “Literary History as a Challenge to Literary Theory” by Hans Robert Jauss:
    • Argument: Jauss presents the idea that meaning is not fixed but evolves over time as texts encounter different historical and cultural contexts. He highlights the significance of the reader’s historical perspective in interpretation.
Common Arguments:
  • Anti-intentionalism asserts that the author’s intentions are often inaccessible or irrelevant, and the focus should shift to the reader’s response and interpretation.
  • It promotes the idea that meaning is not fixed but subject to change based on historical, cultural, and individual factors.
  • Anti-intentionalism challenges the traditional notion of the author as the sole authority on a work’s meaning, advocating for a more democratic and inclusive approach to interpretation.
Anti-intentionalism in Literary Theories

Anti-intentionalism has been influential in various literary theories, leading to new approaches to the study of literature. Here are some examples of how anti-intentionalism has been used in different literary theories:

  1. New Criticism: Anti-intentionalism emerged as a challenge to the New Criticism movement, which emphasized close reading and the importance of authorial intention. Scholars such as W.K. Wimsatt and Monroe Beardsley argued that the author’s intentions should not be considered when interpreting a literary text, and that the meaning of a work should be derived solely from the text itself.
  2. Reader-response theory: Anti-intentionalism has been influential in the development of reader-response theory, which emphasizes the role of the reader in interpreting a literary text. This perspective holds that the meaning of a work is not fixed or predetermined, but rather emerges from the interaction between the text and the reader.
  3. Deconstruction: Anti-intentionalism has played a significant role in deconstruction, a literary theory that emphasizes the instability and ambiguity of meaning. Deconstructionists argue that the meaning of a work cannot be fixed by the author’s intentions, but rather is constantly shifting and open to interpretation.
  4. Postmodernism: Anti-intentionalism has been a key element of postmodern literary theory, which emphasizes the fragmentation and multiplicity of meaning. Postmodernists argue that the meaning of a work is not determined by the author’s intentions, but rather is influenced by the social, historical, and cultural contexts in which it is produced and received.
Anti-Intentionalism and Literary Criticism
WorkCritique
Moby-Dick by Herman MelvilleCritique: From an anti-intentionalist perspective, the richness of Moby-Dick‘s symbolism and metaphors takes center stage. Melville’s personal intentions might be elusive, but the novel invites readers to explore the depths of human obsession, the unknown, and the complexities of the human condition. Readers’ interpretations contribute to the meaning of the text, making it a collaborative venture between the author’s text and the reader’s response.
The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. SalingerCritique: In The Catcher in the Rye, Salinger’s intentions and personal life have been subjects of much speculation, but anti-intentionalism allows us to focus on how readers connect with the character of Holden Caulfield. The novel’s resonance lies in readers’ individual experiences, making it a story that speaks to various generations without relying solely on authorial intent.
The Lord of the Rings by J.R.R. TolkienCritique: Anti-intentionalism helps us appreciate how Tolkien’s epic is open to diverse interpretations. The richness of Middle-earth and its characters is not confined by Tolkien’s original intentions but rather grows through readers’ engagement. The author’s biography and intent matter less than the collective contributions of readers in building the world of Tolkien.
Ulysses by James JoyceCritique: Ulysses is a complex and multilayered work that often defies a single, fixed interpretation. Anti-intentionalism allows readers to approach the novel as a puzzle to be collectively solved. Joyce’s intricate wordplay and stream of consciousness style offer myriad entry points for readers to connect with the text, transcending the need for a definitive authorial intent.
Suggested Readings
  1. Barthes, Roland. Image, Music, Text. Translated by Stephen Heath, Hill and Wang, 1977.
  2. Barthes, Roland. The Death of the Author. In Image, Music, Text, translated by Stephen Heath, Hill and Wang, 1977, pp. 142-148.
  3. Iser, Wolfgang. The Act of Reading: A Theory of Aesthetic Response. Johns Hopkins University Press, 1978.
  4. Jauss, Hans Robert. Literary History as a Challenge to Literary Theory. University of Minnesota Press, 1982.
  5. Johnson, Barbara. The Critical Difference: Essays in the Contemporary Rhetoric of Reading. Johns Hopkins University Press, 1980.
  6. Joyce, James. Ulysses. Oxford University Press, 2008.
  7. Melville, Herman. Moby-Dick. Norton & Company, 2001.
  8. Salinger, J.D. The Catcher in the Rye. Little, Brown and Company, 1951.
  9. Tolkien, J.R.R. The Lord of the Rings. Houghton Mifflin, 2005.

Lulu’s Indianness in Love Medicine

Despite facing various criticisms from society, including being labeled “a flirt” with “tongues less kind” (105), Lulu Lamartine engages with males through various indigenous Indian practices, highlighting Lulu’s Indianness.

Introduction: Lulu’s Indianness

Despite facing various criticisms from society, including being labeled “a flirt” with “tongues less kind” (105), Lulu Lamartine engages with males through various indigenous Indian practices, highlighting Lulu’s Indianness. She articulates her connection by stating, “I was in love with the whole world,” (272), revealing the underlying passion behind her perceived or actual promiscuity. While her actions invite gossip and commentary, Lulu’s feminine power does not reside solely in her supposed promiscuity or affectionate nature. Instead, it lies in her ability to remain unapologetic, never shedding a tear or feeling remorse for her choices (273). This resilience not only reassures herself but also those around her, including her various lovers and her eight sons who are described as “of one soul” (114) with her.

Lulu Lamartine also demonstrates wisdom in choosing between Bev and Henry when they first meet. Her central role in the lives of different characters highlights her multidimensional Indianness. Lulu not only provides essential love medicine to various Indians, showcasing her traditional Indian femininity and empowerment, but she also endeavors to mend connections, especially in her relationships with Bev and Lipsha Morrissey.

Embodiment of Love: Lulu’s Indianness

In matters of love, Lulu Lamartine appears as an embodiment of affection, seeking not only love for herself but also generously showering it on others. She boldly states in her narrative, “I was in love with the whole world” (272), expressing her love for nature and men alike. Lulu’s hunger for love traces back to her childhood when she couldn’t win Nector. This love manifests in ways that attract men, provide them comfort, foster reconnections, and offer healing.

Facing heartbreak with Nector Kashpaw, her “first love” (273), Lulu redirects her affection toward Moses Pillager. She again demonstrates her love by marrying Henry, a strategic move evident in her card game interactions with both brothers (112). Lulu’s subtle gestures, described as “subtle magnets” (113), draw Bev towards her, causing him to forget his mission and enter her bedroom—the “sacred domain of her femininity” (116). Bev remains unaware that he has deviated from his diplomatic mission, showcasing Lulu’s ability to redirect love in a uniquely Indian way, pursuing it through alternative paths.

Lulu’s pursuit of love, despite becoming the talk of the town, reflects her pragmatic approach. In choosing her husbands, she pragmatically seeks love for her survival, marrying one after the other. This decision highlights her courage in dealing with the complexities of love and relationships, showcasing a specific Indian trait of adapting and pursuing love through various avenues.

Courage of Lulu’s Indianness

In matters of courage, Lulu Lamartine exhibits an Indian courage of femininity, evident in her approach to love and her healing touch extended to others. This courage becomes apparent in her interaction with Bev, where she provides a healing touch that almost causes him to forget his mission. Bev, visiting to bring his son, is drawn into her love, automatically entering her bedroom and momentarily setting aside his initial purpose (113). This showcases Lulu’s unique Indian courage in matters of love.

The boldness of Lulu’s femininity is further emphasized when discussing her decisions about marrying the brothers. Bev is taken aback to learn that it was Lulu who decided which brother to marry, a choice considered “bold even for Lulu” (111). This boldness is observed again in her interactions with the boys, where her love is mixed with respect and obedience, as Bev notices that “the younger boys obey her perfectly” (114).

Lulu’s femininity also serves as a healing touch for Lipsha Morrissey, who is unaware of his real mother. When Lulu reveals this truth to him, Lipsha expresses newfound respect and understanding, stating, “I’ll respect her from now on” (299). Lulu’s courageous act not only brings clarity to Lipsha but also provides him with a healing touch, addressing his long-standing ignorance about his true parentage. This bold move reflects Lulu’s courage and unique Indian femininity, leading Lipsha to believe in her “near-divine healing touch” (299), emphasizing the transformative impact of her actions on those she encounters.

Relationships of Lulu’s Indianness

In her relationships with both Bev and Lipsha, Lulu Lamartine serves as a crucial link, facilitating their reconnection with their families and Indian roots. These connections act as healing touches, rekindling family bonds and providing a sense of belonging.

With Bev, Lulu’s presence becomes a source of reconnection, evident when Ben senses a “sweet apprehension of their kinship” upon entering her embrace (114). Despite Bev initially having plans to take his son elsewhere, Lulu’s influence shifts his priorities, leading to a reconnection with his family and nephews. The unity among Lulu and her sons becomes apparent as Bev observes them working together, bound in total loyalty, resembling their youthful period (114). This tradition of reconnection, deeply embedded in Indian femininity, resonates with Bev, who appreciates the strength that binds them together.

Lipsha Morrissey, upon learning about his true parents from Lulu, begins to believe in her near-divine healing touch. He expresses admiration for her perceived power, akin to another lady, Germain, stating, “If she had some kind of power, I wasn’t one to doubt” (299). Lulu’s revelation becomes a powerful force in Lipsha’s life, fostering a reconnection with his family and heritage.

Bev recognizes the strong familial bonds formed by Lulu, acknowledging the interconnectedness of siblings in the same way. Though he doesn’t explicitly mention the femininity that holds them together, it’s implied and appreciated. Both Bev and Lipsha, in their own ways, come to appreciate and understand the deep sense of reconnection that Lulu’s Indian femininity brings to their lives and families.

Conclusion: Lulu’s Indianness

In short, Lulu Nanapush embodies pure Indian character, showcasing her Indianness through expressions of love, attraction, assertion of femininity, and the profound act of reconnecting Indians to their roots. Her love extends to both men and women, evident in her devotion to Nector and later Moses when Nector departs. Despite facing societal criticism, she provides loving comfort to each of her husbands, fostering a sense of unity and familial love among her siblings.

Lulu’s feminine power, often misconstrued as flirtation, serves as a magnetic force, attracting men and patriarchal figures toward her. This power unites Indian males, offering a deeper understanding of family and roots. Lulu’s actions, particularly in dealing with Bev and Lipsha, demonstrate her ability to reconnect individuals with their families, a profound act of restoring lost connections and Indianness. This act proves to be a healing touch for those she reconnects, as seen in Bev’s nostalgic feelings and Lipsha’s gratitude. Lulu Nanapush emerges as a central figure around whom the entire Indian culture revolves, providing it with the necessary subtlety, resilience, and survival power to navigate the challenges posed by the deracination of modern US culture. In her love, strength, and ability to reconnect, Lulu becomes a powerful force in preserving and revitalizing the essence of Indian heritage.

Works Cited: Lulu’s Indianness

Erdrich, Louise. “Love Medicine. 1984.” New and Expanded Version. New York: Holt, 1993.

Relevant Questions about Lulu’s Indianness
  1. How does Lulu Nanapush’s expression of love and her relationships with various men in “Love Medicine” reflect and contribute to her distinct Indianness?
  2. In what ways does Lulu Nanapush’s assertion of femininity, often misunderstood as flirtation, play a crucial role in shaping her relationships and connecting her with other characters in the novel?
  3. How does Lulu Nanapush serve as a symbolic figure in “Love Medicine,” playing a central role in reconnecting characters like Bev and Lipsha to their families and cultural roots, and what does this reveal about her embodiment of Indianness?