“A Sailor Went to Sea”: A Critical Review

“A Sailor Went to Sea” is a traditional children’s nursery rhyme and song. Its exact origins are unknown, making it difficult to definitively credit a specific author or initial publication date.

"A Sailor Went to Sea" by Nursery Rhyme: A Critical Review
Introduction: “A Sailor Went to Sea”

“A Sailor Went to Sea” is a traditional children’s nursery rhyme and song. Its exact origins are unknown, making it difficult to definitively credit a specific author or initial publication date. However, similar versions of the rhyme likely existed in oral tradition for many years. The song’s popularity stems from its catchy repetition, simple actions, and the fun opportunity to learn about sea creatures. Some notable features include its call-and-response style and the cumulative verses that build excitement from line to line.

A sailor went to sea, sea, sea,
To see what he could see, see, see.
But all that he could see, see, see,
Was the bottom of the deep blue sea, sea, sea.

A sailor went to sea, sea, sea,
To see what he could see, see, see.
But all that he could see, see, see,
Was the bottom of the deep blue sea, sea, sea.

Annotations: “A Sailor Went to Sea”
LineAnnotation
A sailor went to sea, sea, sea,Sets up the story, introduces the sailor and the vastness of the ocean.
To see what he could see, see, see.Establishes curiosity and a sense of exploration.
But all that he could see, see, see,Creates suspense and a hint of disappointment.
Was the bottom of the deep blue sea, sea, sea.Reveals the limited view, emphasizing the ocean’s depth and the sailor’s smallness.
Literary And Poetic Devices: “A Sailor Went to Sea”
  1. Repetition: The most obvious device, with the words “sea” and “see” repeated to emphasize the imagery and create rhythm.
  2. Alliteration: The repetition of the “s” sound in “sailor,” “sea,” and “see” adds to the musicality.
  3. Assonance: The repetition of the long “e” sound in “see” creates a pleasing sonic effect.
  4. Consonance: The soft “b” sound in “bottom” and “blue” subtly connects the final line.
  5. Rhyme: The lines end in a simple rhyme scheme (ABC, ABC). This is common for nursery rhymes, making them easier to recall and recite.
  6. Onomatopoeia: While subtle, some argue the word “sea” itself has onomatopoeic qualities, mimicking the sound of the ocean.
  7. Imagery: The rhyme creates vivid mental pictures of the ocean, helping children envision the vastness and the potential for hidden things within the deep.
  8. Symbolism: The sea often represents the unknown, the depths of life, and potential dangers.
  9. Juxtaposition: The contrast between the sailor’s hopeful exploration and the limited view creates a sense of tension.
  10. Suspense: The repeated “But all that he could see…” builds a sense of anticipation.
  11. Surprise: The final line reveals an unexpected and slightly melancholy outcome.
  12. Structure: The cumulative verses, each repeating the previous lines and adding a new one, build up a sense of rhythm and momentum.
  13. Meter: While not perfect, there’s a loose iambic meter (unstressed syllable followed by a stressed syllable), contributing to the nursery rhyme’s sing-song quality.
  14. Rhythm: The combination of repetition, rhyme, and meter creates a strong rhythm for children to enjoy.
Themes: “A Sailor Went to Sea”
  1. Theme 1: Curiosity and Exploration: The nursery rhyme “A Sailor Went to Sea” embodies a sense of childlike wonder and a thirst for exploration. The sailor sets out on his journey with a simple desire: “to see what he could see.” This unbridled curiosity reflects the natural inclination of children to investigate their surroundings and seek new experiences. The rhyme taps into that innate drive for discovery, encouraging a sense of adventure and openness to the unknown.
  2. Theme 2: The Limits of Perception: Despite the sailor’s adventurous spirit, the rhyme underscores the potential limits of our perceptions. His repeated search for something to see ends with a simple view of “the bottom of the deep blue sea.” This unexpected outcome suggests that the world holds mysteries that may remain out of reach. Even with the best of intentions and an explorer’s heart, our perspective can be constrained by circumstance or the nature of reality itself.
  3. Theme 3: The Vastness of Nature: The repetition of the word “sea” throughout the rhyme emphasizes the sheer immensity of the ocean. This seemingly endless expanse of water dwarfs the sailor and his quest, highlighting the awe-inspiring scale of the natural world. The rhyme serves as a playful reminder that humans exist within a much larger ecosystem, one that is both beautiful and humbling.
  4. Theme 4: Disappointment and Acceptance: “A Sailor Went to Sea” subtly introduces the potential for dashed expectations. The repeated phrase “But all that he could see…” builds a sense of anticipation. Yet, the final line reveals a somewhat mundane and limited view. This could be interpreted as a gentle lesson about the difference between our hopes and the reality we sometimes encounter. The rhyme leaves a hint of quiet acceptance, hinting that life’s journeys might not always unfold as we imagine.
Literary Theories and “A Sailor Went to Sea”
Literary TheoryApproachReference from the Poem
FormalismFocus on the text itself: structure, language, literary devices.* Repetition of “sea, sea, sea” and “see, see, see”.
* Simple rhyme scheme and rhythmic pattern.
PsychoanalyticUnconscious desires, symbolism, childhood influences.* The sea as a symbol of the unknown, potential danger, or the subconscious.
* The sailor’s journey as a metaphor for a child’s exploration of the world.
Reader-ResponseEmphasizes the reader’s active role in creating meaning.* A child’s interpretation might focus on the adventure and fun repetition.
* An adult might find hints of deeper themes like disappointment.
FeministExplores gender roles and representation of women.* While not directly applicable, could discuss the traditional focus on a male protagonist.
* Potential to reimagine the rhyme with a female sailor.
MarxistExamines power structures, social class, economic implications* The sailor as a potential working-class figure.
* The vast sea could represent untamed nature vs. potential exploitation of resources.
Critical Questions about “A Sailor Went to Sea”
  • Analyze the function of repetition within the structure of the rhyme.

Answer: The repetition of “sea” and “see” serves multiple purposes. It establishes a strong sense of setting, reinforces the visual and auditory aspects of the ocean, and creates a rhythmic cadence suitable for a children’s rhyme. Additionally, the repetition builds anticipation, emphasizing the contrast between the vastness of the sea and the sailor’s limited perspective.

  • Discuss the potential thematic implications of the rhyme’s anticlimactic ending. * Answer: The sailor only seeing “the bottom of the deep blue sea” subverts potential expectations of thrilling discoveries. This could introduce notions of the limits of perception, suggesting that even great curiosity may not yield fully satisfying answers. It also hints at the contrast between our desires and the reality we encounter.
  • Examine how the rhyme constructs a relationship between humanity and the natural world.

Answer: The emphasis on the sea’s sheer size highlights its power and the sailor’s relative insignificance. This underscores nature’s awe-inspiring qualities and the humbling recognition of human limitations within a larger ecosystem. The sailor represents an innate drive for exploration within this context.

  • Consider whether the sailor functions as a symbolic figure beyond his literal role.
    Answer: The sailor’s journey could be interpreted as a metaphor for the broader human experience of seeking knowledge and understanding. His limited view hints at the potential for both fulfillment and disappointment inherent in the pursuit of discovery, suggesting a universal theme of exploration and its inherent limit
Literary Works Similar to “A Sailor Went to Sea”
Nursery Rhymes and Children’s Songs:
  • “Row, Row, Row Your Boat”: Features repetition, a playful melody, and encourages imaginative actions.
  • “The Wheels on the Bus”: Relies on a repetitive structure, introduces familiar actions in a sing-along format.
  • “Mary Had a Little Lamb”: Tells a simple story focused on a child’s world with a gentle, reassuring tone.
  • “Old MacDonald Had a Farm”: Introduces animal sounds, encourages audience participation, and builds with a cumulative structure.
Short Poems with Nautical Themes:
  • “Sea Fever” by John Masefield: Evokes a deep longing for the sea and a sailor’s life, using more complex language than a nursery rhyme.
  • Excerpts from “The Rime of the Ancient Mariner” by Samuel Taylor Coleridge: Depicts a lengthy and perilous sea voyage with supernatural elements, exploring themes of consequence and the power of nature.
Children’s Books with Exploration Themes:
  • “Where the Wild Things Are” by Maurice Sendak: Follows a child’s symbolic journey of facing inner anxieties and finding a place of belonging.
  • “The Very Hungry Caterpillar” by Eric Carle: Features a simpler structure focused on a caterpillar’s transformation, emphasizing themes of growth and discovery.
Suggested Readings: “A Sailor Went to Sea”
  • Collections and Histories of Nursery Rhymes: These resources provide a broad understanding of the genre and may include discussions of “A Sailor Went to Sea” within its specific context.
    • Opie, Iona, and Peter Opie. The Oxford Dictionary of Nursery Rhymes. Oxford University Press, 1997.
    • “Nursery Rhymes and Songs.” Mama Lisa’s World, [invalid URL removed]
  • Critical Studies of Children’s Literature: These works might reference “A Sailor Went to Sea” as an example when examining characteristics of children’s poetry, the development of oral tradition in literature, or the use of simple literary devices.
    • Hunt, Peter. Children’s Literature. Blackwell Publishing, 2001.
    • Nodelman, Perry. The Pleasures of Children’s Literature. Longman, 2003.
  • Analyses of Poetic Techniques: Explore resources discussing literary devices like repetition, rhyme, and onomatopoeia. “A Sailor Went to Sea” can serve as a practical example for understanding these concepts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *