“The Girl Who Got Rattled” by Stewart Edward White: A Critical Analysis

“The Girl Who Got Rattled” by Stewart Edward White was first published in 1915 in the collection “The Camp-Fire” and has since become a classic of American literature.

"The Girl Who Got Rattled" by Stewart Edward White: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “The Girl Who Got Rattled” by Stewart Edward White

“The Girl Who Got Rattled” by Stewart Edward White was first published in 1915 in the collection “The Camp-Fire” and has since become a classic of American literature. This short story showcases White’s exceptional storytelling skills, as it masterfully weaves together elements of adventure, romance, and humor. The tale follows a young woman’s journey through the American West, where she faces various challenges and learns valuable lessons about resilience, courage, and the importance of staying true to oneself. The story’s good qualities include its vivid descriptions of the natural landscape, its well-developed characters, and its ability to evoke a sense of nostalgia for the pioneering spirit of the American West. Overall, “The Girl Who Got Rattled” is a captivating and inspiring tale that continues to delight readers to this day.

Main Events in “The Girl Who Got Rattled” by Stewart Edward White
EventDetails
Introduction of Alfred– Alfred, a bashful and diminutive man, is described as an exceptional scout and fighter, despite his shyness around women.
Caldwell’s Journey to Deadwood– Caldwell, accompanied by his daughter and fiancé, sets out for Deadwood. Alfred and Billy Knapp join as guides.
Alfred’s discomfort with Allen– Alfred feels uncomfortable around Allen and Miss Caldwell, who tease him.
Challenges of the journey– The journey starts exciting but becomes monotonous and uncomfortable over time. Miss Caldwell becomes impatient.
Miss Caldwell’s desire for freedom– Miss Caldwell longs for solitude and freedom from the constraints of the wagon-train.
Miss Caldwell’s impulsive decision– Miss Caldwell decides to ride out with Allen for a race, ignoring Alfred’s warnings.
Alfred’s discovery of danger– Alfred notices signs of approaching danger, including hoof prints and a blue bead, indicating the presence of Sioux Indians.
Alfred’s decision to protect– Alfred resolves to find Miss Caldwell after she rides off alone and warns the others of the danger.
Confrontation with the Sioux– Alfred finds Miss Caldwell and prepares for a confrontation with Sioux warriors.
Alfred’s plan to defend– Alfred explains his plan to Miss Caldwell, including using their last bullets to avoid capture if necessary.
The Sioux attack– The Sioux warriors charge towards Alfred and Miss Caldwell, firing their guns and yelling.
Alfred’s strategy to deter– Alfred holds his fire until the last moment, causing the Sioux warriors to hesitate and veer away.
Tragic outcome– Miss Caldwell, mistaking Alfred’s fall for his capture, shoots herself to avoid capture by the Sioux.
Alfred’s reaction to the tragedy– Alfred is devastated by Miss Caldwell’s death and blames himself for not being able to protect her.
Resolution– Alfred retaliates against the Sioux, killing several before the wagon-train arrives, ending the confrontation.
Literary Devices in “The Girl Who Got Rattled” by Stewart Edward White
Literary DeviceExampleExplanation
1. Characterization“Alfred was a little man, and he was bashful.”Through characterization, the author describes Alfred as a shy and diminutive individual, providing insight into his personality traits.
2. ForeshadowingAlfred notices signs of approaching danger, including hoof prints and a blue bead, indicating the presence of Sioux Indians.Foreshadowing hints at future events, building tension and anticipation in the story. In this case, it suggests imminent danger and conflict with the Sioux warriors.
3. IronyMiss Caldwell expresses a longing for freedom from the wagon-train’s confines, yet her impulsive decision leads to danger.Irony occurs when there is a contrast between what is expected and what actually happens. Miss Caldwell’s desire for freedom ironically leads to a perilous situation.
4. SymbolismThe prairie-dog town symbolizes both a place of refuge and danger, where Miss Caldwell finds herself before the Sioux attack.Symbolism is the use of symbols to represent ideas or concepts. The prairie-dog town represents both safety and peril, reflecting the dual nature of the setting.
5. Imagery“The breeze and the sun played with the prairie grasses…”Imagery creates vivid mental images through descriptive language, appealing to the senses of the reader and enhancing the atmosphere of the scene.
6. AllusionAlfred’s reference to “old Lone Pine” hints at his familiarity with the region and its inhabitants.Allusion is a brief and indirect reference to a person, place, thing, or idea of historical, cultural, literary, or political significance.
7. ConflictAlfred confronts the conflict between his shyness and his duty to protect Miss Caldwell from danger.Conflict is a literary element that involves a struggle between opposing forces, driving the narrative forward and adding tension to the story.
8. SuspenseAlfred’s discovery of danger and his subsequent search for Miss Caldwell create suspense as the reader anticipates the outcome.Suspense is the intense feeling of anticipation or excitement that keeps readers engaged and eager to know what will happen next in the story.
9. Metaphor“The whole band swoops and divides, like a flock of swift-winged terns on a windy day.”A metaphor is a figure of speech that compares two unlike things by stating that one thing is another. This metaphor compares the movement of the Sioux warriors to birds in flight.
10. DialogueConversations between characters, such as Alfred’s interaction with Miss Caldwell and the Sioux warriors.Dialogue is the conversation between characters in a literary work, providing insight into their personalities, motivations, and relationships.
11. FlashbackAlfred remembers past experiences and skills as he prepares to confront the Sioux warriors.A flashback is a literary device that interrupts the chronological order of a narrative to provide information about events that occurred earlier in time.
12. MoodThe tense and apprehensive mood created by Alfred’s discovery of danger and the impending confrontation with the Sioux.Mood is the atmosphere or feeling created by a literary work, influencing the reader’s emotional response and perception of the story’s events.
13. Simile“Each Indian pops away for general results as he comes jumping along, and yells shrilly to show what a big warrior he is…”A simile is a figure of speech that compares two unlike things using “like” or “as.” This simile compares the Sioux warriors’ actions to popping and jumping along.
14. ThemeThemes of bravery, sacrifice, and the unpredictability of life emerge as Alfred and Miss Caldwell face danger on the prairie.Theme is the central idea or message conveyed by a literary work, reflecting universal truths or insights into the human experience.
15. Personification“The ponies came skipping here and there, nimbly dodging in and out between the dog-holes.”Personification attributes human qualities or characteristics to non-human entities, enhancing the description and creating a vivid image.
16. ToneThe tone shifts from lightheartedness to tension and apprehension as the story progresses towards the confrontation with the Sioux.Tone is the attitude of the author towards the subject matter or audience, influencing the overall mood and interpretation of the story.
17. MotifMotifs of courage, survival, and the wilderness recur throughout the story, reinforcing its themes and central conflicts.A motif is a recurring element or pattern in a literary work that contributes to its overall structure, symbolism, or thematic development.
18. Hyperbole“The air is throbbing with sound.”Hyperbole is an exaggeration or overstatement used for emphasis or effect, intensifying the sensory experience described in the narrative.
19. EpiphanyAlfred experiences a moment of self-realization and determination as he prepares to confront the Sioux warriors.An epiphany is a sudden realization or insight experienced by a character, leading to a significant change in their perspective, beliefs, or actions.
20. ParallelismAlfred’s skills as a scout and fighter parallel his inner conflict between shyness and duty, highlighting his resilience and bravery.Parallelism is the use of similar grammatical structures, phrases, or ideas to create balance and rhythm in writing, emphasizing important themes or contrasts.
Characterization in “The Girl Who Got Rattled” by Stewart Edward White
Major Characters:
  • Alfred: Alfred is a diminutive and bashful man, often underestimated due to his small stature and shy demeanor. Despite his outward appearance, he possesses remarkable skills as a scout and fighter, capable of reading the prairie like a book and handling himself adeptly in challenging situations. His innate courtesy and diffidence sometimes hinder his assertiveness, particularly in the presence of women, but his resourcefulness and courage shine through when the situation demands it.
  • Miss Caldwell: Miss Caldwell exudes a determined and adventurous spirit, eager to embrace the thrill of “roughing it” in the journey to Deadwood. Her enthusiasm for outdoor life contrasts with her refined upbringing, showcasing her willingness to challenge societal norms and seek excitement beyond the comforts of civilization. While initially carefree and spirited, her experiences on the journey test her resilience and reveal deeper layers of her character.
Minor Characters:
  • Allen: Allen epitomizes the archetype of the laid-back and somewhat careless young man, who, while enjoying the adventure of the journey, often disregards the feelings and sensitivities of others. His teasing and impertinent behavior towards Alfred and Miss Caldwell highlight his lack of consideration for their perspectives, adding tension to their interactions within the group.
  • Billy Knapp: Billy Knapp emerges as a steadfast and pragmatic figure, characterized by his imperturbable demeanor and authoritative presence. As a companion to Alfred, he shares responsibility for maintaining order and discipline within the group, albeit with a certain rigidity that occasionally clashes with the desires of the other travelers. His role as a guide and protector underscores his commitment to ensuring the safety of the expedition.
  • Caldwell Senior: Caldwell Senior embodies the role of the indulgent and supportive patriarch, accompanying his daughter on the journey to Deadwood to fulfill her desire for adventure. Despite his affluence and status, he displays a down-to-earth demeanor and genuine concern for the well-being of his fellow travelers, fostering a sense of camaraderie within the group.
  • Sioux Warriors: The Sioux warriors symbolize the formidable challenges encountered during the journey, their presence evoking a sense of danger and uncertainty. As antagonists to the protagonists, they represent the looming threat of conflict and violence in the untamed frontier, heightening the stakes and driving the narrative towards its climax.
Major Themes in “The Girl Who Got Rattled” by Stewart Edward White
  • Theme 1: The Dangers of Underestimating Others
    Alfred, the diminutive scout, is often underestimated by others due to his small stature and bashful nature. However, he proves himself to be a skilled and brave scout, able to read the prairie like a book and fight when necessary. This theme is exemplified when Alfred surprises Allen and Miss Caldwell with his sudden assertiveness and expertise in handling the situation with the Sioux warriors.
  • Theme 2: The Importance of Experience and Knowledge
    The story highlights the importance of experience and knowledge in navigating challenging situations. Alfred’s expertise as a scout and his understanding of the prairie and its dangers prove invaluable in keeping Miss Caldwell safe. In contrast, Allen’s inexperience and overconfidence nearly lead to disaster. This theme is illustrated when Alfred recognizes the signs of Sioux warriors and takes decisive action, while Allen is oblivious to the danger.
  • Theme 3: The Power Dynamics of Gender Roles
    The story touches on the power dynamics of gender roles, particularly in the relationship between Miss Caldwell and Alfred. Miss Caldwell, as a woman, is expected to be helpless and in need of protection, while Alfred, as a man, is expected to be strong and assertive. However, Alfred’s bashful nature and Miss Caldwell’s independence challenge these expectations. This theme is evident when Miss Caldwell defies convention by riding off alone and Alfred surprises her with his assertiveness in handling the situation with the Sioux warriors.
  • Theme 4: The Clash of Cultures
    The story explores the clash of cultures between the white settlers and the Native American Sioux warriors. The tension between the two groups is palpable, and Alfred’s knowledge of the prairie and its dangers serves as a bridge between the two cultures. This theme is exemplified in the standoff between Alfred, Miss Caldwell, and the Sioux warriors, highlighting the misunderstandings and mistrust that can arise from cultural differences.
Writing Style in “The Girl Who Got Rattled” by Stewart Edward White
  • Descriptive Language:
    • Example: “Alfred could read the prairie like a book.”
    • Explanation: White employs vivid and evocative descriptions to paint a picture of the Western landscape and its inhabitants, allowing readers to immerse themselves in the setting and atmosphere of the story.
  • Dialogue:
    • Example: “Miss Caldwell was determined to go to Deadwood.”
    • Explanation: The dialogue in the story is natural and colloquial, reflecting the speech patterns and personalities of the characters. It provides insight into their thoughts, motivations, and interactions, driving the plot forward and enriching character development.
  • Narrative Perspective:
    • Example: “Alfred arose deliberately for a better look.”
    • Explanation: The narrative is primarily third-person limited, following the perspectives and experiences of the characters, particularly Alfred and Miss Caldwell. This allows for a deeper exploration of their thoughts and emotions while maintaining an objective viewpoint on the events unfolding.
  • Suspenseful Pacing:
    • Example: “Alfred straightened suddenly in his saddle and uttered a fervent curse.”
    • Explanation: White builds tension through strategic pacing, gradually escalating the conflict and suspense as the story progresses. Moments of anticipation and uncertainty propel the plot forward, keeping readers engaged and eager to discover the outcome.
  • Symbolism and Imagery:
    • Example: “The Sioux warriors symbolize the formidable challenges encountered during the journey.”
    • Explanation: White employs symbolism and vivid imagery to convey deeper themes and messages within the narrative. Elements such as the prairie landscape, the Sioux warriors, and the journey itself serve as powerful symbols that enrich the story with layers of meaning and significance.
Literary Theories and Interpretation of “The Girl Who Got Rattled” by Stewart Edward White
  • Feminist Theory
  • Interpretation: The story reinforces traditional gender roles, with Miss Caldwell needing male protection and Alfred embodying masculine bravery.
  • Example: Miss Caldwell’s decision to ride off alone is portrayed as reckless, and she requires Alfred’s rescue.
  • Critique: This interpretation overlooks Miss Caldwell’s agency and independence, as well as Alfred’s bashful nature, which challenges traditional gender roles.
  • Postcolonial Theory
  • Interpretation: The story perpetuates the dominant white settler narrative, marginalizing Native American experiences and perspectives.
  • Example: The Sioux warriors are portrayed as threats, reinforcing stereotypes and justifying white violence against them.
  • Critique: This interpretation highlights the story’s problematic representation of Native Americans, but overlooks Alfred’s attempts to communicate and find peace.
  • Psychoanalytic Theory
  • Interpretation: Alfred’s bashfulness and sudden assertiveness reveal repressed desires and a need for control.
  • Example: Alfred’s blushing and stammering around Miss Caldwell suggest unrequited love, while his decisive actions against the Sioux warriors express a latent masculinity.
  • Critique: This interpretation reduces Alfred’s character to psychosexual dynamics, neglecting his skills and experiences as a scout.
  • Marxist Theory
  • Interpretation: The story reflects class dynamics, with the wealthy Caldwell family and their hired scouts exploiting the prairie and its native inhabitants.
  • Example: The Caldwell family’s luxury and privilege contrast with the harsh realities of the prairie and the Sioux warriors’ struggles.
  • Critique: This interpretation oversimplifies the story’s themes, neglecting the complexities of frontier life and the characters’ individual motivations.
  • Ecocritical Theory
  • Interpretation: The story highlights the tension between human exploitation and the natural environment, as well as the interconnectedness of human and nonhuman experiences.
  • Example: The prairie landscape and its creatures (like the prairie dogs) serve as a backdrop for human conflict, while Alfred’s knowledge of the land and its rhythms enables his survival.
  • Critique: This interpretation foregrounds the story’s environmental themes, but might overlook the cultural and social dynamics at play.
Topics, Questions, and Thesis Statements about “The Girl Who Got Rattled” by Stewart Edward White
TopicQuestionThesis Statement
Character DevelopmentHow does Alfred’s character evolve throughout the story?Through his experiences on the journey to Deadwood, Alfred transitions from a timid and bashful individual to a courageous and resourceful protagonist, showcasing his growth and development as he confronts challenges and adversaries.
Themes of Survival and ResilienceWhat themes of survival and resilience are evident in the story?“The Girl Who Got Rattled” explores themes of survival and resilience through the characters’ encounters with adversity on the Western frontier, illustrating their ability to adapt, persevere, and overcome obstacles in the face of danger and uncertainty.
Conflict and ConsequencesHow do conflicts within the story drive the plot and shape the characters’ decisions?The conflicts depicted in “The Girl Who Got Rattled” serve as catalysts for character development and narrative tension, leading to pivotal moments that test the protagonists’ resolve and highlight the consequences of their actions in the unforgiving landscape of the American West.
Gender Roles and ExpectationsHow are gender roles and expectations portrayed in the interactions between characters?Stewart Edward White explores gender roles and expectations in “The Girl Who Got Rattled,” challenging traditional stereotypes through the actions and decisions of characters like Miss Caldwell, who defies societal norms to pursue her own desires and assert her agency in a male-dominated frontier environment.
Short Questions/Answers about/on “The Girl Who Got Rattled” by Stewart Edward White
  1. How does Alfred’s timid demeanor influence his actions? Alfred’s bashful nature often leads him to avoid confrontation and assertiveness, as seen when he refrains from directly addressing Allen’s disrespectful behavior towards him. For instance, when Allen interrupts Alfred’s story and mocks him in front of Miss Caldwell, Alfred blushes and falls silent, demonstrating his reluctance to engage in conflict.
  2. What role does Miss Caldwell play in challenging societal norms? Miss Caldwell defies traditional gender roles and expectations by embracing the hardships of frontier life and actively participating in the journey to Deadwood. Despite societal pressures for women to adhere to domestic roles, she seeks adventure and independence, as evidenced by her decision to join the wagon train and her willingness to race ahead with Allen, disregarding concerns about safety and propriety.
  3. How do conflicts with Native Americans impact the characters’ perceptions of the frontier? The encounters with hostile Sioux warriors highlight the harsh realities of life on the Western frontier and instill fear and uncertainty among the travelers. Alfred’s response to the looming threat of attack underscores the constant vigilance required for survival in the wilderness, as he prepares to defend himself and Miss Caldwell against potential violence.
  4. What themes of resilience emerge amidst the challenges faced by the characters? The resilience of the characters is exemplified by their ability to adapt and endure in the face of adversity. Despite the dangers posed by hostile Native Americans and the harsh conditions of the journey, the travelers persevere, demonstrating their determination to reach their destination. Additionally, Alfred’s resourcefulness and courage in confronting the Sioux warriors reflect the resilience needed to overcome obstacles on the unforgiving frontier.
Literary Works Similar to “The Girl Who Got Rattled” by Stewart Edward White
  1. The Virginian by Owen Wister (1902) – A classic Western novel set in Wyoming, exploring themes of love, honor, and cultural clashes between settlers and Native Americans.
  2. The Big Sky by A.B. Guthrie Jr. (1947) – A historical novel set in the American West, tracing the lives of fur trappers, explorers, and Native Americans amidst the vast, untamed landscape.
  3. True Grit by Charles Portis (1968) – A Western novel about a young girl’s quest for justice, featuring a strong-willed female protagonist and a rugged, unforgiving frontier landscape.
  4. Lonesome Dove by Larry McMurtry (1985) – A Pulitzer Prize-winning novel about two former Texas Rangers on a perilous cattle drive, exploring themes of friendship, love, and the American West.
  5. The Searchers by Alan Le May (1954) – A classic Western novel about a Texan’s obsessive search for his kidnapped niece, delving into themes of family, violence, and racial tension on the frontier.

These works share similarities with “The Girl Who Got Rattled” in their:

  • Western settings and frontier themes
  • Exploration of cultural clashes and racial tensions
  • Strong-willed protagonists and rugged landscapes
  • Themes of love, honor, and survival
  • Historical and adventurous elements
Suggested Readings about/on “The Girl Who Got Rattled” by Stewart Edward White
  • Books:
  • White, Stewart Edward. Blazed trail stories and stories of the wild life. Vol. 28. Ardent Media, 1969.
  • Pence, Raymond Woodbury, ed. Short Stories by Present-day Authors. Macmillan Company, 1922.
  • Articles:
  • Schniedermann, Wibke. “Revision as Nostalgic Practice: The Imagined Adaptation of The Ballad of Buster Scruggs.” Adaptation 15.1 (2022): 68-83.
  • Website Links:
  • https://americanliterature.com/author/stewart-edward-white/short-story/the-girl-who-got-rattled
  • http://www.online-literature.com/stewart-white/
Representative Quotations from “The Girl Who Got Rattled” by Stewart Edward White
QuotationContextTheorization
“Alfred was a little man, and he was bashful.”Introduction to Alfred’s characterThis quote highlights Alfred’s physical and personality traits, which are central to his character development and interactions with others.
“He could read the prairie like a book.”Description of Alfred’s skillsThis quote emphasizes Alfred’s expertise and connection to the natural environment, which serves as a source of power and authority.
“Allen annoyed Alfred, and Miss Caldwell thoughtlessly approved of Allen.”Dynamics between Alfred, Allen, and Miss CaldwellThis quote illustrates the tensions and power dynamics between the three characters, with Alfred’s bashfulness and courtesy leading to his silence and inaction.
“The young Easterner spurred up on the right of the girl’s mount. ‘He’s the queerest little fellow I ever saw!’ he observed, with a laugh.”Allen’s teasing of AlfredThis quote showcases the condescending attitude of Allen towards Alfred, highlighting the contrast between their personalities and approaches to life.
“Alfred surprised Miss Caldwell. His diffident manner suddenly left him. He jumped like lightning from his horse… and ran around to face Miss Caldwell.”Alfred’s transformation in the face of dangerThis quote marks a turning point in Alfred’s character development, as he sheds his bashfulness and takes decisive action to protect Miss Caldwell, revealing a more assertive and capable side.

“The Fly” by Katherine Mansfield: A Critical Analysis

“The Fly” by Katherine Mansfield first appeared in 1922 in The Nation and Athenaeum, a prominent British periodical.

"The Fly" by Katherine Mansfield: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “The Fly” by Katherine Mansfield

“The Fly” by Katherine Mansfield, first appeared in 1922 in The Nation and Athenaeum, a prominent British periodical and was subsequently included in The Doves’ Nest and Other Stories, a collection published posthumously in 1923. “The Fly” embodies Mansfield’s modernist approach to literature, utilizing stream-of-consciousness narration to delve into the protagonist’s emotional state. Composed in the years following World War I, the story subtly reflects the war’s enduring impact on individuals and their relationships.

Main Events in “The Fly” by Katherine Mansfield
  1. Comfort in the Office: Mr. Woodifield finds solace in the comfortable environment of Mr. Frank’s office, contrasting with his lonely and restricted life at home due to his retirement and stroke.
  2. Symbolism of Office Upgrades: Mr. Frank takes pride in the recent upgrades to his office, symbolizing his desire for control and stability amidst personal and professional uncertainties.
  3. Whisky as a Comfort: Mr. Frank offers whisky to Mr. Woodifield as a gesture of kindness and camaraderie, highlighting the solace found in shared moments and the temporary escape from life’s hardships.
  4. News of Graves: Mr. Woodifield shares news about the graves of their sons, prompting Mr. Frank to confront his grief and the passage of time.
  5. Grief and Loss: Mr. Frank’s grief over his son’s death resurfaces, revealing the depth of his emotional turmoil and the ongoing impact of loss.
  6. Memories of the Past: Memories of his son flood Mr. Frank’s mind, illustrating the lingering pain and the inability to move on from the past.
  7. Cruelty Towards the Fly: Mr. Frank’s treatment of the trapped fly reflects his sense of powerlessness and frustration, as well as a darker aspect of his character.
  8. Symbolism of the Fly: The fly trapped in ink symbolizes mortality, vulnerability, and the inevitability of death, mirroring Mr. Frank’s own struggles with mortality and control.
  9. Final Act of Cruelty: Mr. Frank’s decision to end the fly’s life reflects his own sense of hopelessness and the inability to cope with his emotions in a constructive manner.
  10. Loss of Connection: The story ends with Mr. Frank’s inability to recall his previous thoughts, symbolizing his disconnection from his emotions and his struggle to find meaning in his life.
Literary Devices in “The Fly” by Katherine Mansfield
Literary DeviceExampleExplanation
Allusion“They’re quite near each other, it seems.”Allusion refers to a brief and indirect reference to a person, place, thing, or idea of historical, cultural, literary, or political significance. Here, the reference to the graves implies the shared loss experienced by both characters.
Anaphora“Over and under, over and under, went a leg along a wing.”Anaphora is the repetition of a word or phrase at the beginning of successive clauses or sentences. In this example, the repetition of “over and under” emphasizes the repetitive nature of the fly’s actions.
Assonance“Beautifully looked after. Couldn’t be better if they were at home.”Assonance is the repetition of vowel sounds within nearby words. In this case, the repetition of the “oo” sound in “beautifully” and “couldn’t” creates a melodious effect and emphasizes the sense of comfort and care.
Consonance“Nice broad paths.”Consonance is the repetition of consonant sounds within or at the end of nearby words. The repetition of the “d” sound in “broad” and “paths” creates a smooth and rhythmic effect, enhancing the imagery of spaciousness and tranquility.
Foreshadowing“It was plain from his voice how much he liked a nice broad path.”Foreshadowing hints at future events or outcomes in the narrative. Here, Woodifield’s admiration for broad paths subtly foreshadows the theme of mortality and the finality of death, which becomes evident later in the story.
Hyperbole“They’re quite near each other, it seems.”Hyperbole involves exaggeration for emphasis or effect. In this case, the statement implies the proximity of the graves, exaggerating the emotional impact and significance of the location.
Imagery“A dark, squat bottle.”Imagery involves the use of descriptive language to create sensory experiences for the reader. Here, the description of the bottle as “dark” and “squat” paints a vivid mental picture, enhancing the reader’s understanding of the scene.
Irony“He wanted, he intended, he had arranged to weep.”Irony involves a contradiction between expectation and reality. In this example, the irony lies in Mr. Frank’s failed attempt to express his emotions, despite his strong desire and intention to do so.
Metaphor“He wanted, he intended, he had arranged to weep.”A metaphor is a figure of speech that compares two unlike things by suggesting that one thing is another. Here, weeping is metaphorically compared to a planned action or event, emphasizing the emotional disconnect experienced by Mr. Frank.
Onomatopoeia“But just then the boss had an idea.”Onomatopoeia refers to words that imitate the sound they represent. In this instance, the word “had” mimics the sound of a sudden realization or thought occurring in the boss’s mind.
Personification“But then, as if painfully, it dragged itself forward.”Personification attributes human qualities or characteristics to non-human entities. Here, the fly is personified as if experiencing pain and exhibiting determination, enhancing the reader’s empathy towards its struggle.
Repetition“Over and under, over and under, went a leg along a wing.”Repetition involves the repeated use of words or phrases for emphasis or effect. In this example, the repetition of “over and under” emphasizes the laborious and repetitive nature of the fly’s actions, highlighting its struggle.
Simile“Like a minute cat, to clean its face.”A simile is a figure of speech that compares two unlike things using the words “like” or “as.” In this instance, the fly’s action of cleaning its face is likened to the grooming behavior of a cat, enhancing the reader’s understanding through comparison.
Symbolism“The fly trapped in ink symbolizes mortality, vulnerability, and the inevitability of death.”Symbolism involves the use of symbols to represent ideas or concepts beyond their literal meaning. Here, the trapped fly serves as a symbol for deeper themes such as mortality and the fragility of life.
Tone“He started forward and pressed the bell for Macey.”Tone refers to the author’s attitude towards the subject matter or audience, conveyed through the choice of words and details. In this example, the tone is matter-of-fact, reflecting the protagonist’s sense of detachment and routine actions.
Understatement“He was puzzled. Something seemed to be wrong with him.”Understatement involves presenting something as less significant or serious than it actually is. Here, the understatement downplays the protagonist’s internal turmoil and confusion, highlighting his inability to grasp his emotional state.
Verbal Irony“Look sharp!”Verbal irony occurs when a character says something but means the opposite. In this instance, the boss instructs Macey to “look sharp,” implying urgency, while in reality, he is struggling with his own emotions and lack of clarity.
Mood“He felt positively frightened.”Mood refers to the atmosphere or emotional quality of a literary work. In this example, the mood is one of apprehension and uncertainty, conveyed through the protagonist’s feelings of fear and unease.
Paradox“But such a grinding feeling of wretchedness seized him that he felt positively frightened.”A paradox is a statement that appears self-contradictory but reveals a deeper truth. Here, the paradox lies in the juxtaposition of “grinding feeling of wretchedness” and “positively frightened,” illustrating the complexity of the protagonist’s emotions.
Characterization in “The Fly” by Katherine Mansfield
  • The Boss: A Facade of Strength: The unnamed protagonist, referred to solely as “the boss,” is a complex character. Initially, he appears as a successful, energetic businessman. We see this through his pride in his modernized office and his dismissal of Woodifield’s frailty. However, the story subtly reveals his deep grief over his deceased son. His boastful behavior masks a desperate attempt to distract himself from the gaping hole left by his son’s absence. Consider the passage where he boasts about the electric heater, saying, “Look at this beauty… Puts a bit of life into you what?” ([Story Title]). This seemingly innocuous statement can be interpreted as a yearning for the vitality his son brought to his life.
  • Mr. Woodifield: A Foil and a Reminder: A retired man, Woodifield serves as a foil to the boss. He is frail and dependent, representing the natural decline of life. The boss seems to view him with a touch of condescension. However, Woodifield’s purpose goes beyond mere contrast. His forgetfulness and struggle to remember something important foreshadow the boss’s own repressed grief. When Woodifield finally remembers the “awful business” ([Story Title]), it jolts the boss back to the reality of his own loss.
  • The Fly: A Symbol of Torment: While seemingly a minor character, the fly becomes a powerful symbol. The boss’s obsessive torment of the fly reflects his inner turmoil. He projects his frustration and anger over his son’s death onto the helpless creature. The fly’s eventual escape can be seen as a metaphor for the boss’s own inability to escape his grief.
  • The Son: A Lingering Absence: Though never physically present, the boss’s son looms large. The photo above the desk and the boss’s focus on him taking over the business highlight the future stolen by war. The son’s absence creates a void that the boss desperately tries to fill.

Through these characters, Mansfield paints a nuanced portrait of grief. The story explores how loss can manifest in unexpected ways, forcing characters to confront the fragility of life.

Major Themes in “The Fly” by Katherine Mansfield
ThemeDescriptionExample
Grief and LossThe story revolves around the unnamed boss’s profound grief over his deceased son. His boastful behavior and obsession with the fly are attempts to mask his emotional pain. Examples include the photo of the son on the desk, the boss’s dismissal of Woodifield’s frailty, and his relentless pursuit of the fly.
Repressed EmotionsThe boss struggles to express his grief directly. He channels his emotions into outward actions such as boasting and aggression. Woodifield’s forgetfulness also suggests a repressed awareness of a painful event. The story portrays the complexity of dealing with loss and the challenges of confronting difficult emotions.
The Powerlessness of ManThe fly symbolizes the boss’s ultimate powerlessness in the face of death. Despite his relentless efforts, he cannot escape his grief or control the course of life and death. The fly’s eventual escape highlights this powerlessness.
The Fragility of LifeThe story underscores the impermanence of life. The boss’s son’s death serves as a stark reminder of mortality. Woodifield’s physical decline further emphasizes the fleeting nature of life. The story prompts reflection on the preciousness of life and the need to
Writing Style in “The Fly” by Katherine Mansfield
  1. Psychological Realism: Mansfield delves into the inner thoughts and emotions of Mr. Frank, portraying his grief and internal struggles with vivid detail.
  2. Stream of Consciousness: The narrative style mimics Mr. Frank’s thought processes, often drifting from one memory or observation to another without clear transitions.
  3. Symbolism: The trapped fly in the inkpot serves as a powerful symbol throughout the story, representing themes of mortality, fragility, and the inevitability of death.
  4. Descriptive Imagery: Mansfield employs vivid and evocative language to paint a detailed picture of the story’s setting and characters, enhancing the reader’s immersion in the story.
  5. Irony: The story is laced with irony, particularly in Mr. Frank’s treatment of the fly, highlighting the ironic juxtaposition between his empathy for the fly and his own callousness.
Literary Theories and Interpretation of “The Fly” by Katherine Mansfield
Literary TheoryInterpretationExample from “The Fly”
Psychoanalytic TheoryAnalyzes characters’ psychological motivations and conflictsMr. Frank’s fixation on the trapped fly can be interpreted as a manifestation of his unresolved grief and guilt over his son’s death. His treatment of the fly reflects his inner turmoil and repressed emotions.
Feminist TheoryExplores gender roles, power dynamics, and societal expectationsAlthough the story primarily focuses on male characters, feminist analysis can highlight the absence of female voices and the impact of patriarchal norms on expressions of grief and emotional vulnerability.
Marxist TheoryExamines social class, economic conditions, and power structuresThe contrasting lifestyles of Mr. Frank and Mr. Woodifield can be analyzed through a Marxist lens, highlighting the disparities in their wealth, status, and access to comfort and leisure.
Reader-Response TheoryFocuses on the reader’s interpretation and subjective responseReaders may interpret the fly as a symbol of various themes such as mortality, resilience, or the cyclical nature of life, depending on their own experiences and perspectives.
New CriticismEmphasizes close reading of the text and analysis of literary devicesClose examination of Mansfield’s use of symbolism, irony, and stream-of-consciousness narration reveals the story’s complexity and invites readers to explore its deeper layers of meaning.
Topics, Questions, and Thesis Statements about “The Fly” by Katherine Mansfield
TopicQuestionThesis Statement
Grief and MemoryHow does the story portray the characters’ coping mechanisms for grief?“The Fly” by Katherine Mansfield explores how memory and denial function as both burdens and shields in the face of profound grief, ultimately revealing the characters’ struggle to process loss.
Symbolism and MeaningWhat is the significance of the fly in the story?In “The Fly,” the seemingly insignificant fly transcends its physical form to embody the protagonist’s repressed emotions and his ultimate powerlessness in the face of death.
Social CommentaryCan the story be interpreted as a commentary on the impact of war?Beyond a personal narrative of grief, “The Fly” can be seen as a subtle critique of war’s enduring impact on individuals and their capacity for emotional connection.
Modernist TechniquesHow does Mansfield’s use of stream-of-consciousness narration contribute to the story’s impact?Through stream-of-consciousness narration, Mansfield crafts a raw and intimate portrayal of grief in “The Fly,” allowing readers to experience the protagonist’s emotional turmoil firsthand.
Short Questions/Answers about/on “The Fly” by Katherine Mansfield
  • Beyond Annoyance: How does the seemingly insignificant fly morph into a powerful symbol, revealing the boss’s internal struggle in “The Fly” by Katherine Mansfield?
  • This question delves deeper than the fly’s mere presence. It prompts an analysis of the transformation of the fly from a nuisance to a potent symbol. Consider the escalation of the boss’s reaction. How does his relentless pursuit connect to his emotional state? Explore the concept of the fly as a manifestation of the boss’s grief, and analyze how focusing on the fly allows him to avoid confronting a more profound pain.
  • A Haunting Reminder: In “The Fly,” how does the seemingly ordinary photo on the boss’s desk function as a multifaceted symbol of loss and unfulfilled dreams?
  • This question goes beyond a simple description of the photo. It asks you to unpack the layers of meaning embedded within the image. How does the son’s posture and clothing contribute to the symbolic weight of the photo? Consider the concept of the photo as a constant reminder of the stolen future and the void it creates in the boss’s life. Explore how the photo connects to the boss’s attempts to fill that void, including his obsession with the fly.
  • A Mirror to Repressed Grief: How does Mr. Woodifield’s forgetfulness in “The Fly” by Katherine Mansfield act as a commentary on the universality and complexities of coping with loss?
  • This question moves beyond Woodifield’s forgetfulness as a character trait. It asks you to analyze how it serves as a broader thematic device. Explore how Woodifield’s struggle to remember an “awful business” foreshadows the boss’s own repressed grief. Consider the concept of forgetfulness as a coping mechanism and how it reflects the challenges of confronting loss. Analyze how Woodifield’s experience functions as a mirror to the boss’s emotional state, highlighting the universality of grief.
  • An Unresolved Pain: How does the open window at the end of “The Fly” by Katherine Mansfield contribute to the story’s portrayal of the lingering effects of grief?
  • This question moves beyond the literal escape of the fly. It asks you to analyze the symbolic meaning of the open window and its connection to the boss’s emotional state. Explore the concept of the open window as a metaphor for the boss’s inability to escape his grief. Consider how the unresolved nature of the ending reflects the ongoing process of grieving. Analyze how the reader is left to ponder the lasting impact of the son’s death on the boss’s life, highlighting the unresolved nature of the boss’s pain.
Literary Works Similar to “The Fly” by Katherine Mansfield
  1. The Metamorphosis” by Franz Kafka:
    • Like “The Fly,” Kafka’s novella delves into themes of isolation, alienation, and the absurdity of existence. It follows the transformation of Gregor Samsa into a giant insect and explores the consequences of his metamorphosis on his relationships and sense of self.
  2. Bartleby, the Scrivener” by Herman Melville:
    • Melville’s short story examines themes of conformity, individuality, and the dehumanizing effects of modern society. Similar to “The Fly,” it features a protagonist who withdraws from society and adopts passive resistance, challenging conventional norms and expectations.
  3. A Good Man is Hard to Find” by Flannery O’Connor:
    • O’Connor’s short story explores themes of morality, redemption, and the nature of evil. Like “The Fly,” it features unexpected twists and moments of realization that prompt characters to confront the darker aspects of human nature and their own mortality.
  4. The Yellow Wallpaper” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman:
    • Gilman’s short story addresses themes of female oppression, mental illness, and the constraints of gender roles. Like “The Fly,” it employs psychological realism and explores the inner world of its protagonist as she grapples with her deteriorating mental state.
  5. The Dead” by James Joyce:
    • Joyce’s short story is part of his collection “Dubliners” and centers on a dinner party where guests confront issues of love, mortality, and the passage of time. Like “The Fly,” it features introspective characters and moments of epiphany that illuminate the complexities of human experience.
Suggested Readings about/on “The Fly” by Katherine Mansfield
Primary Source:
  • Mansfield, Katherine. “The Fly.” The Doves’ Nest and Other Stories. Constable & Company Ltd, 1923. 1-12. Print.
  • Mansfield, Katherine. Selected stories. Oxford University Press, 2002.
  • Mansfield, Katherine. The collected stories of Katherine Mansfield. Wordsworth Editions, 2006.
Critical Analyses:
  • Michel-Michot, Paulette. “Katherine Mansfield’s” The Fly”: An Attempt to Capture the Boss.” Studies in Short Fiction 11.1 (1974): 85.
  • Bateson, F. W., and B. Shahevitch. “Katherine Mansfield’s ‘The Fly’: A Critical Exercise.” Essays in Criticism 12.1 (1962): 39-53.
  • Sohier, Jacques. “Spectrality in the Short Story ‘The Fly’by Katherine Mansfield.” Études britanniques contemporaines. Revue de la Société dʼétudes anglaises contemporaines 42 (2012): 139-152.
  • GREENWOOD, EB. “KATHERINE MANSFIELD’S ‘THE FLY’III.” Essays in Criticism 12.3 (1962): 341-347.
Web Sources:
Representative Quotations from “The Fly” by Katherine Mansfield
QuotationContextInterpretation
“Y’are very snug in here,” piped old Mr. Woodifield, and he peered out of the great, green-leather armchair…Mr. Woodifield expresses a sense of comfort and longing as he visits the boss’s office, highlighting the contrast between his restricted life at home and the boss’s comfortable surroundings.This quotation sets the tone for the story, emphasizing themes of confinement, longing, and the desire for warmth and companionship. It introduces the idea of seeking solace in familiar places and connections amidst the challenges of aging and isolation.
“I’ve got a little drop of something here that’ll do you good before you go out into the cold again…The boss offers Mr. Woodifield whisky as a gesture of camaraderie and hospitality, attempting to alleviate his friend’s discomfort and bring warmth to their interaction.This quotation reflects the boss’s attempt to assert control over his emotions and maintain a facade of strength in the face of grief. It also symbolizes the futile pursuit of distraction and comfort in the midst of profound loss and emotional turmoil.
“I’ll see nobody for half an hour, Macey,” said the boss…After Mr. Woodifield’s departure, the boss retreats into solitude, signaling his need for introspection and emotional release.This quotation captures the boss’s internal struggle with grief and the overwhelming nature of his emotions. It underscores the theme of isolation and the difficulty of finding solace or resolution in the face of profound loss and existential uncertainty.
“He’s a plucky little devil,” thought the boss…The boss admires the fly’s resilience and determination as it struggles to overcome adversity, projecting his own desire for strength and perseverance onto the insect.This quotation reflects the boss’s attempt to find meaning and inspiration in the fly’s struggle, mirroring his own internal battle with grief and despair. It symbolizes the human capacity for resilience and the innate drive to confront challenges, even in the face of overwhelming odds.
“Bring me some fresh blotting-paper,” he said sternly…The boss’s abrupt shift in focus to mundane tasks reflects his attempt to suppress or distract himself from his overwhelming emotions.This quotation underscores the boss’s internal conflict and his struggle to reconcile his emotional turmoil with the demands of everyday life. It highlights the tension between outward composure and inner turmoil, as well as the futility of attempting to escape or rationalize profound grief.

“The Father” by Bjørnstjerne Bjørnson: A Critical Analysis

“The Father” by Bjørnstjerne Bjørnson, first published in 1860 as part of the collection “Nova” (Night and Day), showcases Bjørnson’s exploration of qualities such as fatherly love, sacrifice, and the struggle for power, set against the context of a rural Norwegian community.

"The Father" by Bjørnstjerne Bjørnson: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “The Father” by Bjørnstjerne Bjørnson

“The Father” by Bjørnstjerne Bjørnson, first published in 1860 as part of the collection “Nova” (Night and Day), showcases Bjørnson’s exploration of qualities such as fatherly love, sacrifice, and the struggle for power, set against the context of a rural Norwegian community. Through the character of the Father, Bjørnson masterfully portrays the complexities of human relationships and the consequences of unchecked ambition, making this work a significant contribution to Norwegian literature.

Main Events in “The Father” by Bjørnstjerne Bjørnson
  1. A Proud Father: Thord Overaas, the wealthiest man in the parish, introduces his newborn son, Finn, to the priest and insists on a special baptism ceremony.
  2. Focus on Ranking: Sixteen years later, Thord returns before his son’s confirmation and pays the priest extra depending on his son’s position in the ceremony (number one).
  3. Securing a Wealthy Marriage: Eight years after that, Thord arranges the banns to be published for his son’s marriage to Karen Storliden, the richest girl in the parish. He pays extra despite it only requiring one dollar.
  4. Tragedy on the Lake: While rowing across the lake to discuss wedding arrangements, Thord’s son falls overboard and drowns. The son tries to grab the oar but fails to stay afloat.
  5. Relentless Search: Thord spends three days and nights tirelessly searching the lake for his son’s body.
  6. Grief and Change: A year later, a gaunt and aged Thord visits the priest, a stark contrast to his previous confident demeanor.
  7. Legacy for the Lost Son: Thord donates a significant amount of money, half the value of his farm, to be invested as a legacy in his son’s name.
  8. Letting Go of Material Wealth: This act shows Thord prioritizing his son’s memory over material possessions.
  9. Finding True Blessing: When the priest questions Thord’s future plans, Thord simply replies, “Something better.”
  10. A Father Transformed: The priest suggests Thord’s son has finally brought him a true blessing, and Thord tearfully agrees, signifying a change in perspective.
Literary Devices in “The Father” by Bjørnstjerne Bjørnson
Literary DeviceExampleExplanation
AllusionReference to Thord’s wealth and influence in the parishAllusion is the reference to something outside the text, here, it refers to Thord’s social status and influence within the community.
Anaphora“There is nothing else” repeated by ThordAnaphora is the repetition of a word or phrase at the beginning of successive clauses. Here, Thord repeats this phrase to emphasize his single-minded focus.
AntagonistThe circumstances leading to the son’s deathThe antagonist is the force or character that opposes the protagonist. In this case, it’s the tragic circumstances that lead to the son’s untimely death.
ConflictMan vs. Nature when the son falls overboardConflict arises when opposing forces clash. Here, it’s the struggle between man (Thord) and nature (the lake) when the son falls into the water.
ForeshadowingThe priest’s words to Thord about his son being a blessingForeshadowing hints at future events. The priest’s words about the son being a blessing subtly suggest the eventual tragedy that befalls Thord’s family.
HyperboleThord’s relentless search for his son’s bodyHyperbole is an exaggerated statement or claim not meant to be taken literally. Thord’s relentless search emphasizes the depth of his grief and determination.
ImageryDescription of the calm, still lakeImagery uses sensory language to create a vivid mental picture. The description of the serene lake evokes a tranquil atmosphere contrasted with the tragedy.
IronyThord’s son, who was meant to be a blessing, diesIrony is a contradiction between what is expected and what actually occurs. Thord’s son, intended as a blessing, meets a tragic fate, which is ironic and unexpected.
Metaphor“The lake lay there as smooth and bright as a mirror”A metaphor compares two unlike things by stating one thing is another. Here, the calm lake is likened to a smooth, bright mirror, emphasizing its tranquility.
MotifThe theme of fatherhood and loss repeated throughoutA motif is a recurring element that reinforces the central themes of a work. Here, the motif of fatherhood and loss underscores the emotional core of the narrative.
ParadoxThord’s son, the supposed blessing, leads to tragedyA paradox is a statement that appears self-contradictory but may reveal a deeper truth. Here, the son, meant to bring blessing, becomes the source of tragedy.
Personification“The lake lay there as smooth and bright as a mirror”Personification attributes human qualities to non-human entities. Here, the lake is described as laying smooth and bright, as if it possesses human-like characteristics.
Repetition“There is nothing else” repeated by ThordRepetition emphasizes a point or idea by restating it. Thord’s repetition of this phrase underscores his singular focus on the matter at hand.
SymbolismThord’s son symbolizing both blessing and tragedySymbolism is the use of symbols to represent ideas or concepts. Thord’s son symbolizes both the potential for blessings (hope) and the reality of tragedy (loss).
ThemeThe complexities of fatherhood and grief exploredTheme is the central idea or message conveyed by a work. Here, the story explores the complexities of fatherhood and the profound grief that accompanies loss.
ToneThe solemn and melancholic tone throughout the story
TragedyThe death of Thord’s son is a tragic event in the storyTragedy is a genre characterized by events leading to the downfall of the protagonist. Here, the death of Thord’s son is a central tragic event in the narrative.
Verbal IronyThord’s statement that he has no troublesVerbal irony occurs when a character says one thing but means another. Thord’s claim of having no troubles contrasts sharply with the tragic events that unfold.
FlashbackThord reflecting on past events with the priestA flashback is a scene set in a time earlier than the main story. Here, Thord reflects on past events with the priest, providing insight into his character and journey.
Characterization in “The Father” by Bjørnstjerne Bjørnson
Major Character:
  • Thord Overaas:
  • The wealthy and influential protagonist undergoes a significant transformation throughout the story. Here’s how Bjørnson develops him:
    • Actions:
      • Initially prideful – arranges a special baptism, boasts about his son’s achievements.
      • Materialistic – throws money at confirmation and wedding.
      • Grief-stricken and persistent – searches relentlessly for his son’s body.
      • Charitable – donates a large sum in his son’s name.
    • Dialogue:
      • Focuses on wealth and status – mentions “no troubles” and boasts about his son’s ranking.
    • Indirect Characterization:
      • Priest’s observations – comments on Thord’s lack of aging (shallow life) and questions if his son brings blessings.
Minor Character:
  • The Priest: Serves as a foil to Thord, highlighting his flaws.
    • Actions:
      • Observant – notices Thord’s lack of change and his focus on money.
      • Insightful – questions Thord’s motives and prompts reflection.
    • Dialogue:
      • Gentle but thought-provoking – asks if Thord’s son is a blessing.
Explanation:

The story follows Thord’s journey from a self-absorbed man concerned with wealth to someone who understands the importance of emotional connection and giving. The priest’s role is crucial in highlighting Thord’s flaws and prompting him to re-evaluate his priorities.

Major Themes in “The Father” by Bjørnstjerne Bjørnson
ThemeExampleExplanation
FatherhoodThord’s request to present his son for baptismThord’s journey as a father begins with the symbolic act of presenting his son for baptism, highlighting his initial hopes and responsibilities as a parent.
Loss and GriefThord’s relentless search for his son’s bodyThe tragic death of Thord’s son plunges him into deep grief, depicted through his desperate search for the body, emphasizing the profound impact of loss on the protagonist.
RedemptionThord’s decision to invest his wealth as a legacyThord’s transformation from a man driven by material wealth to one seeking spiritual fulfillment is evident in his decision to invest his wealth as a legacy, symbolizing his journey towards redemption and growth.
LegacyThord’s investment in his son’s name as a legacyThord’s choice to invest his wealth as a legacy in his son’s name reflects his desire to honor his child’s memory and contribute to a better future, exemplifying the enduring impact of familial bonds and the legacy one leaves behind.
Writing Style in “The Father” by Bjørnstjerne Bjørnson
  • Sparse Dialogue: The story relies heavily on dialogue, but it’s brief and direct. This keeps the focus on the characters’ actions and unspoken emotions.
  • Vivid Descriptions: Bjørnson uses selective details to create impactful imagery. Descriptions like “calm, still day” on the lake and Thord rowing “round and round the spot” paint a picture of grief and desperation.
  • Focus on Action: The story progresses through actions rather than lengthy explanations. We see Thord’s changing behavior towards his son through his actions at the baptism, confirmation, and wedding.
  • Shifting Time: The story jumps forward in time, with phrases like “One day sixteen years later” or “Eight years more rolled by.” This keeps the narrative focused on key events in Thord’s emotional journey.
  • Emotional Impact: Despite the short length, the story evokes strong emotions. The son’s tragic death and Thord’s grief are conveyed powerfully through Bjørnson’s writing choices.
Literary Theories and Interpretation of “The Father” by Bjørnstjerne Bjørnson
  1. Marxist Theory: Marxist theory examines literature through the lens of social class, power dynamics, and economic conditions. In “The Father,” one can interpret Thord’s character and his interactions with society from a Marxist perspective. Thord, as the wealthiest and most influential person in his parish, represents the bourgeoisie, while the peasant community symbolizes the proletariat. Thord’s wealth and status shape his actions, such as his ability to pay the priest generously or his social standing affecting his son’s marriage prospects. The story reflects the unequal distribution of wealth and power, highlighting societal hierarchies and the impact of economic factors on individual lives.
  2. Feminist Theory: Feminist theory focuses on gender dynamics, power structures, and representations of women in literature. While “The Father” primarily revolves around Thord’s experiences, the female characters, such as Karen Storliden, Thord’s son’s bride, offer avenues for feminist analysis. Karen’s role in the story is largely defined by her familial wealth and social status, as indicated by her being the “richest girl in the parish.” Her agency and voice are overshadowed by male characters like Thord and the priest. Examining Karen’s character and the treatment of women in the story sheds light on patriarchal norms and societal expectations of gender roles during the time period.
  3. Psychoanalytic Theory: Psychoanalytic theory, stemming from Freudian psychology, explores the subconscious mind, motivations, and conflicts of characters. Thord’s journey in “The Father” can be analyzed through a psychoanalytic lens, particularly regarding his relationship with his son and the trauma of his loss. Thord’s relentless search for his son’s body, despite the inevitability of death, reveals deep-seated psychological conflicts, such as guilt, grief, and the desire for redemption. His actions and emotional responses can be interpreted as manifestations of unconscious desires and anxieties, providing insight into his psyche and inner turmoil.
  4. Reader-Response Theory: Reader-response theory emphasizes the role of the reader in interpreting and constructing meaning from a text. In “The Father,” readers’ interpretations may vary based on their personal experiences, beliefs, and cultural backgrounds. For instance, readers may empathize with Thord’s grief and moral journey, interpreting his actions as a universal exploration of love, loss, and redemption. Alternatively, readers may critique Thord’s character and societal values, highlighting themes of class inequality, patriarchy, and the limitations of traditional masculinity. Reader-response theory underscores the active engagement of readers in shaping their understanding of the text and the multiple perspectives it offers.
Topics, Questions and Thesis Statements about “The Father” by Bjørnstjerne Bjørnson
  • Topic 1: Transformation Through Loss
  • Question: How does the loss of his son impact Thord’s character?
  • Thesis Statement: Bjørnson uses Thord’s changing relationship with his son and the grief over his death to portray a profound transformation from materialism and self-absorption to an understanding of love and loss.
  • Topic 2: The Significance of Symbols
  • Question: What role does the lake play in the story?
  • Thesis Statement: The lake functions as a symbolic representation of Thord’s emotional journey. Initially calm and serene, it becomes a place of desperate searching and ultimately reflects his newfound peace.
  • Topic 3: The Priest as a Foil
  • Question: How does the priest’s character serve to highlight Thord’s flaws?
  • Thesis Statement: Through the priest’s observations and insightful questions, Bjørnson exposes Thord’s shallowness and self-importance, prompting the reader to consider the importance of emotional connection.
  • Topic 4: Minimalism and Emotional Impact
  • Question: How does Bjørnson’s writing style contribute to the story’s impact?
  • Thesis Statement: Bjørnson’s minimalist approach, utilizing sparse dialogue, vivid descriptions, and a focus on action, amplifies the emotional core of the story, making the themes of grief, transformation, and love resonate powerfully with the reader.
Short Questions/Answers about/on “The Father” by Bjørnstjerne Bjørnson
  • How does Thord initially present himself in the story?
  • Thord’s introduction in “The Father” paints a picture of a man consumed by pride and materialism. We see this in his very first actions. He doesn’t simply bring his son for baptism; he arranges a special ceremony on a weekday, showcasing a desire for distinction. His boastful remark, “That is because I have no troubles,” further reveals a shallow understanding of life, focusing solely on outward success. When he pays the priest for his son’s confirmation and wedding, the focus is on the amount (“Here are ten dollars” and “three dollars”) rather than the occasion itself. These initial interactions establish Thord as someone more concerned with wealth and status than emotional connection.
  • What event exposes a turning point in Thord’s relationship with his son?
  • The sudden and tragic death of his son by drowning marks a clear turning point in Thord’s relationship. Up until this point, his interactions with his son have been impersonal and transactional. However, when his son falls overboard, Thord’s immediate reaction is one of desperation. His cries of “Take hold of the oar!” and “Wait a moment!” showcase a sudden surge of paternal concern. The most significant change comes after his son sinks. The story describes Thord “holding the boat still, and stared at the spot where his son had gone down,” refusing to believe his loss. His relentless search for the body over “three days and three nights” highlights a depth of grief previously unseen. This event shatters Thord’s self-absorbed exterior and forces him to confront the emotional void in his relationship with his son.
  • How does the priest act as a foil to Thord?
  • The priest serves as a moral compass throughout the story, his observations and questions highlighting Thord’s flaws. A subtle example of this is the priest’s comment on Thord’s lack of aging. While seemingly a compliment, it can be interpreted as a suggestion that Thord’s life lacks emotional depth, leading to a stagnant appearance. More directly, the priest questions if Thord’s son brings him “blessings.” This simple inquiry challenges Thord’s self-perception and prompts the reader to consider the true meaning of having a child. By showcasing a deeper understanding of human connection, the priest acts as a foil to Thord’s initial self-absorption.
  • What is the significance of the ending of the story?
  • The story’s ending portrays Thord’s profound transformation. He starts by selling his farm, a symbol of his past materialistic focus. This act suggests a detachment from the things he once valued most. The large sum of money he donates in his son’s name signifies a shift in priorities. It’s no longer about personal gain; it’s about giving back and honoring his son’s memory. Finally, Thord’s tears, a stark contrast to his initial stoicism, showcase a newfound vulnerability and acceptance of his grief. The priest’s gentle observation, “I think your son has at last brought you a true blessing,” underscores Thord’s emotional journey. He has moved from a place of self-absorption to one of understanding and compassion, a true “blessing” brought on by his son, even in death.
Literary Works Similar to “The Father” by Bjørnstjerne Bjørnson
  1. “Ghosts” by Henrik Ibsen: Like Bjørnson, Ibsen was a prominent Norwegian playwright and contemporary of Bjørnstjerne Bjørnson. “Ghosts” explores themes of family secrets, societal expectations, and the consequences of past actions, similar to the moral complexities examined in “The Father.”
  2. “Death of a Salesman” by Arthur Miller: Arthur Miller’s play delves into the struggles of a father, Willy Loman, as he grapples with his perceived failures and the disillusionment of the American Dream. The play examines themes of family dynamics, identity, and the pursuit of success, resonating with the themes of fatherhood and redemption in “The Father.”
  3. The Road by Cormac McCarthy: While stylistically different from “The Father,” McCarthy’s novel shares themes of parental love, loss, and the struggle for survival. Set in a post-apocalyptic world, “The Road” follows a father and son’s journey across a desolate landscape, highlighting the enduring bond between parent and child amidst bleak circumstances.
  4. Fathers and Sons by Ivan Turgenev: Turgenev’s novel explores generational conflicts and societal changes in 19th-century Russia. Through the relationship between the conservative father figure, Nikolai Petrovich, and his progressive son, Arkady, the novel delves into themes of tradition, rebellion, and the evolving role of family in society.
  5. The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini: Hosseini’s novel portrays the complex relationship between fathers and sons against the backdrop of Afghanistan’s turbulent history. Through the protagonist Amir’s journey of redemption and reconciliation with his past, the novel examines themes of guilt, forgiveness, and the enduring impact of familial bonds.
Suggested Readings about/on “The Father” by Bjørnstjerne Bjørnson
  • Boyesen, Hjalmar Hjorth. “Björnstjerne Björnson as a Dramatist.” The North American Review 116.238 (1873): 109-138.
  • Bjørnson, Bjørnstjerne. The Novels of Björnstjerne Björnson: Magnhild & Dust. Vol. 6. W. Heinemann, 1897.
  • Bjornson, Bjornstjerne. In God’s Way. BoD–Books on Demand, 2020.
  • Willcox, Louise Collier. “Bjornstjerne Bjornson.” The North American Review 192.656 (1910): 44-55.
  • https://www.britannica.com/summary/Bjornstjerne-Bjornson
Representative Quotations from “The Father” by Bjørnstjerne Bjørnson
QuoteContextTheorization
“That is because I have no troubles,”This is Thord’s response to the priest’s comment about him aging well.This quote reveals Thord’s initial self-absorption. He equates a lack of visible problems with a good life, failing to recognize the emotional void in his relationships.
“I did not wish to pay the priest until I heard what number the boy would have…”Thord says this after his son is confirmed.This quote highlights Thord’s materialism. He seems more concerned with his son’s outward achievement (ranking) than the religious ceremony itself.
“But now I am through with him,”Thord says this after arranging his son’s wedding.This quote foreshadows Thord’s eventual transformation. Here, he displays a coldness and detachment, considering his parenting duties over.
“For three days and three nights people saw the father rowing round and round the spot…”This describes Thord’s relentless search for his son’s body.This quote signifies a turning point. Thord’s desperate actions demonstrate his grief and a newfound depth of emotion.
“It is half the price of my gard. I sold it today.”Thord reveals how much money he is donating to charity.This quote showcases Thord’s significant change. Selling his farm, a symbol of his wealth, demonstrates his shift in priorities.
“I think your son has at last brought you a true blessing.”The priest’s observation about Thord’s son.This quote summarizes Thord’s journey. His son’s death, though tragic, has forced him to confront his emotions and become a more compassionate person.

“In Tenebris” by Thomas Hardy: A Critical Analysis

“In Tenebris” by Thomas Hardy first appeared in 1901 in his collection “Poems of the Past and the Present,” marking a turning point in his literary output, showcasing a deepening pessimism and disillusionment.

"In Tenebris" by Thomas Hardy: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “In Tenebris” by Thomas Hardy

“In Tenebris” by Thomas Hardy first appeared in 1901 in his collection “Poems of the Past and the Present,” marking a turning point in his literary output, showcasing a deepening pessimism and disillusionment. The poem confronts themes of profound grief, loss, and the uncaring nature of the natural world in the face of human suffering. The title itself, derived from Latin as “In Darkness,” underscores the poem’s exploration of emotional desolation.

Text: “In Tenebris” by Thomas Hardy

“Percussus sum sicut foenum, et aruit cor meum.” —Ps. ci.

Wintertime nighs;

But my bereavement-pain

It cannot bring again:

Twice no one dies.

Flower-petals flee;

But, since it once hath been,

No more that severing scene

Can harrow me.

Birds faint in dread:

I shall not lose old strength

In the lone frost’s black length:

Strength long since fled!

Leaves freeze to dun;

But friends can not turn cold

This season as of old

For him with none.

Tempests may scath;

But love can not make smart

Again this year his heart

Who no heart hath.

Black is night’s cope;

But death will not appal

One who, past doubtings all,

Waits in unhope.

Annotations: “In Tenebris” by Thomas Hardy  
StanzaAnnotation
1* Wintertime nighs: Winter approaches, often seen as a symbol of death and hardship.
* Percussus sum sicut foenum, et aruit cor meum (Ps. ci): A Latin quote from Psalm 101 meaning “I am withered like grass, and my heart is dried up.” Sets the tone of despair.
* Twice no one dies: The speaker acknowledges the finality of death – one cannot die again.
2* Flower-petals flee: Flowers, representing beauty and life, inevitably die.
* But, since it once hath been: The pain of loss, though present, cannot be a new experience.
* No more that severing scene / Can harrow me: The speaker has already endured the worst of the loss.
3* Birds faint in dread: Birds, symbolic of hope and freedom, fear the coming winter.
* I shall not lose old strength / In the lone frost’s black length: The speaker is already emotionally numb, incapable of further suffering. * Strength long since fled!: The speaker has already lost their emotional resilience.
4* Leaves freeze to dun: Leaves, representing vitality, lose their color and life in winter.
* But friends can not turn cold / This season as of old / For him with none: The speaker highlights the additional pain of loss in winter for those who are alone.
5* Tempests may scath: Storms may bring destruction.
* But love can not make smart / Again this year his heart / Who no heart hath: Love’s sting is irrelevant to someone who no longer has the capacity to feel it.
6* Black is night’s cope: Night, symbolizing darkness and death, arrives.
* But death will not appal / One who, past doubtings all, / Waits in unhope: The speaker, having lost all hope, does not fear death’s arrival.
Literary and Poetic Devices: “In Tenebris” by Thomas Hardy
DeviceExplanation
Alliteration
AllusionReference to Psalms 102:4 in Latin, suggesting a theme of desolation and despair.
AssonanceRepetition of vowel sounds, as seen in “Twice no one dies.”
ConsonanceRepetition of consonant sounds, like the “s” sound in “Birds faint in dread.”
EnjambmentThe continuation of a sentence without a pause beyond the end of a line or stanza.
ImageryVivid descriptions that appeal to the senses, such as “lone frost’s black length.”
IronyThe contrast between what is expected and what actually happens, like “Flower-petals flee.”
MetaphorA comparison between two unlike things without using “like” or “as,” as in “Black is night’s cope.”
OnomatopoeiaThe use of words that imitate the sound they describe, like “Tempests may scath.”
PersonificationGiving human qualities to non-human entities, as in “Leaves freeze to dun.”
RepetitionRepeated use of words or phrases, such as “Strength long since fled!”
SimileA comparison using “like” or “as,” as in “Percussus sum sicut foenum.”
SymbolismThe use of symbols to represent ideas or concepts, such as “Black is night’s cope.”
SynecdocheA figure of speech in which a part is used to represent the whole or the whole for a part, like “Flower-petals flee.”
ToneThe author’s attitude towards the subject, which in this case could be somber or resigned.
RepetitionRepeated use of words or phrases, such as “Strength long since fled!”
EnjambmentThe continuation of a sentence without a pause beyond the end of a line or stanza.
MetonymySubstituting the name of one thing with something closely associated with it, like “heart” for emotions.
OxymoronThe juxtaposition of contradictory terms, as in “lone frost’s black length.”
ApostropheAddressing something nonhuman as if it were human, like “Black is night’s cope.”
Themes: “In Tenebris” by Thomas Hardy  
  1. Grief and Loss: One of the central themes of “In Tenebris” is the profound sense of grief and the inability to overcome loss. Hardy portrays this theme through the imagery of winter and the repetition of sorrowful refrains. For instance, the lines “Wintertime nighs; / But my bereavement-pain / It cannot bring again” encapsulate the enduring anguish of the speaker, highlighting the permanent void left by loss. The poem reflects on the futile longing to reverse the irreversible, underscoring the inescapable nature of grief.
  2. Resilience and Endurance: Despite the pervasive sorrow depicted in the poem, there is also a theme of resilience and inner strength. Hardy suggests that even in the darkest of times, there remains a glimmer of fortitude within the human spirit. The line “Strength long since fled!” implies a resilience that persists despite the passage of time and the harshness of life’s trials. Through this theme, the poem offers a testament to the indomitable nature of the human soul, capable of enduring even the harshest of winters.
  3. Transient Nature of Happiness: Another theme explored in “In Tenebris” is the fleetingness of joy and beauty. Hardy employs imagery of ephemeral natural phenomena, such as flower petals fleeing and leaves freezing, to convey the impermanence of happiness. The line “Flower-petals flee” serves as a poignant reminder of the transient nature of life’s pleasures, highlighting the ephemeral nature of joy and beauty in the face of inevitable change.
  4. Existential Reflection: The poem also delves into existential themes, contemplating the meaning of life and the inevitability of death. Through allusions and symbolic language, Hardy prompts reflection on the human condition and the mysteries of existence. The line “Waits in unhope” encapsulates a sense of existential resignation, suggesting a bleak acceptance of the unknown. This theme invites readers to confront the uncertainties of mortality and grapple with the ultimate questions of existence.
Literary Theories and “In Tenebris” by Thomas Hardy  
Literary TheoryInterpretation
Marxist CriticismThe poem explores the suffering and despair of the working class, with the speaker trapped in a bleak, industrialized world.
Psychoanalytic CriticismThe speaker’s darkness and anguish represent unconscious emotions and repressed desires, with the poem being a manifestation of their inner turmoil.
Feminist CriticismThe poem’s focus on male suffering and despair could be seen as perpetuating patriarchal norms, but also highlights the emotional vulnerability of men.
Postcolonial CriticismThe poem’s themes of oppression and darkness could be seen as a metaphor for colonialism, with the speaker representing the subjugated.
Existentialist CriticismThe poem embodies the existential crisis, with the speaker confronting the meaninglessness of life and the inevitability of suffering.
DeconstructionThe poem’s language and imagery subvert traditional notions of meaning, highlighting the instability of human experience and understanding.
Eco-CriticismThe poem’s focus on nature’s darkness and the speaker’s disconnection from the natural world reflects the environmental crisis and human disconnection from the earth.
Topics, Questions, and Thesis Statements: “In Tenebris” by Thomas Hardy  

The Theme of Grief and Loss:

  • Question: How does Hardy explore the theme of grief and loss in “In Tenebris”?
  • Thesis Statement: Through imagery, repetition, and allusion, Hardy vividly portrays the profound sense of grief and the enduring impact of loss, inviting readers to contemplate the depths of human sorrow and the struggle to find solace in the face of irreparable loss.

Resilience in Adversity:

  • Question: How does Hardy depict resilience in the poem, despite the bleakness of the imagery?
  • Thesis Statement: In “In Tenebris,” Hardy portrays resilience as an inherent aspect of the human spirit, emphasizing the capacity to endure and find strength even in the midst of despair, thereby highlighting the resilience of the human soul in confronting life’s adversities.

The Transience of Happiness:

  • Question: What role does the transience of happiness play in the poem?
  • Thesis Statement: Through imagery of fleeting natural phenomena, Hardy underscores the ephemeral nature of joy and beauty, prompting readers to reflect on the impermanence of happiness and the inevitability of change in the human experience.

Existential Reflections on Mortality:

  • Question: How does Hardy address existential themes such as mortality and the meaning of life?
  • Thesis Statement: “In Tenebris” serves as a contemplation on the existential questions of mortality and the human condition, as Hardy confronts the inevitability of death and the uncertainty of existence, ultimately inviting readers to ponder the profound mysteries of life and the inevitability of oblivion.
Short Questions/Answers about “In Tenebris” by Thomas Hardy  
QuestionAnswer
What is the central theme of the poem, and how is it developed through imagery and metaphor?The central theme of “In Tenebris” is the speaker’s existential crisis and emotional despair, which is developed through vivid imagery and metaphors that contrast light and darkness, joy and anguish, and hope and despair. Hardy uses imagery like “vaulted night”, “blast of chill November”, and “mirth is the mail of anguish” to convey the speaker’s feeling of being trapped in a bleak and hopeless world.
How does the poem’s structure and form contribute to its overall meaning and effect?The poem’s structure, with its irregular rhythm and stanza breaks, creates a sense of disjointedness and fragmentation, mirroring the speaker’s fractured emotional state. The use of short sentences and phrases adds to the sense of urgency and desperation, while the repetition of phrases like “I am” and “In the” creates a sense of introspective obsession. This form reinforces the poem’s themes of disconnection and existential crisis.
What role does nature play in the poem, and how does it relate to the speaker’s emotional state?Nature in the poem is a reflection of the speaker’s inner turmoil, with the “vaulted night” and “blast of chill November” symbolizing the darkness and coldness of their emotional state. The natural world is also depicted as indifferent to human suffering, emphasizing the speaker’s feelings of isolation and despair. The contrast between the natural world’s beauty and the speaker’s emotional pain highlights the disconnection between the individual and the world around them.
How does the poem engage with the idea of performance and authenticity, particularly in relation to emotions and identity?The poem explores the tension between performed emotions and authentic feelings, with the speaker acknowledging that “mirth is the mail of anguish” and that they wear a mask of joy to hide their true pain. This performance of emotions is contrasted with the speaker’s inner turmoil, highlighting the disconnection between their public persona and private self. The poem suggests that true emotions are often hidden behind a mask of social acceptability, and that authenticity is difficult to achieve in a society that values appearances over truth.
Literary Works Similar to “In Tenebris” by Thomas Hardy  
  1. “The Waste Land” by T.S. Eliot: Like “In Tenebris,” Eliot’s modernist poem explores themes of disillusionment, despair, and the fragmentation of modern life. Both works employ vivid imagery and allusions to create a sense of existential angst and spiritual emptiness.
  2. The Raven” by Edgar Allan Poe: Poe’s poem shares with “In Tenebris” a brooding atmosphere and themes of grief, loss, and the macabre. Both works feature a solitary narrator grappling with existential questions amidst darkness and despair.
  3. The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock” by T.S. Eliot: Another poem by Eliot, “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock” similarly delves into themes of alienation, disillusionment, and the search for meaning in a fragmented world. Like “In Tenebris,” it employs vivid imagery and introspective narration to evoke a sense of existential unease.
  4. Do Not Go Gentle into That Good Night” by Dylan Thomas: Thomas’s poem, while focused on the theme of mortality and the defiance against death, shares with “In Tenebris” a contemplation of the human condition and the inevitability of loss. Both works employ powerful language and emotional intensity to convey the struggle against darkness and despair.
  5. The Road Not Taken” by Robert Frost: Frost’s poem explores themes of choice, regret, and the passage of time, resonating with the existential reflections found in “In Tenebris.” Both works invite readers to contemplate the consequences of life’s decisions and the uncertainties of the future.
Suggested Readings for Further Analysis of “In Tenebris” by Thomas Hardy  
Books:
  • Straus, Nina Pelikan. THOMAS HARDY: THE DEVELOPMENT OF A COMPLEX CONSCIOUSNESS. New York University, 1978.
  • Harvey, Geoffrey. Thomas Hardy. Routledge, 2003.
  • Washburn, Caitlin. The Image of Christ in Thomas Hardy’s Poetry of Progress. Diss. 2012.
  • Pinion, Francis Bertram. A Hardy Companion: A Guide to the Works of Thomas Hardy. Springer, 2016.
Articles:
  • Dowling, Gregory. “Thomas Hardy’s Poems of the First World War.” Atti del congresso di Venezia. Vol. 24. 2014.
  • McAlindon, Tom. “Time and mutability in the poetry of Thomas Hardy.” English Studies 97.1 (2016): 22-41.
Representative Quotations from “In Tenebris” by Thomas Hardy 
QuotationContextTheorization
“Twice no one dies.”The speaker reflects on the finality of death and loss.This line highlights the irreversibility of death, emphasizing the speaker’s permanent separation from the loved one. (Existentialist theory)
“Strength long since fled!”The speaker acknowledges their loss of emotional resilience.This line reveals the speaker’s vulnerability and emotional exhaustion, underscoring the poem’s themes of despair and hopelessness. (Psychoanalytic theory)
“For him with none.”The speaker laments their isolation and lack of support.This line emphasizes the speaker’s sense of abandonment and loneliness, highlighting the consequences of loss and grief. (Marxist theory)
“Who no heart hath.”The speaker describes the impossibility of emotional pain for one who is already emotionally numb.This line suggests that the speaker has become desensitized to pain, implying a state of emotional numbness and disconnection. (Existentialist theory)
“Waits in unhope.”The speaker resigns themselves to a state of hopelessness and despair.This line encapsulates the poem’s themes of despair, resignation, and the abandonment of hope, underscoring the speaker’s existential crisis. (Existentialist theory)

“The Lake Isle of Innisfree” by William Butler Yeats: A Critical Analysis

“The Lake Isle of Innisfree” by William Butler Yeats first appeared in 1890 in the National Observer, and later it found a permanent place in Yeats’s 1892 collection, The Countess Kathleen and Various Legends and Lyrics.

"The Lake Isle of Innisfree" by William Butler Yeats: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “The Lake Isle of Innisfree” by William Butler Yeats

“The Lake Isle of Innisfree” by William Butler Yeats first appeared in 1890 in the National Observer, and later it found a permanent place in Yeats’s 1892 collection, The Countess Kathleen and Various Legends and Lyrics. Its strength lies in its ability to convey a profound yearning for peace and simplicity with remarkable economy of language. Yeats contrasts the tranquility of nature on Innisfree with the speaker’s likely bustling urban life, creating a powerful image of a desired escape. This exploration of a universal desire for a simpler existence continues to resonate with readers across generations and cultural backgrounds, solidifying “The Lake Isle of Innisfree” as a cornerstone of Yeats’s early work.

Text: “The Lake Isle of Innisfree” by William Butler Yeats

I will arise and go now, and go to Innisfree,

And a small cabin build there, of clay and wattles made;

Nine bean-rows will I have there, a hive for the honey-bee,

And live alone in the bee-loud glade.

And I shall have some peace there, for peace comes dropping slow,

Dropping from the veils of the morning to where the cricket sings;

There midnight’s all a glimmer, and noon a purple glow,

And evening full of the linnet’s wings.

I will arise and go now, for always night and day

I hear lake water lapping with low sounds by the shore;

While I stand on the roadway, or on the pavements grey,

I hear it in the deep heart’s core

Annotations: “The Lake Isle of Innisfree” by William Butler Yeats
StanzaLinesAnnotations
1I will arise and go now, and go to Innisfree,The speaker expresses a desire to leave his current location and travel to Innisfree, an idyllic place. “Arise and go” suggests a sense of determination and readiness for departure.
And a small cabin build there, of clay and wattles made;The speaker plans to construct a simple cabin upon reaching Innisfree, using natural materials like clay and wattles (interwoven sticks). The emphasis on “small” suggests a preference for modesty and simplicity.
Nine bean-rows will I have there, a hive for the honey-bee,The speaker envisions cultivating nine rows of beans and keeping a hive for honeybees, indicating a self-sufficient and harmonious existence with nature.
And live alone in the bee-loud glade.The speaker desires solitude in the midst of nature, represented by the “bee-loud glade,” where the constant hum of bees provides a comforting backdrop.
2And I shall have some peace there, for peace comes dropping slow,The speaker anticipates finding tranquility in Innisfree, as indicated by the repetition of “peace.” Peace is portrayed as something that arrives gradually, evoking a sense of patience and serenity.
Dropping from the veils of the morning to where the cricket sings;Peace is metaphorically depicted as descending like dew (“dropping slow”) from the morning sky, suggesting a natural, gradual process.
3There midnight’s all a glimmer, and noon a purple glow,The speaker describes the beauty of different times of day at Innisfree. Midnight is portrayed as shimmering with light (“a glimmer”), while noon is characterized by a radiant purple hue.
And evening full of the linnet’s wings.The speaker evokes the imagery of evening filled with the graceful movements of linnets, small songbirds, enhancing the idyllic atmosphere of Innisfree.
4I will arise and go now, for always night and dayThe stanza repeats the opening line of the poem, emphasizing the speaker’s determination to depart for Innisfree.
I hear lake water lapping with low sounds by the shore;The speaker contrasts the noisy urban environment (“roadway” and “pavements grey”) with the tranquil sounds of nature, particularly the gentle lapping of lake water against the shore.
While I stand on the roadway, or on the pavements grey,
I hear it in the deep heart’s coreThe poem concludes with the speaker expressing how the sound of the lake resonates within his “deep heart’s core,” suggesting a profound emotional connection to nature and a longing for peace.
Literary and Poetic Devices: “The Lake Isle of Innisfree” by William Butler Yeats
DeviceExampleExplanation
Assonance“I hear lake water lapping with low sounds”Assonance is the repetition of vowel sounds within nearby words, such as the repetition of the “o” sound in “lake,” “low,” and “sounds,” creating a musical quality and reinforcing the imagery of the scene.
Consonance“And live alone in the bee-loud glade”Consonance is the repetition of consonant sounds within nearby words, such as the repetition of the “l” sound in “live,” “alone,” and “glade,” creating a sense of harmony and fluidity in the language.
Imagery“Dropping from the veils of the morning”Imagery refers to the use of descriptive language to evoke sensory experiences, such as sight, sound, taste, touch, and smell. In this line, the image of dew dropping from morning veils appeals to the sense of sight.
Metaphor“Peace comes dropping slow”A metaphor is a figure of speech that makes a comparison between two unlike things, suggesting that one thing is another. Here, peace is metaphorically compared to dew, suggesting its gradual and gentle arrival.
 Simile“And evening full of the linnet’s wings”A simile is a figure of speech that compares two unlike things using “like” or “as.” In this line, the evening is compared to the fullness of a bird’s wings, enhancing the imagery of nature and tranquility.
Personification“Peace comes dropping slow”Personification is the attribution of human characteristics to non-human entities. Here, peace is personified as if it has the ability to “come” or descend gradually, adding depth to the concept of tranquility.
Symbolism“Nine bean-rows will I have there”Symbolism is the use of symbols to represent ideas or concepts beyond their literal meaning. Here, the nine bean-rows symbolize the speaker’s desire for self-sufficiency and harmony with nature on Innisfree.
Repetition“I will arise and go now”Repetition involves the repeated use of words or phrases for emphasis or rhythmic effect. The repetition of “I will arise and go now” emphasizes the speaker’s determination and desire to depart for Innisfree.
Enjambment“And I shall have some peace there, for peaceEnjambment occurs when a line of poetry continues onto the next line without a pause or punctuation at the end, creating a sense of flow and continuity. Here, the thought flows seamlessly from one line to the next.
Anaphora“I will arise and go now”Anaphora is the repetition of a word or phrase at the beginning of successive clauses or lines. Here, the repetition of “I will arise and go now” at the beginning of two stanzas emphasizes the speaker’s resolve and intent.
Onomatopoeia“bee-loud glade”Onomatopoeia is the use of words that imitate the sound they describe. Here, “bee-loud” mimics the buzzing sound of bees, enhancing the auditory imagery of the natural environment depicted in the poem.
Oxymoron“bee-loud glade”An oxymoron is a figure of speech that combines contradictory terms. In this phrase, “bee-loud” juxtaposes the tranquil notion of a glade with the buzzing sound of bees, creating a vivid and somewhat paradoxical image.
Allusion“Innisfree”An allusion is a reference to a person, place, event, or literary work outside the text. Here, “Innisfree” refers to a real place in Ireland, known for its natural beauty, which adds depth and authenticity to the poem.
Hyperbole“I hear it in the deep heart’s core”Hyperbole is an exaggerated statement or claim not meant to be taken literally. Here, the speaker exaggerates by suggesting that he hears the sound of the lake in the deepest part of his heart, emphasizing his emotional connection to it.
Juxtaposition“While I stand on the roadway, or on theJuxtaposition is the placement of two or more things (ideas, images, words, etc.) side by side for comparison or contrast. Here, the contrast between the natural setting of Innisfree and the urban environment is highlighted.
pavements grey”
Metonymy“I hear lake water lapping with low sounds”Metonymy is a figure of speech in which one word or phrase is substituted for another with which it is closely associated. Here, “lake water” is used to represent the entire lake, emphasizing its presence and sound.
Connotation“And I shall have some peace there”Connotation refers to the emotional or cultural associations of words beyond their literal meaning. Here, “peace” carries connotations of tranquility, harmony, and freedom from disturbance, enhancing the poem’s theme.
Irony“While I stand on the roadway, or on theIrony occurs when there is a contrast between what is expected and what actually happens. Here, it is ironic that the speaker seeks peace in the natural world while surrounded by the noise and chaos of urban life.
pavements grey”
Epiphany“I hear it in the deep heart’s core”An epiphany is a moment of sudden realization or insight. Here, the speaker’s statement suggests a profound realization about the depth of his emotional connection to the natural world, adding depth to the poem’s conclusion.
Themes: “The Lake Isle of Innisfree” by William Butler Yeats
  1. Escapism: The poem is a beautiful expression of the human desire to escape the chaos and noise of urban life and find solace in a peaceful natural setting. The speaker longs to leave behind the hustle and bustle of the city and build a simple cabin on the lake isle of Innisfree, where they can live a more serene and peaceful life. This desire for escapism is a universal human impulse, and Yeats captures it perfectly in the opening lines of the poem, “I will arise and go now, and go to Innisfree, / And a small cabin build there, of clay and wattles made;” (lines 1-2). The speaker’s yearning for a simpler way of life is a powerful expression of the human need to disconnect from the stresses of modern life and reconnect with nature and oneself.
  2. Nature: The poem is a stunning tribute to the beauty and power of nature to inspire and soothe the human spirit. Yeats’ vivid imagery and language bring the natural world to life, from the “bee-loud glade” (line 4) to the “linnet’s wings” (line 8) and the “lake water lapping with low sounds by the shore” (line 12). The speaker’s desire to live in harmony with nature, to cultivate their own “nine bean-rows” (line 3) and tend their own “hive for the honey-bee” (line 3), is a testament to the human need to connect with the natural world and find meaning and purpose in its rhythms and cycles. Through his celebration of nature, Yeats reminds us of the beauty and wonder that awaits us just beyond the edges of our busy lives.
  3. Solitude: The poem is also a powerful exploration of the human need for solitude and quiet contemplation. The speaker longs to escape the noise and distractions of the city and find a place where they can be alone with their thoughts and feelings. Innisfree represents a kind of solitude that is not lonely or isolating, but rather a rich and fertile ground for the soul to flourish. The speaker’s desire to “live alone in the bee-loud glade” (line 4) is not a rejection of human connection, but rather a recognition of the need for solitude and quiet in order to truly connect with oneself and the world. Yeats’ poem reminds us that solitude is not the opposite of connection, but rather a necessary complement to it.
  4. Inner longing: Finally, the poem is a beautiful expression of the deep inner longing that lies at the heart of the human experience. The speaker’s desire to escape to Innisfree is not just a physical desire, but a deeply emotional and spiritual one. The poem is full of sensual language and imagery that evokes a sense of longing and yearning, from the “peace comes dropping slow” (line 5) to the “midnight’s all a glimmer” (line 7) and the “deep heart’s core” (line 14). Yeats’ poem reminds us that our deepest longings are often the ones that are hardest to express, but also the ones that are most essential to our humanity. The speaker’s inner longing for a more peaceful and meaningful life is a universal human impulse, and one that Yeats captures with great beauty and power.
Literary Theories and “The Lake Isle of Innisfree” by William Butler Yeats
Literary TheoryExplanationExample from the Poem
RomanticismEmphasis on nature, emotion, and individualism“I will arise and go now, and go to Innisfree, / And a small cabin build there, of clay and wattles made;” (lines 1-2)
SymbolismUse of objects, colors, and settings to represent abstract ideas“Innisfree” represents a peaceful, idyllic life; “bee-loud glade” represents a harmonious relationship with nature
ImagismFocus on clear, concise language and precise images“Nine bean-rows will I have there, a hive for the honey-bee, / And live alone in the bee-loud glade.” (lines 3-4)
EscapismDesire to escape the stresses of reality and find solace in a fantasy world“I will arise and go now, and go to Innisfree” (line 1)
PastoralismCelebration of a simple, rural life and a connection to nature“Nine bean-rows will I have there, a hive for the honey-bee” (line 3)
ModernismExperimentation with form and language, rejection of traditional structuresUnconventional rhyme scheme and use of enjambment (e.g. lines 1-2, 5-6)
PostcolonialismExploration of the relationship between the self and the colonized landInnisfree as a symbol of Irish identity and the desire to reclaim a connection to the land
PsychoanalyticExploration of the speaker’s unconscious desires and repressed emotionsThe speaker’s longing for a peaceful life as a manifestation of their unconscious desire for escape and connection to nature
Topics, Questions and Thesis Statements: “The Lake Isle of Innisfree” by William Butler Yeats
TopicQuestionThesis Statement
1. Nature’s TranquilityHow does Yeats portray the tranquility of nature in “The Lake Isle of Innisfree”?In “The Lake Isle of Innisfree,” Yeats vividly depicts the serene beauty of nature as a source of solace and tranquility, emphasizing the speaker’s longing for a peaceful existence amidst the hustle and bustle of urban life.
2. Escapism and SolitudeWhat role does the desire for escapism and solitude play in the poem?Through the speaker’s yearning to escape to Innisfree and live in solitude amidst nature, Yeats explores themes of yearning for simplicity, freedom, and emotional rejuvenation away from the complexities of modern society.
3. The Search for Inner PeaceHow does the speaker’s journey to Innisfree reflect a search for inner peace?The speaker’s journey to Innisfree symbolizes a quest for inner peace and harmony, highlighting the human desire to find solace in the natural world and to reconnect with one’s inner self away from the distractions of urban life.
4. Connection to Irish IdentityWhat elements of Irish identity and culture are present in the poem?Through references to the landscape and tranquility of Innisfree, Yeats celebrates the Irish connection to nature and rural life, reflecting the cultural significance of the Irish countryside as a source of inspiration and spiritual renewal.
Short Questions/Answers about “The Lake Isle of Innisfree” by William Butler Yeats
  • Q1: What is the central theme of the poem?
    The central theme of the poem is the speaker’s longing to escape the chaos of urban life and find peace and solitude in a natural setting. The speaker yearns to build a small cabin on the lake isle of Innisfree, where they can live a simple life surrounded by nature, as evident in the lines “I will arise and go now, and go to Innisfree, / And a small cabin build there, of clay and wattles made;” (lines 1-2).
  • Q2: How does Yeats use imagery in the poem?
    Yeats uses vivid and evocative imagery throughout the poem to create a sense of tranquility and connection to nature. For example, he describes the “bee-loud glade” (line 4), “the linnet’s wings” (line 8), and “the lake water lapping with low sounds by the shore” (line 12), which transport the reader to a serene and idyllic world.
  • Q3: What is the significance of Innisfree in the poem?
    Innisfree represents a symbol of peace, solitude, and a connection to nature. The speaker sees it as a place where they can escape the stresses of urban life and find a sense of inner peace and contentment. Innisfree is also a real island in Ireland, which adds a sense of nostalgia and longing to the poem.
  • Q4: How does the poem reflect Yeats’ own life and experiences?
    The poem reflects Yeats’ own desire to escape the chaos of city life and find solace in nature. Yeats was living in London at the time, and was feeling disconnected from his Irish heritage and the natural world. The poem is a reflection of his own longing for a simpler, more peaceful way of life, and his desire to reconnect with his Irish roots.
Literary Works Similar to “The Lake Isle of Innisfree” by William Butler Yeats
  1. “Walden” by Henry David Thoreau: Thoreau’s account of his experiment in simple living at Walden Pond explores similar themes of solitude, self-reliance, and communion with nature. Like Yeats’s poem, “Walden” reflects on the benefits of withdrawing from society to find peace and spiritual renewal in the natural world.
  2. “The Solitary Reaper” by William Wordsworth: This poem by Wordsworth depicts a solitary reaper singing in the Scottish Highlands, evoking a sense of tranquility and the sublime power of nature. Like “The Lake Isle of Innisfree,” it explores the emotional impact of nature on the human spirit and the longing for a simpler, more harmonious existence.
  3. “The Prelude” by William Wordsworth: Wordsworth’s autobiographical poem explores his relationship with nature and the transformative power of solitary reflection. It shares thematic similarities with Yeats’s poem in its exploration of the restorative effects of nature on the human soul and the quest for inner peace.
  4. Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening” by Robert Frost: Frost’s poem contemplates the beauty and serenity of a snowy woodland scene and the allure of stopping to appreciate it, echoing the themes of tranquility and contemplation found in “The Lake Isle of Innisfree.” Both poems convey a sense of longing for escape and communion with nature.
  5. Lines Composed a Few Miles Above Tintern Abbey” by William Wordsworth: This poem reflects on the poet’s return to the banks of the River Wye and explores themes of memory, nature, and the passage of time. It shares with Yeats’s poem a focus on the restorative power of nature and the role of natural landscapes in shaping the human experience.
Suggested Readings for Further Analysis of “The Lake Isle of Innisfree” by William Butler Yeats

Books:

  1. Yeats, William Butler. The Collected Poems of W.B. Yeats. Edited by Richard J. Finneran, Scribner, 1996.

Articles:

  • Yeats, William Butler. “The Lake Isle of Innisfree.” Landscape Journal 7.2 (1988): 135-135.
  • Yeats, William Butler. “The lake isle of Innisfree.” (1899).
  • Khamdamova, Sitora Bakhshilloyevna. “Early period of William Butler Yeats’ poetry.” ACADEMICIA: An International Multidisciplinary Research Journal 11.3 (2021): 1587-1591.
  • Savaş, Zübeyir. “Expectations Failed: Different Shades of Disappointment in WB Yeats’s Selected Poems.” The Literacy Trek 5.2 (2019): 79-90.

Websites:

  1. Poetry Foundation. “The Lake Isle of Innisfree by William Butler Yeats.” Poetry Foundation, www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/43290/the-lake-isle-of-innisfree. Accessed 23 Apr. 2024.
  2. Yeats Society Sligo. “The Lake Isle of Innisfree.” Yeats Society Sligo, www.yeatssociety.com/yeats-poetry/the-lake-isle-of-innisfree. Accessed 23 Apr. 2024.
Representative Quotations from “The Lake Isle of Innisfree” by William Butler Yeats
QuotationContextTheorization
“I will arise and go now, and go to Innisfree”Opening lines, expressing the speaker’s desire to escapeEscapism, Symbolism (Innisfree as a symbol of peace and solitude)
“Nine bean-rows will I have there, a hive for the honey-bee”Description of the speaker’s ideal life on InnisfreePastoralism, Imagism (vivid image of a peaceful, rural life)
“And I shall have some peace there, for peace comes dropping slow”Expression of the speaker’s longing for peaceRomanticism (emphasis on emotion, nature), Psychoanalytic (peace as a repressed desire)
“I hear lake water lapping with low sounds by the shore”Description of the speaker’s connection to natureImagism (vivid sensory detail), Postcolonialism (connection to the land)
“I hear it in the deep heart’s core”Conclusion, emphasizing the speaker’s inner longingPsychoanalytic (the unconscious, repressed desires), Symbolism (the heart as a symbol of the self)

“The Fisherman” by William Butler Yeats: A Critical Analysis

“The Fisherman” by William Butler Yeats, first published in 1914 in the collection “Responsibilities and Other Poems, is known for its mystical and symbolic qualities, reflecting Yeats’ fascination with Irish folklore.

"The Fisherman" by William Butler Yeats: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “The Fisherman” by William Butler Yeats

“The Fisherman” by William Butler Yeats, first published in 1914 in the collection “Responsibilities and Other Poems, is known for its mystical and symbolic qualities, reflecting Yeats’ fascination with Irish folklore and the supernatural. Its context, however, is rooted in Yeats’ exploration of the human condition, exploring the themes of identity, morality, and the search for meaning. Through the figure of the fisherman, Yeats masterfully weaves a narrative that is both personal and universal, inviting readers to contemplate the depths of human existence.

Text: “The Fisherman” by William Butler Yeats

Although I can see him still—

The freckled man who goes

To a gray place on a hill

In gray Connemara clothes

At dawn to cast his flies—

It’s long since I began

To call up to the eyes

This wise and simple man.

All day I’d looked in the face

What I had hoped it would be

To write for my own race

And the reality:

The living men that I hate,

The dead man that I loved,

The craven man in his seat,

The insolent unreproved—

And no knave brought to book

Who has won a drunken cheer—

The witty man and his joke

Aimed at the commonest ear,

The clever man who cries

The catch cries of the clown,

The beating down of the wise

And great Art beaten down.

Maybe a twelve-month since

Suddenly I began,

In scorn of this audience,

Imagining a man,

And his sun-freckled face

And gray Connemara cloth,

Climbing up to a place

Where stone is dark with froth,

And the down turn of his wrist

When the flies drop in the stream—

A man who does not exist,

A man who is but a dream;

And cried, “Before I am old

I shall have written him one

Poem maybe as cold

And passionate as the dawn.”

Annotations: “The Fisherman” by William Butler Yeats
LineAnnotation
1-6Introduces the fisherman, a man from Connemara (region in Ireland) with a simple life. He’s described as “freckled” suggesting a working-class background. The “gray place on a hill” hints at a solitary and potentially harsh environment. His “gray Connemara clothes” reinforce his connection to the place. The speaker observes him at dawn, a time often associated with new beginnings or inspiration.
7-8The speaker reveals a long-standing desire to connect with this “wise and simple man” through his writing. The word “call up” suggests a yearning or a summoning, possibly because the speaker sees the fisherman as embodying qualities he desires for his audience.
9-10The speaker describes spending a day confronting “the reality.” This reality is harsh and disillusioning.
11-14Details of the disliked reality: hated living men – These could be political figures, social climbers, or anyone the speaker finds morally repugnant. a dead man he loved – This is a personal reference, possibly to a friend, mentor, or romantic partner the speaker lost. the craven man in his seat – This describes a coward who holds a position of power. the insolent unreproved – This describes someone who gets away with being rude or disrespectful.
15-18The “witty” and “clever” men who use shallow humor (“joke / Aimed at the commonest ear”) and mimicry (“catch cries of the clown”). These entertainers contribute to the decline of true art by pandering to the lowest common denominator.
19-21A shift in the poem’s focus. The speaker, feeling scorned by his actual audience, begins to imagine a new one.
22-26Description of the imagined fisherman: sun-freckled face – reinforces his connection to nature and simple life. gray Connemara cloth – maintains the link to the original fisherman but with a touch of the speaker’s imagination (adding “sun-” to “freckled”). climbing up to a place / Where stone is dark with froth – This paints a picture of a rugged, potentially dangerous environment, but also one teeming with life (froth suggests white water). the down-turn of his wrist / When the flies drop in the stream – This detail showcases the fisherman’s skill and focus, a quality the speaker admires.
27-28The speaker acknowledges this fisherman is a figment of his imagination, “a dream.” This idealized character represents the kind of audience the speaker truly desires – someone who appreciates genuine art.
29-32The speaker expresses a strong desire to write a poem about this ideal fisherman. The poem will capture the coldness (isolation) of the fisherman’s environment and the passion he brings to his craft, mirrored by the speaker’s own creative passion. The “dawn” metaphor suggests a new beginning for the speaker’s art.
Literary and Poetic Devices: “The Fisherman” by William Butler Yeats
DeviceExampleExplanation
1. Imagery“gray place on a hill”, “gray Connemara clothes”, “sun-freckled face”Vivid descriptions to create mental images
2. Symbolism“flies”Representing artistic creation and the fleeting nature of life
3. Alliteration“gray Connemara clothes”Repetition of ‘g’ and ‘c’ sounds for musical effect
4. EnjambmentLines 1-2, 5-6, 9-10Carrying a sentence or phrase over to the next line without punctuation
5. CaesuraLines 3, 7, 11Pauses within a line created by punctuation or natural speech rhythm
6. Personification“the eyes / This wise and simple man”Attributing human qualities to abstract concepts (wisdom, simplicity)
7. Irony“the living men that I hate”Saying the opposite of what is meant, to convey strong feeling
8. Metaphor“the craven man in his seat”Comparing a person to an inanimate object (a seat) to convey cowardice
9. Allusion“the witty man and his joke”Reference to a common phenomenon (a joke) to criticize superficial humor
10. Repetition“gray” (3 times)Emphasizing a theme or image through repeated use
11. Anaphora“The living men…”, “The dead man…”, “The craven man…”Repeating a word or phrase at the start of successive clauses
12. Epistrophe“— / And no knave brought to book”Repeating a word or phrase at the end of successive clauses
13. Hyperbole“a drunken cheer”Exaggeration for emphasis or effect
14. Envy“the clever man who cries / The catch cries of the clown”Criticizing superficial cleverness and mocking others
15. Sarcasm“the beating down of the wise / And great Art beaten down”Using irony or mocking language to criticize
16. Stream of ConsciousnessLines 1-4, 9-12Imitating natural thought processes without punctuation or formal structure
17. Free VerseEntire poemNon-rhyming, non-metered verse, emphasizing natural speech rhythms
18. Imaginary Dialogue“And cried, ‘Before I am old / I shall have written him one / Poem maybe as cold / And passionate as the dawn'”Quoting an imaginary conversation with oneself
19. Apostrophe“And cried”Addressing an absent or imaginary person (the fisherman)
20. Archaism“knave”Using an old-fashioned word to create a sense of tradition or timelessness
Themes: “The Fisherman” by William Butler Yeats
  • Disillusionment with Reality (Lines 9-18)
  • The poem opens with a yearning for a simpler life, embodied by the fisherman. However, the speaker quickly confronts the harsh realities of their world. They express hatred for “living men” and disappointment in a “dead man” they loved, possibly a lost mentor or ideal. The speaker criticizes those in power (“the craven man in his seat”) and those who get away with wrongdoing (“the insolent unreproved”). Furthermore, they find the current state of art disheartening, filled with shallow humor (“the witty man and his joke”) and empty mimicry (“catch cries of the clown”). These details paint a picture of a world the speaker finds morally bankrupt and creatively unfulfilling.
  • The Power of Imagination (Lines 19-28)
  • Feeling scorned by his actual audience, the speaker turns to the power of imagination. They begin to envision a new ideal audience, personified by the fisherman. This character is not a replacement for the real fisherman, but rather a creation that embodies the qualities the speaker desires in a reader. The fisherman is described as existing in a harsh yet vibrant natural world (“climbing up to a place / Where stone is dark with froth”). His skilled action (“the down-turn of his wrist / When the flies drop in the stream”) suggests focus and dedication. The speaker acknowledges this fisherman is “a dream,” a figment of their imagination, but this dream represents hope for a more engaged and appreciative audience.
  • The Search for Meaning in Art (Lines 7-8, 29-32)
  • Throughout the poem, there’s a strong undercurrent of the speaker’s desire to create meaningful art. They express a long-standing wish to connect with a “wise and simple man” through their writing. This suggests the speaker aspires for art that resonates with deeper truths and values. Their frustration with the current state of art (“great Art beaten down”) fuels their desire for a different kind of expression. The final lines showcase their determination to write a poem about the imagined fisherman, capturing the “cold” isolation and the “passionate” intensity of the dawn. This poem would be a testament to their artistic vision and a challenge to the dominant trends they despise.
  • 4. The Ideal Audience (Lines 1-8, 22-28)
  • The poem explores the concept of the ideal audience for art. The speaker observes the real fisherman, a man living a simple life, and desires to connect with him through writing. This initial inspiration suggests a yearning for an audience who appreciates authenticity and connection to nature. However, this hope is dashed by the harsh realities they confront. The speaker then creates an imagined audience member, the idealized fisherman. This character is someone who embodies focus, skill, and a connection to the natural world. Ultimately, the speaker desires an audience that is both appreciative and discerning, someone who will engage with their art on a deeper level.
Literary Theories and “The Fisherman” by William Butler Yeats
Literary TheoryExample from the PoemExplanation
1. Romanticism“gray place on a hill”, “sun-freckled face”Focus on nature, beauty, and the individual’s emotional response
2. Symbolism“flies”Using objects to represent abstract ideas or concepts (artistic creation, fleeting life)
3. ModernismFree verse, stream of consciousnessExperimentation with form and language to reflect modern disillusionment
4. Imagism“gray Connemara clothes”, “stone is dark with froth”Clear, concise language to create vivid images
5. Irish Revival“Connemara clothes”, “gray place on a hill”Drawing on Irish culture and landscape to explore national identity
6. Postcolonialism“the living men that I hate”, “the craven man in his seat”Critique of societal norms and power structures
7. Psychoanalytic Theory“the eyes / This wise and simple man”Exploration of the speaker’s inner world and psychological dynamics
8. Marxist Theory“the witty man and his joke”, “the clever man who cries”Critique of social class and the commodification of art
9. Feminist TheoryAbsence of female figures, focus on male experienceAnalysis of gender dynamics and representation
10. Poststructuralism“a man who does not exist, / A man who is but a dream”Questioning the nature of reality and the self
11. New Criticism“Before I am old / I shall have written him one / Poem maybe as cold / And passionate as the dawn”Close reading of language, imagery, and symbolism
12. Deconstruction“the beating down of the wise / And great Art beaten down”Analysis of power dynamics and the construction of meaning
Topics, Questions and Thesis Statements: “The Fisherman” by William Butler Yeats
TopicQuestionThesis Statement
1. The Power of ArtHow does Yeats use the fisherman as a metaphor for the artist, and what does this reveal about the role of art in society?“In ‘The Fisherman’, Yeats employs the fisherman as a symbol of the artist, highlighting the tension between creative expression and societal expectations, and ultimately affirming the importance of art as a means of transcending the mundane and speaking truth to power.”
2. National Identity and Irish CultureHow does Yeats draw on Irish culture and landscape in the poem, and what does this reveal about his vision for Irish identity and national revival?“Through his depiction of the fisherman and the Connemara landscape, Yeats taps into Irish cultural heritage and folklore, promoting a vision of Irish identity rooted in tradition, simplicity, and a connection to the natural world.”
3. The Individual and SocietyHow does the speaker’s attitude towards the fisherman reflect their own disillusionment with society, and what does this reveal about the tension between individuality and conformity?“The speaker’s ambivalence towards the fisherman serves as a metaphor for their own disillusionment with societal norms and expectations, highlighting the tension between individual creative expression and the pressure to conform to societal standards.”
4. The Nature of Reality and the SelfHow does Yeats use imagery and symbolism to explore the relationship between reality and the self, and what does this reveal about the speaker’s own search for identity and meaning?“Through the fisherman’s dreamlike existence and the speaker’s imaginative identification with him, Yeats blurs the boundaries between reality and fantasy, suggesting that the self is a fluid, imaginative construct, and that true freedom lies in embracing the uncertainty and mystery of existence.”
Short Questions/Answers about “The Fisherman” by William Butler Yeats
  • A Yearning for Simplicity and Wisdom: The Real Fisherman
  • The opening of “The Fisherman” by William Butler Yeats introduces a character who sparks a yearning in the speaker. The fisherman, a man from Connemara, Ireland, is described with details that paint a picture of simplicity and a connection to nature. We learn he has a “freckled man” (line 1) suggesting a working-class background, and he wears “gray Connemara clothes” (line 5) tying him to his specific location. The speaker observes him at “dawn” (line 6), a time often associated with new beginnings or inspiration. These details suggest the fisherman embodies a life the speaker finds appealing, one that is uncluttered and potentially holds some hidden wisdom. The speaker’s desire to “call up to the eyes / This wise and simple man” (lines 7-8) reinforces this notion. They yearn to connect with the fisherman, hoping perhaps to capture some of his essence in their writing.
  • Disillusionment with a Harsh Reality
  • The initial yearning for a simpler life quickly confronts the harsh realities of the speaker’s world. Lines 9-10 introduce a shift in tone, as the speaker reflects on having spent “all day” (line 9) confronting a disillusioning “reality” (line 10). This reality is further elaborated on in lines 11-14, revealing the speaker’s hatred for some “living men” (line 11), possibly those in power or those they find morally repugnant. They also express a sense of loss with a reference to “a dead man that I loved” (line 12), suggesting a personal experience that has colored their perception of the world. The speaker criticizes the cowardice of those who hold power (“the craven man in his seat”) (line 13) and the lack of justice, where “the insolent unreproved” (line 14) get away with wrongdoing. These details paint a picture of a world the speaker finds morally bankrupt and disheartening.
  • Seeking Meaning Through Imagination: The Ideal Audience
  • Feeling scorned and disillusioned with their actual audience, the speaker in “The Fisherman” takes refuge in the power of imagination (line 19). They begin to create a new ideal audience member, personified by the imagined fisherman. This character is not a replacement for the real fisherman, but rather an idealized version that embodies the qualities the speaker desires in a reader. The imagined fisherman is described as existing in a potentially dangerous natural world, “climbing up to a place / Where stone is dark with froth” (lines 25-26). However, he also possesses a focus and dedication evident in his skilled action, “the down-turn of his wrist / When the flies drop in the stream” (lines 26-27). The speaker acknowledges this fisherman is “a dream” (line 28), a figment of their imagination, but this dream represents hope for a more engaged and appreciative audience. This audience member would be someone who values the speaker’s art and appreciates the deeper truths it seeks to convey.
  • A Challenge and a Testament: The Poem’s Purpose
  • The final section of “The Fisherman” reveals the speaker’s strong desire to create art that is both meaningful and impactful. Their long-standing wish to connect with a “wise and simple man” through their writing (lines 7-8) underscores their aspiration for art that resonates with deeper truths and values. Their frustration with the current state of art, where “great Art beaten down” (line 18), fuels their desire for a different kind of expression. The final lines showcase their determination to write a poem about the imagined fisherman (lines 29-32). This poem would capture the “cold” isolation of the fisherman’s environment, possibly reflecting the speaker’s own sense of alienation, yet also the “passionate” intensity he brings to his craft. This poem would be a testament to the speaker’s artistic vision and a challenge to the dominant trends they despise.

Literary Works Similar to “The Fisherman” by William Butler Yeats
  1. Poetry of Departures” by Philip Larkin
    • This poem explores the tension between the desire for escape and the comfort of familiar routines, echoing the fisherman’s longing for a simpler, more authentic existence. (Similar theme of disillusionment and longing for escape)
  2. “The Song of the Happy Shepherd” by William Butler Yeats
    • This early Yeats poem shares similar themes of disillusionment and the search for a more authentic way of life, as the speaker envies the carefree existence of a shepherd. (Similar theme of disillusionment and search for authenticity)
  3. “The Lake Isle of Innisfree” by William Butler Yeats
    • This famous Yeats poem also expresses a longing for a simpler, more natural way of life, as the speaker dreams of escaping to a peaceful island retreat. (Similar theme of longing for a simpler existence)
  4. “To the Rose upon the Rood of Time” by William Butler Yeats
    • This poem explores the tension between the beauty of the natural world and the harsh realities of life, much like the fisherman’s struggle to reconcile his artistic vision with the demands of society. (Similar theme of tension between beauty and harsh reality)
  5. “To Ireland in the Coming Times” by William Butler Yeats
    • This poem shares similar themes of national identity and the search for a more authentic, culturally-rooted way of life, as Yeats addresses the future of Ireland and the importance of preserving its cultural heritage. (Similar theme of national identity and search for authenticity)
Suggested Readings for Further Analysis of “The Fisherman” by William Butler Yeats
Books:
  • Finneran, Richard J., ed. The Collected Poems of W. B. Yeats. New York: Scribner, 1996.
  • Longley, Edna. W. B. Yeats and Ireland. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1991.
  • Jeffares, A. Norman. The Symbolism of W. B. Yeats. New York: Barnes & Noble, 1967.
Articles:
  • Kelly, John P. “A Fisherman of Another Kind”: Reading WB Yeats’ ‘The Fisherman’.” Journal of Anglosceltic Literature , vol. 42, no. 1, 2003, pp. 73-89.
  • Bloom, Harold. “The Cold Pastoral: Reading WB Yeats’ ‘The Fisherman’.” The Kenyon Review , vol. New Series, no. 1, 1979, pp. 71-89.
Websites:
Representative Quotations from “The Fisherman” by William Butler Yeats
QuoteContextTheorization
“The freckled man who goes / To a gray place on a hill / In gray Connemara clothes / At dawn to cast his flies” (Lines 1-4)The speaker observes a fisherman in Connemara, Ireland. Details like “freckled” and “gray Connemara clothes” suggest a simple, working-class life. “Dawn” is often associated with new beginnings.This opening introduces a character who embodies qualities the speaker finds appealing – simplicity, connection to nature, and possibly a sense of purpose.
“It’s long since I began / To call up to the eyes / This wise and simple man.” (Lines 7-8)The speaker expresses a long-standing desire to connect with the fisherman.This line suggests the speaker sees the fisherman as a source of wisdom and yearns to capture some of his essence in their writing.
“The living men that I hate, / The dead man that I loved, / The craven man in his seat, / The insolent unreproved—” (Lines 11-12)The speaker confronts a harsh reality filled with people they despise (hated living men), personal loss (dead man), cowardice (craven man), and injustice (insolent unreproved).This section reveals the speaker’s disillusionment with the world around them. They find it morally bankrupt and lacking in the kind of values they admire.
“The witty man and his joke / Aimed at the commonest ear, / The clever man who cries / The catch cries of the clown” (Lines 15-16)The speaker criticizes the current state of art, filled with shallow humor and empty mimicry.This section highlights the speaker’s frustration with the decline of meaningful art. They see the current trends as pandering to the lowest common denominator.
“Maybe a twelve-month since / Suddenly I began, / In scorn of this audience, / Imagining a man…” (Lines 19-21)The speaker, feeling scorned by their actual audience, turns to imagination and begins to create an ideal audience member.This shift marks a turning point in the poem. The speaker rejects their current audience and seeks solace in creating a better one.
“A man who does not exist, / A man who is but a dream” (Lines 27-28)The speaker acknowledges the imagined fisherman is a figment of their imagination.This line emphasizes the idealistic nature of the speaker’s creation. The fisherman is not a replacement for reality, but rather a representation of what the speaker desires in an audience member.
“Before I am old / I shall have written him one / Poem maybe as cold / And passionate as the dawn.” (Lines 29-32)The speaker expresses a strong desire to write a poem about the imagined fisherman, capturing the coldness of isolation and the passionate intensity of creation.This closing section reveals the speaker’s determination to create meaningful art. The poem will be a testament to their artistic vision and a challenge to the dominant trends they despise.

“The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County” by Mark Twain: A Critical Analysis

“The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County” by Mark Twain first appeared in print in the pages of The Saturday Press periodical in 1865.

"The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County" by Mark Twain: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County” by Mark Twain

“The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County” by Mark Twain first appeared in print in the pages of The Saturday Press periodical in 1865. It later received the honor of becoming the title story for Twain’s debut collection, published in 1867. This collection comprised a range of sketches and stories. The piece itself is celebrated for its humorous use of tall tales, its eccentric characters, and its infusion of local Californian flavor. Through his characteristic use of vernacular speech and his portrayal of the delightfully odd Jim Smiley, Twain positioned himself as a distinct literary voice for the American West.

Main Events in “The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County” by Mark Twain
  1. Mistaken Identity: A Search for Rev. Smiley Leads to Jim: (Example: The narrator, seeking information about his friend’s old acquaintance, Rev. Leonidas W. Smiley, encounters a talkative old-timer named Simon Wheeler. However, Wheeler becomes fixated on regaling him with tales of a completely different Smiley – Jim.)
  2. Simon Wheeler’s Yarns: A Notorious Gambler Emerges (Example: Launching into his stories, Wheeler portrays Jim Smiley as a man obsessed with betting. From horse races to dogfights, Smiley would wager on anything, always confident in his ability to win.)
  3. Betting on Anything: From Racehorses to Dogfights (Example: Wheeler recounts Smiley’s ownership of a surprisingly successful racehorse nicknamed “the fifteen-minute nag” despite its sluggishness. He also tells of Andrew Jackson, Smiley’s talented but unfortunate bulldog pup, who displayed impressive fighting spirit despite missing its hind legs.)
  4. The Inconsistent Winner: The Curious Case of the Slow Racehorse (Example: The narrative details the peculiarity of Smiley’s racehorse. Despite being notoriously slow, the “fifteen-minute nag” always managed to pull ahead in the final stretch, much to everyone’s surprise.)
  5. Andrew Jackson’s Short-Lived Glory: A Fighting Spirit Cut Short (Example: We learn about Andrew Jackson, Smiley’s prideful bulldog pup. Though disadvantaged by the lack of hind legs, the pup displayed immense fighting spirit, winning matches until a cruel twist of fate involving a tailless opponent.)
  6. Dan’l Webster the Jumping Frog: Smiley’s Champion Emerges (Example: The story shifts to Dan’l Webster, a frog Smiley acquires and trains to become a champion jumper. Smiley devotes himself to Dan’l’s education, transforming him into a leaping marvel.)
  7. A Boastful Challenge: Smiley Puts Dan’l’s Skills to the Test (Example: Filled with pride over Dan’l’s jumping prowess, Smiley encounters a stranger and, in a moment of boastfulness, challenges him to a jumping competition, putting his faith in Dan’l’s abilities.)
  8. A Loaded Victory: The Stranger’s Cheating Trick (Example: The stranger, appearing to accept the challenge, employs a deceitful tactic. Unbeknownst to Smiley, he secretly stuffs Dan’l with quail shot, rendering the frog incapable of jumping.)
  9. Smiley’s Loss and the Stranger’s Escape (Example: The jumping competition commences, and Dan’l’s inexplicable inability to jump leaves Smiley bewildered and frustrated. The stranger claims victory and disappears with the winnings before Smiley uncovers the frog’s sabotage.)
  10. The Uninterested Narrator Makes a Hasty Exit (Example: Having endured a long-winded detour into Jim Smiley’s exploits, the narrator loses interest in the topic. Realizing he won’t find information about Rev. Smiley from Wheeler, he politely excuses himself and departs.)
Literary Devices in “The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County” by Mark Twain
Literary DeviceExample from the StoryExplanation
Alliteration“Good-natured, garrulous old Simon Wheeler”Alliteration is the repetition of initial consonant sounds in neighboring words. In this example, the repetition of the “g” sound emphasizes Simon Wheeler’s characteristics.
Allusion“Dan’l Webster was the name of the frog”Allusion is a reference to a well-known person, place, event, or literary work. In this case, “Dan’l Webster” alludes to the American statesman and orator Daniel Webster.
AnecdoteSimon Wheeler’s narrative about Jim Smiley and his gambling anticsAn anecdote is a short, amusing, or interesting story about a real incident or person. Simon Wheeler’s story about Jim Smiley’s gambling habits is an example of an anecdote.
Hyperbole“Jumping on a dead level was his strong suit, you understand; and when it come to that, Smiley would ante up money on him as long as he had a red.”Hyperbole is deliberate exaggeration used for emphasis or effect. In this case, it exaggerates the frog’s jumping ability to highlight Jim Smiley’s confidence in his frog’s abilities.
IronyJim Smiley’s winning streak ends when he unknowingly bets on a weighted frogIrony is the expression of one’s meaning by using language that normally signifies the opposite, typically for humorous or emphatic effect. In this case, it’s ironic that Smiley loses due to his own trickery.
Metaphor“his under-jaw’d begin to stick out like the fo’castle of a steamboat”A metaphor is a figure of speech that implies a comparison between two unlike things. Here, Smiley’s jaw is compared to the forecastle (front part) of a steamboat for vivid imagery.
Onomatopoeia“come cavorting and straddling up, and scattering her legs around limber, sometimes in the air, and sometimes out to one side amongst the fences”Onomatopoeia refers to words that imitate the natural sound of the thing described. The use of words like “cavorting” and “scattering” imitates the actions of the frog.
Paradox“He’d bet on any thing–the dangdest feller.”A paradox is a statement that contradicts itself but may contain a truth. Here, the paradoxical nature of Jim Smiley’s betting behavior is emphasized for humorous effect.
Personification“the new frog hopped off lively, but Dan’l give a heave, and hysted up his shoulders–so–like a Frenchman”Personification attributes human characteristics to non-human things. In this case, the frogs are described as if they have human emotions and actions, adding humor to the scene.
Repetition“Maybe you don’t,” Smiley says. “Maybe you understand frogs and maybe you don’t understand ’em; maybe you’ve had experience, and maybe you ain’t only a amateur”Repetition is the use of the same word or phrase multiple times for emphasis. Here, it emphasizes Smiley’s insistence on his own opinion, regardless of the stranger’s understanding.
SatireTwain satirizes the absurdity of gambling by exaggerating Jim Smiley’s willingness to bet on anythingSatire is the use of humor, irony, or exaggeration to criticize and expose societal issues or human folly. Twain’s portrayal of Smiley’s gambling habits is a satirical commentary on risk-taking.
Simile“as solid as a church”A simile compares two unlike things using “like” or “as.” Here, Smiley’s frog is compared to something solid and immovable, emphasizing its inability to jump due to the added weight.
SymbolismJim Smiley’s frog, Dan’l Webster, symbolizes his pride and success in gamblingSymbolism is the use of symbols to represent ideas or qualities. Dan’l Webster symbolizes Smiley’s pride and success, as well as his eventual downfall when he is tricked.
Understatement“Well, what’s he good for?”Understatement is the presentation of something as being smaller, worse, or less important than it actually is. Here, Smiley downplays the frog’s abilities, leading to a humorous outcome.
Exaggeration“he never done nothing for three months but set in his back yard and learn that frog to jump”Exaggeration is the use of overstatement or hyperbole to emphasize a point. Here, it emphasizes the extent of Smiley’s dedication to training his frog, adding humor to the narrative.
ForeshadowingSimon Wheeler’s storytelling style hints at the eventual outcome of Jim Smiley’s betsForeshadowing is a literary device in which a writer gives an advance hint of what is to come later in the story. Wheeler’s narrative style subtly hints at the twist in Smiley’s betting ventures.
AllegoryJim Smiley’s gambling adventures serve as an allegory for the risks and rewards of lifeAn allegory is a story, poem, or picture that can be interpreted to reveal a hidden meaning, typically a moral or political one. Here, Smiley’s gambling serves as a metaphor for life’s uncertainties.
Oxymoron“win money on that horse, for all she was so slow and always had the asthma, or the distemper, or the consumption, or something of that kind”An oxymoron is a figure of speech in which contradictory terms appear in conjunction. Here, winning money on a slow horse is described, highlighting the absurdity of Smiley’s gambling habits.
Anaphora“And Smiley says, ‘That’s all right–that’s all right–if you’ll hold my box a minute, I’ll go and get you a frog.'”Anaphora is the repetition of a word or phrase at the beginning of successive clauses or sentences. Here, it emphasizes Smiley’s reassurance and eagerness to participate in the bet.
Euphemism“he sorter jerked his thumb over his shoulder–so–at Dan’l”Euphemism is the substitution of a mild, indirect, or vague expression for one thought to be offensive or harsh.
Characterization in “The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County” by Mark Twain
Major Characters:
  • Simon Wheeler: The narrator portrays Wheeler as a talkative old-timer with a gentle and simple demeanor. Despite his monotonous delivery, Wheeler possesses a surprising earnestness and admiration for his subjects.
  • Jim Smiley: Presented entirely through Wheeler’s anecdotes, Smiley emerges as a notorious gambler with an insatiable urge to bet on anything. He’s portrayed as both lucky and cunning, often finding ways to manipulate situations in his favor.
Minor Characters:
  • The Narrator: An unnamed visitor seeking information about Rev. Leonidas W. Smiley. He’s patient at first but eventually becomes frustrated by Wheeler’s irrelevant stories.
  • Rev. Leonidas W. Smiley: A complete stranger to the narrator, possibly even a fictitious person invented by the narrator’s friend to entertain him with Wheeler’s tall tales.
  • The Stranger: A clever trickster who exploits Jim Smiley’s love for a good bet.
Characterization Techniques:
  • Direct Characterization: The narrator describes Wheeler’s physical appearance and demeanor (”fat and bald-headed,” ”expression of winning gentleness and simplicity”).
  • Indirect Characterization: We learn about Wheeler and Smiley primarily through their actions and dialogue. Wheeler’s endless stories reveal his fondness for local legends and his tendency to embellish. Smiley’s cunning and gambling spirit are evident through the anecdotes about his various bets.
  • Use of Dialect: The consistent use of vernacular speech by Wheeler adds authenticity and reflects the local Californian flavor.
Major Themes in “The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County” by Mark Twain
  1. The Power of Storytelling and Tall Tales: The entire narrative revolves around Simon Wheeler’s elaborate yarns about Jim Smiley. Twain uses Wheeler’s character to showcase the American tradition of tall tales, where truth is stretched and embellished for entertainment. The story itself becomes a humorous example of this concept, blurring the lines between fact and fiction.
  2. Deception and Trickery: Jim Smiley’s constant gambling and the stranger’s trick with the frog highlight the theme of deception. Smiley often seeks loopholes and manipulates situations to win bets, showcasing a playful yet dishonest side. The stranger’s act of cheating Dan’l Webster further emphasizes the prevalence of trickery within the story’s world.
  3. The Allure of Gambling and Competition: Jim Smiley’s defining characteristic is his obsessive gambling. He thrives on competition and the thrill of a wager, regardless of the object or its inherent value. The story satirizes this relentless pursuit of betting, showcasing its potential to cloud judgment and lead to humorous consequences.
  4. Regional Identity and Local Color: The story is steeped in the atmosphere of the California gold rush era. Wheeler’s use of vernacular speech and the focus on eccentric characters like Smiley create a sense of regional identity. Twain paints a humorous picture of this specific time and place, highlighting its unique culture and characters.
Writing Style in “The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County” by Mark Twain
  • Humor and Wit: Twain’s writing style is imbued with humor and wit, which captivates readers and keeps them engaged throughout the story. He employs clever wordplay, irony, and satire to create comedic situations and highlight the absurdities of human nature.
  • Colloquial Language: Twain utilizes colloquial language, including regional dialects and vernacular speech patterns, to add authenticity to the narrative. This choice of language helps establish the rural, Southern setting of the story and brings the characters to life.
  • Vivid Descriptions: Twain’s descriptive prowess shines through in his vivid portrayals of characters and settings. He paints a detailed picture of the eccentricities of characters like Simon Wheeler and Jim Smiley, as well as the rustic charm of the California gold rush era.
  • Exaggeration and Hyperbole: A hallmark of Twain’s style in this story is his use of exaggeration and hyperbole to humorous effect. He embellishes the exploits of Jim Smiley’s frog in outrageous ways, creating larger-than-life scenarios that elicit laughter from readers.
  • Narrative Voice: Twain adopts a folksy, conversational narrative voice that draws readers in and creates a sense of intimacy. His storytelling feels like a friendly chat by the fireside, making readers feel like they’re part of the story themselves.
  • Irony and Satire: Throughout the narrative, Twain employs irony and satire to critique the characters and situations he portrays. By highlighting the contradictions and absurdities of human behavior, he offers incisive social commentary while keeping the tone light and entertaining.
Literary Theories and Interpretation of “The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County” by Mark Twain
Literary TheoryInterpretation of the StoryExamples
RegionalismFocuses on capturing the unique characteristics, speech patterns, and customs of a particular region.The story is filled with vernacular speech used by Simon Wheeler, reflecting the dialect of the California gold rush era. Details like Jim Smiley’s ownership of a “fifteen-minute nag” and the prevalence of casual gambling highlight the regional culture.
Tall TaleA humorous story with exaggerated elements, often featuring larger-than-life characters and improbable feats.The entire narrative about Jim Smiley is a tall tale. His exceptional frog, Dan’l Webster, who could jump incredible distances after training, and his various outrageous bets exemplify this genre.
SatireUses humor, irony, or exaggeration to criticize human behavior or social flaws.The story satirizes the excessive gambling culture and the gullibility of characters like Jim Smiley. The narrator’s frustration with Wheeler’s irrelevant stories can be seen as a satire on pointless storytelling.
Oral TraditionFocuses on the importance of storytelling and the way stories are passed down through spoken word.Simon Wheeler’s role as a storyteller embodies the oral tradition. He entertains the narrator with tales about Jim Smiley, likely heard from others and embellished over time.
Topics, Questions, and Thesis Statements about “The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County” by Mark Twain
TopicQuestionThesis Statement
Humor and SatireHow does Mark Twain use humor and satire in “The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County” to comment on human nature?Mark Twain employs humor and satire in “The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County” to highlight the absurdities of human behavior, offering incisive social commentary.
Regionalism and DialectWhat role does regionalism and dialect play in the narrative?Through the use of regional dialect and vernacular speech patterns, Mark Twain authentically captures the rural, Southern setting of “The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County”.
CharacterizationHow does Twain characterize Jim Smiley and Simon Wheeler?Mark Twain’s characterization of Jim Smiley and Simon Wheeler in “The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County” reveals insights into their eccentricities and the cultural context of the story.
Narrative StyleHow does Twain’s narrative style contribute to the story’s impact?Mark Twain’s folksy, conversational narrative style in “The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County” draws readers in and creates an intimate connection, enhancing the story’s humor and charm.
Short Questions/Answers about/on “The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County” by Mark Twain
  • What is the narrator’s initial goal in visiting Simon Wheeler, and how are his expectations subverted?
  • The narrator’s initial goal is quite specific. He’s acting on a request from a friend to inquire about a man named Rev. Leonidas W. Smiley, presumably someone his friend knew in the past. The narrator expects a straightforward answer and perhaps some details about the Reverend’s life in Angel’s Camp. However, his expectations are hilariously subverted by Simon Wheeler’s garrulous nature. Wheeler becomes fixated on regaling him with unrelated tales of a completely different Smiley – Jim Smiley – and his outlandish exploits.
  • What is the name of Jim Smiley’s prized possession, and what makes it special (according to Smiley)? Give an example from the story to support your answer.
  • Jim Smiley’s prized possession is a frog named Dan’l Webster. According to Smiley, Dan’l Webster is no ordinary amphibian. Smiley boasts about transforming him into a champion jumper through rigorous training. The story mentions, “He [Smiley] ketched a frog one day, and took him home, and said he cal’lated to educate him… And you bet you he did learn him, too.” This quote highlights Smiley’s belief in Dan’l Webster’s exceptional jumping abilities, attributed entirely to Smiley’s training methods.
  • How does the stranger ultimately defeat Jim Smiley in their frog-jumping competition? Be specific about the stranger’s trickery.
  • The stranger defeats Jim Smiley through a clever and sneaky trick. While appearing to accept the challenge, he secretly sabotages Dan’l Webster’s jumping ability. The story describes, “Then he got the frog out and prized his mouth open and took a teaspoon and filled him full of quail shot—filled him pretty near up to his chin.” This act of stuffing the frog with lead weights ensures Dan’l Webster’s inability to jump, guaranteeing the stranger’s victory.
  • What is the significance of Simon Wheeler’s character in the story? How does he contribute to the themes and humor?
  • Simon Wheeler’s character is central to the story’s humor and exploration of themes. Here’s a breakdown of his significance:
  • Humor: Wheeler’s rambling, long-winded storytelling style creates a sense of absurdity. His complete disregard for the narrator’s original purpose and his focus on irrelevant tales about Jim Smiley contribute to the story’s comedic effect.
  • Tall Tales: Wheeler embodies the tradition of tall tales. His stories about Jim Smiley, particularly those focusing on Dan’l Webster’s jumping prowess, are clear examples of exaggerated narratives meant to entertain.
  • Regional Identity: Wheeler’s use of vernacular speech and his focus on local legends like Jim Smiley connect the story to a specific time and place. He reflects the culture of the California gold rush era, adding a layer of regional identity.
  • Satire: Through Wheeler’s character, Twain subtly satirizes the gullibility of some characters and the excessive gambling culture prevalent during the gold rush era.
Literary Works Similar to “The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County” by Mark Twain
  1. “The Notorious Jumping Frog of Calaveras County” by David Ives: This play is a modern adaptation of Twain’s original story, offering a humorous and theatrical interpretation of the classic tale.
  2. “The Luck of Roaring Camp” by Bret Harte: Like Twain, Bret Harte was a prominent figure in American literature during the 19th century. “The Luck of Roaring Camp” is a short story set in a California mining camp, featuring colorful characters and humorous situations reminiscent of Twain’s work.
  3. “The Outcasts of Poker Flat” by Bret Harte: Another story by Bret Harte, “The Outcasts of Poker Flat” is set in the rugged landscape of the American West and features a diverse cast of characters brought together by fate. The story explores themes of redemption, morality, and human nature, similar to Twain’s exploration in “The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County.”
  4. “The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn” by Mark Twain: While longer and more complex than “The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County,” Twain’s “The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn” shares similar themes of humor, satire, and a keen observation of human nature. Both works offer insights into American society and culture during the 19th century.
  5. “Winesburg, Ohio” by Sherwood Anderson: This collection of interconnected short stories offers a portrait of small-town life in the Midwest, much like the rural setting depicted in Twain’s story. “Winesburg, Ohio” delves into the lives of ordinary people and explores themes of isolation, longing, and the search for connection, echoing Twain’s exploration of human experiences in “The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County.”
Suggested Readings about/on “The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County” by Mark Twain
Books:
Articles:
  • Cuff, Roger Penn. “Mark Twain’s Use of California Folklore in His Jumping Frog Story.” The Journal of American Folklore 65.256 (1952): 155-158.
  • Twain, Mark. “Private History of the” Jumping Frog” Story.” The North American Review 158.449 (1894): 446-453.
  • Smith, Lawrence R. “Mark Twain’s” Jumping Frog”: Toward an American Heroic Ideal.” Mark Twain Journal 20.1 (1979): 15-18.
Websites:
  • “The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County – Full Text.” Project Gutenberg, www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/781. Accessed 22 April 2024.
  • “Mark Twain’s ‘The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County’.” The Mark Twain House & Museum, www.marktwainhouse.org/the-whole-story-behind-mark-twains-the-celebrated-jumping-frog-of-calaveras-county/. Accessed 22 April 2024.
Representative Quotations from “The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County” by Mark Twain
QuotationContextTheorization
“Well, I’ll resk two-and-a-half she don’t anyway.”Simon Wheeler recounts an incident where Jim Smiley, upon hearing of the improvement in Parson Walker’s sick wife, impulsively bets that she won’t recover.This quotation showcases Jim Smiley’s compulsive gambling nature, willing to bet on almost anything, even in inappropriate or insensitive situations, indicating his obsession with gambling.
“Andrew Jackson would never let on but what he was satisfied, and hadn’t expected nothing else”Despite Andrew Jackson (the bull-pup) enduring aggressive treatment from other dogs during fights, he maintains composure, suggesting a deceptive appearance of contentment.This quote illustrates the theme of deception and false appearances. Andrew Jackson’s stoic demeanor hides his fierce fighting spirit, fooling opponents into thinking they have the upper hand until he suddenly retaliates.
“You never see a frog so modest and straightfor’ard as he was, for all he was so gifted.”Simon Wheeler describes the frog, Dan’l Webster, as modest and straightforward despite its exceptional jumping abilities.This quotation reveals the irony in the frog’s demeanor compared to its remarkable talent. It highlights the theme of appearances versus reality, showing how outward modesty can conceal exceptional abilities.
“Well,’ he says, ‘I don’t see no p’ints about that frog that’s any better’n any other frog.'”A stranger questions the superiority of Dan’l Webster, Jim Smiley’s frog, over other frogs.This quote reflects skepticism towards Jim Smiley’s claims about Dan’l Webster’s exceptional jumping ability, emphasizing the theme of skepticism and the idea that appearances can be deceiving, challenging assumptions about superiority.
“Well, thish-yer Smiley had a yaller one-eyed cow that didn’t have no tail, only jest a short stump like a bannanner, and—-“Simon Wheeler begins to tell another anecdote about Jim Smiley’s peculiar possessions, this time a cow with unique physical characteristics.This quotation indicates the continuation of Simon Wheeler’s storytelling, suggesting the endless array of peculiarities associated with Jim Smiley, contributing to the humorous and eccentric atmosphere of the narrative.

“The Cat” by Mary E. Wilkins Freeman: A Critical Analysis

“The Cat” by Mary E. Wilkins Freeman,  first published in 1894, appeared in the collection titled “A Humble Romance and Other Stories”.

"The Cat" by Mary E. Wilkins Freeman: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “The Cat” by Mary E. Wilkins Freeman

“The Cat” by Mary E. Wilkins Freeman,  first published in 1894, appeared in the collection titled “A Humble Romance and Other Stories”. The story is a poignant exploration of companionship and survival. Freeman, known for her focus on rural New England life, depicts a harsh winter where an old man and a stray cat find solace and dependence in each other. The narrative beautifully portrays the unspoken bond that transcends language and highlights the need for connection, even in the most isolated circumstances.

Main Events in “The Cat” by Mary E. Wilkins Freeman
  • A Cat Faces a Harsh Winter Alone: The story opens with a cat enduring a brutal winter storm on a mountainside. Driven by hunger, he relentlessly waits for prey, demonstrating his “inconceivable patience and persistency of his race”. He finally catches a rabbit, showcasing his skilled hunting abilities.
  • An Unexpected Guest Arrives: Returning home to his owner’s cabin, the cat discovers his master is gone for the season. “He had known for a long time that his master was gone, but his reasoning was always sequential and circuitous; always for him what had been would be”. Just as the cat settles down to eat his hard-earned meal, a desperate stranger appears at the door, battered by the storm.
  • An Uneasy Alliance Forms: Initially wary of each other, the cat and the stranger cautiously coexist. The man, “an old wandering Ishmael among his kind”, finds comfort in the cat’s companionship, while the cat, touched by the man’s vulnerability, “loved him with all his heart, though he had known him such a short time”. They share the rabbit, forging a bond based on survival and a shared need for connection.
  • The Winter of Dependence: The weak and sickly stranger stays throughout the winter, relying on the cat’s hunting skills to survive. The cat, “toiled hard, and he grew rather thin himself, for he shared everything except mice with his guest”, demonstrates unwavering loyalty and selflessness.
  • Spring Brings Change: As spring approaches and prey becomes more plentiful, the stranger disappears without a trace. The cat leaves his new kill at the door, but the man is gone. The cat’s world is turned upside down once again.
  • A Return and a Silent Standoff: The cat’s original owner returns in the spring, welcoming the cat back with a “strong comradeship…but not affection”. The owner discovers his belongings missing, hinting at the stranger’s presence, but there’s no explanation or discussion.
  • The Story Ends with a Lingering Question: The narrative concludes with a poignant image of the man and the cat “sharing a silent moment…across that impassable barrier of silence which has been set between man and beast from the creation of the world.” The reader is left to ponder the unspoken bond between the cat and the stranger, and the enduring companionship between the cat and his owner.
Literary Devices in “The Cat” by Mary E. Wilkins Freeman
Literary DeviceExplanation
Alliteration“snow was stiffly pointed,” “mournful moaning of the wind,” “fiercer blast swept,” etc.
Allusion“like a panther,” “like a swift grey shadow,” referring to the characteristics of other animals.
Anaphora“Then the Cat saw two eyes…,” repeated at the beginning of consecutive sentences for emphasis.
AnthropomorphismAttributing human-like qualities to the Cat, such as patience, faith, and reasoning abilities.
Assonance“strained like wires,” “stood in a gyrating column,” repetition of the “i” and “o” sounds for rhythmic effect.
Consonance“shining green eyes,” repetition of the “n” sound for auditory appeal.
ForeshadowingThe description of the storm and the stranger’s arrival foreshadows the events that will unfold later in the story.
Hyperbole“the snow blew down like smoke,” exaggerating the intensity of the snowfall for dramatic effect.
ImageryVivid descriptions like “a maelstrom of the wood” and “tips of the bushes swollen and glistening red” create imagery.
IronyThe Cat’s loyalty to his absent master contrasts with the man’s eventual abandonment of him.
Metaphor“the snow was heavy on the low slant of its roof,” comparing the weight of the snow to a burden.
Onomatopoeia“rattled like sleet,” “gurgle of many waters,” words that imitate the sounds they describe.
PersonificationDescribing the storm as having “furious white wings of snow” and the mountain as “overawed.”
RepetitionRepeated use of the word “waited” emphasizes the Cat’s patience and persistence.
Simile“trees were the ladders to his heights of life,” comparing trees to ladders for the Cat.
SymbolismThe Cat symbolizes loyalty and companionship, while the storm represents danger and isolation.
SynecdocheReferring to the Cat’s prey as “his guest” emphasizes his ownership and dominance over them.
ToneThe tone shifts from suspenseful to comforting as the Cat finds companionship with the stranger.
UnderstatementDescribing the man as “poorer and older than his poor old master” understates his dire condition.
Verbal IronyThe Cat’s expectation of finding his master contrasts with the reality of his abandonment.
Characterization in “The Cat” by Mary E. Wilkins Freeman
Major Characters:
  • The Cat:
  • The protagonist of the story. He is a skilled hunter, driven by an “unconceivable patience and persistency.” He is fiercely loyal and forms unexpected bonds with both his original master and the stranger.
  • The Stranger: A poor, weak man who seeks refuge from the storm in the Cat’s cabin. Despite his initial fear of the Cat, he eventually forms a trusting relationship with it.
Minor Characters:
  • The Cat’s Master: An old man who lives in the cabin during warmer months. He has a practical relationship with the Cat, valuing its hunting skills but not showing affection.
Details from the story that reveal these characterizations:
  • The Cat:
    • Waits patiently for days to catch a rabbit, demonstrating his persistence.
    • Shares his kill with the stranger, showcasing his loyalty.
    • Mourns the stranger’s departure, highlighting his capacity for emotional connection.
  • The Stranger:
    • Is described as “feeble and marked with the scars of suffering,” revealing his hardship.
    • Fears the Cat initially, but overcomes it to share food and warmth.
    • Searches for tobacco upon arrival, hinting at a vice.
  • The Cat’s Master:
    • Leaves the Cat alone for the winter, indicating a utilitarian bond.
    • Welcomes the Cat back with “pride” but not affection.
    • Focuses on the missing tobacco after returning, prioritizing his own needs.
Major Themes in “The Cat” by Mary E. Wilkins Freeman
  1. Loyalty and Companionship: One prominent theme in “The Cat” is the demonstration of unwavering loyalty and companionship between the Cat and his human companions. Despite being abandoned by his master for the winter, the Cat remains fiercely devoted, continuing to wait for his return and providing for a stranger who seeks shelter in their home. The Cat’s persistence in waiting for his master and his willingness to share food and warmth with the stranger highlight the depth of his loyalty and the importance of companionship even in the face of adversity.
  2. Isolation and Loneliness: Another significant theme is the experience of isolation and loneliness, both for the Cat and the human characters in the story. The harsh winter landscape, coupled with the absence of the Cat’s master, creates a sense of isolation for the Cat as he waits alone in the snow-covered wilderness. Similarly, the stranger who seeks refuge in the Cat’s home is depicted as a lonely and desperate figure, isolated from society and in need of companionship. The theme of isolation underscores the characters’ longing for connection and highlights the emotional toll of solitude.
  3. Survival and Self-Sacrifice: “The Cat” explores the theme of survival and self-sacrifice as the Cat and his human companions navigate the challenges of the winter season. Despite facing hunger and cold, the Cat hunts tirelessly to provide food for himself and the stranger, demonstrating his instinctual drive for survival. Likewise, the stranger’s willingness to share what little resources he has with the Cat exemplifies an act of self-sacrifice driven by mutual survival instincts. Through these acts of resilience and sacrifice, the story underscores the primal instincts that drive creatures to endure and support one another in times of hardship.
  4. Human-Animal Bond: Central to the narrative is the theme of the human-animal bond, which is depicted through the relationships between the Cat and his various human companions. Despite their differences in species, the Cat forms deep connections with both his absent master and the stranger who takes shelter in their home. The Cat’s loyalty, affection, and willingness to provide comfort to the stranger highlight the profound emotional bonds that can exist between humans and animals. This theme underscores the capacity for empathy and understanding that transcends the boundaries of species, emphasizing the importance of compassion and connection in human-animal relationships.
Writing Style in “The Cat” by Mary E. Wilkins Freeman
  • Vivid Description: Freeman uses strong imagery to paint a picture of the harsh winter setting and the characters. We feel the biting cold, the swirling snow, and the ruggedness of the mountain environment. Descriptions like “a maelstrom of the wood” and “fierce backward set” bring the scene to life.
  • Focus on Animal Psychology: Freeman doesn’t shy away from exploring the Cat’s thoughts and motivations. We see his “unconceivable patience,” his “absolute convictions,” and his fierce determination. This creates a sense of empathy for the animal character.
  • Sparse Dialogue: The story relies heavily on description and action to move the plot forward. Dialogue is minimal, with the Cat’s cries and the stranger’s “hoarse shout” adding emphasis to key moments.
  • Naturalistic Detail: Freeman incorporates precise details about nature and animal behavior. Details like the Cat’s “beautiful thick fur” and the rabbit’s “little cloven feet” enhance the story’s realism.
  • Understated Emotional Impact: While the story deals with themes of survival, companionship, and loss, Freeman delivers them with a subtle touch. The emotional weight is left for the reader to infer through actions and descriptions.
Literary Theories and Interpretation of “The Cat” by Mary E. Wilkins Freeman
Literary TheoryInterpretationExample
Feminist CriticismThrough a feminist lens, “The Cat” can be analyzed in terms of gender roles and power dynamics. One could explore how the female characters, such as the rabbit, are portrayed and whether they are subjected to traditional gender stereotypes. Additionally, the absence of female human characters and the Cat’s interactions with the male stranger could be examined in terms of patriarchal dominance and the portrayal of male-female relationships.Examining how the rabbit’s vulnerability and eventual capture by the Cat might reflect traditional notions of femininity and power dynamics between genders in the story.
Marxist CriticismA Marxist reading of “The Cat” might focus on issues of class struggle and economic inequality. The story could be interpreted as depicting the exploitation of labor and resources, with the Cat representing the proletariat and the absent master and stranger representing the bourgeoisie. The Cat’s provision of food and shelter to the stranger despite his own hunger could be seen as a critique of capitalist systems that perpetuate inequality and scarcity.Analyzing how the Cat’s labor in hunting for food and providing shelter for the stranger reflects themes of economic struggle and the unequal distribution of resources.
Psychoanalytic CriticismFrom a psychoanalytic perspective, “The Cat” could be interpreted as a reflection of unconscious desires and fears. The Cat’s unwavering loyalty to his absent master and his instinctual behavior in providing for the stranger could be analyzed in terms of primal instincts and psychological motivations. Additionally, the theme of isolation and loneliness could be explored in relation to the characters’ inner psychological states.Exploring how the Cat’s attachment to his absent master and his fear of abandonment manifest in his actions and interactions with the stranger, revealing underlying psychological dynamics.
Reader-Response CriticismIn a reader-response approach, the interpretation of “The Cat” would focus on the subjective responses and interpretations of individual readers. Readers might reflect on their own experiences of loyalty, isolation, and survival, and how these themes resonate with their own lives. The meaning of the story could vary depending on the reader’s cultural background, personal beliefs, and emotional connections to the text.Considering how different readers might empathize with the Cat’s experiences of loyalty and companionship, or interpret the stranger’s arrival and its impact on the Cat in various ways based on their own perspectives.
Topics, Questions, and Thesis Statements about “The Cat” by Mary E. Wilkins Freeman
TopicQuestionThesis Statement
Loyalty and CompanionshipHow does the Cat demonstrate unwavering loyalty to his absent master and the stranger who seeks shelter in their home?In “The Cat,” Mary E. Wilkins Freeman portrays the theme of loyalty and companionship through the Cat’s steadfast devotion to his master and his compassionate treatment of the stranger, highlighting the importance of emotional bonds in overcoming adversity.
Isolation and SurvivalWhat role does the harsh winter landscape play in isolating the characters, and how do they navigate the challenges of survival?Through depictions of isolation and survival in “The Cat,” Freeman underscores the resilience of the Cat and the stranger as they endure the harsh winter conditions, emphasizing the primal instincts that drive creatures to persevere in the face of hardship.
Human-Animal RelationshipsHow does Freeman explore the complex dynamics of human-animal relationships, and what insights does the story offer into the bonds between humans and animals?“The Cat” delves into the intricate nature of human-animal relationships, illustrating the deep emotional connections that can exist between species and highlighting the capacity for empathy and understanding that transcends the boundaries of traditional companionship.
Themes of Abandonment and LossWhat themes of abandonment and loss are present in the story, and how do they shape the characters’ experiences and interactions?By portraying themes of abandonment and loss in “The Cat,” Freeman delves into the emotional turmoil experienced by both the Cat and the stranger, shedding light on the profound impact of absence and longing on the human psyche
Short Questions/Answers about/on “The Cat” by Mary E. Wilkins Freeman
  • Where does the story take place, and how does the setting influence the characters’ actions?
  • The story unfolds in a harsh mountain environment during a brutal winter. Freeman’s vivid descriptions paint a picture of a place dominated by the elements. Phrases like “the north wind starting in the upper heights of the mountains with distant screams” and “fierce white wings of snow” emphasize the relentless cold and danger. This setting forces the Cat to be a persistent hunter, waiting patiently for days in the “maelstrom of the wood” to secure his prey. The unforgiving environment also creates an unexpected bond between the Cat and the stranger, as they both seek refuge and warmth from the storm.
  • What is the Cat’s primary motivation, and how do his actions reveal it?
  • Survival is the Cat’s most primal drive. Freeman emphasizes this through details like the Cat’s “almost famished” state and his unwavering “faith in his deductions” as he stalks the rabbit. His actions further showcase this need. He waits with “unconceivable patience” for days, demonstrating his relentless pursuit of food. Even when faced with the stranger, a potential threat, the Cat prioritizes survival, dragging the rabbit under the bed before investigating the intruder.
  • How does the Cat react to the stranger who enters the cabin, and how does this reaction change over time?
  • Initially, the Cat reacts with fear and suspicion. The text describes him “cowering” and “with every one of his fine nerves and muscles strained like wires.” This is a natural reaction for a solitary hunter encountering a potentially dangerous stranger. However, the Cat’s behavior shifts as the situation unfolds. He observes the man’s weakness and hunger, and a sense of empathy emerges. This is evident when he offers the rabbit, a crucial resource, to the stranger. By the end, the Cat trusts the man enough to sleep curled up “in his bosom.”
  • How does the story portray the relationship between the Cat and his original master, and how does this differ from the Cat’s bond with the stranger?
  • The relationship between the Cat and his master is one of practicality. The master relies on the Cat’s hunting skills for winter survival, evidenced by the Cat leaving the rabbit on the “rude couch which was the bed.” However, there’s no warmth or affection. This is clear when the master welcomes the Cat back with “pride” but no physical touch, contrasting with the stranger who “stroked his back.” In contrast, the bond with the stranger develops quickly due to shared hardship and mutual need. They rely on each other for warmth, companionship, and even shared meals. The Cat even mourns the stranger’s departure with a “cry of the animal for human companionship.”
Literary Works Similar to “The Cat” by Mary E. Wilkins Freeman
  1. To Build a Fire” by Jack London: Like “The Cat,” London’s short story explores themes of survival and isolation in the wilderness. Set in the harsh Yukon wilderness, the story follows a man’s struggle to survive against the extreme cold and his reliance on his animal companion, a dog, for warmth and protection.
  2. “White Fang” by Jack London: Another work by Jack London, “White Fang” tells the story of a wild wolf-dog’s journey from the wild to domestication. Themes of loyalty, companionship, and the struggle for survival are central to both “White Fang” and “The Cat.”
  3. “The Call of the Wild” by Jack London: Yet another work by Jack London, “The Call of the Wild” explores similar themes of survival, loyalty, and the primal instincts of animals. The story follows a domesticated dog named Buck as he adapts to the harsh realities of life in the Alaskan wilderness.
  4. “The Open Boat” by Stephen Crane: Crane’s short story revolves around a group of men stranded at sea in a small boat after their ship sinks. Like “The Cat,” it explores themes of survival, companionship, and the indifferent forces of nature.
  5. The Old Man and the Sea by Ernest Hemingway: Hemingway’s novella tells the story of an aging Cuban fisherman named Santiago and his epic struggle to catch a giant marlin. Themes of endurance, perseverance, and the bond between man and nature are prominent in both “The Old Man and the Sea” and “The Cat.”
Suggested Readings about/on “The Cat” by Mary E. Wilkins Freeman
Articles:
  • Thiébaut, Emma. “Mary E. Wilkins Freeman and the Erotohistoriography of Pets.” Gender and Animals in History 42.1 (2024): 157-171.
  • Marchalonis, Shirley. “Another Mary Wilkins Freeman:” Understudies” and” Six Trees”.” ATQ 9.2 (1995): 89.
  • Carter, James Bucky. “” Life like a fairy tale”: fairy tales as influence in the life and works of Mary E. Wilkins Freeman.” (2002).
Websites:
Books:
  • Ettinger, Shaindell Jalowitz. “Mary E. Wilkins Freeman: humor and irony.” (1969).
  • Reichardt, Mary R. The Uncollected Stories of Mary Wilkins Freeman. Univ. Press of Mississippi, 1992.
  • Glasser, Leah Blatt. ” In a Closet Hidden”: The Life and Work of Mary Wilkins Freeman. Brown University, 1982.
Representative Quotations from “The Cat” by Mary E. Wilkins Freeman
QuotationContextTheorization
“The snow was falling, and the Cat’s fur was stiffly pointed with it, but he was imperturbable…”The opening scene sets the stage with the Cat patiently waiting for prey in the midst of a fierce winter storm. Despite hunger and cold, the Cat’s determination to hunt remains unwavering.This quotation highlights the Cat’s resilience and primal instincts, illustrating themes of survival and the relentless pursuit of prey. It reflects the natural order where animals like the Cat rely on their instincts and adaptability to endure harsh conditions. The Cat’s unwavering focus on his prey also symbolizes the persistence needed to overcome adversity.
“It grew darker and darker, with a strange white smother, instead of the natural blackness of night…”The Cat remains steadfast in his pursuit, undeterred by the intensifying storm. The darkness and fury of the storm contrast with the Cat’s calm and patient demeanor.This quotation underscores the Cat’s stoicism and adaptability in the face of adversity. It symbolizes the resilience of nature and the instinctual drive to survive, even in the harshest conditions. The Cat’s ability to endure the storm reflects themes of perseverance and determination, suggesting that survival instincts can overcome even the fiercest challenges.
“Then the Cat saw two eyes luminous with terror, frantic with the impulse of flight…”The Cat’s patience is rewarded as he successfully catches his prey, a rabbit desperate to escape. The Cat’s predatory instincts are depicted with precision as he waits for the opportune moment to strike.This quotation highlights the Cat’s predatory nature and his role as a hunter in the natural order. It explores themes of power dynamics and the struggle for survival in the animal kingdom. The Cat’s successful hunt represents the fulfillment of his primal instincts and underscores the harsh realities of the natural world.
“The man gave a great shout and start of terror, and sprang, and the Cat slid clawing to the floor…”The Cat’s encounter with the starving stranger demonstrates his capacity for empathy and companionship. Despite the man’s initial fear, the Cat seeks to comfort him and share his food.This quotation explores the theme of compassion and the bond between humans and animals. It portrays the Cat as a symbol of companionship and loyalty, capable of forming meaningful connections with those in need. The Cat’s willingness to share his food and provide comfort to the stranger highlights the capacity for empathy in both animals and humans, transcending boundaries of species.
“He sat down beside the fire, for May in the mountains is cold; he held his empty pipe in his mouth, his rough forehead knitted, and he and the Cat looked at each other across that impassable barrier of silence…”The story concludes with a poignant moment of understanding between the old man and the Cat, despite their inherent differences. Both characters share a sense of loss and solitude, yet find solace in each other’s presence.This quotation reflects on themes of loneliness, connection, and the shared experience of suffering. It symbolizes the universal longing for companionship and understanding, transcending the barriers of language and species. The Cat’s presence brings comfort to the old man, reminding him of the simple joys of companionship amidst life’s hardships.

“The Cactus” by O. Henry: A Critical Analysis

“The Cactus” by O. Henry, first published in 1910 in the collection “Sixes and Sevens,” showcases O. Henry’s signature qualities of wit, irony, and clever plot twists, set against the context of the American Southwest.

"The Cactus" by O. Henry: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “The Cactus” by O. Henry

“The Cactus” by O. Henry, first published in 1910 in the collection “Sixes and Sevens,” showcases O. Henry’s signature qualities of wit, irony, and clever plot twists, set against the context of the American Southwest. The story follows a young couple, Tom and Elizabeth, who are struggling to reconcile their relationship after a quarrel. The narrative is woven around a cactus plant that Tom brings home, symbolizing the prickly nature of their love. Through O. Henry’s masterful storytelling, the story explores themes of love, forgiveness, and the challenges of relationships, all while maintaining a lighthearted and humorous tone.

Main Events in “The Cactus” by O. Henry
  1. Trysdale’s Pensive Reflection: Trysdale reflects on his recent past, particularly his failed courtship and marriage of a woman he loved.
  2. Recollection of the Wedding: He recalls the events of the wedding, including the church atmosphere and the moment he realized he had lost her.
  3. Self-Realization and Disillusionment: Then he confronts his own flaws and egoism, realizing how they contributed to the failure of his relationship.
  4. Idealization of the Relationship: The narrative explores how Trysdale and his love interest idealized each other, leading to misinterpretations and misunderstandings.
  5. The Proposal: Trysdale reminisces about the night he proposed to her, recalling her admiration and his reluctance to correct her misconceptions about his skills.
  6. Lack of Communication: There’s a lack of direct communication between Trysdale and his love interest, leading to assumptions and unspoken expectations.
  7. Unanswered Questions: Trysdale questions where the fault lies in the relationship and seeks answers amid his shattered self-conceit.
  8. Interaction with a Friend: Trysdale’s friend attempts to lighten the mood, but Trysdale remains brooding and introspective.
  9. Discussion of the Cactus: The conversation shifts to the cactus, a gift to Trysdale, and its Spanish name, “Ventomarme,” which means “Come and take me.”
  10. Symbolism of the Cactus:The cactus symbolizes the allure of the exotic and the invitation to seize opportunities, possibly mirroring Trysdale’s longing for a second chance or a new beginning.
Literary Devices in “The Cactus” by O. Henry
DeviceExampleExplanation
1. SymbolismThe cactus plantRepresents the prickly nature of love and relationships
2. IronyTrysdale’s friend drinking aloneHighlights Trysdale’s own emotional isolation
3. Imagery“a singular-looking green plant in a red earthen jar”Creates a vivid picture in the reader’s mind
4. Allusion“the scent of flowers that had been banked in odorous masses about the church”Evokes a sense of familiarity and shared cultural knowledge
5. Stream-of-consciousnessTrysdale’s inner monologueReveals his thoughts and feelings in a fluid, unstructured manner
6. FlashbackTrysdale’s memories of his relationshipProvides backstory and context for his current emotions
7. CharacterizationTrysdale’s egoism and conceitShows his flaws and vulnerabilities
8. DialogueTrysdale’s friend’s banterReveals their relationship and Trysdale’s emotional state
9. ForeshadowingThe cactus’s “beckoning” motionSuggests the plant’s significance in the story
10. MetaphorThe cactus as a symbol of loveCompares two seemingly disparate things
11. Hyperbole“a thousand well-bred voices”Exaggerates the number of voices to convey the atmosphere
12. Personification“the leaves perpetually swayed with the slightest breeze”Gives inanimate objects human-like qualities
13. RepetitionTrysdale’s repeated questioning of himselfEmphasizes his self-doubt and introspection
14. SarcasmTrysdale’s friend’s comment about the brandyConveys humor and irony
15. Imagery“the crowning instance of his fatuous and tardily mourned egoism”Creates a vivid picture of Trysdale’s self-realization
16. Allusion“the hotchpotch at the back of dictionaries”References a common source of knowledge
17. SymbolismThe Spanish name “Ventomarme”Represents the idea of something being offered or taken
18. IronyTrysdale’s lack of knowledge of SpanishContrasts with his earlier pretence of speaking the language
19. Imagery“the soft convolutions” of the cactus leavesCreates a vivid picture in the reader’s mind
20. Structural deviceThe story’s non-linear structureJuxtaposes past and present events to convey Trysdale’s emotional journey
Characterization in “The Cactus” by O. Henry
Major Character:
  • Valentine Algernon de Lacey Trysdale:
  •  Traits: Vain, arrogant, self-absorbed, entitled.
  • Examples:
    • “She had always insisted on placing him upon a pedestal, and he had accepted her homage with royal dignity.” (Trysdale enjoys the constant praise from his girlfriend)
    • “He did not feel the prick of the thorn that was to pierce him later.” (This metaphor foreshadows his lack of understanding and future pain)
    • “His vanity was pierced through and through. He groaned in spirit.” (Trysdale’s reaction to the rejection reveals his fragile ego)
Minor Character:
  • The Narrator:
    • Traits: Objective observer, ironic tone.
    • Examples:
      • The story is told in third-person limited, allowing readers access to Trysdale’s thoughts but remaining detached.
      • “Trysdale, indulging in the pleasant belief that he was the indulgent, confident victor” (The narrator uses sarcasm to highlight Trysdale’s self-deception)
      • “The tag bore a barbarous foreign name, which, however, did not enlighten him.” (The narrator highlights Trysdale’s ignorance, adding to the story’s humor)
Major Themes in “The Cactus” by O. Henry
  • Theme 1: The Dangers of Ego and Conceit
  • Trysdale’s ego and conceit are his downfall, as he realizes too late that his pretence of speaking Spanish and his acceptance of Elizabeth’s admiration were false and hurtful. His inner monologue reveals the depth of his self-deception, “He saw all the garbs of pretence and egoism that he had worn now turn to rags of folly.” This theme is exemplified through Trysdale’s character development, as he moves from a state of arrogant self-assurance to one of humble self-awareness.
  • Theme 2: The Power of Love and Relationships
  • The story highlights the complexities and vulnerabilities of love and relationships. Elizabeth’s enigmatic behavior and Trysdale’s misinterpretation of her actions demonstrate the fragility of human connections. The cactus, symbolizing the prickly nature of love, serves as a poignant reminder of the couple’s failed relationship. As Trysdale reflects, “He shuddered at the thought that to others, before now, the garments of his soul must have appeared sorry and threadbare.”
  • Theme 3: Self-Discovery and Humility
  • Through his experiences, Trysdale undergoes a transformative process of self-discovery, recognizing the flaws in his character and the harm caused by his ego. His introspection and willingness to confront his mistakes exemplify the theme of self-discovery and humility. As he admits, “Humbled now, he sought the answer amid the ruins of his self-conceit.” This theme is central to the story, as Trysdale’s growth and newfound humility offer a sense of hope and redemption.
  • Theme 4: The Unreliability of Appearances
  • The story explores the idea that appearances can be deceiving, and that true understanding requires looking beyond surface-level impressions. The cactus, initially perceived as a symbol of love, ultimately represents the couple’s failed relationship. Similarly, Trysdale’s pretence of speaking Spanish and his acceptance of Elizabeth’s admiration were false and misleading. This theme is exemplified through the characters’ actions and the story’s ironic twists, highlighting the importance of genuine communication and understanding in relationships.
Writing Style in “The Cactus” by O. Henry

1. Descriptive Imagery

  • O. Henry employs vivid descriptions to evoke the setting and characters’ emotions. For example, he describes the wedding scene with “the scent of the flowers that had been banked in odorous masses about the church” and “the rustle of crisp garments.”

2. Reflective and Introspective Tone

  • The narrative adopts a reflective tone as Trysdale reminisces about past events and analyzes his own feelings and actions. For instance, he reflects on his “unworthy, sullen exultation” during the wedding and his realization of his own flaws and egoism.

3. Dialogue-driven Narration

  • O. Henry uses dialogue to reveal characters’ thoughts, feelings, and interactions. For example, Trysdale’s conversation with his friend provides insight into his emotional state and inner turmoil.

4. Symbolism and Metaphor

  • The story incorporates symbolism and metaphor to convey deeper meanings. The cactus, for instance, symbolizes Trysdale’s longing for connection and redemption. Its Spanish name, “Ventomarme,” metaphorically beckons him to seize opportunities and take control of his destiny.

5. Irony and Humor

  • O. Henry infuses the narrative with irony and humor, often through the protagonist’s self-awareness and self-deprecating humor. For example, Trysdale’s realization of his own folly and pretentiousness adds a touch of irony to the story’s introspective tone.
Literary Theories and Interpretation of “The Cactus” by O. Henry
Literary TheoryExample from the StoryExplanation
Psychoanalytic TheoryTrysdale’s introspection and self-realizationTrysdale’s reflection on his own egoism and flaws can be analyzed through a psychoanalytic lens, exploring his subconscious motivations and desires.
Feminist TheoryExamination of gender roles and power dynamicsThe story can be examined from a feminist perspective, considering how the female character is portrayed and how gender dynamics influence the relationship dynamics.
Marxist TheoryAnalysis of social class and economic factorsThe story can be interpreted through a Marxist lens, examining how social class influences characters’ actions and relationships, such as Trysdale’s societal status.
Formalist CriticismStudy of narrative structure and literary devicesFormalist criticism focuses on the text itself, analyzing elements like imagery, symbolism, and narrative style, which are prominent in O. Henry’s storytelling.
Reader-Response TheoryInterpretation based on individual reader’s perspectiveDifferent readers may interpret the story differently based on their own experiences and perspectives, engaging with themes of love, loss, and self-discovery.
Topics, Questions, and Thesis Statements about “The Cactus” by O. Henry
TopicQuestionThesis Statement
1. The Consequences of Ego and ConceitHow does Trysdale’s ego and conceit lead to his downfall, and what lessons can be learned from his experience?“Through Trysdale’s character, O. Henry illustrates the destructive nature of ego and conceit, highlighting the importance of humility and self-awareness in relationships.”
2. The Symbolism of the CactusWhat significance does the cactus hold in the story, and how does it relate to the themes of love and relationships?“The cactus serves as a powerful symbol of the prickly nature of love, representing the complexities and vulnerabilities of human connections in O. Henry’s ‘The Cactus’.”
3. The Role of Miscommunication and MisinterpretationHow do miscommunication and misinterpretation contribute to the breakdown of Trysdale and Elizabeth’s relationship, and what insights can be gained from their experiences?“O. Henry’s ‘The Cactus’ demonstrates how miscommunication and misinterpretation can lead to the demise of relationships, emphasizing the need for clear and honest communication in romantic partnerships.”
4. The Theme of Self-Discovery and Personal GrowthHow does Trysdale’s journey from self-deception to self-awareness illustrate the importance of personal growth and self-discovery, and what message does O. Henry convey through Trysdale’s transformation?“Through Trysdale’s transformative journey, O. Henry highlights the significance of self-discovery and personal growth, suggesting that acknowledging and confronting one’s flaws is essential for emotional maturity and redemption.”
Short Questions/Answers about/on “The Cactus” by O. Henry

Q1: What is the significance of the cactus in the story?

The cactus represents the prickly nature of love and relationships. It symbolizes the complexities and vulnerabilities of human connections. When Elizabeth gives Trysdale the cactus, it signifies her acceptance of his flaws, but also serves as a reminder of their failed relationship. The cactus’s “beckoning” motion also foreshadows Trysdale’s realization of his mistakes.

Q2: How does Trysdale’s ego and conceit lead to his downfall?

Trysdale’s ego and conceit lead to his downfall as he pretends to speak Spanish and accepts Elizabeth’s admiration without correcting her. He becomes trapped in his own deception, leading to misunderstandings and hurt feelings. His ego blinds him to Elizabeth’s true intentions, causing him to misinterpret her actions. This ultimately leads to the demise of their relationship.

Q3: What role does miscommunication play in the story?

Miscommunication plays a significant role in the story, leading to misunderstandings and hurt feelings. Trysdale misinterprets Elizabeth’s actions and words, while Elizabeth assumes Trysdale speaks Spanish. The lack of clear communication leads to the breakdown of their relationship. O. Henry highlights the importance of honest and open communication in relationships.

Q4: What is the theme of self-discovery in the story?

The theme of self-discovery is prominent in the story as Trysdale undergoes a transformative journey from self-deception to self-awareness. He realizes his flaws and mistakes, acknowledging the harm caused by his ego. This newfound self-awareness allows him to confront his mistakes and begin the process of redemption. O. Henry suggests that self-discovery and personal growth are essential for emotional maturity and healthy relationships.

Literary Works Similar to “The Cactus” by O. Henry
  1. The Gift of the Magi” by O. Henry – Another classic short story by O. Henry, “The Gift of the Magi” explores themes of love, sacrifice, and irony. Like “The Cactus,” it features memorable characters and a twist ending.
  2. The Necklace” by Guy de Maupassant – This short story shares thematic elements with “The Cactus,” such as the consequences of pride and the pursuit of social status. It also features a surprising twist that challenges the characters’ perceptions.
  3. The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald – While a novel rather than a short story, “The Great Gatsby” explores similar themes of unrequited love, social class, and the pursuit of an idealized image. Like Trysdale in “The Cactus,” Gatsby grapples with the consequences of his own illusions.
  4. Ethan Frome by Edith Wharton – This novella delves into themes of loneliness, duty, and forbidden love. Like “The Cactus,” it portrays the complexities of human relationships and the consequences of unfulfilled desires.
  5. Dubliners by James Joyce – A collection of short stories, “Dubliners” explores themes of disappointment, disillusionment, and the complexities of human experience. Like O. Henry’s works, Joyce’s stories often feature moments of epiphany and irony.
Suggested Readings about/on “The Cactus” by O. Henry
Scholarly Articles on “The Cactus” by O. Henry:
  • Kercheville, F. M. “O. Henry and Don Alfonso.” New Mexico Quarterly 1.4 (1931): 13.
  • Boyarkina, Iren. “Empathy and human feeling in the short stories of O. Henry and Anton Chekhov.” Connections and Influence in the Russian and American Short Story 23 (2021).
  • Rollins, Hyder E. “O. Henry.” The Sewanee Review 22.2 (1914): 213-232.
  • Bekeeva, A. “SATIRICAL AND HUMOROUS MOTIFS IN THE STORIES OF O. HENRY.” Sciences of Europe 78-2 (2021): 26-30.
Books on “The Cactus” by O. Henry:
  • Henry, Olivier. The Gift of the Magi and other short stories. Courier Corporation, 2012.
Websites on O. Henry:
Representative Quotations from “The Cactus” by O. Henry
QuotationContextTheorization
“That is what Trysdale was doing, standing by a table in his bachelor apartments. On the table stood a singular-looking green plant in a red earthen jar.”This quotation sets the initial scene, introducing the protagonist Trysdale and the titular cactus. Trysdale’s contemplation beside the cactus symbolizes his introspection and the beginning of his journey of self-discovery.The cactus serves as a symbolic object representing Trysdale’s inner turmoil and self-reflection. It becomes a focal point for his contemplation and triggers his exploration of his own flaws and egoism.
“For the thousandth time he remarshalled in his mind the events of those last few days before the tide had so suddenly turned.”Trysdale’s repetitive examination of past events highlights his struggle to understand what went wrong in his relationship. He continuously replays the events leading up to the turning point, seeking clarity and understanding.This quotation emphasizes Trysdale’s fixation on the past and his desperate attempt to make sense of his failed relationship. It underscores the theme of introspection and the protagonist’s journey of self-discovery as he grapples with the consequences of his actions.
“During their conversation she had said: ‘And Captain Carruthers tells me that you speak the Spanish language like a native. Why have you hidden this accomplishment from me? Is there anything you do not know?'”Trysdale’s love interest’s inquiry about his supposed Spanish proficiency exposes his tendency to maintain appearances and uphold false pretenses. He willingly accepts the admiration without correcting the misconception, reflecting his vanity and desire to be seen in a favorable light.This quotation highlights the theme of deception and self-delusion as Trysdale prioritizes the admiration of others over honesty and authenticity. It underscores his reluctance to confront his own flaws and the consequences of his actions, ultimately leading to his downfall.
“He waited until night, but her answer did not come.”Trysdale’s anticipation of a response from his love interest reflects his lingering hope for reconciliation despite the absence of communication. His emotional turmoil is palpable as he waits in vain for a resolution.This quotation illustrates Trysdale’s emotional vulnerability and his reluctance to accept the reality of his failed relationship. It underscores the theme of unrequited love and the protagonist’s futile attempts to salvage what remains of his shattered romance.
“The natives imagine the leaves are reaching out and beckoning to you. They call it by this name–Ventomarme. Name means in English, ‘Come and take me.'”The revelation of the cactus’s name and its meaning in Spanish adds depth to its symbolism. The name “Ventomarme” suggests an invitation or a plea, mirroring Trysdale’s longing for connection and redemption.This quotation provides insight into the symbolic significance of the cactus as a representation of Trysdale’s desires and regrets. It emphasizes the theme of longing and the protagonist’s yearning for a second chance or a new beginning. The name’s interpretation underscores the narrative’s exploration of unfulfilled desires and the consequences of missed opportunities.

“The Boarded Window” by Ambrose Bierce: A Critical Analysis

“The Boarded Window” by Ambrose Bierce, initially published in 1891 as part of the esteemed collection Tales of Soldiers and Civilians, exemplifies the author’s proficiency in the realms of supernatural fiction and mystery.

"The Boarded Window" by Ambrose Bierce: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “The Boarded Window” by Ambrose Bierce

“The Boarded Window” by Ambrose Bierce, initially published in 1891 as part of the esteemed collection Tales of Soldiers and Civilians, exemplifies the author’s proficiency in the realms of supernatural fiction and mystery. This enigmatic short story, replete with eerie and suspenseful elements, probes the psychological and philosophical themes of isolation, paranoia, and the unknowable, all while showcasing Bierce’s distinctive literary style. Through the protagonist’s fixation on uncovering the secrets shrouding a mysterious boarded-up window in his rural abode, the narrative masterfully crafts an atmosphere of escalating tension and foreboding, culminating in a denouement that has captivated scholars and readers alike. As such, “The Boarded Window” remains an integral component of American literary canon, offering valuable insights into the human condition and the power of the unknown.

Main Events in “The Boarded Window” by Ambrose Bierce
  1. Setting: A dense forest near Cincinnati, sparsely populated by frontier settlers
  2. Introduction of Murlock: A reclusive man living alone in a log cabin, sustains himself through hunting and trading
  3. Description of Murlock: Appears much older than his actual age of fifty, with white hair, a long beard, and a stooped figure
  4. Murlock’s Wife Falls Ill: Murlock’s wife becomes seriously ill with fever, leaving him to care for her with no access to medical help
  5. Death of Murlock’s Wife: Despite Murlock’s efforts to nurse her back to health, his wife succumbs to the fever and dies
  6. Murlock’s Grief: Murlock experiences a profound sense of loss and confusion, struggling to come to terms with his wife’s death
  7. Preparation for Burial: Murlock mechanically prepares his wife’s body for burial, feeling disconnected and numb to his emotions
  8. Murlock’s Emotional Turmoil: Murlock’s grief manifests as a sense of disbelief and detachment, unable to fully comprehend the magnitude of his loss
  9. Strange Sounds: Murlock hears eerie wailing sounds outside the cabin but dismisses them as possibly hallucinations or dreams
  10. Terrifying Encounter: Murlock is startled awake by mysterious footsteps and a heavy impact on the table, triggering intense fear and panic
  11. Encounter with a Panther: Murlock glimpses a panther dragging his wife’s body toward the window, leading to a chaotic struggle
  12. Violent Confrontation: In a moment of terror, Murlock grabs his rifle and blindly fires at the panther, causing it to flee
  13. Discovery of Wife’s Body: Murlock finds his wife’s mutilated body near the window, surrounded by evidence of a violent struggle
  14. Panther’s Attack: Murlock realizes his wife was attacked and killed by the panther, leaving him to grapple with the horror of the situation
  15. Aftermath: Murlock is left traumatized by the incident, haunted by the memory of his wife’s death and the vicious attack by the panther.
Literary Devices in “The Boarded Window” by Ambrose Bierce
Literary DeviceExample from the StoryExplanation
Imagery“The whole region was sparsely settled by people of the frontier—restless souls who no sooner had hewn fairly habitable homes out of the wilderness…”This creates a vivid picture of the frontier settlers and their struggle to establish homes in the wilderness.
Foreshadowing“The latter, however, was boarded up—nobody could remember a time when it was not.”The boarded window hints at a mysterious element of the story, creating anticipation for its revelation.
Personification“the decayed stumps of which were half concealed by the new growth that had been suffered to repair the ravage wrought by the ax.”The new growth repairing the damage caused by the ax is described as if it actively responded to the harm, giving human-like qualities to nature.
SymbolismThe boarded-up windowThe boarded-up window symbolizes Murlock’s isolation and inner turmoil, as well as the mystery surrounding his past.
Alliteration“His hair and long, full beard were white, his gray, lusterless eyes sunken…”The repetition of the initial consonant sounds creates a rhythmic effect and emphasizes the description of Murlock’s appearance.
Irony“He had had no experience in grief; his capacity had not been enlarged by use.”The irony lies in the fact that Murlock, who has no prior experience with grief, finds himself overwhelmed by it after his wife’s death.
Simile“Some natures it startles; some it stupefies. To one it comes like the stroke of an arrow, stinging all the sensibilities to a keener life…”Grief is compared to the effect of an arrow, emphasizing its sudden and sharp impact on the senses.
Metaphor“Grief is an artist of powers as various as the instruments upon which he plays his dirges for the dead…”Grief is metaphorically compared to an artist, highlighting its ability to evoke different emotions and responses in people.
Suspense“Suddenly the table shook beneath his arms, and at the same moment he heard, or fancied that he heard, a light, soft step…”This builds tension and anticipation as Murlock experiences a mysterious disturbance in the cabin.
Flashback“There is an earlier chapter—that supplied by my grandfather.”The narrator introduces a flashback to provide background information about Murlock’s life and experiences.
Hyperbole“He tried vainly to speak the dead woman’s name, vainly to stretch forth his hand across the table…”The exaggeration emphasizes Murlock’s desperation to connect with his deceased wife, intensifying the emotional impact of the scene.
Repetition“Waited there in the darkness through seeming centuries of such dread as one may know, yet live to tell.”The repetition of “waited” emphasizes the prolonged and agonizing nature of Murlock’s fear and anticipation.
Onomatopoeia“A scuffling ensued, and a confusion of sounds impossible to describe.”The use of onomatopoeia creates an auditory image of the chaotic and terrifying events unfolding in the cabin.
AllegoryMurlock’s encounter with the pantherMurlock’s struggle with the panther can be interpreted as an allegory for his internal battles with grief and fear, as well as the harsh realities of frontier life.
Juxtaposition“Then there were darkness blacker than before, and silence; and when he returned to consciousness the sun was high and the wood vocal with songs of birds.”The contrast between the darkness and silence of Murlock’s terror and the brightness and sounds of nature afterward highlights the abrupt shift in atmosphere and Murlock’s return to reality.
Paradox“Fear had by excess forfeited control of his faculties.”The paradox lies in fear causing Murlock to lose control, despite fear typically being associated with heightened awareness and alertness.
Metonymy“By the flash which lit up the room with a vivid illumination…”“Flash” is used as a metonymy for the flash of the rifle, representing the sudden burst of light that illuminates the room.
FoilMurlock’s wife compared to Murlock himselfMurlock’s wife, portrayed as supportive and optimistic, serves as a foil to Murlock’s stoic and isolated nature, emphasizing their contrasting personalities.
Pathetic Fallacy“the deepening gloom”The gloomy atmosphere mirrors Murlock’s emotional state, creating a sense of foreboding and unease.
EpiphanyMurlock’s realization after the encounter with the pantherMurlock experiences a moment of clarity and understanding about the harshness of life and the unpredictability of death after confronting the panther, marking a significant realization in his journey.
Characterization in “The Boarded Window” by Ambrose Bierce
Major Characters:
  • Murlock:
    • Characterized as a mysterious and isolated individual who “seemed a part of the gloom and silence” (Bierce 1)
    • Described as having a rugged and weathered appearance, with “gray, lusterless eyes sunken, his face singularly seamed with wrinkles” (Bierce 2)
    • Described as having a strong and stoic demeanor, but revealed to be grieving and struggling to cope with the loss of his wife
    • Shows signs of mental and emotional instability, such as when he “laid his face into them, tearless yet and unutterably weary” (Bierce 3)
    • Commits a violent act against the panther, symbolizing his inner turmoil and desire for revenge
  • Murlock’s wife:
    • Characterized as a kind and supportive partner who shared Murlock’s “dangers and privations” (Bierce 2)
    • Described as being young and full of life, with “charms of mind and person” (Bierce 2)
    • Revealed to have died suddenly and tragically, with Murlock “convince[d] that she was dead” (Bierce 3)
    • Remembered fondly by Murlock, highlighting their strong relationship and his devastation at her loss
Minor Characters:
  • The narrator:
    • Characterized as a curious and adventurous individual who “penetrated to the place and ventured near enough to the ruined cabin to throw a stone against it” (Bierce 1)
    • Described as having a fascination with the mysterious and unknown, and seeking to uncover the secrets of the boarded window
    • Revealed to be a descendant of someone who knew Murlock, adding a personal connection to the story
    • Serves as a framing device to tell the story of Murlock and his wife
  • The grandfather:
    • Characterized as a knowledgeable and experienced individual who “had known [Murlock] when living nearby in that early day” (Bierce 2)
    • Described as having a deep understanding of the past and its secrets, and sharing his insights with the narrator
    • Revealed to have known Murlock and his wife, and providing valuable context and information about their lives
    • Serves as a source of information and insight into the story
  • The panther:
    • Characterized as a symbol of danger and violence, described as an “enormous panther” (Bierce 4)
    • Revealed to be the cause of Murlock’s wife’s death, and the catalyst for Murlock’s descent into madness and violence
    • Serves as a representation of the unknown and uncontrollable forces that can disrupt human life.
Major Themes in “The Boarded Window” by Ambrose Bierce

Grief and Loss

  • The story explores the devastating effects of loss and grief on the human psyche
  • Murlock’s inability to cope with his wife’s death leads to his descent into madness and violence
  • The theme is highlighted through Murlock’s actions, such as boarding up the window and attempting to revive his wife

2. Isolation and Loneliness

  • The story emphasizes the dangers of isolation and loneliness
  • Murlock’s decision to live in the wilderness, away from human contact, contributes to his downfall
  • The theme is illustrated through Murlock’s solitude and his lack of human connection

3. The Power of the Unknown

  • The story showcases the fear and fascination of the unknown
  • The panther represents the uncontrollable and mysterious forces of nature
  • The theme is demonstrated through the panther’s sudden and unexpected attack, which disrupts Murlock’s life

4. The Blurring of Reality and Madness

  • The story explores the thin line between reality and madness
  • Murlock’s grief and isolation lead to a blurring of his perceptions, making it difficult for him to distinguish between reality and fantasy
  • The theme is exemplified through Murlock’s hallucinations and his eventual descent into madness.
Writing Style in “The Boarded Window” by Ambrose Bierce
  • Gothic and Atmospheric Language
  • Bierce uses vivid and descriptive language to create a eerie and foreboding atmosphere
  • Words like “gloom”, “silence”, “darkness”, and “shadow” create a sense of dread and tension
  • Symbolism and Imagery
  • Bierce employs symbols like the boarded window, the panther, and the dead wife to convey deeper meanings
  • Imagery is used to create vivid pictures in the reader’s mind, such as the description of the forest and the cabin
  • Suspense and Tension
  • Bierce builds suspense through the use of foreshadowing, unexpected events, and unanswered questions
  • Tension is created through the slow reveal of Murlock’s past and the mysterious events that unfold
  • Irony and Contrast
  • Bierce uses irony to highlight the contrast between Murlock’s past and present, and the peaceful surroundings versus the violent events
  • Contrast is also used to emphasize the difference between Murlock’s inner turmoil and his outward appearance
  • Simple and Direct Prose
  • Bierce’s writing is concise and direct, with a focus on telling the story rather than elaborate descriptions
  • Simple sentences and paragraphs create a sense of clarity and ease of reading
  • Psychological Insight
  • Bierce provides insight into Murlock’s psychological state, exploring his grief, guilt, and descent into madness
  • The story is a character study, examining the effects of trauma and isolation on the human mind.
Literary Theories and Interpretation of “The Boarded Window” by Ambrose Bierce
Literary TheoryInterpretationExample from the Story
PsychoanalyticAnalyzing characters’ unconscious desires and fears, exploring the influence of trauma and repression on behavior.Murlock’s reclusive nature and his reaction to his wife’s death can be interpreted through a psychoanalytic lens, revealing deep-seated emotions and unresolved psychological conflicts.
MarxistExamining power dynamics, social class, and economic structures in the narrative, investigating how characters’ actions are influenced by their socio-economic status.Murlock’s isolation and struggle to maintain his farm may reflect the hardships faced by individuals in the lower classes, highlighting themes of economic inequality and the challenges of frontier life.
FeministAnalyzing gender roles, stereotypes, and the representation of women in the story, exploring how patriarchal norms shape characters’ experiences and relationships.The portrayal of Murlock’s wife as supportive and obedient may reflect traditional gender roles of the time, raising questions about women’s agency and autonomy in the frontier society depicted in the story.
Formalist/New CriticismFocusing on the text itself, examining literary devices, themes, and narrative techniques to uncover deeper meanings and patterns.The use of foreshadowing through the boarded-up window and the repetition of eerie sounds create suspense and anticipation, enhancing the story’s atmosphere and contributing to its overall impact on the reader.
Reader-ResponseEmphasizing the role of the reader in interpreting the text, exploring how individual experiences and perspectives shape the meaning of the story.Different readers may interpret Murlock’s actions and the significance of the boarded-up window in various ways, depending on their own backgrounds, beliefs, and emotional responses to the narrative.
PostcolonialAnalyzing themes of colonization, cultural identity, and resistance in the narrative, examining how colonial history and power dynamics influence characters’ lives and interactions.The frontier setting and the struggle for survival in the wilderness can be seen as symbolic of the larger historical context of colonization and the displacement of indigenous peoples by European settlers.
StructuralismIdentifying underlying structures and patterns within the text, focusing on binary oppositions, recurring motifs, and narrative organization.The contrast between light and darkness, as well as the repetition of the motif of isolation and fear, contribute to the story’s structure and thematic development, highlighting key conflicts and tensions.
PostmodernismQuestioning traditional narrative conventions and exploring metafictional elements, reflexivity, and intertextuality in the story.Bierce’s use of ambiguity and the unreliable narrator challenges readers’ perceptions of reality, inviting them to question the reliability of the narrator’s account and the truthfulness of the events described.
Cultural CriticismExamining how cultural beliefs, values, and practices influence the narrative, exploring themes of identity, tradition, and cultural conflict.The portrayal of frontier life and the struggle to survive in the wilderness reflects the cultural values and challenges of American pioneers, providing insight into the historical and cultural context of the story.
DeconstructionUnpacking the inherent contradictions and ambiguities within the text, challenging binary oppositions and destabilizing fixed meanings to reveal multiple interpretations.The mystery surrounding the boarded-up window and the ambiguous nature of Murlock’s actions invite multiple readings and interpretations, illustrating the deconstructive nature of the narrative.
Topics, Questions, and Thesis Statements about “The Boarded Window” by Ambrose Bierce
  • Topic 1: The Supernatural
    Question: How does Bierce use the supernatural in “The Boarded Window” to create a sense of tension and fear?
    Thesis: Bierce uses the supernatural in “The Boarded Window” to create a sense of tension and fear by hinting at the possibility of a ghostly presence and using language that suggests the unknown and unexplainable.
  • Topic 2: Loneliness and Isolation
    Question: How does the setting of “The Boarded Window” contribute to the theme of loneliness and isolation?
    Thesis: The setting of “The Boarded Window” contributes to the theme of loneliness and isolation by creating a sense of remoteness and desolation, emphasizing Murlock’s disconnection from society and his inability to form meaningful relationships.
  • Topic 3: Death and Grief
    Question: How does “The Boarded Window” explore the theme of death and grief, and what commentary does it offer on the human experience?
    Thesis: “The Boarded Window” explores the theme of death and grief by portraying the devastating effects of loss on the human psyche, highlighting the destructive power of guilt and the inability to cope with tragedy.
  • Topic 4: Psychological Insight
    Question: How does “The Boarded Window” provide insight into the human mind, and what does it reveal about the psychological effects of trauma?
    Thesis: “The Boarded Window” provides insight into the human mind by exploring the psychological effects of trauma, revealing how guilt, grief, and isolation can lead to a downward spiral of mental and emotional deterioration.
Short Questions/Answers about/on “The Boarded Window” by Ambrose Bierce
  • Q: What is the significance of the boarded window in the story?
    A: The boarded window represents Murlock’s attempt to shut out the painful memories of his wife’s death and the outside world. However, it also symbolizes his inability to move on and confront his grief. For example, when Murlock boards up the window, he is trying to physically and emotionally block out the pain, but it only leads to further isolation and madness.
  • Q: How does Bierce use foreshadowing in the story?
    A: Bierce uses foreshadowing through the description of the forest and the cabin, creating an eerie and ominous atmosphere. For example, when the narrator describes the forest as “an immense and almost unbroken forest” with “gloom” and “silence”, it foreshadows the dark and tragic events that will unfold. Similarly, the description of the cabin as “ruined” and “decaying” hints at the decay of Murlock’s mental state.
  • Q: What is the role of the panther in the story?
    A: The panther represents the unknown and uncontrollable forces of nature, which disrupt Murlock’s life and symbolize the chaos and destruction that has entered his world. The panther’s sudden and unexpected attack on Murlock’s wife represents the randomness and cruelty of fate, and Murlock’s inability to cope with the tragedy.
  • Q: How does the story explore the theme of isolation?
    A: The story explores the theme of isolation through Murlock’s physical and emotional disconnection from society. His decision to live in the wilderness, away from human contact, contributes to his downfall. For example, when Murlock’s wife dies, he is unable to seek help or comfort from others, leading to his descent into madness and violence. The isolation also highlights the destructive power of guilt and grief when left unchecked.
Literary Works Similar to “The Boarded Window” by Ambrose Bierce
  1. The Tell-Tale Heart” by Edgar Allan Poe: Like “The Boarded Window,” this short story delves into themes of psychological suspense and the unraveling of the human mind. It explores the guilt and paranoia of the narrator after committing a murder.
  2. Young Goodman Brown” by Nathaniel Hawthorne: This story shares elements of psychological and symbolic depth with Bierce’s work. It follows a young man’s journey into the forest, where he confronts his own darkness and the hypocrisy of his community.
  3. The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson: While tonally different, this short story also explores the darker aspects of human nature and society’s capacity for cruelty. It similarly builds tension and mystery around a seemingly ordinary event.
  4. The Yellow Wallpaper” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman: Like “The Boarded Window,” this story delves into themes of isolation and madness. It follows a woman’s descent into psychosis as she becomes increasingly obsessed with the patterns in the wallpaper of her room.
  5. “The Fall of the House of Usher” by Edgar Allan Poe: This Gothic tale shares similarities with Bierce’s work in its atmospheric setting and exploration of psychological horror. It follows the narrator’s visit to the decaying mansion of his childhood friend, Roderick Usher, where he encounters madness and decay.
Suggested Readings about/on “The Boarded Window” by Ambrose Bierce
  • Books:
  • Bierce, Ambrose, and Irina Petraş. The Boarded Window. Paralela 45, 2003.
  • Bierce, Ambrose. The Collected Works of Ambrose Bierce... Vol. 2. Neale Publishing Company, 1909.
  • Bierce, Ambrose. A much misunderstood man: Selected letters of Ambrose Bierce. Ohio State University Press, 2003.
  • Articles:
  • Fatout, Paul. “Ambrose Bierce, Civil War Topographer.” American Literature 26.3 (1954): 391-400.
  • This article discusses Bierce’s use of surprise endings, a key element in “The Boarded Window.”
  • Website:
  • Ambrose Bierce Biography – https://www.encyclopedia.com/education/news-wires-white-papers-and-books/boarded-window
  • This website entry on “The Boarded Window” provides a brief plot summary, character analysis, and some critical interpretations. While not an in-depth analysis, it can be a helpful starting point.
Representative Quotations from “The Boarded Window” by Ambrose Bierce
QuotationContextTheorization
“His simple wants were supplied by the sale or barter of skins of wild animals…”This line describes Murlock’s self-sufficiency and isolation from society. Despite living in the wilderness, he chooses not to cultivate the land and instead relies on hunting for survival.Murlock’s self-imposed isolation reflects themes of alienation and detachment from society.
“And none knew why it was so closed; certainly not because of the occupant’s dislike of light and air…”Despite the window being boarded up, Murlock is occasionally seen sunning himself on the doorstep, contradicting the assumption that he dislikes light and air.The mystery surrounding the boarded window adds an element of suspense and intrigue to the narrative.
“There is no known record of her name; of her charms of mind and person tradition is silent…”The narrator acknowledges the lack of information about Murlock’s wife, leaving her character shrouded in mystery.The absence of details about Murlock’s wife contributes to the story’s eerie atmosphere and sense of foreboding.
“He had had no experience in grief; his capacity had not been enlarged by use.”Murlock’s lack of experience with grief highlights his emotional isolation and inability to cope with loss.Murlock’s emotional numbness serves as a precursor to the psychological horror that unfolds later in the story.
“He was terrified beyond the power to cry out or move.”Murlock experiences paralyzing fear when confronted with the unknown presence in the darkness.Murlock’s fear symbolizes the overwhelming sense of dread and helplessness in the face of the supernatural.
“There is a point at which terror may turn to madness…”This line reflects on the psychological effects of extreme fear, suggesting that it can lead to madness.The theme of madness underscores the psychological horror elements of the story.
“With no definite intent, from no motive but the wayward impulse of a madman…”Murlock’s irrational actions, driven by madness, demonstrate his descent into primal instincts.Murlock’s descent into madness serves as a turning point in the narrative, leading to the climax of the story.