“Youth and Age” by Samuel Taylor Coleridge: A Critical Analysis

“Youth and Age” by Samuel Taylor Coleridge was first published sometime between 1823 and 1832, the exact year being a matter of some debate.

"Youth and Age" by Samuel Taylor Coleridge: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “Youth and Age” by Samuel Taylor Coleridge

“Youth and Age” by Samuel Taylor Coleridge was first published sometime between 1823 and 1832, the exact year being a matter of some debate. It appeared in his collection “Poems,” a volume that showcased Coleridge’s mastery of various poetic styles and explored themes that would become hallmarks of Romanticism, including the power of nature, the beauty and loss of youth, and the search for meaning in life. The poem itself is a poignant meditation on the passage of time, contrasting the vibrancy and optimism of youth with the introspection and physical limitations of age.

Text: “Youth and Age” by Samuel Taylor Coleridge

Verse, a breeze mid blossoms straying,

Where Hope clung feeding, like a bee—

Both were mine! Life went a-maying

With Nature, Hope, and Poesy,

When I was young!

When I was young?—Ah, woful When!

Ah! for the change ‘twixt Now and Then!

This breathing house not built with hands,

This body that does me grievous wrong,

O’er aery cliffs and glittering sands,

How lightly then it flashed along:—

Like those trim skiffs, unknown of yore,

On winding lakes and rivers wide,

That ask no aid of sail or oar,

That fear no spite of wind or tide!

Nought cared this body for wind or weather

When Youth and I lived in’t together.

Flowers are lovely; Love is flower-like;

Friendship is a sheltering tree;

O! the joys, that came down shower-like,

Of Friendship, Love, and Liberty,

Ere I was old!

Ere I was old? Ah woeful Ere,

Which tells me, Youth’s no longer here!

O Youth! for years so many and sweet,

‘Tis known, that Thou and I were one,

I’ll think it but a fond conceit—

It cannot be that Thou art gone!

Thy vesper-bell hath not yet toll’d:—

And thou wert aye a masker bold!

What strange disguise hast now put on,

To make believe, that thou are gone?

I see these locks in silvery slips,

This drooping gait, this altered size:

But Spring-tide blossoms on thy lips,

And tears take sunshine from thine eyes!

Life is but thought: so think I will

That Youth and I are house-mates still.

Dew-drops are the gems of morning,

But the tears of mournful eve!

Where no hope is, life’s a warning

That only serves to make us grieve,

When we are old:

That only serves to make us grieve

With oft and tedious taking-leave,

Like some poor nigh-related guest,

That may not rudely be dismist;

Yet hath outstay’d his welcome while,

And tells the jest without the smile.

Annotations: “Youth and Age” by Samuel Taylor Coleridge
StanzaAnnotation
Verse, a breeze mid blossoms straying, Where Hope clung feeding, like a bee— Both were mine! Life went a-maying With Nature, Hope, and Poesy, When I was young!The speaker nostalgically recalls the carefree nature of youth, symbolized by a gentle breeze among blossoms, where hope flourished. They reminisce about a time filled with vitality, nature, hope, and poetry.
When I was young?—Ah, woful When! Ah! for the change ‘twixt Now and Then! This breathing house not built with hands, This body that does me grievous wrong, O’er aery cliffs and glittering sands, How lightly then it flashed along:—The speaker expresses sorrow over the passage of time and the transformation from youth to age. They lament the limitations and betrayals of the aging body, contrasting it with the once carefree and agile nature of youth.
Like those trim skiffs, unknown of yore, On winding lakes and rivers wide, That ask no aid of sail or oar, That fear no spite of wind or tide! Nought cared this body for wind or weather When Youth and I lived in’t together.Youth is likened to a small boat effortlessly navigating through life’s challenges. The speaker reflects on the fearlessness and resilience of youth, where the body seemed unaffected by external forces.
Flowers are lovely; Love is flower-like; Friendship is a sheltering tree; O! the joys, that came down shower-like, Of Friendship, Love, and Liberty, Ere I was old!The speaker celebrates the beauty of youth and the joys it brings, comparing them to flowers, love, and the shelter of friendship. They fondly recall the abundance of happiness and freedom experienced in youth.
Ere I was old? Ah woeful Ere, Which tells me, Youth’s no longer here! O Youth! for years so many and sweet, ‘Tis known, that Thou and I were one, I’ll think it but a fond conceit— It cannot be that Thou art gone!The speaker laments the loss of youth, refusing to fully accept its departure. They reminisce about the unity and sweetness of their relationship with youth, expressing disbelief at its absence.
Thy vesper-bell hath not yet toll’d:— And thou wert aye a masker bold! What strange disguise hast now put on, To make believe, that thou are gone? I see these locks in silvery slips, This drooping gait, this altered size:The speaker questions the apparent disappearance of youth, suggesting that it may still be present in disguise. They observe the physical signs of aging but perceive a lingering vitality in the midst of change.
But Spring-tide blossoms on thy lips, And tears take sunshine from thine eyes! Life is but thought: so think I will That Youth and I are house-mates still.Despite the effects of aging, the speaker perceives a youthful essence within themselves. They reflect on the transient nature of life, maintaining a mental connection to their youth, viewing them as enduring companions.
Dew-drops are the gems of morning, But the tears of mournful eve! Where no hope is, life’s a warning That only serves to make us grieve, When we are old:The speaker contrasts the purity of youth with the sorrow of aging, where life becomes a warning in the absence of hope. They acknowledge the grief that accompanies old age, emphasizing the fleeting nature of life.
Literary And Poetic Devices: “Youth and Age” by Samuel Taylor Coleridge
DeviceExample from “Youth and Age”Explanation
Allusion“Life went a-maying” (alluding to the tradition of celebrating May 1st)Reference to a person, place, event, or work of art to create a richer meaning
Amplification“O! the joys, that came down shower-like” (emphasizing the abundance of joys)Extending a detail or idea to emphasize its significance
Analogy“Flowers are lovely; Love is flower-like” (comparing love to a flower)Comparing two things to explain a concept
Anaphora“Ah! for the change…”, “Ah woeful When!”, “Ah woeful Ere” (repeating “Ah” at the start of successive clauses)Repetition of a word or phrase at the beginning of successive clauses
Aphorism“Life is but thought: so think I will” (a general truth)A short, witty statement expressing a general truth
Assonance“sheltering tree”, “silvery slips”Repetition of vowel sounds for a musical effect
Enjambment“When I was young?—Ah, woful When! / Ah! for the change ‘twixt Now and Then!” (sentence continues into the next line without punctuation)Carrying a sentence or phrase over to the next line without a pause
Hyperbole“O! the joys, that came down shower-like” (exaggerating the abundance of joys)Exaggeration for emphasis or effect
Imagery“breathing house not built with hands”, “Spring-tide blossoms on thy lips” (vividly describing a scene)Language that creates vivid sensory experiences for the reader
Irony“Youth’s no longer here!” (contrasting the expected meaning)Conveying a meaning that is opposite of what is explicitly stated
Juxtaposition“Youth and Age” (comparing two contrasting ideas)Placing two or more elements or ideas side by side to compare or contrast them
Metaphor“Life is but thought” (comparing life to a thought)Comparing two things without “like” or “as”
MeterThe poem follows a consistent iambic tetrameter rhythmA regular pattern of stressed and unstressed syllables in a line
Onomatopoeia(none in this poem)Words that imitate the sounds they describe
Oxymoron(none in this poem)Combining two words that are opposite in meaning
Personification“Hope clung feeding, like a bee” (giving hope human-like qualities)Attributing human qualities or characteristics to non-human entities
Repetition“When I was young”, “Ah! woeful When!”, “Ah! woeful Ere” (repeating phrases for emphasis)Repeating words or phrases for emphasis or effect
Rhyme“bliss” and “kiss”, “wide” and “tide” (ending sounds of words that match)Words with identical ending sounds
Simile“Hope clung feeding, like a bee” (comparing hope to a bee using “like”)Comparing two things using “like” or “as”
Symbolism“Fountains, full of life and bliss” (fountains representing abundance and joy)Using objects, colors, or other elements to represent abstract ideas or concepts
Themes: “Youth and Age” by Samuel Taylor Coleridge
  1. Youth and Old Age: The poem is a lamentation of the passing of the poet’s youth and his reluctant acceptance of old age. The poet compares the joys and freedom of his youth with the helplessness and sadness of his old age. In his youth, the poet was full of life and energy, “Life went a-maying / With Nature, Hope, and Poesy” (lines 3-4), but now he feels old and weak, “This breathing house not built with hands, / This body that does me grievous wrong” (lines 5-6). The poet longs for his youth and regrets the passing of time, “When I was young?—Ah, woful When! / Ah! for the change ‘twixt Now and Then!” (lines 1-2).
  2. Nature: The poem portrays the poet’s attraction to nature in his youth and his disconnection from it in old age. The poet describes his youth as a time when he was strong and active and could climb high peaks and run on sandy beaches, “O’er aery cliffs and glittering sands, / How lightly then it flashed along” (lines 9-10). In contrast, in his old age, he feels disconnected from nature and can no longer enjoy its beauty, “Nought cared this body for wind or weather / When Youth and I lived in’t together” (lines 11-12). The poet’s relationship with nature reflects his own growth and decay.
  3. Hope and Hopelessness: The poem shows the poet’s hope and optimism in his youth and his hopelessness and despair in old age. The poet describes how he used to be full of love, joy, and liberty in his youth, “Flowers are lovely; Love is flower-like; / Friendship is a sheltering tree” (lines 13-14), but now he feels weak and helpless, “When I was old? Ah woeful Ere, / Which tells me, Youth’s no longer here!” (lines 17-18). The poet’s hope and optimism have been replaced with despair and hopelessness.
  4. Memory and Nostalgia: The poem expresses the poet’s nostalgia for his youth and his memories of the past. The poet remembers his youth as a time when he could write poetry and enjoy the company of nature, “Dew-drops are the gems of morning, / But the tears of mournful eve!” (lines 25-26). He also remembers the joys of friendship, love, and liberty that he had in abundance when he was young, “O! the joys, that came down shower-like, / Of Friendship, Love, and Liberty” (lines 19-20). The poet is nostalgic for the passing of his youth and the loss of his creative energy, “Life is but thought: so think I will / That Youth and I are house-mates still” (lines 27-28). The poem is a nostalgic reflection on the passing of youth and the fleeting nature of life.
Literary Theories and Interpretations of “Youth and Age” by Samuel Taylor Coleridge
  1. Biographical Interpretation: This approach examines how the poet’s own life experiences might have influenced the poem. Coleridge struggled with various personal and physical afflictions throughout his life, including addiction and illness. “Youth and Age” could reflect his own feelings of nostalgia for his youth and lamentation for the changes brought about by aging. For example, lines such as “This body that does me grievous wrong” and “What strange disguise hast now put on” may allude to Coleridge’s physical ailments and the sense of betrayal he felt from his own body.
  2. Romanticism: Viewing the poem through the lens of Romanticism highlights its emphasis on nature, emotion, and the passage of time. Coleridge, as a prominent Romantic poet, often explored themes related to nature’s beauty, the passage of time, and the power of imagination. In “Youth and Age,” nature is depicted as a source of joy and freedom in youth, but also as a reminder of mortality and loss in old age. For instance, the imagery of “Flowers are lovely; Love is flower-like” and “Dew-drops are the gems of morning” evokes the Romantic fascination with nature’s beauty and its fleeting nature.
  3. Psychoanalytic Criticism: Applying psychoanalytic theory to the poem involves examining the speaker’s psyche and unconscious motivations. The poem can be seen as a reflection of the speaker’s internal struggle to come to terms with aging and the loss of youth. The repeated questioning and denial of aging (“Ere I was old?” and “It cannot be that Thou art gone!”) suggest a psychological resistance to accepting the passage of time. Additionally, the personification of youth as a “masker bold” and the refusal to acknowledge its departure may indicate a subconscious defense mechanism to cope with mortality and the fear of death.
Critical Questions about “Youth and Age” by Samuel Taylor Coleridge
QuestionAnswer
How does the poem portray the contrast between youth and age?The poem portrays the stark contrast between youth and age through the speaker’s nostalgic and melancholic tone. In youth, the speaker was vibrant and full of vitality, “Life went a-maying / With Nature, Hope, and Poesy” (lines 3-4), while in age, the speaker feels burdened by frailty and weakness, lamenting, “This breathing house not built with hands, / This body that does me grievous wrong” (lines 5-6). The speaker yearns for the vigor of youth and mourns the relentless passage of time, “When I was young?—Ah, woful When! / Ah! for the change ‘twixt Now and Then!” (lines 1-2).
How does the poem use nature imagery to convey the speaker’s emotions?The poem employs vivid nature imagery to convey the speaker’s emotions and illustrate his connection with the natural world. In youth, the speaker’s vitality is echoed in nature’s beauty, “O’er aery cliffs and glittering sands, / How lightly then it flashed along” (lines 9-10), whereas in age, the speaker feels estranged from nature, lamenting, “Nought cared this body for wind or weather / When Youth and I lived in’t together” (lines 11-12). The speaker’s relationship with nature serves as a mirror to his own growth and decline.
How does the poem explore the theme of hope and hopelessness?The poem delves into the theme of hope and hopelessness by contrasting the speaker’s experiences in youth and age. In youth, the speaker exudes hope and optimism, celebrating, “Flowers are lovely; Love is flower-like; / Friendship is a sheltering tree” (lines 13-14), but in age, the speaker is enveloped in despair, lamenting, “When I was old? Ah woeful Ere, / Which tells me, Youth’s no longer here!” (lines 17-18). The speaker’s youthful hopefulness has given way to desolation and hopelessness.
How does the poem use memory and nostalgia to convey the speaker’s emotions?The poem utilizes memory and nostalgia to convey the speaker’s emotions and express his longing for days gone by. The speaker reminisces about the joy and creativity of youth, musing, “Dew-drops are the gems of morning, / But the tears of mournful eve!” (lines 25-26), and nostalgically imagines a continued companionship with youth, reflecting, “Life is but thought: so think I will / That Youth and I are house-mates still” (lines 27-28). The speaker’s wistful nostalgia underscores his regret and
Literary Works Similar to “Youth and Age” by Samuel Taylor Coleridge
  1. “Ode to a Nightingale” by John Keats: This poem by John Keats explores the contrast between the fleeting beauty of youth and the enduring power of art. Like “Youth and Age,” it meditates on the transience of life and the longing for an idealized past.
  2. “When You Are Old” by W.B. Yeats: W.B. Yeats’s poem reflects on aging and lost love, addressing the passage of time and the regrets that come with it. It shares a similar melancholic tone with “Youth and Age” and explores the themes of nostalgia and longing for the past.
  3. “To Autumn” by John Keats: Another poem by Keats, “To Autumn,” celebrates the beauty of the season while also contemplating the passage of time and the inevitability of change. It shares with “Youth and Age” a focus on the cycles of nature and the fleeting nature of youth.
  4. The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock” by T.S. Eliot: T.S. Eliot’s modernist poem delves into the themes of aging, regret, and the fear of mortality. Like “Youth and Age,” it explores the disillusionment and existential angst that can accompany the process of growing older.
  5. Lines Composed a Few Miles above Tintern Abbey” by William Wordsworth: Wordsworth’s poem reflects on the passage of time and the relationship between nature, memory, and the self. It shares with “Youth and Age” a contemplative tone and explores the theme of memory and its role in shaping our understanding of the past.
Suggested Readings: “Youth and Age” by Samuel Taylor Coleridge
  • Coleridge, Samuel Taylor, et al. Samuel Taylor Coleridge. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1985.
  • Youngquist, Paul. “Rehabilitating Coleridge: Poetry, Philosophy, Excess.” ELH 66.4 (1999): 885-909.
  • Coleridge, Samuel Taylor. The complete poetical works of Samuel Taylor Coleridge: including poems and versions of poems now published for the first time. Vol. 1. Clarendon Press, 1912.
  • Coleridge, Samuel Taylor. Poetical Works: Including Poems and Versions of Poems Herein Published for the First Time. H. Frowde, 1912.
Representative Quotations “Youth and Age” by Samuel Taylor Coleridge
QuotationContextTheoretical Perspective
“Both were mine! Life went a-maying With Nature, Hope, and Poesy, When I was young!”Coleridge reminisces about the vitality of youth, deeply connected to nature and creativity.Romanticism – Celebrates youth as a time of innocence and inspiration, intertwining human experience with the natural world.
“O’er aery cliffs and glittering sands, How lightly then it flashed along:— Like those trim skiffs, unknown of yore, On winding lakes and rivers wide…”Coleridge vividly recalls the freedom and agility of youth, unburdened by age.Embodiment – Highlights the youthful body as a vessel of experience, agile and effortless in navigating life’s challenges.
“O Youth! for years so many and sweet, ‘Tis known, that Thou and I were one, I’ll think it but a fond conceit— It cannot be that Thou art gone!”Coleridge refuses to accept the loss of youth, clinging to its enduring presence within himself.Identity Continuity – Reflects the psychological defense mechanism of denial, maintaining a sense of selfhood despite aging.
“Life is but thought: so think I will That Youth and I are house-mates still.”Coleridge equates youth with a state of mind, defying the inevitability of physical aging.Phenomenalism – Suggests reality is constructed through subjective perception, allowing for the subjective experience of youthfulness despite age.
“Where no hope is, life’s a warning That only serves to make us grieve, When we are old: That only serves to make us grieve…”Coleridge reflects on the melancholy reality of old age, where hope diminishes and life becomes burdensome.Existentialism – Emphasizes the struggle to find meaning in the face of mortality, confronting the limitations of human existence in old age.

“Design” by Robert Frost: A Critical Analysis

“Design” by Robert Frost, first published in 1936 as part of his collection “A Further Range”, is a masterful exploration of the human experience.

"Design" by Robert Frost: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “Design” by Robert Frost

“Design” by Robert Frost, first published in 1936 as part of his collection “A Further Range”, is a masterful exploration of the human experience, delving into themes of fate, free will, and the interconnectedness of life. With qualities of concise language, clever imagery, and a nuanced tone, “Design” presents a seemingly simple yet profoundly complex meditation on the nature of existence. The poem’s use of a white moth, a white spider, and a white flower to explore the idea of design in the natural world is a testament to Frost’s skillful craftsmanship, inviting readers to ponder the intricate web of life and our place within it.

Text: “Design” by Robert Frost

I found a dimpled spider, fat and white,
On a white heal-all, holding up a moth
Like a white piece of rigid satin cloth–
Assorted characters of death and blight
Mixed ready to begin the morning right,
Like the ingredients of a witches’ broth–
A snow-drop spider, a flower like a froth,
And dead wings carried like a paper kite.

What had that flower to do with being white,
The wayside blue and innocent heal-all?
What brought the kindred spider to that height,
Then steered the white moth thither in the night?
What but design of darkness to appall?–
If design govern in a thing so small.

Annotations: “Design” by Robert Frost
Text: “Design” by Robert FrostAnnotations
I found a dimpled spider, fat and white,The speaker discovers a spider on a flower, describing it as “fat and white.”
On a white heal-all, holding up a mothThe spider is positioned on a heal-all flower, holding a moth.
Like a white piece of rigid satin cloth–The moth is likened to a piece of white satin cloth.
Assorted characters of death and blightThe scene is described as containing various symbols of death and decay.
Mixed ready to begin the morning right,The imagery suggests a sinister atmosphere preparing for the day ahead.
Like the ingredients of a witches’ broth–The scene is compared to the components of a potion used in witchcraft.
A snow-drop spider, a flower like a froth,Additional elements of the scene are described, including a snow-drop spider and frothy flowers.
And dead wings carried like a paper kite.The image of dead wings being carried is compared to a paper kite.
What had that flower to do with being white,The speaker questions the significance of the flower being white.
The wayside blue and innocent heal-all?The heal-all flower is described as blue and innocent.
What brought the kindred spider to that height,The speaker questions why the spider is on the flower.
Then steered the white moth thither in the night?The speaker wonders what guided the moth to the flower at night.
What but design of darkness to appall?–The poem suggests a sinister purpose behind the arrangement of these elements.
If design govern in a thing so small.The final line reflects on the concept of design or purpose in even the smallest details of nature.

Literary And Poetic Devices: “Design” by Robert Frost

Literary/Poetic DeviceExampleExplanation
Allusion“witches’ broth”Reference to a potion used in witchcraft, creating an atmosphere of mystery and foreboding.
Assonance“snow-drop spider”The repetition of the “o” sound creates a musical effect and draws attention to the spider’s delicate appearance.
Consonance“ready to begin”Repetition of the “d” sound creates a sense of anticipation and readiness.
Enjambment“On a white heal-all, holding up a moth / Like a white piece of rigid satin cloth–“The continuation of a phrase over line breaks creates a sense of flow and visual continuity.
Hyperbole“Assorted characters of death and blight”Exaggeration to emphasize the unsettling nature of the scene and the presence of death.
Imagery“fat and white spider,” “white moth,” “rigid satin cloth,” “dead wings carried like a paper kite”Vivid descriptions that appeal to the senses, creating a clear mental image of the scene.
IronyThe description of the seemingly innocent scene of a spider on a flower holding a moth contrasts with the underlying sinister tone.The speaker observes a scene that appears innocent but carries dark implications, adding layers of meaning to the poem.
Metaphor“Like the ingredients of a witches’ broth”Comparing the scene to the components of a witch’s potion, emphasizing its eerie quality.
Onomatopoeia“dimpled spider”The word “dimpled” suggests the appearance of the spider, adding texture to the description.
Oxymoron“Assorted characters of death and blight”Combining contradictory terms to emphasize the unsettling nature of the scene.
Paradox“Design of darkness to appall”Contradictory statement emphasizing the sinister intention behind the seemingly natural arrangement.
Personification“What brought the kindred spider to that height”Assigning human-like qualities of relationship to the spider and flower, implying a connection between them.
Repetition“white” is repeated multiple times throughout the poemEmphasizing the significance of the color white in the scene and its associations with purity and death.
Simile“Like a white piece of rigid satin cloth–“Comparing the moth to a piece of cloth, highlighting its appearance and texture.
SymbolismThe spider, moth, and flower symbolize various aspects of nature and death.Each element carries symbolic significance, representing broader themes of life, death, and the natural order.
Synecdoche“dead wings”Using a part to represent the whole, emphasizing the moth’s mortality and fragility.
ToneThe tone of the poem is ominous and contemplative, as the speaker reflects on the dark aspects of nature.The overall mood of the poem is somber and introspective, inviting readers to contemplate the deeper meaning behind the scene.
UnderstatementThe simplicity of the language contrasts with the complexity of the themesThe straightforward language belies the depth of meaning and complexity of the scene, creating a sense of understated unease.
WordplayThe title “Design”The title plays with the idea of intentional arrangement in nature, prompting readers to consider the purpose behind seemingly random occurrences.
Themes: “Design” by Robert Frost
  1. Nature’s Cruelty and Indifference: One prominent theme in “Design” is the portrayal of nature as indifferent and even cruel. Frost presents a scene where a seemingly innocent spider is holding a moth on a flower, creating an image of death and decay. The description of “Assorted characters of death and blight” and the comparison to a “witches’ broth” evoke a sense of darkness and malevolence within the natural world. This theme is reinforced by the speaker’s contemplation of the purpose behind such arrangements, suggesting a design of darkness that appalls. Despite the beauty of the white flower and the delicate moth, their encounter ends in death, highlighting nature’s indifference to life and its relentless cycle of creation and destruction.
  2. The Ambiguity of Design and Purpose: Another theme explored in “Design” is the ambiguity surrounding the concept of design and purpose in nature. The speaker questions the significance of the spider, moth, and flower being brought together in such a manner, suggesting a deliberate arrangement with sinister implications. The repetition of the word “white” and the description of the scene as if it were carefully crafted underscore the idea of design, but the speaker ultimately concludes with uncertainty, pondering whether design governs even in the smallest details of nature. This theme invites readers to consider the complexity of nature and the mysteries that lie beyond human comprehension.
  3. The Duality of Innocence and Malevolence: “Design” also explores the duality between innocence and malevolence, particularly in the context of the natural world. The poem presents seemingly innocent elements—a white flower, a moth, and a spider—yet juxtaposes them in a way that suggests darker undertones. The innocence of the white flower and the delicate moth is contrasted with the predatory nature of the spider, creating a tension between beauty and danger. This theme is reinforced by the description of the moth’s dead wings carried like a paper kite, symbolizing the fragility of life and the inevitability of death. Through this duality, Frost highlights the complexities of nature and the inherent tension between life and death.
  4. Human Reflection on Nature’s Mysteries: Finally, “Design” reflects the human inclination to reflect on the mysteries of nature and seek meaning in seemingly random occurrences. The speaker’s contemplation of the scene—a spider holding a moth on a flower—reveals a desire to understand the underlying purpose or design behind such arrangements. This theme is evident in lines such as “What brought the kindred spider to that height” and “What but design of darkness to appall?,” where the speaker grapples with existential questions about the nature of existence and the role of design in shaping the world. Through this introspection, Frost invites readers to ponder the complexities of the natural world and the limitations of human understanding when confronted with its mysteries.
Literary Theories and Interpretations of “Design” by Robert Frost
TheoryInterpretationExampleExplanation
SymbolismThe poem is rich in symbols that represent death, innocence, and darkness.The spider, moth, and heal-all flower symbolize death, innocence, and purity respectively.Frost uses these symbols to explore the idea of design and intention in nature, questioning whether there is a larger purpose or governing force behind the intricate web of life and death.
NaturalismThe poem presents a bleak and deterministic view of nature, where life and death are intertwined.The “assorted characters of death and blight” and “dead wings carried like a paper kite” illustrate the natural world’s indifference to life.Frost’s poem highlights the natural world’s amoral and unforgiving nature, where life and death coexist and are inescapably linked.
ExistentialismThe poem raises questions about the purpose and meaning of life, encouraging the reader to ponder the existence of a larger design or governing force.The speaker’s rhetorical questions (“What had that flower to do with being white…?”, “What but design of darkness to appall?”) illustrate the search for meaning and purpose.Frost’s poem invites the reader to confront the possibility that there may be no inherent design or purpose in life, leaving us to create our own meaning in an uncertain world.
Critical Questions about “Design” by Robert Frost
  • Question 1: What is the speaker’s attitude towards the natural world, and how does this attitude relate to the concept of “design”?
  • The speaker’s attitude towards the natural world is one of curiosity and skepticism, as evident in the lines “What had that flower to do with being white, / The wayside blue and innocent heal-all?” (Frost 5-6). The speaker seems to be questioning the purpose or intention behind the natural world’s arrangements, implying a sense of detachment or even disillusionment. This attitude is central to the poem’s exploration of “design,” as the speaker wonders whether there is a governing force or intention behind the intricate web of life and death.
  • Question 2: How does the poem’s use of imagery and symbolism contribute to its themes of death, innocence, and design?
  • The poem’s use of imagery and symbolism is crucial in conveying its themes, as seen in the lines “A snow-drop spider, a flower like a froth, / And dead wings carried like a paper kite” (Frost 7-8). The snow-drop spider and heal-all flower symbolize death and innocence, respectively, while the dead wings evoke a sense of fragility and mortality. These images, along with the “dimpled spider” and “white piece of rigid satin cloth” (Frost 1-2), create a vivid and unsettling picture of life and death intertwined, underscoring the speaker’s questions about design and intention.
  • Question 3: What is the significance of the speaker’s final question, “What but design of darkness to appall?” (Frost 14), and how does it relate to the poem’s overall message?
  • The speaker’s final question, “What but design of darkness to appall?” (Frost 14), is a rhetorical one, implying that the natural world’s arrangements may be governed by a “design of darkness” that is beyond human comprehension. This question resonates with the poem’s overall message, suggesting that the natural world is indifferent to human life and that our existence may be subject to forces beyond our control. The use of “appall” also implies a sense of horror or dismay, highlighting the speaker’s ambivalence towards the natural world and its mysterious designs.
Literary Works Similar to “Design” by Robert Frost
  1. “The Second Coming” by W.B. Yeats – This poem delves into themes of chaos, darkness, and the idea of an impending apocalyptic event. Like “Design,” it explores the presence of evil and foreboding in the world.
  2. Ozymandias” by Percy Bysshe Shelley – While not directly addressing the themes of evil or fate, this poem reflects on the transience of power and the inevitable decline of empires. It shares a sense of irony and contemplation about the nature of existence, akin to Frost’s work.
  3. “The Hollow Men” by T.S. Eliot – This poem explores themes of emptiness, disillusionment, and the frailty of human existence. It shares with “Design” a sense of desolation and the presence of malevolent forces.
  4. The Rime of the Ancient Mariner” by Samuel Taylor Coleridge – This epic poem explores themes of sin, redemption, and the supernatural. Like “Design,” it contains elements of darkness and explores the consequences of human actions.
  5. “A Poison Tree” by William Blake – This poem explores the theme of repressed anger and the destructive power of holding onto grudges. It shares with “Design” a sense of darkness and the potential for evil within human nature.
Suggested Readings: “Design” by Robert Frost
Representative Quotations “Design” by Robert Frost
QuotationContext and Theoretical Perspective
“I found a dimpled spider, fat and white, / On a white heal-all, holding up a moth / Like a white piece of rigid satin cloth”The speaker describes a scene where a spider, a heal-all flower, and a moth are juxtaposed. The whiteness of the spider, flower, and moth creates an eerie atmosphere. From a theoretical perspective, this imagery evokes a sense of symbolism, suggesting themes of purity, death, and the interconnectedness of life and death.
“Assorted characters of death and blight / Mixed ready to begin the morning right, / Like the ingredients of a witches’ broth”The speaker observes the scene as if it were a concoction of death and decay, likening it to a witches’ broth. This metaphor emphasizes the ominous nature of the scene. From a theoretical perspective, this imagery could be interpreted through a lens of existentialism, highlighting the randomness and absurdity of existence, where life and death coexist in a chaotic manner.
“What had that flower to do with being white, / The wayside blue and innocent heal-all?”The speaker questions the significance of the white flower (heal-all) in the context of its surroundings. This line reflects on the arbitrary nature of existence and the puzzling coexistence of innocence and death. From a theoretical perspective, this reflects existentialist themes of questioning the meaning and purpose behind seemingly random events in life.
“What brought the kindred spider to that height, / Then steered the white moth thither in the night?”The speaker wonders about the forces or “design” behind the spider’s actions and the moth’s fate. This line suggests a sense of inevitability or predetermined fate, implying that there might be a hidden order or design governing even the smallest occurrences in nature. From a theoretical perspective, this raises questions about determinism versus free will and the existence of a higher power or cosmic order.
“What but design of darkness to appall?– / If design govern in a thing so small.”The speaker concludes by suggesting that the scene is governed by a malevolent “design of darkness.” This final statement underscores the eerie and unsettling nature of the scene, implying that even the smallest details of existence may be orchestrated by sinister forces. From a theoretical perspective, this echoes themes of nihilism, suggesting that life is ultimately governed by forces beyond human comprehension, leading to a sense of existential dread and despair.

“An Inquiry” by Anton Chekhov: A Critical Analysis

“An Inquiry” by Anton Chekhov, an influential writer, was published in 1886 as part of the collection “Motley Stories” or “Pestrye rasskazy”.

"An Inquiry" by Anton Chekhov: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “An Inquiry” by Anton Chekhov

“An Inquiry” by Anton Chekhov, an influential writer, was published in 1886 as part of the collection “Motley Stories” or “Pestrye rasskazy”. This marked a significant milestone in Chekhov’s writing career, as it showcased his unique blend of humor and incisive social commentary. Through this collection, Chekhov’s signature style began to take shape, demonstrating his mastery of crafting stories that both entertain and provoke thought.

Main Events in “An Inquiry” by Anton Chekhov
  1. Voldyrev’s Arrival at the Government Office:
    • Voldyrev, a country gentleman, enters the government office to make an inquiry.
    • He encounters a porter and asks for directions to the inquiry desk.
  2. Interaction with the Clerk:
    • Voldyrev approaches the clerk, who is absorbed in his work and indifferent to his presence.
    • Despite Voldyrev’s repeated attempts to get the clerk’s attention, he is ignored.
  3. Frustration and Persistence:
    • Voldyrev becomes increasingly frustrated as the clerk continues to disregard him.
    • He tries to draw the clerk’s attention to his lawsuit with the heirs of Princess Gugulin but is unsuccessful.
  4. Offering a Bribe:
    • In a desperate attempt to get the clerk’s attention, Voldyrev lays a rouble note on the clerk’s desk.
    • The clerk momentarily notices the money but quickly returns to his work.
  5. Further Attempts to Communicate:
    • Voldyrev tries to engage the clerk in conversation about his case, but the clerk remains preoccupied.
  6. Suggestion from the Porter:
    • The porter advises Voldyrev to offer more money to the clerk to secure his cooperation.
  7. Offering a Larger Bribe:
    • Voldyrev lays another rouble note on the clerk’s desk, hoping to finally get his attention.
  8. The Clerk’s Response:
    • The clerk finally acknowledges Voldyrev and becomes attentive to his needs.
    • He provides the necessary information and assistance regarding Voldyrev’s inquiry.
  9. Sudden Change in Attitude:
    • Once the clerk is engaged with Voldyrev, he becomes friendly and helpful, offering assistance with the inquiry and making small talk.
  10. Completion of the Inquiry:
    • The clerk efficiently handles Voldyrev’s request, arranges for a copy of the resolution, and provides additional assistance.
    • Voldyrev leaves the office feeling uncomfortable but satisfied with the outcome of his inquiry.
  11. Parting Gift:
    • Before leaving, Voldyrev gives the clerk another rouble as a token of appreciation.
    • The clerk graciously accepts the money, bowing and smiling in gratitude.
  12. Reflection on the Encounter:
    • Voldyrev reflects on the encounter with the clerk and the system of bribery and corruption within the government office.
    • Despite his discomfort, he acknowledges the necessity of offering bribes to expedite bureaucratic processes.
Literary Devices in “An Inquiry” by Anton Chekhov
DeviceExplanation
AllusionReference to the “Council of the second of March” without explanation, assuming the reader is familiar with the context.
CharacterizationChekhov’s vivid descriptions of Voldyrev and the clerk, revealing their personalities and traits.
ContrastThe clerk’s sudden change from indifference to enthusiasm after receiving the third rouble note.
DialogueConversations between Voldyrev and the clerk, revealing their characters and advancing the plot.
FlashbackVoldyrev’s recollection of his lawsuit with the heirs of Princess Gugulin.
HyperboleThe clerk’s exaggerated reactions and movements, such as his “hurricane-like” liveliness.
ImageryVivid descriptions of settings and characters, like the “green table spotted like typhus” and the clerk’s “long pimply nose”.
IronyVoldyrev’s frustration and helplessness despite his wealth and social status.
JuxtapositionThe contrast between Voldyrev’s dignified appearance and his humiliating treatment by the clerk.
MetaphorComparing the clerk’s writing to a “hurricane” and the rouble notes to “conjuring tricks”.
MotifThe recurring theme of corruption and bribery in the government office.
Narrative StructureThe story’s linear progression, following Voldyrev’s visit to the government office.
PathosEvoking sympathy for Voldyrev’s plight and frustration.
PersonificationAttributing human-like qualities to the fly, which “walked” and “settled” on the clerk’s ear.
SatireChekhov’s critique of bureaucratic corruption and inefficiency.
SettingThe vivid description of the government office, creating a sense of atmosphere and context.
SymbolismThe rouble notes symbolizing bribery and corruption.
ToneChekhov’s sarcastic and ironic tone, conveyed through the narrative voice and character interactions.
VerisimilitudeThe realistic portrayal of a government office and its inner workings.
Characterization in “An Inquiry” by Anton Chekhov
Major Character: Voldyrev
  • Appearance: Voldyrev is portrayed as a tall, thick-set country gentleman with a cropped head and prominent eyes. This physical description suggests his stature and presence.
  • Actions: He takes the initiative to inquire at the government office, persistently attempts to gain the clerk’s attention, and resorts to offering bribes to expedite the process. These actions demonstrate his determination and frustration with bureaucratic inefficiency.
  • Thoughts and Feelings: Throughout the story, Voldyrev experiences increasing frustration and desperation as he is repeatedly ignored by the clerk. His discomfort with the system of bribery is evident in his inner reflections.
Minor Character: Clerk
  • Appearance: The clerk is described as a young man with hair standing up in four tufts, a long pimply nose, and a care-worn expression. This physical description adds to the clerk’s portrayal as indifferent and absorbed in his work.
  • Actions: Initially, the clerk is entirely absorbed in his tasks, ignoring Voldyrev’s attempts to communicate. It is only after receiving bribes that he becomes attentive and helpful.
  • Thoughts and Feelings: While the story does not directly delve into the clerk’s inner thoughts and feelings, his actions suggest a lack of concern for the needs of others until incentivized.
Minor Character: Porter
  • Appearance: The porter’s appearance is not explicitly described in the story.
  • Actions: He provides Voldyrev with directions to the inquiry desk and suggests offering a bribe to the clerk to expedite the process. This indicates his familiarity with the inner workings of the government office and the prevalence of corruption.
  • Thoughts and Feelings: The porter’s advice to Voldyrev reflects a pragmatic understanding of how to navigate the bureaucracy, indicating a resignation to the system’s flaws.
Examples from the Story:
  • Voldyrev’s frustration is palpable as he repeatedly tries to gain the clerk’s attention to no avail.
  • The clerk’s indifference is underscored by his lack of response until he is enticed with bribes.
  • The porter’s suggestion highlights the systemic corruption within the government office, portraying a bleak reality of bureaucratic inefficiency.
Major Themes in “An Inquiry” by Anton Chekhov
  1. Bureaucracy and Inefficiency: The story is a masterclass in depicting the frustrating nature of bureaucracy. Voldyrev politely inquires about his case but is repeatedly ignored. The clerks, described as a “scribbling brotherhood” focus on paperwork and swatting flies rather than assisting him. Voldyrev coughs, blows his nose, and tries to get their attention for a full two minutes before resorting to other measures. This extended sequence emphasizes the inefficiency and indifference of the bureaucratic system.
  2. Corruption: The turning point in the story arrives when Voldyrev resorts to bribery. He lays a rouble note on an open book before the clerk, who promptly ignores him. Only after placing another rouble note on the book does the clerk finally acknowledge Voldyrev. This blatant exchange highlights the corrupt nature of the system, where basic services are only obtainable through unofficial means. The story doesn’t judge Voldyrev for resorting to bribery, instead focusing on the system that necessitates such actions.
  3. Social Class: Chekhov subtly critiques the disparity in social treatment based on class. Voldyrev, despite being a landowner, is initially disregarded by the lower-ranking clerks. The clerk doesn’t even acknowledge him, shouting instead about a merchant who needs to sign a complaint. This highlights the power dynamic at play. However, once Voldyrev offers bribes, he is treated with respect and deference. The clerk becomes “as lively as though he were whirled round by a hurricane,” providing information, a copy of the resolution, and even small talk about the weather. The story exposes the hypocrisy of the social hierarchy, where outward respect is easily bought, not earned.
  4. Isolation and Helplessness: Voldyrev’s experience is marked by a sense of isolation. He is unable to navigate the complex bureaucratic system on his own. The silence after his inquiries lasts for two minutes, emphasizing his feeling of being unheard and powerless. The porter’s advice to bribe the clerk further underscores Voldyrev’s helplessness within the system. Chekhov evokes a sense of sympathy for the individual struggling within a larger, uncaring system.
Writing Style in “An Inquiry” by Anton Chekhov
  • Concise and direct language:
    • Example: “IT was midday. Voldyrev, a tall, thick-set country gentleman… took off his overcoat, mopped his brow with his silk handkerchief, and somewhat diffidently went into the government office.”
  • Vivid descriptions:
    • Example: “a young man with his hair standing up in four tufts on his head, with a long pimply nose, and a long faded uniform”
  • Satirical tone:
    • Example: “They write! They write, the devil take them entirely!” (Voldyrev’s frustrated thought)
  • Irony:
    • Example: Voldyrev’s dignified appearance and social status contrasted with his humiliating treatment by the clerk
  • Symbolism:
    • Example: The rouble notes symbolizing bribery and corruption
  • Characterization through action:
    • Example: The clerk’s sudden change from indifference to enthusiasm after receiving the third rouble note
  • Dialogue revealing character:
    • Example: Voldyrev’s polite and respectful language vs. the clerk’s dismissive and rude tone
  • Imagery and sensory details:
    • Example: “a green table spotted like typhus”, “a fly was walking about near his right nostril”
  • Bureaucratic language and jargon:
    • Example: “the resolution of the Council of the second of March”, “the complaint lodged with the police”
  • Contrast and juxtaposition:
    • Example: Voldyrev’s dignified appearance vs. the clerk’s disheveled and unprofessional appearance
  • Realistic portrayal of setting:
    • Example: The vivid description of the government office, including the “scratching” sounds of writing and the “furthest recesses” of the office
Literary Theories and Interpretation of “An Inquiry” by Anton Chekhov

1. Realism:

  • Focus on Everyday Life: Chekhov’s story is a prime example of realism. It depicts a mundane situation – a man trying to navigate a bureaucratic maze – with meticulous detail. The descriptions of the office, the clerk’s appearance, and even the fly buzzing around him create a sense of authenticity and familiarity.
  • Social Commentary: Realism often critiques social issues. Here, Chekhov exposes the inefficiency and corruption within the bureaucracy. The indifferent, fly-chasing clerk only becomes helpful after receiving bribes. This highlights the plight of ordinary citizens who are forced to navigate a system rigged against them.

2. Marxism:

  • Class Conflict: A Marxist interpretation would focus on the power dynamics between social classes. Voldyrev, despite being a landowner, is powerless against the lower-ranking clerk. The clerk’s dismissive behavior and demands for bribes reflect the exploitation of the upper class over the working class.
  • Alienation: Marxism also explores the concept of alienation from labor. The clerk’s monotonous routine of copying documents contributes to a sense of alienation from his work. He lacks any real agency or control over his role within the system.

3. Absurdism:

  • Meaninglessness of Existence: An absurdist approach would view Voldyrev’s struggle as inherently meaningless. His attempts to navigate the bureaucracy are met with frustration and absurdity. The act of repeatedly offering bribes becomes a comical yet futile attempt to make sense of a nonsensical system.
  • Isolation of the Individual: Absurdism emphasizes the isolation of the individual in a chaotic world. Voldyrev’s repeated attempts to communicate are ignored, highlighting the absurdity of human connection. The story’s ending, where Voldyrev feels strangely compelled to offer another bribe, reinforces this sense of isolation and powerlessness.
Topics, Questions, and Thesis Statements about “An Inquiry” by Anton Chekhov
TopicQuestionThesis Statement
Corruption and BureaucracyHow does Chekhov portray the corrupt and inefficient nature of the government office in “An Inquiry”?In “An Inquiry”, Chekhov uses satire and irony to expose the corrupt and bureaucratic system of the government office, highlighting the struggle of the individual against the oppressive and indifferent authorities.
Social Class and StatusHow does Chekhov use Voldyrev’s character to comment on social class and status in “An Inquiry”?Through Voldyrev’s experiences, Chekhov critiques the social hierarchy of Imperial Russia, revealing how wealth and status are no guarantee of respect or fair treatment, and highlighting the vulnerabilities of the upper class.
Power Dynamics and ControlHow does Chekhov portray the power dynamics between Voldyrev and the clerk in “An Inquiry”?In “An Inquiry”, Chekhov explores the theme of power and control, demonstrating how the clerk’s manipulation of Voldyrev reveals the corrupting influence of authority and the ways in which those in power maintain control over others.
Absurdity and FutilityHow does Chekhov use absurdity and futility to comment on the human condition in “An Inquiry”?Through the absurd and futile interactions between Voldyrev and the clerk, Chekhov highlights the existential crisis of modern life, revealing the absurdity and futility of human endeavors in the face of bureaucratic indifference and the search for meaning.
Short Questions/Answers about/on “An Inquiry” by Anton Chekhov
  1. What is the central conflict in “An Inquiry”? The central conflict revolves around Voldyrev’s futile attempts to navigate the bureaucratic system at the government office. Despite his earnest inquiries, he is repeatedly ignored by the clerk, highlighting the frustrations of dealing with bureaucratic inefficiency. This conflict is evident in Voldyrev’s increasing desperation and the clerk’s indifference to his needs.
  2. How does Voldyrev attempt to overcome the obstacles he faces in the government office? Voldyrev tries various tactics to gain the clerk’s attention and expedite his inquiry. He persistently addresses the clerk, attempts to engage him in conversation, and ultimately resorts to offering bribes to secure his cooperation. These actions reflect Voldyrev’s determination and frustration with the bureaucratic process, as he navigates the system’s complexities in search of a resolution to his inquiry.
  3. What role does bribery play in the story? Bribery serves as a means for Voldyrev to overcome the bureaucratic hurdles he encounters at the government office. When traditional methods of communication fail, Voldyrev resorts to offering bribes to the clerk in exchange for his cooperation. The porter even advises him to offer more money to expedite the process, highlighting the prevalence of corruption within the system. This theme underscores the story’s critique of bureaucratic inefficiency and the moral compromises individuals are forced to make in order to navigate it.
  4. How does Chekhov characterize the clerk and the porter? Chekhov characterizes the clerk as indifferent and absorbed in his work, initially ignoring Voldyrev’s inquiries until bribed. In contrast, the porter is portrayed as pragmatic and knowledgeable about the inner workings of the government office. He offers Voldyrev advice on how to navigate the bureaucracy, reflecting a resigned acceptance of the system’s flaws. These characterizations add depth to the story’s exploration of bureaucratic inefficiency and corruption, portraying a bleak reality of societal dysfunction.
Literary Works Similar to “An Inquiry” by Anton Chekhov
  1. The Overcoat” by Nikolai Gogol: Gogol’s story explores themes of bureaucratic absurdity and the dehumanizing effects of a rigid social hierarchy. Similar to “An Inquiry,” it depicts the struggles of a low-ranking government clerk who faces indifference and mistreatment from his superiors.
  2. Bartleby, the Scrivener” by Herman Melville: Melville’s story delves into the life of a scrivener who gradually withdraws from society and refuses to perform his duties, embodying themes of alienation and resistance to authority. Like “An Inquiry,” it critiques the dehumanizing nature of bureaucratic systems.
  3. “The Nose” by Nikolai Gogol: In this satirical tale, a man wakes up to find that his nose has inexplicably disappeared, leading to absurd encounters with authority figures and a bureaucratic investigation. Like “An Inquiry,” it employs humor and absurdity to critique societal norms and bureaucratic inefficiency.
  4. The Bet” by Anton Chekhov: Chekhov’s story revolves around a bet between a banker and a young lawyer, exploring themes of morality, materialism, and the corrupting influence of wealth. While different in plot, it shares Chekhov’s characteristic focus on human nature and societal critique.
  5. The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson: Jackson’s chilling story depicts a small town’s annual lottery, revealing the dark underbelly of conformity and mob mentality. Like “An Inquiry,” it explores themes of social conformity, power dynamics, and the dangers of blindly following tradition.
Suggested Readings about/on “An Inquiry” by Anton Chekhov
  • Bayley, John. Chekhov: A Biographical and Critical Study. Cambridge University Press, 1983.
  • Chekhov, Anton. The Collected Short Stories of Anton Chekhov. DigiCat, 2022.
  • Chekhov, Anton. Anton Chekhov: The Collected Novellas and Short Stories in Multiple Translations. DigiCat, 2023.
  • Chekhov, Anton. The Collected Works of Anton Chekhov: Plays, Novellas, Short Stories, Autobiographical Writings & Reminiscences. DigiCat, 2023.
  • Hagan, John. “Chekhov’s Fiction and the Ideal of “Objectivity”.” PMLA 81.5 (1966): 409-417.
Representative Quotations from “An Inquiry” by Anton Chekhov
QuotationContextTheoretical Perspective
“Where can I make an inquiry here?”Voldyrev seeks assistance upon entering the government office to make an inquiry about a resolution of the Council.Reader-Response Criticism: Initiates reader engagement by presenting a question that establishes the narrative conflict and prompts curiosity about the unfolding events.
“Can I make an inquiry here?”Voldyrev repeats his inquiry to the clerk, who remains absorbed in his work and indifferent to his presence.Marxist Criticism: Reflects the power dynamics within bureaucratic systems, where lower-ranking individuals struggle for attention and assistance from those in positions of authority.
“A little inquiry… May I trouble you?”Voldyrev attempts to engage the clerk in conversation, emphasizing the simplicity and brevity of his request.Structuralism: Highlights the significance of language and communication in shaping interpersonal interactions, as Voldyrev seeks to navigate the bureaucratic system through verbal exchange.
“They write!”Voldyrev’s frustrated thought as he observes the clerks immersed in their tasks, ignoring his inquiries.Postcolonial Criticism: Suggests a critique of hierarchical power structures and the marginalization of individuals within bureaucratic institutions, reflecting themes of oppression and alienation.
“You give him three roubles.”The porter advises Voldyrev to offer a larger bribe to the clerk to secure his cooperation in the inquiry.Feminist Criticism: Illustrates the commodification of assistance, where individuals with financial resources exert power and influence over those in subordinate positions, perpetuating systemic inequalities.
“Ah… what do you want?”The clerk finally acknowledges Voldyrev’s presence after being offered a bribe, displaying sudden attentiveness.Psychoanalytic Criticism: Implies a shift in the clerk’s subconscious motivations, as the promise of financial gain prompts him to engage with Voldyrev and fulfill his duties.
“The Gugulin case, isn’t it? Very good.”The clerk becomes cooperative and lively after receiving the bribe, providing assistance with Voldyrev’s inquiry and engaging in friendly conversation.New Historicism: Reflects the transactional nature of interpersonal relationships within bureaucratic systems, where bribery facilitates social interaction and influences outcomes.
“Well, what people!”Voldyrev reflects on the encounter as he leaves the government office, acknowledging the societal norms and behaviors observed during his inquiry.Cultural Criticism: Offers insight into social dynamics and norms within bureaucratic institutions, emphasizing the acceptance and normalization of bribery as a means of navigating bureaucratic processes.

“An Uncomfortable Bed” by Guy de Maupassant: A Critical Analysis

“An Uncomfortable Bed” by Guy de Maupassant first appeared in print in 1884, though the exact collection remains uncertain.

"An Uncomfortable Bed" by Guy de Maupassant: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “An Uncomfortable Bed” by Guy de Maupassant

“An Uncomfortable Bed” by Guy de Maupassant first appeared in print in 1884, though the exact collection remains uncertain. The story showcases Maupassant’s signature strengths as a short story writer. With its economical prose and unexpected twist, “An Uncomfortable Bed” exemplifies his ability to weave tension and humor into a tightly constructed narrative. The protagonist’s escalating paranoia, fueled by his friends’ reputation for practical jokes, keeps the reader engaged while prompting reflection on the subjectivity of perception and the potential for self-sabotage.

Main Events in “An Uncomfortable Bed” by Guy de Maupassant
  1. Arrival at the Chateau: The narrator arrives at a chateau in Picardy for the hunting season and is given a warm welcome by his friends.
  2. Suspicion of a Practical Joke: The narrator is suspicious of his friends’ excessive merriment and thinks they are planning a practical joke on him.
  3. Bedtime Preparations: The narrator takes precautions to avoid a potential joke, lighting all the candles, closing the shutters, and dragging the mattress into the middle of the room.
  4. A Sleepless Hour: The narrator remains awake for an hour, starting at every sound, before finally falling asleep.
  5. A Sudden Awakening: The narrator is awakened by a heavy body falling on top of him and a burning liquid being poured on his face.
  6. Panic and Confusion: The narrator feels suffocated, stretches out his hand, and hits the face of the person on top of him, receiving a hail of cuffings in return.
  7. Escape into the Corridor: The narrator jumps out of bed and rushes into the corridor in his nightshirt.
  8. The Morning After: The narrator finds it is broad daylight, and his friends are hurrying into the apartment.
  9. The Valet’s Mishap: The narrator and his friends find the valet, who was bringing the narrator his morning tea, sprawled over the improvised bed, having tripped and spilled the tea.
  10. The Joke Backfires: The narrator realizes that his precautions have led to the very interlude he was trying to avoid, and his friends laugh at the absurdity of the situation.
Literary Devices in “An Uncomfortable Bed” by Guy de Maupassant
Literary DeviceExampleExplanation
Allusion“a sideboard laden with plates and dishes”Reference to a common object to create a vivid image.
Amplification“excessive mirth”, “far too great”Emphasizing a point by repeating or strengthening it.
Anaphora“I did not want to be caught. Ah! certainly not! certainly not!”Repetition of a phrase or word at the beginning of successive clauses.
Assumption“They must be looking out in their own minds for some good bit of fun.”The narrator assumes his friends’ intentions without explicit evidence.
Characterization“My friends were fond of practical joking, as all my friends are.”Description of a character’s traits or qualities.
Climax“I was awakened with a start by the fall of a heavy body”The most intense or critical moment in the story.
Exaggeration“a princely reception”Overstatement for emphasis or effect.
Foreshadowing“I smelled a practical joke in the air”Hinting at events that will occur later in the story.
Hyperbole“a double share of amusement”Exaggeration for emphasis or effect.
Imagery“the faces of the servants”, “the ceiling, the hangings, the floor”Vivid descriptions to create mental images.
Inference“I thought: ‘Here are people who take a double share of amusement, and apparently without reason.'”Drawing a conclusion based on evidence or circumstances.
IronyThe narrator’s precautions leading to the very outcome he tried to avoidA contrast between what is expected and what occurs.
Juxtaposition“I was watchful, restless. I did not let a word or a meaning or a gesture escape me.”Placing two or more elements side by side to compare or contrast.
MisdirectionThe narrator’s focus on the bed and his friends’ joke, when the real joke comes from the valetDiverting attention away from the true source of the joke.
Narrative Hook“One autumn I went to stay for the hunting season with some friends in a chateau in Picardy.”An opening that grabs the reader’s attention.
Onomatopoeia“a dreadful noise, as if a sideboard laden with plates and dishes had fallen down”Words imitating the sounds they describe.
ParanoiaThe narrator’s suspicion and mistrust of his friendsExcessive or irrational suspicion or mistrust.
Personification“the bed was particularly suspicious-looking”Attributing human qualities or characteristics to non-human entities.
SuspenseThe narrator’s wait for the joke to unfoldA feeling of tension or anticipation.
Understatement“I was ridiculous”Downplaying the significance or seriousness of something.
Characterization in “An Uncomfortable Bed” by Guy de Maupassant
Major Character: Narrator
  • The narrator is depicted as cautious, suspicious, and easily startled. He is aware of his friends’ penchant for practical jokes and is constantly on guard against becoming the victim.
  • Example: “I said to myself: ‘Look out, old ferret! They have something in preparation for you.'”
Minor Characters: Friends
  • The friends of the narrator are described as fond of practical joking and eager to orchestrate elaborate pranks.
  • Example: “My friends were fond of practical joking, as all my friends are.”
Minor Character: Servants
  • The servants in the chateau are mentioned briefly but contribute to the atmosphere of suspicion and paranoia.
  • Example: “I even looked distrustfully at the faces of the servants.”
Minor Character: Valet
  • The valet plays a crucial role in the practical joke orchestrated by the narrator’s friends, though unwittingly. He becomes the unexpected perpetrator of the final prank.
  • Example: “we found, sprawling over my improvised bed, the dismayed valet, who, while bringing me my morning cup of tea, had tripped over this obstacle in the middle of the floor, and fallen on his stomach, spilling, in spite of himself, my breakfast over my face.”
Major Themes in “An Uncomfortable Bed” by Guy de Maupassant
  • Theme 1: Paranoia and Suspicion
  • The story highlights the dangers of unchecked paranoia and suspicion. The narrator’s assumption that his friends are plotting a practical joke on him leads him to take extreme precautions, which ultimately lead to the very outcome he tried to avoid. His suspicion and mistrust are so intense that he becomes convinced that even the servants are in on the joke, demonstrating how paranoia can lead to a distorted perception of reality. For example, when the narrator hears laughter and whispering in the corridor, he immediately assumes it’s his friends spying on him, rather than considering alternative explanations.
  • Theme 2: The Power of Assumptions
  • The story showcases how assumptions can lead to misinterpretation and misunderstanding. The narrator assumes his friends’ intentions and takes action based on those assumptions, without ever confirming them. This highlights how assumptions can lead to a self-fulfilling prophecy, where our beliefs shape our experiences. For instance, the narrator assumes the bed is suspicious and takes drastic measures to avoid a potential joke, which ultimately leads to the valet’s accident and the very outcome he feared.
  • Theme 3: The Unreliability of Perception
  • The story demonstrates how our perceptions can be unreliable and influenced by our biases and assumptions. The narrator’s perception of the situation is skewed by his paranoia and suspicion, leading him to misinterpret innocent events and behaviors. For example, when the valet enters the room with the tea, the narrator assumes it’s part of the joke, rather than a genuine attempt to serve him. This highlights how our perceptions can be distorted by our preconceptions and assumptions.
  • Theme 4: The Consequences of Overthinking
  • The story illustrates the consequences of overthinking and overanalyzing situations. The narrator’s excessive caution and preparation lead to a series of events that ultimately result in the very outcome he tried to avoid. This highlights how overthinking can lead to a self-fulfilling prophecy, where our excessive caution and preparation create the very problems we’re trying to avoid. For instance, if the narrator had simply gone to bed without taking extreme precautions, the valet’s accident might not have occurred.
Writing Style in “An Uncomfortable Bed” by Guy de Maupassant
  • Conversational tone: Maupassant uses a conversational tone to create a sense of intimacy and immediacy, drawing the reader into the narrator’s thoughts and feelings.
  • Example: “I do not care to know any other sort of people. I said to myself: ‘Look out, old ferret! They have something in preparation for you.'”
  • Irony and sarcasm: Maupassant employs irony and sarcasm to highlight the narrator’s paranoia and the absurdity of the situation.
  • Example: “Ah! certainly not! certainly not! Then I suddenly bethought myself of a precaution which I consider one of extreme efficacy…”
  • Vivid imagery: Maupassant uses vivid imagery to create a sense of atmosphere and tension, drawing the reader into the narrator’s world.
  • Example: “I heard laughter and whispering in the corridor. Without doubt they were spying on me. I cast a glance around the walls, the furniture, the ceiling, the hangings, the floor.”
  • Stream-of-consciousness: Maupassant employs stream-of-consciousness narration to convey the narrator’s thoughts and feelings in real-time, creating a sense of urgency and immediacy.
  • Example: “I thought: ‘Here are people who take a double share of amusement, and apparently without reason. They must be looking out in their own minds for some good bit of fun. Assuredly I am to be the victim of the joke. Attention!'”
  • Hyperbole and exaggeration: Maupassant uses hyperbole and exaggeration to emphasize the narrator’s paranoia and the absurdity of the situation.
  • Example: “a princely reception”, “a double share of amusement”
  • Buildup of tension: Maupassant expertly builds tension throughout the story, creating a sense of anticipation and suspense in the reader.
  • Example: “I remained awake for at least another hour, starting at the slightest sound. Everything seemed quiet in the chateau. I fell asleep.”
  • Unexpected twist: Maupassant uses an unexpected twist at the end of the story to subvert the reader’s expectations and create a sense of surprise and irony.
Literary Theories and Interpretation of “An Uncomfortable Bed” by Guy de Maupassant
Literary TheoryInterpretationExampleCritique
Psychoanalytic TheoryThe story can be interpreted through the lens of psychoanalytic theory, focusing on the narrator’s subconscious fears and anxieties manifesting in his paranoia and distrust.The narrator’s constant suspicion and fear of being the victim of a practical joke reflect deep-seated anxieties and insecurities.Critics might argue that while psychoanalytic interpretations can provide insight into characters’ motivations and behaviors, they can also be speculative and subjective, depending heavily on the interpreter’s analysis.
Marxist TheoryA Marxist interpretation might view the story as a commentary on the power dynamics between social classes, with the wealthy friends exerting control and dominance over the narrator, who is portrayed as more vulnerable and subordinate.The friends’ privileged position allows them to orchestrate elaborate pranks at the expense of the narrator, highlighting their social and economic advantage.Critics might argue that while Marxist analysis can uncover underlying power structures and inequalities, it may oversimplify the complexities of human relationships and motivations depicted in the story.
Reader-Response TheoryFrom a reader-response perspective, the story’s meaning is constructed through the reader’s interaction with the text, with each reader bringing their own interpretations and experiences to the narrative.Different readers may empathize with the narrator’s paranoia and fear, while others may find humor in the absurdity of the situation.Critics might argue that reader-response theory can be overly subjective, as interpretations can vary widely among readers and may not always align with the author’s intent or thematic elements.
Topics, Questions, and Thesis Statements about “An Uncomfortable Bed” by Guy de Maupassant
TopicQuestionThesis Statement
Paranoia and SuspicionHow does the narrator’s paranoia and suspicion lead to his downfall?“Through his excessive caution and assumption of his friends’ intentions, the narrator in ‘An Uncomfortable Bed’ ultimately becomes the architect of his own misfortune, highlighting the dangers of unchecked paranoia and suspicion.”
The Power of AssumptionsWhat role do assumptions play in shaping the narrator’s experience?“In ‘An Uncomfortable Bed’, Maupassant demonstrates how assumptions can lead to misinterpretation and misunderstanding, as the narrator’s unfounded assumptions about his friends’ intentions lead to a series of events that ultimately result in the very outcome he feared.”
The Unreliability of PerceptionHow does the story highlight the unreliability of human perception?“Through the narrator’s distorted perceptions and misinterpretations, ‘An Uncomfortable Bed’ illustrates the unreliability of human perception, demonstrating how our biases and assumptions can shape our understanding of reality.”
Irony and the Human ConditionWhat commentary does the story offer on the human condition through its use of irony?“In ‘An Uncomfortable Bed’, Maupassant employs irony to highlight the absurdity and foolishness of human behavior, particularly in regards to our tendency towards paranoia and assumption, ultimately commenting on the human condition and our propensity for self-fulfilling prophecies.”
Short Questions/Answers about/on “An Uncomfortable Bed” by Guy de Maupassant
  1. What is the central theme of “An Uncomfortable Bed” by Guy de Maupassant? The central theme of “An Uncomfortable Bed” revolves around paranoia and the fear of being the victim of a practical joke. The narrator’s constant suspicion and anxiety underscore the theme of mistrust and the unpredictability of human interactions. For instance, the narrator’s apprehensive demeanor and meticulous precautions, such as inspecting the room and relocating the bed, highlight his fear of becoming the target of his friends’ amusement.
  2. How does Guy de Maupassant create tension in “An Uncomfortable Bed”? Guy de Maupassant employs suspenseful elements to create tension throughout the story. The narrator’s heightened awareness and anticipation of a practical joke contribute to the atmosphere of unease and foreboding. Maupassant builds suspense through the narrator’s meticulous inspection of the room, his heightened senses, and the gradual revelation of the prank. For example, the narrator’s fear escalates as he imagines various scenarios of potential harm, keeping readers on edge until the climax of the story.
  3. What role do the narrator’s friends play in “An Uncomfortable Bed”? The narrator’s friends serve as instigators and orchestrators of the practical joke at his expense. Their fondness for practical joking sets the stage for the escalating tension and paranoia experienced by the narrator. Throughout the story, the friends’ covert laughter and exaggerated behavior contribute to the sense of impending mischief. Their involvement in the prank reflects their enjoyment of manipulation and amusement at the narrator’s expense.
  4. How does the story “An Uncomfortable Bed” conclude? “An Uncomfortable Bed” concludes with a revelation that subverts the narrator’s expectations and resolves the tension. The final prank is revealed to be an unintended consequence of the valet’s clumsiness rather than a deliberate scheme by the narrator’s friends. The narrative ends with laughter and relief as the true nature of the situation is unveiled, highlighting the absurdity of the narrator’s fears and the humorous misunderstanding that ensues.
Literary Works Similar to “An Uncomfortable Bed” by Guy de Maupassant
  1. The Open Window” by Saki (H.H. Munro): This story revolves around a young woman who spins a tale to a visitor about her aunt’s tragic history, only to reveal a shocking twist at the end. Like “An Uncomfortable Bed,” it features elements of deception, manipulation, and an unexpected conclusion.
  2. The Tell-Tale Heart” by Edgar Allan Poe: This classic tale follows an unnamed narrator who insists on their sanity while recounting their meticulous murder of an old man with a “vulture eye.” The story explores themes of paranoia, guilt, and the unreliability of the narrator’s perspective, similar to the tension and suspicion in Maupassant’s story.
  3. The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson: In this chilling narrative, a small town participates in an annual ritual where one person is selected by lottery to be stoned to death. Like “An Uncomfortable Bed,” it builds tension through a sense of impending doom and features a shocking revelation about human nature.
  4. “The Landlady” by Roald Dahl: This story follows a young traveler who stays at a seemingly quaint bed and breakfast, only to discover a sinister secret about the landlady. It shares themes of deception, manipulation, and unexpected twists, similar to the narrative structure of Maupassant’s story.
  5. The Monkey’s Paw” by W.W. Jacobs: This classic horror story revolves around a magical talisman that grants its owner three wishes, with disastrous consequences. Like “An Uncomfortable Bed,” it explores themes of superstition, paranoia, and the unforeseen consequences of human desires.
Suggested Readings about/on “An Uncomfortable Bed” by Guy de Maupassant
  • Maupassant, Guy de. “An Uncomfortable Bed.” The Complete Short Stories of Guy de Maupassant, edited by Michael Leverson Meyer, Stone & Kimball, 1903.
  • De Maupassant, Guy. Collected Short Stories of Guy de Maupassant: The Necklace+ The Piece of String+ Boule de Suif+ Mademoiselle Fifi+ Pierrot+ Two Friends+ La Maison Tellier+ Ghosts and much more. Good Press, 2024.
  • Stivale, Charles J. The art of rupture: narrative desire and duplicity in the tales of Guy de Maupassant. University of Michigan Press, 1994.
  • MacNamara, Matthew. “A Critical Stage in the Evolution of Maupassant’s Story-Telling.” The Modern Language Review (1976): 294-303.
Representative Quotations from “An Uncomfortable Bed” by Guy de Maupassant
QuotationContextTheoretical Perspective
“During the dinner, the mirth was excessive, far too great, in fact.”This quotation highlights the atmosphere of exaggerated amusement and anticipation preceding the practical joke orchestrated by the narrator’s friends.Sociological Perspective – Reflects social dynamics and the group’s collective behavior, suggesting the influence of social norms and expectations.
“I must have been in a deep sleep for a long time, but all of a sudden, I was awakened with a start…”This quotation marks the climax of the story, where the narrator experiences the culmination of his fears as the practical joke is executed.Psychoanalytic Perspective – Represents the eruption of the unconscious fears and anxieties into the conscious mind, triggering a moment of intense terror.
“I felt myself suffocating under the weight that was crushing me and preventing me from moving.”This quotation captures the physical sensation of panic and helplessness experienced by the narrator during the climax of the story.Psychological Perspective – Illustrates the visceral response to fear and danger, highlighting the physiological effects of stress on the body.
“The precautions I had taken…had only brought about the interlude I had been striving to avoid.”This quotation reflects the irony of the narrator’s actions, as his attempts to prevent the practical joke inadvertently lead to its execution.Structuralist Perspective – Demonstrates the interplay between cause and effect, revealing the underlying structure and patterns in the narrative.
“Ah! how they all laughed that day!”This quotation concludes the story with a sense of relief and humor as the true nature of the situation is revealed, bringing closure to the narrative.Reader-Response Perspective – Emphasizes the role of the reader’s interpretation and emotional response in shaping the meaning and impact of the story.

“The Wicked Prince” by Hans Christian Andersen: A Critical Analysis

“The Wicked Prince” by Hans Christian Andersen was first published in 1840 as part of the collection “Fairy Tales Told for Children, Third Collection, Third Booklet”.

"The Wicked Prince" by Hans Christian Andersen: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “The Wicked Prince” by Hans Christian Andersen

“The Wicked Prince” by Hans Christian Andersen was first published in 1840 as part of the collection “Fairy Tales Told for Children, Third Collection, Third Booklet”. This story features a prince who is consumed by his own ambition and greed, and is willing to go to great lengths to achieve his goals, including murdering his own father and brother. The tale explores themes of power, corruption, and the consequences of one’s actions, and is a classic example of Andersen’s ability to craft dark and thought-provoking stories that continue to captivate readers to this day.

Main Events in “The Wicked Prince” by Hans Christian Andersen

1. The Ambition of the Wicked Prince

  • The prince’s sole desire is to conquer all countries and instill fear among people through destruction and violence.

2. Devastation and Misery

  • He leads his soldiers to destroy crops, burn down villages, and cause endless suffering among innocent civilians.

3. Accumulation of Wealth and Power

  • Despite the misery he inflicts, the prince amasses enormous wealth from his conquests, building opulent palaces and churches admired by many.

4. Insatiable Greed

  • Not content with his wealth and power, the prince craves more, seeking to surpass all others in might and dominance.

5. Defeat of Neighboring Kingdoms

  • Through relentless warfare, he defeats neighboring kingdoms, subjecting their kings to humiliating servitude.

6. Hubris and Defiance

  • The prince’s arrogance leads him to seek to conquer even God, ordering the construction of a magnificent flying ship armed with cannons.

7. Divine Intervention

  • God sends an angel to thwart the prince’s hubristic ambitions, leading to a confrontation in the skies.

8. Humiliation and Defeat

  • Despite the prince’s efforts, he is ultimately defeated by a single drop of blood from the angel, causing his ship to crash.

9. Persistent Pursuit of Conquest

  • Undeterred, the prince spends seven years planning new methods to conquer God, amassing a vast army and constructing formidable weapons.

10. The Prince’s Downfall

  • In a moment of irony, the prince’s downfall comes from a swarm of gnats, symbolizing the folly of his pride and the inevitability of divine retribution.
Literary Devices in “The Wicked Prince” by Hans Christian Andersen
Literary DeviceExample from the StoryExplanation
AllegoryThe prince’s ambition to conquer God symbolizes human hubris.The story’s events and characters represent abstract ideas or moral qualities, providing a deeper meaning beyond the literal narrative.
Alliteration“His heart and mind were set upon conquering all the countries.”The repetition of consonant sounds, such as the repeated “c” sound in “conquering” and “countries,” adds rhythm and emphasis to the sentence.
Allusion“Hundreds of eagles were attached to this ship…”Reference to eagles could allude to strength, power, or military prowess, common symbols in literature and mythology.
Apostrophe“I will conquer God!”The prince directly addresses and challenges God, emphasizing his defiance and arrogance.
Assonance“He brought enormous wealth home…”The repetition of vowel sounds, such as the repeated “o” sound in “enormous” and “home,” creates a melodic effect and reinforces the description.
Connotation“His power increased day by day…”The word “increased” suggests growth and expansion, connoting the prince’s escalating influence and dominance.
Hyperbole“The flames licked the green leaves off the branches…”Exaggeration for dramatic effect emphasizes the intensity of the destruction caused by the prince’s soldiers.
IronyThe prince’s downfall comes from a swarm of gnats.The outcome is contrary to what one might expect; the powerful prince is defeated by something seemingly insignificant, highlighting the theme of hubris.
Metaphor“The earth was soon left far below…”The comparison of the earth to a distant object reinforces the idea of the ship’s ascent into the sky, creating vivid imagery.
Onomatopoeia“…the wind roared round the prince’s head…”Words that imitate natural sounds, such as “roared,” enhance the sensory experience, evoking the ferocity of the wind.
Oxymoron“Magnificent palaces, churches, and halls…”The juxtaposition of “magnificent” with “devastation” and “destruction” emphasizes the prince’s contradictory actions and their consequences.
Paradox“He spent seven years in the construction of wonderful ships…”The idea of “wonderful” ships being used for destructive purposes creates a paradox, highlighting the prince’s twisted priorities.
Personification“The wind roared round the prince’s head…”Assigning human characteristics, such as roaring, to the wind enhances the description, making it more vivid and engaging.
Repetition“What a mighty prince!”The repetition of the phrase emphasizes the admiration and fear inspired by the prince’s power, reinforcing his dominance.
SatireDescription of the prince’s actions and ambitions.The story ridicules the prince’s hubris and the destructive consequences of his quest for power, serving as a critique of authoritarianism and greed.
Simile“The ship… was covered with thousands of eyes, like the tail of a peacock…”The comparison using “like” enhances the imagery, allowing readers to visualize the ship’s ornate decoration.
SymbolismThe prince’s ship symbolizes his arrogance and defiance.The ship represents the prince’s hubris and desire to surpass divine authority, embodying themes of pride and recklessness.
ToneThe tone of the story is ominous and cautionary.The author’s attitude toward the subject matter is conveyed through the tone, which warns readers of the consequences of unchecked ambition and cruelty.
Understatement“One single gnat had placed itself inside one of the coverings…”The significance of the gnat’s role in the prince’s downfall is downplayed, emphasizing the irony and unexpected nature of his defeat.
Verbal Irony“I will conquer God!”The prince’s boastful statement is ironically juxtaposed with his subsequent defeat by a mere insect, highlighting the futility of his ambition.

Characterization in “The Wicked Prince” by Hans Christian Andersen
  • The Wicked Prince: The titular character, the Wicked Prince, is the embodiment of arrogance and warmongering. The story opens with a chilling description of his actions: “he devastated their countries with fire and sword, and his soldiers trod down the crops in the fields and destroyed the peasants’ huts by fire” [1]. This sets the tone for his complete disregard for human life and his delight in destruction. His obsession with conquest is further emphasized by his insatiable desire for more power. Even after accumulating immense wealth and conquering numerous lands, he declares, ““What a mighty prince! But I must have more—much more. No power on earth must equal mine, far less exceed it” [2]. This insatiable ambition ultimately leads to his downfall as he delusionally attempts to conquer God. The prince’s foolishness is highlighted by his ultimate defeat at the hands of a tiny gnat, showcasing the absurdity of his arrogance.
  • The Prince’s Soldiers: The prince’s soldiers are portrayed as extensions of his cruelty. The text describes them as “demons” whose enjoyment comes from inflicting misery [1]. They readily carry out the prince’s violent orders, mirroring his lack of empathy. Their actions solidify the image of the prince as a ruler who thrives on destruction.
  • The Conquered Kings: The conquered kings serve as a constant reminder of the human cost of the prince’s wars. Reduced to “chained up with golden fetters to his chariot” [2], they become symbols of humiliation and subjugation. Their presence highlights the prince’s disregard for the suffering he inflicts on others.
  • The Priests: The priests are the only ones who dare to oppose the prince. When the prince demands his statue be placed on the altar, they remind him, ““Prince, you are mighty indeed, but God’s power is much greater than yours; we dare not obey your orders” [2]. They represent a voice of reason and morality, the sole opposition to the prince’s absolute power.
  • The Angel and The Gnats: The angel and the gnats function as instruments of divine intervention. The angel, unharmed by the prince’s bullets, showcases the limitations of human power against a higher force. The gnats, a seemingly insignificant annoyance, ultimately drive the prince mad. Their role underscores the prince’s ultimate failure and the insignificance of his actions in the face of God’s will.
Major Themes in “The Wicked Prince” by Hans Christian Andersen
  1. Hubris and Arrogance: One of the central themes of “The Wicked Prince” is the destructive nature of hubris and arrogance. The prince’s insatiable thirst for power leads him to believe he can conquer even God Himself. This hubris is evident in his relentless pursuit of dominance over others and his defiance of divine authority. For example, when the prince declares, “I will conquer God!” he demonstrates his arrogance and overestimation of his own abilities. Despite his grandiose ambitions, the prince’s downfall ultimately comes from a seemingly insignificant source—the sting of a gnat—which serves as a powerful reminder of the consequences of unchecked pride.
  2. Consequences of Tyranny: Another prominent theme in the story is the devastating consequences of tyranny and oppression. The prince’s ruthless quest for conquest results in widespread destruction, suffering, and loss for countless innocent people. His soldiers lay waste to villages, destroy crops, and subject conquered kings to humiliating servitude. The story illustrates the brutal reality of life under a tyrant’s rule, where the pursuit of power comes at the expense of human lives and well-being. The imagery of devastated landscapes and oppressed populations highlights the profound impact of the prince’s tyranny on society.
  3. Divine Justice and Humility: “The Wicked Prince” also explores the theme of divine justice and the importance of humility before higher powers. Despite his immense power and wealth, the prince’s attempts to defy God ultimately end in failure and humiliation. When he arrogantly proclaims his intention to conquer God, he is swiftly brought down by a single drop of blood from an angel, symbolizing the inevitability of divine retribution. This serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of pride and the importance of recognizing one’s limitations in the face of divine authority.
  4. Redemption and Consequences: Lastly, the story touches on the themes of redemption and the consequences of one’s actions. Throughout the narrative, the prince’s relentless pursuit of power leads to his own downfall and eventual realization of the folly of his ambitions. His defeat by a swarm of gnats serves as a humbling moment, prompting him to reflect on his actions and the suffering he has caused. This moment of humility, though forced upon him, opens the possibility for redemption and self-awareness. The story underscores the idea that actions have consequences and that true growth and redemption can only come from acknowledging one’s mistakes and striving to make amends.
Writing Style in “The Wicked Prince” by Hans Christian Andersen
  1. Imagery and Descriptive Language: Andersen uses vivid and descriptive language to paint a picture of the prince’s destruction and cruelty, such as “the flames licked the green leaves off the branches, and the fruit hung dried up on the singed black trees” and “the clouds around…took strange shapes, like crabs many, many miles long, which stretched their claws out after him”.
  2. Symbolism: The prince’s ship and its many eyes (gun barrels) symbolize his power and aggression, while the angel and his shining wings represent God’s power and goodness.
  3. Irony and Satire: Andersen uses irony and satire to highlight the prince’s foolishness and arrogance, such as when the prince says “I will conquer God too” and when his soldiers mock him after he is overcome by a single gnat.
  4. Repetition: The repetition of the prince’s phrase “I will conquer God” emphasizes his determination and stubbornness, as well as his ultimate downfall.
  5. Biblical Allusions: The story contains allusions to biblical themes and imagery, such as the prince’s attempt to reach heaven and his ultimate punishment, which echoes the story of Lucifer’s fall from heaven.
  6. Folk Tale Elements: The story contains elements of traditional folk tales, such as the use of magical creatures (eagles, angels, gnats) and the prince’s ultimate comeuppance.
Literary Theories and Interpretation of “The Wicked Prince” by Hans Christian Andersen

1. The Archetypal Theory:

This theory focuses on universal symbols and character types that appear across cultures and stories.

  • The Wicked Prince: He embodies the archetype of the tyrant. His desire for absolute power, disregard for human life, and eventual downfall are characteristics commonly associated with tyrannical figures.
  • The Angel: The angel represents the archetype of the divine messenger. Its presence signifies God’s intervention and power, reminding the prince of his limitations.

2. The Psychoanalytic Theory

This theory analyzes characters and stories through the lens of psychology, particularly focusing on the human psyche.

  • The Prince’s Ambition: The prince’s relentless pursuit of power can be interpreted as a manifestation of an inferiority complex. His need to conquer and dominate could stem from a deep-seated insecurity.
  • The Gnats: The gnats, while seemingly insignificant, drive the prince mad. They could symbolize the repressed anger or frustration the prince has ignored throughout his reign.

3. The Moral Allegory:

This theory suggests that a story can be interpreted as a representation of a moral lesson.

  • The Prince’s Downfall: The story serves as a moral allegory for the dangers of hubris and unchecked ambition. The prince’s ultimate defeat warns against the consequences of arrogance and defying a higher power.
  • The Power of Humility: The conquered kings and the priests, despite their suffering, represent the value of humility and accepting one’s limitations.
Topics, Questions, and Thesis Statements about “The Wicked Prince” by Hans Christian Andersen
TopicQuestionThesis Statement
The Psychological Motivations of PowerWhat drives the prince’s insatiable thirst for power?Despite his outward displays of dominance, the prince’s relentless pursuit of power in “The Wicked Prince” can be attributed to deep-seated psychological motivations rooted in insecurity, fear, and a desire for control.
Religious Symbolism and InterpretationHow does the story explore themes of divine justice and redemption?Through its portrayal of the prince’s hubristic ambitions and eventual downfall, “The Wicked Prince” serves as a cautionary tale about the consequences of defying divine authority and the possibility of redemption through humility and self-awareness.
Sociopolitical AllegoryWhat parallels can be drawn between the prince’s actions and real-world political dynamics?Hans Christian Andersen’s “The Wicked Prince” can be interpreted as a powerful allegory for the dangers of authoritarianism and the devastating impact of unchecked power on society, serving as a timeless warning against tyranny and oppression.
Short Questions/Answers about/on “The Wicked Prince” by Hans Christian Andersen
  • What drives the prince’s insatiable ambition, and how does his desire for power and control ultimately lead to his downfall?
    The prince’s insatiable ambition is driven by his desire for dominance and control over all aspects of life. He is consumed by his own ego and a sense of entitlement, which ultimately leads to his downfall. His attempt to conquer Heaven and overthrow God is a symbol of his hubris and arrogance, and his defeat by a single gnat sent by God serves as a reminder of the limits of human power and the dangers of unchecked ambition.
  • How does the story use the prince’s character to explore the consequences of unchecked power and the dangers of corruption?
    The story uses the prince’s character to explore the consequences of unchecked power and the dangers of corruption by portraying him as a ruthless and cunning leader who will stop at nothing to achieve his goals. His actions and decisions are driven by his desire for power and control, rather than a sense of justice or compassion, and he is willing to do whatever it takes to maintain his position and status. Through the prince’s character, the story highlights the dangers of corruption and the importance of accountability and humility in leadership.
  • What role do the supernatural elements in the story play in exploring the themes of power, corruption, and the human condition?
    The supernatural elements in the story, such as the angel and the gnat sent by God, play a significant role in exploring the themes of power, corruption, and the human condition. These elements serve as a reminder of the limits of human power and the existence of a higher authority, and they highlight the consequences of attempting to defy or overthrow God. The supernatural elements also add a sense of wonder and awe to the story, and they serve as a reminder of the mysteries and complexities of the universe.
  • How does the story’s use of imagery and symbolism contribute to its exploration of the human condition and the nature of power and corruption?
    The story’s use of imagery and symbolism contributes significantly to its exploration of the human condition and the nature of power and corruption. The prince’s ship, with its many eyes and guns, serves as a symbol of his power and aggression, while the angel’s shining wings and the gnat’s sting represent the power and authority of God. The imagery of the prince’s ship rising towards the sun and then crashing to the earth serves as a symbol of his hubris and fall, and the use of natural imagery, such as the clouds and the wind, adds a sense of scope and scale to the story. The imagery and symbolism in the story serve to reinforce its themes and messages, and they add depth and complexity to the narrative.
Literary Works Similar to “The Wicked Prince” by Hans Christian Andersen
  1. “The Emperor’s New Clothes” by Hans Christian Andersen: This classic tale by Andersen explores themes of vanity, deception, and the folly of pride, similar to “The Wicked Prince.” It critiques the dangers of arrogance and the consequences of self-delusion.
  2. The Tell-Tale Heart” by Edgar Allan Poe: Poe’s short story delves into themes of guilt, paranoia, and the consequences of obsession. Like “The Wicked Prince,” it explores the psychological unraveling of its protagonist as a result of his dark impulses.
  3. The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson: Jackson’s chilling tale examines the dangers of blindly following tradition and the dark side of human nature. Like “The Wicked Prince,” it explores themes of tyranny, oppression, and the consequences of unchecked authority.
  4. Young Goodman Brown” by Nathaniel Hawthorne: Hawthorne’s story delves into themes of temptation, sin, and the nature of evil. Similar to “The Wicked Prince,” it explores the moral decay that accompanies the pursuit of forbidden desires.
  5. The Necklace” by Guy de Maupassant: This short story explores themes of vanity, ambition, and the consequences of social climbing. Like “The Wicked Prince,” it serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of obsession and the pursuit of material wealth.
Suggested Readings about/on “The Wicked Prince” by Hans Christian Andersen
  • Wullschlager, Jackie. Hans Christian Andersen: The Life of a Storyteller. Secker & Warburg, 2000.
  • McGillis, Karen. “The Dark Stuff in Hans Christian Andersen’s Fairy Tales.” The New Yorker, The New Yorker, 18 Dec. 2014.
  • Hans Christian Andersen Center. University of Southern Denmark, https://www.sdu.dk/en/forskning/hca.
Representative Quotations from “The Wicked Prince” by Hans Christian Andersen
QuotationContextTheoretical Perspectives
“Many a poor mother fled, her naked baby in her arms, behind the still smoking walls of her cottage…”This quote highlights the devastation caused by the prince’s conquests, depicting the suffering of innocent civilians caught in the crossfire of war.Feminist Criticism: Analyze the portrayal of women and mothers as victims of war, exploring themes of vulnerability and powerlessness.
“The prince often looked with delight upon his gold and his magnificent edifices…”Here, the prince’s obsession with wealth and power is evident as he takes pleasure in his opulent possessions, indifferent to the suffering he has caused to attain them.Marxist Criticism: Examine the prince’s exploitation of labor and resources to amass wealth, exploring themes of class disparity and economic inequality.
“Well,” said the prince. “Then I will conquer God too.”This declaration reflects the prince’s hubris and delusions of grandeur, as he seeks to defy divine authority and assert his dominance over all realms, including the spiritual.Psychoanalytic Criticism: Interpret the prince’s desire to conquer God as a manifestation of his unconscious fears and insecurities, exploring themes of power and control.
“One drop of blood, one single drop, came out of the white feathers of the angel’s wings and fell upon the ship…”The angel’s blood serves as a symbolic representation of divine intervention and the prince’s ultimate defeat, highlighting the consequences of his defiance and arrogance.Religious Criticism: Analyze the symbolism of the angel’s blood and its significance within the context of the story’s religious themes, exploring concepts of sin, redemption, and divine justice.
“And he spent seven years in the construction of wonderful ships to sail through the air…”This quote demonstrates the prince’s persistence and obsession in his quest to conquer God, as he devotes immense resources and effort to the construction of formidable weapons.Postcolonial Criticism: Examine the prince’s imperialism and colonial ambitions as a reflection of Western hegemony and cultural superiority, exploring themes of domination and resistance.
“The servants carried out his orders, but one single gnat had placed itself inside one of the coverings…”Despite his attempts to protect himself from the gnats, the prince’s vulnerability is exposed by a single insect, leading to his humiliating defeat and descent into madness.Ecocriticism: Interpret the gnats as agents of nature’s revenge against human hubris and environmental destruction, exploring themes of ecological balance and interconnectedness.
“who now mocked at him, the mad prince, who wished to make war with God, and was overcome by a single little gnat.”The prince’s humiliation and downfall serve as a cautionary tale about the consequences of hubris and the inevitability of divine retribution, as he is mocked by his own soldiers.Existentialist Criticism: Analyze the prince’s existential crisis and loss of identity as he confronts the absurdity of his actions and the futility of his quest for power and meaning.

“Daystar” by Rita Dove: A Critical Analysis

“Daystar” by Rita Dove, first published in 1995 as part of her collection “Mother Love”is a beautiful and poignant exploration of motherhood, identity, and the search for self.

"Daystar" by Rita Dove: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “Daystar” by Rita Dove

“Daystar” by Rita Dove, first published in 1995 as part of her collection “Mother Love”is a beautiful and poignant exploration of motherhood, identity, and the search for self. With qualities of lyrical language, rich imagery, and a strong narrative voice, “Daystar” delves into the complexities of a mother’s role and the speaker’s own journey towards self-discovery. The poem’s use of metaphor, particularly the image of the daystar, adds a layer of depth and symbolism, making it a powerful and relatable read.

Text: “Daystar” by Rita Dove

She wanted a little room for thinking;
but she saw diapers steaming on the line,
a doll slumped behind the door.

So she lugged a chair behind the garage
to sit out the children’s naps.

Sometimes there were things to watch –
the pinched armor of a vanished cricket,
a floating maple leaf. Other days
she stared until she was assured
when she closed her eyes
she’d see only her own vivid blood.

She had an hour, at best, before Liza appeared
pouting from the top of the stairs.
And just what was mother doing
out back with the field mice?  Why,

building a palace. Later
that night when Thomas rolled over and
lurched into her, she would open her eyes
and think of the place that was hers
for an hour – where
she was nothing,
pure nothing, in the middle of the day.

Annotations: “Daystar” by Rita Dove
Text: “Daystar” by Rita DoveAnnotations
She wanted a little room for thinking;The speaker desires solitude and space for contemplation.
but she saw diapers steaming on the line,Her domestic responsibilities intrude upon her desire for solitude.
a doll slumped behind the door.Symbolizes the presence of motherhood and its demands.
So she lugged a chair behind the garageShe takes proactive measures to find a space for herself.
to sit out the children’s naps.Utilizing the time when her children are asleep.
Sometimes there were things to watch –She finds solace in observing nature or small details.
the pinched armor of a vanished cricket,Observing mundane or transient aspects of nature.
a floating maple leaf. Other daysNature provides her with moments of contemplation and escape.
she stared until she was assuredReflecting on her own thoughts and existence.
when she closed her eyesSeeking inner peace and clarity.
she’d see only her own vivid blood.Her internal struggles and vitality are emphasized.
She had an hour, at best, before Liza appearedLimited time for her personal space before her daughter interrupts.
pouting from the top of the stairs.Liza’s demeanor indicates annoyance or dissatisfaction.
And just what was mother doingLiza is curious about her mother’s activities.
out back with the field mice? Why,The speaker’s actions seem strange or mysterious to her daughter.
building a palace. LaterThe speaker’s imaginative response to her daughter’s inquiry.
that night when Thomas rolled over andReference to her husband, Thomas.
lurched into her, she would open her eyesInterruption of her thoughts by her husband’s presence.
and think of the place that was hersReturning to her brief moment of solitude.
for an hour – whereHighlighting the significance of her solitary hour.
she was nothing,Emphasizing her escape from the demands of her role as a mother.
pure nothing, in the middle of the day.Finding peace and liberation in solitude during daylight hours.
Literary And Poetic Devices: “Daystar” by Rita Dove
Literary/Poetic DeviceExample from “Daystar”Explanation
Imagery“diapers steaming on the line”Vivid description using sensory details to evoke the scene of domestic life.
Symbolism“a doll slumped behind the door”The doll symbolizes the speaker’s maternal duties and the burden of motherhood.
Metaphor“the pinched armor of a vanished cricket”Describing the exoskeleton of a cricket as armor, suggesting resilience and fragility.
Alliteration“Liza appeared pouting”Repetition of the ‘p’ sound creates a rhythmic effect and emphasizes Liza’s mood.
Simile“pure nothing, in the middle of the day”Comparing the speaker’s state of solitude to “pure nothing” using “like” or “as.”
Personification“a floating maple leaf”Assigning human qualities to a maple leaf, giving it the ability to float as if by its own will.
Irony“building a palace”The speaker’s response to her daughter’s inquiry about her activities is ironic, as she is not literally building a palace but seeking solitude.
Enjambment“building a palace. Later / that night”The continuation of a sentence or phrase across line breaks, creating a sense of flow and continuity.
Repetition“She wanted a little room for thinking”Repeating the phrase emphasizes the speaker’s desire for solitude and reflection.
Allusion“Daystar”Referring to the title of the poem, which alludes to the sun, suggesting both illumination and oppressive heat.
Hyperbole“she’d see only her own vivid blood”Exaggerating the intensity of the speaker’s internal focus and awareness.
Onomatopoeia“diapers steaming”Words that imitate the sound they represent, enhancing the sensory experience of the scene.
Assonance“pouting from the top of the stairs”Repetition of vowel sounds within words, creating a musical effect and drawing attention to Liza’s mood.
Oxymoron“pinched armor”Combining contradictory terms (“pinched” and “armor”) to create a striking image of the cricket’s exoskeleton.
Juxtaposition“So she lugged a chair behind the garage / to sit out the children’s naps.”Placing the speaker’s desire for solitude alongside her maternal duties highlights the tension between the two.
Metonymy“building a palace”Using “palace” to represent the speaker’s mental refuge or inner sanctuary.
Consonance“diapers steaming on the line”Repetition of consonant sounds within words, creating a sense of harmony and rhythm.
Anaphora“Sometimes there were things to watch –”Repetition of the phrase at the beginning of successive lines, emphasizing the speaker’s moments of observation.
Euphemism“Thomas rolled over and lurched into her”Using “rolled over” to describe Thomas’s movement in bed, masking the more intimate action of physical closeness.
Paradox“she was nothing, pure nothing”Contradictory statement emphasizing the speaker’s sense of self-obliteration and liberation in solitude.
Themes: “Daystar” by Rita Dove
  1. The Quest for Solitude and Personal Space: The poem highlights the mother’s longing for a moment of solitude and personal space, away from the demands of motherhood. The opening lines “She wanted a little room for thinking; / but she saw diapers steaming on the line, / a doll slumped behind the door” (lines 1-3) illustrate the contrast between her desire for quiet contemplation and the chaotic reality of her domestic life. The speaker’s actions, like lugging a chair behind the garage, demonstrate her determination to carve out a space for herself, no matter how small.
  2. Motherhood and its Demands: The poem portrays the exhausting and all-consuming nature of motherhood, where the speaker’s time and energy are constantly devoted to her children. The lines “She had an hour, at best, before Liza appeared / pouting from the top of the stairs” (lines 9-10) emphasize the limited window of time the mother has to herself before her child’s needs take priority again. The poem also touches on the societal expectations placed on mothers, as seen in the question “And just what was mother doing / out back with the field mice?” (lines 11-12), implying that a mother’s actions are always subject to scrutiny.
  3. Escapism and the Desire for Freedom: The speaker’s actions in the poem reveal a desire to escape the confines of her domestic life and tap into a sense of freedom. By sitting behind the garage, she creates a temporary escape from her responsibilities, allowing herself to “watch” and “stare” (lines 5 and 7) at the world around her. The image of building a “palace” (line 14) suggests a longing for a grander, more expansive existence beyond the limitations of her current life.
  4. Identity and Self-Discovery: The poem explores the speaker’s search for self and her struggle to maintain a sense of identity outside of her role as a mother. The lines “where / she was nothing, / pure nothing, in the middle of the day” (lines 17-19) suggest a desire to shed the burdens and expectations of motherhood and exist in a state of simplicity and freedom. The speaker’s hour of solitude becomes a moment of self-discovery, where she can reconnect with her own thoughts and desires, unencumbered by the demands of others.
Literary Theories and Interpretations of “Daystar” by Rita Dove
Literary TheoryInterpretationExample from “Daystar”
Feminist CriticismExamining the poem through the lens of feminist theory reveals the struggles of women in balancing domestic responsibilities with personal aspirations. The speaker’s desire for solitude reflects the limitations imposed by traditional gender roles, where women are primarily seen as caregivers and homemakers.The depiction of the speaker finding a secluded spot behind the garage to escape the demands of motherhood highlights the challenges faced by women in finding time for personal reflection and self-care amidst their familial duties.
Psychoanalytic CriticismPsychoanalytic theory can interpret the poem as an exploration of the speaker’s subconscious desires and conflicts. The longing for solitude and the imagery of “building a palace” may symbolize the speaker’s need for autonomy and self-actualization outside of her roles as a wife and mother.The speaker’s inner turmoil and desire for escape are evident in her vivid imagination of a place where she is “nothing, pure nothing,” suggesting a subconscious desire for freedom from societal expectations and domestic constraints.
EcocriticismEcocriticism focuses on the relationship between literature and the environment, interpreting the natural imagery in the poem as symbolic of humanity’s connection to the natural world. The speaker’s moments of contemplation amidst nature reflect a desire for harmony and a respite from the pressures of urban life.The speaker’s observations of nature, such as the “pinched armor of a vanished cricket” and the “floating maple leaf,” highlight the significance of the natural world in providing solace and inspiration, suggesting a longing for a deeper connection to the environment.
Critical Questions about “Daystar” by Rita Dove
  • How does the poem “Daystar” challenge traditional notions of motherhood and domesticity, and what implications does this have for our understanding of gender roles and societal expectations?
  • The poem subverts the idealized image of motherhood by portraying a mother who longs for solitude and freedom, rather than embracing her role as a caregiver. The lines “She wanted a little room for thinking; / but she saw diapers steaming on the line, / a doll slumped behind the door” (lines 1-3) highlight the tension between the mother’s desires and her responsibilities, suggesting that motherhood is not always a fulfilling or empowering experience.
  • In what ways does the poem use the natural world to explore the speaker’s inner life and emotional state, and what symbolic significance do the images of nature hold in the poem?
  • The poem employs natural imagery, such as the “pinched armor of a vanished cricket” and the “floating maple leaf” (lines 6 and 8), to convey the speaker’s feelings of confinement and longing. These images also symbolize the speaker’s desire for freedom and her sense of disconnection from the natural world, highlighting the tension between her inner life and her external circumstances.
  • How does the poem’s use of language and form contribute to its exploration of identity, selfhood, and the search for autonomy, and what role do the poem’s structural divisions and line breaks play in conveying the speaker’s emotional journey?
  • The poem’s use of short, fragmented sentences and stanzas creates a sense of disjointedness and fragmentation, mirroring the speaker’s feelings of disconnection and isolation. The line breaks and structural divisions also emphasize the speaker’s moments of introspection and self-reflection, such as the lines “where / she was nothing, / pure nothing, in the middle of the day” (lines 17-19), which highlight her desire for self-annihilation and rebirth.
Literary Works Similar to “Daystar” by Rita Dove
  1. “The Mother” by Gwendolyn Brooks: This poem explores the complex emotions surrounding motherhood, including the sacrifices and struggles mothers face.
  2. “The Bean Eaters” by Gwendolyn Brooks: While not specifically about motherhood, this poem delves into the quiet, everyday lives of an elderly couple, reflecting on themes of solitude and resilience.
  3. “To My Daughter Leaving Home” by Linda Pastan: This poem captures the bittersweet moment of a mother watching her daughter grow up and leave home, reflecting on the passage of time and the complexities of mother-daughter relationships.
  4. “Birches” by Robert Frost: Although not directly about motherhood, this poem reflects on the desire for escape and renewal, themes that resonate with the speaker’s yearning for solitude in “Daystar.”
  5. “The Lanyard” by Billy Collins: This poem humorously explores the relationship between a mother and her child, reflecting on the ways in which love and gratitude are expressed and received.
Suggested Readings: “Daystar” by Rita Dove
  • Georgoudaki, Ekaterini. “Rita Dove: Crossing Boundaries.” Callaloo 14.2 (1991): 419-433.
  • Righelato, Pat. Understanding Rita Dove. Univ of South Carolina Press, 2006.
  • Wright, LaVonna D. “Breaking Black Boundaries: The Poetry of Rita Dove.” (2020).
  • Richards, Page. “Rita Dove and Backyard Updates.” The Backyard of the US Mansion (2011).
  • McDowell, Robert. “The Assembling Vision of Rita Dove.” Writers and Their Craft: Short Stories & Essays on the Narrative (1991): 294.
Representative Quotations from “Daystar” by Rita Dove
QuotationContextTheoretical Perspective
“She wanted a little room for thinking;”The speaker desires solitude and space for introspection, but is surrounded by domestic responsibilities.Feminist Theory: Highlights the constraints on women’s autonomy and agency in domestic spaces.
“a doll slumped behind the door.”The doll represents the speaker’s lost identity and creativity, relegated to the background.Psychoanalytic Theory: Symbolizes the repression of the speaker’s desires and creative potential.
“She had an hour, at best, before Liza appeared”The speaker has limited time for herself before her child’s needs take priority.Critical Race Theory: Illustrates the oppressive nature of societal expectations on mothers, particularly women of color.
“building a palace.”The speaker creates a mental escape, a “palace” of freedom and autonomy.Postcolonial Theory: Represents the speaker’s resistance to oppressive structures and her desire for self-determination.
“where she was nothing, pure nothing, in the middle of the day.”The speaker finds freedom in anonymity and self-annihilation.Existentialist Theory: Highlights the speaker’s search for authenticity and freedom in a seemingly meaningless world.

“Solomon Grundy”: A Nursery Rhyme

“Solomon Grundy” is a traditional nursery rhyme character in American folklore, originating from a 19th-century poem.

"Solomon Grundy": A Nursery Rhyme
Introduction: “Solomon Grundy”

“Solomon Grundy” is a traditional nursery rhyme character in American folklore, originating from a 19th-century poem. He is depicted as an undead creature, born on a Monday, living for a short time, and dying on a Saturday. This enigmatic figure has become a cultural icon, symbolizing the cycle of life and death, and the power of oral tradition in folklore.

Text: “Solomon Grundy”

Solomon Grundy,
Born on a Monday,
Christened on Tuesday,
Married on Wednesday,
Took ill on Thursday,
Grew worse on Friday,
Died on Saturday,
Buried on Sunday.
That was the end,
Of Solomon Grundy

Annotations: “Solomon Grundy” by Anonymous
LineAnnotations
Solomon Grundy,The introduction of the titular character, Solomon Grundy, sets the stage for the poem’s narrative.
Born on a Monday,Provides the birth day of Solomon Grundy, establishing a chronological sequence for his life events.
Christened on Tuesday,Indicates the day Solomon Grundy was baptized, following his birth.
Married on Wednesday,Describes Solomon Grundy’s wedding day, continuing the progression of his life.
Took ill on Thursday,Marks the beginning of Solomon Grundy’s decline in health, introducing a turning point in the narrative.
Grew worse on Friday,Highlights the worsening condition of Solomon Grundy’s illness, leading towards an inevitable conclusion.
Died on Saturday,Specifies the day of Solomon Grundy’s death, bringing his life to its conclusion.
Buried on Sunday.Concludes Solomon Grundy’s life cycle with his burial, completing the narrative arc.
That was the end,Reflects on the finality of Solomon Grundy’s life, indicating the closure of his story.
Of Solomon GrundyReiterates the name of the character and signals the conclusion of the poem.
Literary And Poetic Devices: “Solomon Grundy”
DeviceExampleExplanation
Assonance“Took ill on Thursday”The repetition of the vowel sound in “Took” and “Thursday” creates a musical quality and enhances the poem’s rhythm.
Caesura“Solomon Grundy,”The comma after “Solomon Grundy” creates a pause, adding emphasis to the introduction of the character and setting the tone.
Consonance“Born on a Monday”The repetition of the consonant sound “n” in “born” and “Monday” creates a harmonious effect and reinforces the day of the week.
Enjambment“Died on Saturday, Buried on Sunday”The continuation of the sentence from one line to the next (“Saturday, Buried on Sunday”) without a pause enhances the flow of the poem.
Hyperbole“That was the end”The statement exaggerates the finality of Solomon Grundy’s life, emphasizing the irreversibility of death.
Imagery“Grew worse on Friday”The phrase evokes a vivid image of Solomon Grundy’s deteriorating health, allowing readers to visualize his decline.
Irony“Born on a Monday”It’s ironic that Solomon Grundy’s life begins on a Monday, a day associated with new beginnings, yet his life ends tragically.
Metaphor“Married on Wednesday”The metaphor compares Solomon Grundy’s marriage to the day Wednesday, suggesting that his union occurred swiftly or abruptly.
Onomatopoeia“Took ill on Thursday”The word “ill” imitates the sound of discomfort or sickness, enhancing the reader’s understanding of Solomon Grundy’s condition.
Oxymoron“That was the end”The phrase combines contradictory terms (“end” and “was”), highlighting the finality of Solomon Grundy’s life.
Paradox“That was the end”The statement appears contradictory because an “end” typically implies finality, yet it also suggests the beginning of something new.
Personification“Grew worse on Friday”Assigning human characteristics (growth) to Solomon Grundy’s illness (Friday) enhances the poem’s imagery and emotional impact.
Repetition“Solomon Grundy”The repeated use of the character’s name throughout the poem reinforces his identity and serves as a structural device.
Rhyme“Married on Wednesday”The words “Wednesday” and “wed” rhyme, creating a musical quality and enhancing the poem’s rhythm.
Simile“Christened on Tuesday”The simile compares Solomon Grundy’s baptism to the day Tuesday, suggesting a connection between the two events.
Symbolism“Buried on Sunday”Sunday traditionally represents the end of the week and is associated with rest or religious observance, symbolizing the conclusion of life.
Synecdoche“That was the end”The word “end” represents the entirety of Solomon Grundy’s life, emphasizing the finality of his existence.
Tone“That was the end”The statement carries a somber and conclusive tone, reflecting the inevitability of death and the poem’s overarching theme.
Verbal Irony“Married on Wednesday”While weddings are typically joyous occasions, the fact that Solomon Grundy’s marriage occurred swiftly on a weekday adds a sense of irony.
Themes: “Solomon Grundy”
  • Theme 1: The Cycle of Life: The poem “Solomon Grundy” explores the theme of the cycle of life, tracing the protagonist’s journey from birth to death. The rhyme succinctly covers the significant events of Solomon Grundy’s life, from being “Born on a Monday” to being “Buried on Sunday” (lines 1 and 8). This cycle is a universal human experience, and the poem’s use of a week’s duration highlights the brevity and fragility of life.
  • Theme 2: Fate and Inevitability: The poem also explores the theme of fate and inevitability, suggesting that Solomon Grundy’s life was predetermined. The use of specific days of the week for each event creates a sense of inexorable progression, implying that his life was always headed towards its tragic conclusion. The line “That was the end, / Of Solomon Grundy” (lines 9-10) drives home the sense of finality and the impossibility of escape.
  • Theme 3: The Passage of Time: The poem examines the theme of the passage of time, using the days of the week to mark the swift progression of Solomon Grundy’s life. The rhyme moves rapidly from birth to death, emphasizing the fleeting nature of human existence. The line “Grew worse on Friday, / Died on Saturday” (lines 6-7) highlights the speed at which life can deteriorate and come to an end.
  • Theme 4: Mortality and the Human Condition: Finally, the poem confronts the theme of mortality and the human condition, presenting a stark and unvarnished portrayal of life’s fragility. Solomon Grundy’s story serves as a reminder that death is an inevitable part of human experience, and that life can change irreparably in a short span. The poem’s simplicity and directness drive home this message, leaving the reader to ponder the transience of human existence.
Literary Theories and Interpretations of “Solomon Grundy”
Literary TheoryInterpretationReference from the Poem
StructuralismThe poem’s use of a repetitive structure (each line starting with a day of the week) creates a sense of inevitability and fate, emphasizing the idea that Solomon Grundy’s life was predetermined.“Born on a Monday, / Christened on Tuesday, / Married on Wednesday, / …” (lines 1-3)
SymbolismThe days of the week can be seen as symbols for the stages of life, with Monday representing birth, Wednesday representing maturity, and Saturday representing death.“Took ill on Thursday, / Grew worse on Friday, / Died on Saturday” (lines 5-7)
ExistentialismThe poem’s portrayal of Solomon Grundy’s brief and unfulfilling life can be seen as a commentary on the absurdity and meaninglessness of human existence.“That was the end, / Of Solomon Grundy” (lines 9-10)
Critical Questions about “Solomon Grundy”
  • How does the structured repetition of days of the week contribute to the thematic development of the poem?
  • The poem follows the pattern of Solomon Grundy’s life events occurring on each day of the week, from his birth on Monday to his burial on Sunday. This structured repetition creates a sense of inevitability and cyclical nature, highlighting the passage of time and the universal experience of life’s milestones. It also emphasizes the fleeting nature of existence and the inevitability of mortality, as each day brings Solomon Grundy closer to his ultimate fate.
  • What significance do the life events of Solomon Grundy hold within the context of the poem’s themes?
  • Each life event depicted in the poem, such as Solomon Grundy’s birth, baptism, marriage, illness, and death, symbolizes a stage in the journey of life. These events serve as metaphors for the human experience, reflecting themes of birth, growth, love, suffering, and mortality. For example, Solomon Grundy’s rapid progression from birth to death in the span of a week underscores the brevity and unpredictability of life, prompting readers to contemplate the nature of existence and the passage of time.
  • How does the poem’s conclusion contribute to its overall impact and interpretation?
  • The concluding lines “That was the end, Of Solomon Grundy” mark the finality of Solomon Grundy’s life and the closure of the poem. This conclusion leaves readers with a sense of contemplation and reflection on the transience of life and the inevitability of death. It underscores the poem’s thematic exploration of mortality and the human condition, inviting readers to consider the legacy and significance of one’s life in the face of mortality.
Literary Works Similar to “Solomon Grundy”
  1. “Richard Cory” by Edwin Arlington Robinson: This poem tells the story of a wealthy and respected man named Richard Cory who, despite his apparent success, takes his own life. Similar to “Solomon Grundy,” it explores the theme of the unpredictability of life and the contrast between outward appearances and inner turmoil.
  2. The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock” by T.S. Eliot: “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock” is a modernist poem that follows the internal monologue of the protagonist, Prufrock, as he reflects on his life and experiences. Like “Solomon Grundy,” it delves into themes of mortality, existential angst, and the passage of time.
  3. Do Not Go Gentle into That Good Night” by Dylan Thomas: This villanelle by Dylan Thomas passionately urges the reader to resist death and fight against the dying of the light. While tonally different from “Solomon Grundy,” it shares a thematic exploration of mortality and the inevitability of death.
  4. Ozymandias” by Percy Bysshe Shelley: “Ozymandias” is a sonnet that explores the fleeting nature of power and legacy. Like “Solomon Grundy,” it reflects on the passage of time and the eventual demise of even the most powerful figures, emphasizing the transience of human achievement.
  5. Because I could not stop for Death” by Emily Dickinson: In this poem, Death is personified as a gentleman who takes the speaker on a carriage ride through various stages of life and eventually to eternity. Similar to “Solomon Grundy,” it contemplates the inevitability of death and the journey towards the afterlife.
Suggested Readings: “Solomon Grundy”
  • Symons, Julian. The End of Solomon Grundy. House of Stratus, 2011.
  • Jorgensen, Brian. “Solomon Rex and Solomon Grundy.” Journal of Education 175.3 (1993): 65-84.
  • Tierney, Stephen. “Solomon Grundy Does Constitutional Change: The Smith Commission Timetable to Transform the Scottish Parliament.” (2014).
  • Taylor, Archer. “The Nursery Rhyme of Solomon Grundy.” Journal of American Folklore (1956): 356-356.
Representative Quotations “Solomon Grundy”
QuotationContextTheoretical Perspective
“Born on a Monday”Opening line, introducing Solomon Grundy’s birthStructuralism: Highlights the repetitive structure of the poem, emphasizing the inevitability of Solomon Grundy’s life events.
“Took ill on Thursday, / Grew worse on Friday”Describing Solomon Grundy’s declineSymbolism: Thursday and Friday can be seen as symbols for the decline and deterioration of life, highlighting the poem’s exploration of mortality.
“Died on Saturday”Announcing Solomon Grundy’s deathExistentialism: Emphasizes the finality and absurdity of death, underscoring the poem’s existential themes.
“Buried on Sunday”Concluding Solomon Grundy’s life cycleCyclical Nature of Life: Sunday, the day of rest, marks the end of Solomon Grundy’s life, suggesting a cyclical nature to human existence.
“That was the end, / Of Solomon Grundy”Final lines, summarizing Solomon Grundy’s lifeAbsurdism: Highlights the brevity and meaninglessness of Solomon Grundy’s life, underscoring the poem’s absurdist themes.

“Row, Row, Row Your Boat”: A Nursery Rhyme

“Row, Row, Row Your Boat” is a timeless and iconic children’s song that has been delighting kids and adults alike for generations.

"Row, Row, Row Your Boat": A Nursery Rhyme
Introduction: “Row, Row, Row Your Boat”

“Row, Row, Row Your Boat” is a timeless and iconic children’s song that has been delighting kids and adults alike for generations. With its gentle melody and soothing lyrics, this classic ditty has become a staple of childhood, evoking images of peaceful streams, lazy summer days, and the simple joys of life. First published in the 1850s, this beloved song has undergone many variations and adaptations, yet its core message of serenity and contentment remains unchanged, continuing to captivate audiences around the world.

Text: “Row, Row, Row Your Boat”

Row, row, row your boat
Gently up the creek
If you see a little mouse
Don’t forget to squeak!

Row, row, row your boat
Gently down the stream
If you see a crocodile
Don’t forget to scream!

Row, row, row your boat
Gently to the shore
If you see a lion
Don’t forget to roar!

Annotations: “Row, Row, Row Your Boat”
LineAnnotation
1“Row, row, row your boat” – This line serves as the main refrain of the song, emphasizing the action of rowing.
2“Gently up the creek” – Describes the gentle motion of rowing the boat upstream in a peaceful manner.
3“If you see a little mouse” – Introduces a playful element, suggesting the possibility of encountering a mouse while rowing.
4“Don’t forget to squeak!” – Playfully encourages the reader to mimic the sound of a mouse by squeaking.
5“Row, row, row your boat” – Repeats the main refrain, reinforcing the central theme of rowing.
6“Gently down the stream” – Describes the calm movement of rowing the boat downstream with the flow of the stream.
7“If you see a crocodile” – Adds a sense of adventure by suggesting the possibility of encountering a crocodile.
8“Don’t forget to scream!” – Playfully suggests reacting with a scream if one encounters a crocodile, adding humor to the verse.
9“Row, row, row your boat” – Recurrence of the refrain, maintaining the rhythmic structure of the song.
10“Gently to the shore” – Indicates the gentle approach of rowing the boat towards the safety of the shore.
11“If you see a lion” – Introduces another adventurous element, imagining the possibility of encountering a lion.
12“Don’t forget to roar!” – Encourages the reader to participate by roaring like a lion, adding an interactive and fun aspect to the verse.
Literary And Poetic Devices: “Row, Row, Row Your Boat”.
  1. Alliteration: Repetition of initial consonant sounds, e.g., “row, row, row”.
  2. Assonance: Repetition of vowel sounds, e.g., “gently up the creek”.
  3. Hyperbole: Exaggeration for emphasis, e.g., “don’t forget to squeak” (one might not actually squeak at a mouse).
  4. Imagery: Vivid descriptions of sensory experiences, e.g., “little mouse”, “crocodile”, “lion”.
  5. Irony: Contrast between expected and actual events, e.g., screaming at a crocodile (not a typical response).
  6. Meter: Pattern of stressed and unstressed syllables, e.g., “Row, row, row your boat” (trochaic meter).
  7. Onomatopoeia: Words imitating sounds they describe, e.g., “squeak”, “scream”, “roar”.
  8. Personification: Attributing human qualities to non-human entities, e.g., “don’t forget to squeak” (as if the speaker is addressing the boat).
  9. Refrain: Repeated phrase or line, e.g., “Row, row, row your boat”.
  10. Repetition: Repeated words or phrases, e.g., “row, row, row”, “don’t forget to”.
  11. Rhyme: End rhymes, e.g., “creek” and “squeak”, “stream” and “scream”.
  12. Satire: Humorous critique of human behavior, e.g., the absurdity of screaming at a crocodile.
  13. Simile: Comparing two unlike things, e.g., “gently up the creek” (comparing boat to a gentle movement).
  14. Symbolism: Using objects to represent abstract ideas, e.g., boat and water may symbolize life’s journey.
  15. Wordplay: Using words in a playful or clever way, e.g., “don’t forget to squeak” (using a mouse’s sound to create humor).
Themes: “Row, Row, Row Your Boat”
  • Theme 1: Life’s Journey
    The poem explores the idea of life’s journey, using the boat and water as metaphors. The speaker encourages the reader to “row, row, row” their boat, suggesting a sense of progress and movement through life’s challenges. The gentle and peaceful tone of the poem suggests a smooth and serene journey, with the speaker urging the reader to enjoy the ride.
  • Theme 2: Humor and Whimsy
    The poem uses humor and whimsy to create a playful tone, with the speaker instructing the reader to “squeak” at a mouse and “scream” at a crocodile. These absurd responses to encountering wildlife add a lighthearted and comedic touch to the poem, making it a delightful and entertaining read.
  • Theme 3: Courage and Resilience
    The poem also explores the themes of courage and resilience, as the speaker encourages the reader to face their fears and overcome obstacles. The image of the boat navigating through the water, despite encountering a crocodile, suggests a sense of determination and bravery. The speaker’s urging to “row, row, row” despite challenges suggests a resilience and perseverance in the face of adversity.
  • Theme 4: Imagination and Creativity
    Finally, the poem celebrates the power of imagination and creativity, using vivid imagery and fantastical scenarios to create a sense of wonder and enchantment. The speaker’s use of imaginative language, such as “gently up the creek” and “little mouse”, creates a sense of fantasy and play, encouraging the reader to engage their imagination and creativity.
Literary Theories and “Row, Row, Row Your Boat”
  1. New Criticism (Formalist Theory): New Criticism emphasizes close reading of the text itself, focusing on literary devices, structure, and themes within the work. In “Row Row Row Your Boat,” the repetition of the phrase “Row, row, row your boat” serves as a structural element, reinforcing the central theme of perseverance and journeying through life’s challenges. Each stanza presents a new encounter with animals along the way, creating a playful and rhythmic narrative. Additionally, the use of imperative verbs (“squeak,” “scream,” “roar”) encourages reader participation and engagement with the text.
  2. Reader-Response Theory: Reader-Response Theory focuses on the role of the reader in interpreting and creating meaning from a text. In “Row Row Row Your Boat,” readers may interpret the encounters with the mouse, crocodile, and lion as metaphors for different obstacles or dangers one might encounter in life’s journey. The reader’s personal experiences and cultural background may influence how they perceive these encounters and the overall message of the poem. For example, someone who fears the unknown may see the crocodile as representing danger, while someone else may interpret it as symbolizing resilience or bravery.
  3. Psychoanalytic Criticism: Psychoanalytic Criticism explores the unconscious motivations and desires of characters or authors within a literary work. In “Row Row Row Your Boat,” one could apply this theory to analyze the underlying themes of fear and courage. The encounters with the mouse, crocodile, and lion may represent the protagonist’s internal struggles or fears as they navigate life’s journey. For instance, the mouse could symbolize innocence and vulnerability, the crocodile could symbolize primal instincts or hidden dangers, and the lion could symbolize strength and assertiveness. By confronting and overcoming these symbolic challenges, the protagonist demonstrates psychological growth and resilience.
Critical Questions about “Row, Row, Row Your Boat”
  • How does the repetition of the refrain contribute to the poem’s meaning and structure?
  • The repetition of the refrain “Row, row, row your boat” serves as a structural and thematic anchor throughout the poem. It establishes a rhythmic pattern that mirrors the action of rowing and reinforces the central theme of perseverance and progression. Each repetition acts as a refrain, linking the stanzas together and emphasizing the continuous journey depicted in the poem. For example, in the first stanza, the repetition creates a sense of rhythm and movement as the boat is gently rowed “up the creek.” Similarly, in the second stanza, the refrain is repeated as the boat is rowed “down the stream,” maintaining the rhythmic flow of the poem.
  • What role do the encounters with different animals play in the thematic development of the poem?
  • The encounters with the mouse, crocodile, and lion serve as symbolic challenges or obstacles encountered along life’s journey, contributing to the thematic development of the poem. Each animal encounter presents a different scenario requiring a specific response, adding depth to the exploration of courage and resilience. For instance, the encounter with the mouse encourages playfulness and spontaneity, as indicated by the instruction to “squeak.” In contrast, the encounter with the crocodile introduces a sense of danger or threat, prompting the reader to “scream” in response. Finally, the encounter with the lion highlights the need for assertiveness and strength, as exemplified by the instruction to “roar.”
  • How does the poem invite reader engagement and participation through its interactive elements?
  • The poem actively engages the reader through its use of imperative verbs and playful instructions, inviting participation and interaction with the text. By prompting readers to imagine themselves in the scenario and respond accordingly, the poem fosters a sense of immersion and agency. For example, the instruction to “squeak” when encountering the mouse encourages readers to actively engage their imaginations and vocalize the sound of a mouse. Similarly, the instructions to “scream” and “roar” in response to the crocodile and lion, respectively, prompt readers to express emotions and reactions, further enhancing their involvement in the narrative.
Literary Works Similar to “Row, Row, Row Your Boat”
  1. “The Owl and the Pussy-Cat” by Edward Lear: This poem follows the whimsical journey of an owl and a pussy-cat as they set sail in a pea-green boat to get married. Like “Row Row Row Your Boat,” it features repetitive phrases and a lighthearted tone, creating a delightful and memorable narrative.
  2. “Wynken, Blynken, and Nod” by Eugene Field: “Wynken, Blynken, and Nod” tells the story of three children sailing off to a magical land in a wooden shoe, guided by the stars. With its dreamy imagery and rhythmic cadence, this poem shares a sense of adventure and imagination akin to “Row Row Row Your Boat.”
  3. “The Quangle Wangle’s Hat” by Edward Lear: Another poem by Edward Lear, “The Quangle Wangle’s Hat” is a nonsensical and imaginative piece featuring fantastical creatures and vivid imagery. Its playful language and whimsical tone evoke a similar sense of wonder and joy as “Row Row Row Your Boat.”
  4. Jabberwocky” by Lewis Carroll: “Jabberwocky” is a famous poem from Carroll’s novel “Through the Looking-Glass,” featuring invented words and nonsensical language. While more complex in its language, it shares a similar sense of playful whimsy and imaginative storytelling with “Row Row Row Your Boat.”
  5. The Highwayman” by Alfred Noyes: “The Highwayman” is a narrative poem that tells the story of a highwayman’s love for a landlord’s daughter and his tragic fate. While tonally different from “Row Row Row Your Boat,” it shares themes of adventure, romance, and the journey through life’s challenges. Its rhythmic and evocative language makes it a compelling read akin to the playful spirit of the nursery rhyme.
Suggested Readings: “Row, Row, Row Your Boat”
  • Niland, Amanda. “‘Row, row, row your boat’: singing, identity and belonging in a nursery.” International Journal of Early Years Education 23.1 (2015): 4-16.
  • Mulcahy, Rory, and Edwina Luck. “Row! Row! Row your boat! Transformative value cocreation and codestruction in elite and Olympic rowers.” Journal of Sport Management 34.4 (2020): 354-366.
  • Garner, Daisy. “Row, row, row your boat: A peak inside club rowing team.” UWIRE Text (2020): 1-1.
Representative Quotations “Row, Row, Row Your Boat”
QuotationContextLiterary Theoretical Perspective
“Row, row, row your boat”The opening line, setting the tone and theme of the poem.Structuralism: The repetition of “row” creates a structural pattern, emphasizing the rhythm and unity of the poem.
“Gently up the creek”The speaker describes the boat’s movement, creating a peaceful atmosphere.Romanticism: The use of “gently” and “creek” creates a vivid image of a serene and idyllic natural setting, characteristic of Romantic poetry.
“If you see a little mouse / Don’t forget to squeak!”The speaker instructs the reader to respond to a mouse, adding humor and whimsy.Absurdism: The absurd response to a mouse creates a playful and nonsensical tone, characteristic of Absurdist literature.
“If you see a crocodile / Don’t forget to scream!”The speaker instructs the reader to respond to a crocodile, highlighting courage and resilience.Symbolism: The crocodile may symbolize a fearsome obstacle, and the speaker’s instruction to scream represents the need to confront and overcome challenges.
“Row, row, row your boat / Gently to the shore”The final lines, emphasizing the journey’s end and the importance of perseverance.Journey Motif: The boat’s journey represents a common literary motif, symbolizing life’s journey and the importance of persistence and determination.

“Lizzie Borden Took an Ax”: A Critical Analysis

“Lizzie Borden Took an Ax” is a traditional nursery rhyme that emerged in the United States in the late 19th century.

"Lizzie Borden Took an Ax": A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “Lizzie Borden Took an Ax”

“Lizzie Borden Took an Ax” is a traditional nursery rhyme that emerged in the United States in the late 19th century. The rhyme is based on the true story of Lizzie Borden, who was accused of murdering her parents with an ax in 1892. The rhyme’s usage is widespread, having been passed down through generations, and is often recited or sung with hand-clapping games. Its qualities include a catchy melody, simple language, and a haunting, repetitive structure, making it a memorable and enduring part of American folklore. Despite its dark inspiration, the rhyme has become a cultural phenomenon, symbolizing the public’s fascination with true crime stories and the power of oral tradition.

Text: “Lizzie Borden Took an Ax”

Lizzie Borden took an ax

And gave her mother forty whacks,

And when she saw what she had done,

She gave her father forty-one.

Annotations: “Lizzie Borden Took an Ax”
LineAnalysis
“Lizzie Borden took an ax”This line introduces the main subject of the nursery rhyme, Lizzie Borden, and sets the scene for the violent act that is to follow.
“And gave her mother forty whacks”The imagery here suggests that Lizzie Borden used an ax to brutally murder her mother, delivering forty blows. The term “whacks” emphasizes the violent nature of the act.
“And when she saw what she had done”This line implies that Lizzie Borden realized the consequences of her actions after murdering her mother, indicating a moment of realization or shock.
“She gave her father forty-one”Following the pattern established in the previous line, Lizzie Borden proceeds to kill her father with even more blows, adding one more to the count, totaling forty-one.
Literary And Poetic Devices: “Lizzie Borden Took an Ax”
DeviceDescription
AlliterationThe repetition of consonant sounds in close proximity, as seen in ” She gave her father forty-one ” which creates a rhythmic and memorable effect.
HyperboleHyperbole is evident in the exaggerated number of blows inflicted by Lizzie Borden: “forty whacks” on her mother and “forty-one” on her father. This amplifies the gruesome nature of the murders, emphasizing their shocking brutality.
ImageryVivid mental images are evoked, particularly in the descriptions of violence using the ax, contributing to the dark and unsettling tone of the nursery rhyme.
PersonificationThe ax is given agency and action, as if it is capable of making conscious decisions, in the phrase “Lizzie Borden took an ax.” This personification adds a sinister quality to the object, heightening its role in the violent acts depicted.
RepetitionThe repetition of the word “forty” emphasizes the number of blows delivered by Lizzie Borden, intensifying the horror of the murders.
RhymeThe rhyme scheme is AABB, with each pair of lines ending in words that sound similar (e.g., “ax” and “whacks,” “done” and “one”). This regular rhyme scheme contributes to the nursery rhyme’s sing-song quality, making it easier to remember while also reinforcing its macabre subject matter.
SymbolismThe ax serves as a symbol of violence and death throughout the nursery rhyme, representing Lizzie Borden’s murderous intentions and actions. Its repeated mention underscores its significance in the narrative, heightening its impact on the reader.
Themes: “Lizzie Borden Took an Ax”
  • Theme 1: Violence and Aggression: The poem explores the theme of violence and aggression through the brutal actions of Lizzie Borden. The repetition of “forty whacks” and “forty-one” emphasizes the severity and intensity of the violence, creating a sense of shock and horror (lines 2 and 4). The use of an ax as a weapon also adds to the brutality and suddenness of the act. This theme is significant because it highlights the destructive nature of human behavior and the devastating consequences of unchecked aggression.
  • Theme 2: Family Dynamics and Dysfunction: The poem also explores the theme of family dynamics and dysfunction through the relationship between Lizzie and her parents. The fact that Lizzie attacks both her mother and father suggests a deep-seated anger and resentment towards her family (lines 1 and 3). The violence may be seen as a manifestation of the emotional turmoil and tension within the family. This theme is significant because it highlights the complexities and challenges of family relationships and the potential consequences of unresolved conflicts.
  • Theme 3: Madness and the Unreliability of Narrators: The poem’s tone and language suggest a sense of madness and unreliability, raising questions about the narrator’s perspective and Lizzie’s motivations. The use of a nursery rhyme-like structure and rhyme scheme creates a sense of playfulness and innocence, which contrasts with the brutality of the actions described (lines 1-4). This contrast may imply that the narrator is unreliable or that Lizzie’s actions were driven by a disturbed mind. This theme is significant because it highlights the complexity of human psychology and the potential for unexpected violence and madness to erupt in seemingly ordinary lives.
Literary Theories and Interpretations of “Lizzie Borden Took an Ax”
Literary TheoryInterpretationReference from the Poem
SymbolismThe ax and whacks are symbols that represent the criminality of Lizzie Borden’s actions.“Lizzie Borden took an ax / And gave her mother forty whacks”
IronyThe poem’s use of a nursery rhyme structure and rhyme scheme creates a sense of irony, as the subject matter is dark and violent.“And when she saw what she had done, / She gave her father forty-one”
Feminist TheoryThe poem can be seen as a commentary on the societal expectations placed on women, as Lizzie Borden’s actions are seen as a rebellion against her patriarchal family structure.“Lizzie Borden took an ax / And gave her mother forty whacks”
Critical Questions about “Lizzie Borden Took an Ax”
  • How does the nursery rhyme “Lizzie Borden Took an Ax” employ symbolism to convey its themes of violence and guilt?
  • The repeated mention of the ax throughout the poem serves as a powerful symbol of both physical violence and psychological turmoil. The line “Lizzie Borden took an ax” not only introduces the instrument used in the murders but also symbolizes Lizzie’s agency and intent to commit the heinous acts. Additionally, the phrase “forty whacks” and “forty-one” symbolize the excessive brutality of the murders, indicating the depth of the violence inflicted upon Lizzie’s victims. Through these symbols, the poem explores themes of guilt, as Lizzie is depicted as both the perpetrator and the one who must confront the consequences of her actions, as evidenced by the line “And when she saw what she had done.” Thus, symbolism in the poem not only enriches its imagery but also deepens its exploration of complex themes.
  • How does the use of repetition contribute to the ominous tone of “Lizzie Borden Took an Ax”?
  • The repetition of the word “forty” throughout the poem intensifies the sense of dread and horror surrounding the murders committed by Lizzie Borden. The phrase “forty whacks” emphasizes the sheer brutality of the violence inflicted upon Lizzie’s mother, while the subsequent “forty-one” adds an even more sinister dimension to the narrative. This repetition not only underscores the gruesome nature of the crimes but also creates a rhythmic cadence that amplifies the poem’s ominous atmosphere. By repeating the number of blows delivered by Lizzie, the poem accentuates the chilling reality of the murders and leaves a lasting impact on the reader, reinforcing the sense of foreboding that pervades the narrative.
  • How does the nursery rhyme “Lizzie Borden Took an Ax” challenge traditional notions of innocence and childhood?
  • Despite its simplistic language and sing-song rhythm, the poem delves into dark and disturbing subject matter, blurring the lines between innocence and guilt. By centering the narrative around a young woman who commits violent acts, the poem subverts expectations of childhood innocence and highlights the capacity for evil within individuals, regardless of age. The juxtaposition of the nursery rhyme’s familiar structure with its macabre content creates a sense of unease, forcing readers to confront the darker aspects of human nature. Through its portrayal of Lizzie Borden’s crimes, the poem challenges conventional depictions of innocence in childhood literature and prompts reflection on the complexities of morality and human behavior.
Literary Works Similar to “Lizzie Borden Took an Ax”
  1. “Here We Go Round the Mulberry Bush” – a rhyme and children’s circle game.
  2. “London Bridge is Falling Down” – this could be about a Viking attack in 1014, the difficulties associated with building the bridge, or even the burial of children under the bridge.
  3. “Ring a Ring o’ Roses” – is usually interpreted as an allusion to the Black Death and the symptoms associated with the illness.
  4. “Three Blind Mice” – a nursery rhyme and musical round.
  5. “Mary, Mary, Quite Contrary” – a nursery rhyme about Mary, Queen of Scots, and the beheading of her husband.
Suggested Readings: “Lizzie Borden Took an Ax”
  • Miner, Madonne. ““Lizzie Borden took an ax”: Enacting blood relations.” Text and Performance Quarterly 6.2 (1986): 10-21.
  • Schofield, Ann. “Lizzie Borden took an axe: history, feminism and American culture.” American Studies 34.1 (1993): 91-103.
  • Annissa, Fitri. “Feminist Analysis of Lizzie Borden and Her Ambivalence in ‘Lizzie Borden Took An Ax’(2014) and ‘The Lizzie Borden Chronicles’(2015).”
  • Herde, Gayle W. LIZZIE BORDEN TOOK AN AX AND GAVE HER LAWYER FORTY WHACKS: A GENERIC ANALYSIS OF THE CLOSING ARGUMENT FOR. Diss. University of Colorado at Denver, 1998.
Representative Quotations “Lizzie Borden Took an Ax”
QuotationContextTheoretical Perspective
“Lizzie Borden took an ax”The opening line of the poem, introducing the main character and weapon.Feminist Theory: Lizzie Borden’s actions can be seen as a rebellion against patriarchal society.
“And gave her mother forty whacks”Lizzie’s violent act against her mother, emphasizing the severity of the crime.Psychoanalytic Theory: Lizzie’s actions may be seen as a manifestation of unconscious desires and repressed emotions.
“And when she saw what she had done”Lizzie’s realization of her actions, potentially indicating remorse or shock.Guilt and Shame Theory: Lizzie’s actions may be driven by feelings of guilt and shame, leading to a cycle of violence.
“She gave her father forty-one”Lizzie’s continued violence against her father, potentially indicating a desire for revenge or control.Patriarchal Violence Theory: Lizzie’s actions may be seen as a response to the patriarchal violence and oppression she experienced in her family.

“New Day’s Lyric” by Amanda Gorman: A Critical Analysis

“New Day’s Lyric” by “Amanda Gorman was first published in late 2021, and not tied to a specific collection but rather released independently.

"New Day's Lyric" by Amanda Gorman: A Critical Analysis
Introduction: “New Day’s Lyric” by Amanda Gorman

“New Day’s Lyric” by “Amanda Gorman was first published in late 2021, and not tied to a specific collection but rather released independently. The poem explores hope and transformation, urging readers to move beyond past hardships and embrace the possibilities of a new year (or a new beginning). It’s a powerful testament to unity and collective action, leaving readers with a sense of optimism and a call to courageously face the uncharted future.

Text: “New Day’s Lyric” by Amanda Gorman

May this be the day

We come together.

Mourning, we come to mend,

Withered, we come to weather,

Torn, we come to tend,

Battered, we come to better.

Tethered by this year of yearning,

We are learning

That though we weren’t ready for this,

We have been readied by it.

We steadily vow that no matter

How we are weighed down,

We must always pave a way forward.

This hope is our door, our portal.

Even if we never get back to normal,

Someday we can venture beyond it,

To leave the known and take the first steps.

So let us not return to what was normal,

But reach toward what is next.

What was cursed, we will cure.

What was plagued, we will prove pure.

Where we tend to argue, we will try to agree,

Those fortunes we forswore, now the future we foresee,

Where we weren’t aware, we’re now awake;

Those moments we missed

Are now these moments we make,

The moments we meet,

And our hearts, once altogether beaten,

Now all together beat.

Come, look up with kindness yet,

For even solace can be sourced from sorrow.

We remember, not just for the sake of yesterday,

But to take on tomorrow.

We heed this old spirit,

In a New Day’s lyric,

In our hearts, we hear it:

For auld lang syne, my dear,

For auld lang syne.

Be bold, sang Time this year,

Be bold, sang Time,

For when you honor yesterday,

Tomorrow ye will find.

Know what we’ve fought

Need not be forgot nor for none.

It defines us, binds us as one,

Come over, join this day just begun.

For wherever we come together,

We will forever overcome.

Annotations: “New Day’s Lyric” by Amanda Gorman
TextAnnotations
May this be the daySetting the tone for hope and renewal, invoking the possibility of a fresh start.
We come together.Emphasizing unity and solidarity in facing challenges.
Mourning, we come to mend,Acknowledging past hardships and losses while seeking healing and restoration.
Withered, we come to weather,Describing resilience in enduring difficult circumstances.
Torn, we come to tend,Conveying a commitment to nurturing and repairing what has been damaged or divided.
Battered, we come to better.Expressing the determination to emerge stronger and improved from adversity.
Tethered by this year of yearning,Reflecting on the collective longing and longing experienced during a challenging period.
We are learningHighlighting the process of growth and adaptation amid adversity.
That though we weren’t ready for this,Recognizing the unpreparedness for the challenges faced.
We have been readied by it.Acknowledging the transformative impact of adversity in preparing individuals for the future.
We steadily vow that no matterCommitting to resilience and persistence regardless of obstacles.
How we are weighed down,Acknowledging the burdens and challenges faced.
We must always pave a way forward.Emphasizing the importance of progress and moving ahead despite difficulties.
This hope is our door, our portal.Describing hope as a gateway to a better future.
Even if we never get back to normal,Acknowledging the possibility of a new normalcy rather than a return to the past.
Someday we can venture beyond it,Encouraging exploration and growth beyond current limitations.
To leave the known and take the first steps.Embracing change and embarking on new journeys.
So let us not return to what was normal,Rejecting the idea of reverting to previous conditions.
But reach toward what is next.Advocating for progress and forward-thinking.
What was cursed, we will cure.Promising to overcome challenges and adversities.
What was plagued, we will prove pure.Committing to transform negativity into positivity and purity.
Where we tend to argue, we will try to agree,Emphasizing the importance of cooperation and harmony in resolving conflicts.
Those fortunes we forswore, now the future we foresee,Recognizing a shift in priorities and perspectives towards a brighter future.
Where we weren’t aware, we’re now awake;Acknowledging newfound awareness and consciousness.
Those moments we missedReflecting on missed opportunities and experiences.
Are now these moments we make,Embracing the present and actively creating meaningful experiences.
The moments we meet,Celebrating connections and encounters.
And our hearts, once altogether beaten,Describing resilience and unity in overcoming challenges.
Now all together beat.Signifying strength and solidarity.
Come, look up with kindness yet,Encouraging optimism and compassion in the face of difficulties.
For even solace can be sourced from sorrow.Recognizing the potential for comfort and growth even in times of sadness.
We remember, not just for the sake of yesterday,Emphasizing the importance of learning from the past.
But to take on tomorrow.Highlighting the role of past experiences in shaping future actions and decisions.
We heed this old spirit,Acknowledging the wisdom and resilience of previous generations.
In a New Day’s lyric,Embracing renewal and possibility in a new era.
In our hearts, we hear it:Signifying the internalization of hope and inspiration.
For auld lang syne, my dear,Referencing the traditional Scottish song about friendship and remembrance.
For auld lang syne.Expressing the enduring nature of connections and memories.
Be bold, sang Time this year,Encouraging courage and boldness in facing the future.
Be bold, sang Time,Reinforcing the call to action and resilience in the passage of time.
For when you honor yesterday,Recognizing the importance of acknowledging and learning from the past.
Tomorrow ye will find.Emphasizing the potential for growth and progress in the future.
Know what we’ve foughtAcknowledging past struggles and challenges.
Need not be forgot nor for none.Emphasizing the importance of remembering and learning from past experiences.
It defines us, binds us as one,Highlighting the role of shared experiences in uniting communities.
Come over, join this day just begun.Inviting participation and engagement in the ongoing journey of renewal and growth.
For wherever we come together,Recognizing the strength and resilience found in unity.
We will forever overcome.Affirming the belief in overcoming obstacles and challenges as a united community.
Literary And Poetic Devices: “New Day’s Lyric” by Amanda Gorman
  1. Metaphor: Comparing the challenges of the year to being tethered by a yearning.
  2. Alliteration: “We steadily vow that no matter / How we are weighed down.”
  3. Repetition: Repeating “We come” emphasizes unity and solidarity.
  4. Anaphora: “What was cursed, we will cure. / What was plagued, we will prove pure.”
  5. Imagery: “Withered, we come to weather, / Torn, we come to tend” paints vivid pictures of resilience.
  6. Personification: Time is personified, reaching toward the future with “But reach toward what is next.”
  7. Symbolism: “This hope is our door, our portal.” Hope symbolizes a gateway to a better future.
  8. Assonance: “Where we tend to argue, we will try to agree.” The repeated ‘e’ sound adds musicality.
  9. Consonance: “Those fortunes we forswore, now the future we foresee.” The repeated ‘s’ sound enhances the poem’s rhythm.
  10. Enjambment: “We remember, not just for the sake of yesterday, / But to take on tomorrow.” Thoughts flow continuously across lines.
  11. Onomatopoeia: “Now all together beat.” The word ‘beat’ imitates the sound of a heart.
  12. Oxymoron: “Even solace can be sourced from sorrow.” Contrasting comfort and sadness.
  13. Hyperbole: “For auld lang syne.” The phrase exaggerates an everlasting connection beyond time.
  14. Irony: “Where we weren’t aware, we’re now awake.” Contrasting states of consciousness.
  15. Euphemism: “Battered, we come to better.” Softening the harshness of ‘battered’.
  16. Allusion: “For auld lang syne.” Referring to the traditional Scottish song about friendship and remembrance.
  17. Simile: “Come, look up with kindness yet.” Comparing kindness to a positive action.
  18. Parallelism: “Be bold, sang Time this year, / Be bold, sang Time.” Repeating for emphasis.
  19. Antithesis: “For when you honor yesterday, / Tomorrow ye will find.” Contrasting past and future actions.
  20. Juxtaposition: “What was cursed, we will cure. / What was plagued, we will prove pure.” Contrasting ideas side by side.
Themes: “New Day’s Lyric” by Amanda Gorman
  1. Resilience and Unity: Amanda Gorman’s “New Day’s Lyric” resonates with the theme of resilience and unity amidst adversity. Through the imagery of coming together despite being torn, withered, and battered, Gorman emphasizes the collective strength found in unity. The repetition of “we come” reinforces the idea of communal solidarity, regardless of individual struggles. Gorman highlights the transformative power of shared experiences, suggesting that although the challenges may have been unexpected, they have ultimately prepared and united us. This theme of resilience and unity is encapsulated in the line “For wherever we come together, we will forever overcome,” emphasizing the enduring strength found in communal support and solidarity.
  2. Hope and Transformation: In “New Day’s Lyric,” Amanda Gorman explores the theme of hope and transformation, emphasizing the potential for growth and renewal even in the face of adversity. Gorman portrays hope as a guiding force, symbolized by the metaphorical door or portal to a better future. She encourages embracing change and moving forward, rather than simply returning to a pre-existing state. The lines “Even if we never get back to normal, Someday we can venture beyond it,” suggest a hopeful outlook towards the future, rooted in the belief that positive transformation is possible. Gorman’s emphasis on curing what was cursed and proving purity where there was once plague underscores the theme of hope and transformation, highlighting the capacity for change and renewal.
  3. Reflection and Progress: Reflecting on the past to pave the way for progress is a central theme in Amanda Gorman’s “New Day’s Lyric.” Gorman emphasizes the importance of acknowledging and learning from past experiences, both individually and collectively, in order to move forward. The poem encourages introspection and self-awareness, suggesting that moments of hardship have the potential to become opportunities for growth and development. By recognizing the mistakes and missed opportunities of the past, individuals can actively shape a better future. Gorman’s call to “heed this old spirit, In a New Day’s lyric,” underscores the theme of reflection and progress, urging listeners to honor the past while embracing the possibilities of the future.
  4. Perseverance and Hope: Throughout “New Day’s Lyric,” Amanda Gorman celebrates the themes of perseverance and hope, emphasizing the resilience of the human spirit in the face of adversity. The poem acknowledges the challenges and hardships endured, but also highlights the determination to overcome and thrive. Gorman’s imagery of hearts beating together and the repeated emphasis on coming together despite difficulties underscores the theme of perseverance and hope. The closing lines, “Know what we’ve fought Need not be forgot nor for none. It defines us, binds us as one,” encapsulate the idea that through perseverance and solidarity, individuals can overcome obstacles and create a brighter future.
Literary Theories and Interpretations of “New Day’s Lyric” by Amanda Gorman
Literary TheoryInterpretationReferences from the Poem
1. New Historicism“New Day’s Lyric” can be interpreted through the lens of New Historicism, which examines literary texts in the context of historical and cultural factors. Gorman’s poem reflects the collective experiences and struggles of a community during a specific period, likely referring to the challenges faced during the COVID-19 pandemic. By acknowledging the hardships and transformations of this era, Gorman creates a poetic narrative that captures the zeitgeist of the time, offering insights into societal resilience and unity.– References to collective experiences and struggles: “Mourning, we come to mend,” “Withered, we come to weather,” “Torn, we come to tend,” “Battered, we come to better.” – Emphasis on learning from past experiences: “That though we weren’t ready for this, We have been readied by it.” – Reflection on the past and its impact on the present: “We remember, not just for the sake of yesterday, But to take on tomorrow.”
2. Feminist CriticismA feminist interpretation of “New Day’s Lyric” could focus on the empowerment of marginalized voices and the celebration of collective strength. Gorman’s poem emphasizes the resilience and unity of individuals coming together to confront adversity, which can be seen as a feminist act of solidarity. The repeated use of “we” highlights the importance of community and collaboration, echoing feminist principles of collective action and support. Additionally, Gorman’s portrayal of hope and transformation can be viewed through a feminist lens, as it reflects the agency and resilience of individuals facing systemic challenges.– Celebration of collective strength: “We come together,” “Our hearts, once altogether beaten, Now all together beat.” – Emphasis on solidarity and collaboration: “For wherever we come together, We will forever overcome.” – Portrayal of hope and agency: “Even if we never get back to normal, Someday we can venture beyond it,” “What was cursed, we will cure.”
3. EcocriticismThrough an ecocritical lens, “New Day’s Lyric” can be interpreted as a reflection on humanity’s relationship with nature and the environment. While the poem primarily addresses human resilience in the face of adversity, it also contains subtle references to ecological themes. Gorman’s emphasis on transformation and renewal can be extended to include the concept of ecological regeneration and sustainability. The poem’s call to “tend” and “better” suggests a responsibility to care for both ourselves and the natural world, highlighting the interconnectedness of human and environmental well-being.– Implicit references to nature and renewal: “We steadily vow that no matter How we are weighed down, We must always pave a way forward.” – Emphasis on caring for the environment: “What was cursed, we will cure,” “Where we tend to argue, we will try to agree.” – Recognition of interconnectedness: “For wherever we come together, We will forever overcome.”
Critical Questions about “New Day’s Lyric” by Amanda Gorman
  • Question 1: What is the central theme of the poem, and how does the speaker convey a sense of unity and collective action?
  • Answer: The central theme of the poem is the idea of coming together and moving forward in the face of adversity. The speaker emphasizes the importance of unity and perseverance in overcoming challenges, as seen in lines such as “May this be the day / We come together” and “We steadily vow that no matter / How we are weighed down, / We must always pave a way forward” (Gorman 1-4). The use of the word “we” throughout the poem creates a sense of inclusivity and shared experience, emphasizing that the speaker is not alone in their struggles or hopes. The repetition of phrases like “we come” and “we will” also reinforces the idea of collective action and shared responsibility.
  • Question 2: How does the speaker view the concept of “normal” in the poem, and what implications does this have for the reader?
  • Answer: The speaker suggests that returning to what was considered “normal” before is not desirable or possible. Instead, they encourage the reader to “reach toward what is next” and to “venture beyond” what is familiar (Gorman 17-18). This indicates a desire for progress and growth, rather than a return to the status quo. By rejecting the idea of returning to “normal,” the speaker implies that the past is not something to be romanticized or clung to, but rather something to be learned from and built upon. This message encourages the reader to embrace change and look towards the future with hope and optimism.
  • Question 3: What role does memory play in the poem, and how does the speaker use it to inspire action?
  • Answer: Memory is presented as a source of strength and inspiration in the poem. The speaker notes that “We remember, not just for the sake of yesterday, / But to take on tomorrow” (Gorman 29-30). This suggests that remembering the past is essential for moving forward and building a better future. The speaker also uses memory to honor the struggles and hardships of the past, acknowledging that “what we’ve fought / Need not be forgot nor for none” (Gorman 35-36). By remembering and learning from the past, the speaker encourages the reader to use those experiences to inform and motivate their actions in the present and future.
  • Question 4: What message does the poem convey about the power of collective action, and how does it relate to the idea of a “new day”?
  • Answer: The poem emphasizes the idea that when people come together, they can overcome even the most daunting challenges. The speaker declares, “For wherever we come together, / We will forever overcome” (Gorman 39-40). This message highlights the importance of unity, solidarity, and collective action in achieving positive change. The idea of a “new day” represents a fresh start and a chance for renewal, and the speaker suggests that this new beginning is only possible through collective action and a shared commitment to moving forward. By emphasizing the power of collective action, the speaker encourages the reader to work together towards a brighter future.
Literary Works Similar to “New Day’s Lyric” by Amanda Gorman
  1. “Still I Rise” by Maya Angelou: Maya Angelou’s “Still I Rise” celebrates resilience, strength, and the ability to overcome adversity. Like “New Day’s Lyric,” it emphasizes the power of resilience and determination in the face of challenges.
  2. “The Hill We Climb” by Amanda Gorman: Another poem by Amanda Gorman, “The Hill We Climb,” shares thematic similarities with “New Day’s Lyric.” Both poems explore themes of resilience, unity, and hope in the face of adversity.
  3. “Invictus” by William Ernest Henley: “Invictus” by William Ernest Henley is a classic poem that celebrates the indomitable human spirit in the face of adversity. Like “New Day’s Lyric,” it emphasizes the power of perseverance and resilience.
  4. I, Too” by Langston Hughes: Langston Hughes’s “I, Too” speaks to the resilience and hope of marginalized communities, much like the themes explored in “New Day’s Lyric.” Both poems emphasize the importance of unity and overcoming oppression.
  5. “If We Must Die” by Claude McKay: Claude McKay’s “If We Must Die” is a powerful poem that speaks to the strength and resilience of individuals facing oppression and adversity. Similar to “New Day’s Lyric,” it emphasizes the importance of unity and perseverance in the face of hardship.
Suggested Readings: “New Day’s Lyric” by Amanda Gorman
  • Gorman, Amanda. The Hill We Climb: An Inaugural Poem for the Country. Viking, 2021.
  • Assad, Hafizh, and Devi Hellystia. “Personification in Call Us What We Carry Poems by Amanda Gorman 2021.” J-Lalite: Journal of English Studies 3.2 (2022): 174-181.
  • Uremović, Mia. America Through Its Inaugural Poems. Diss. University of Zagreb. Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences. Department of English language and literature, 2021.
  • Morton, Ayo Mariama. “Lifting as We Climb: Amanda Gorman and Womanist Vernacular Discourse at the 2021 Presidential Inauguration.” Journal for the History of Rhetoric 25.1 (2022): 83-95.
  • https://www.theamandagorman.com/
Representative Quotations “New Day’s Lyric” by Amanda Gorman
QuotationContextTheoretical Perspectives
“May this be the day / We come together.”The opening lines of the poem, setting the tone for unity and collective action.Social Identity Theory: The speaker emphasizes the importance of shared identity and collective action.
“We steadily vow that no matter / How we are weighed down, / We must always pave a way forward.”The speaker emphasizes perseverance and progress despite adversity.Resilience Theory: The speaker highlights the ability to bounce back from challenges and find a way forward.
“This hope is our door, our portal. / Even if we never get back to normal, / Someday we can venture beyond it, / To leave the known and take the first steps.”The speaker describes hope as a catalyst for progress and growth.Hope Theory: The speaker emphasizes the role of hope in motivating action and achieving positive change.
“What was cursed, we will cure. / What was plagued, we will prove pure.”The speaker describes the transformation of past struggles into opportunities for growth and redemption.Trauma-Informed Care: The speaker acknowledges the impact of past traumas and emphasizes the possibility of healing and transformation.
“For wherever we come together, / We will forever overcome.”The final lines of the poem, emphasizing the power of collective action and unity.Collective Efficacy: The speaker highlights the idea that together, individuals can achieve more than alone, and that collective action leads to success.