Essentialism in Literature & Literary Theory

Etymology of Essentialism

Table of Contents

The term “essentialism” is derived from the word “essence,” which has its roots in Latin (essentia) and Middle English (essencial). It refers to the concept of inherent and fundamental qualities or characteristics that define the nature of something. Essentialism as a philosophical and educational concept emerged in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, building upon this idea of a fixed and unchanging core.

It primarily emerged within the context of essentialist philosophies of education, which advocated for a focus on a fixed and unchanging core of knowledge and skills as the foundation of curriculum and instruction. Drawing on the ancient concept of “essence” from Aristotle’s philosophy, essentialism posits that there are inherent, timeless qualities or truths that define the nature of a subject or discipline.

Meanings of Essentialism

Aspect	Meaning
Philosophical Foundation	In literary theory, essentialism refers to the belief that texts have inherent, unchanging meanings and that these meanings can be discovered through analysis.
Interpretation Approach	It entails a rigid approach to literary interpretation, where a text is seen as possessing a fixed and singular essence, often overlooking nuances and multiple interpretations.
Critique of Essentialism	Many literary theorists critique essentialism for its tendency to oversimplify the complexities of literature and disregard the role of context, reader response, and cultural influences in shaping meaning.
Post-Structuralist Alternative	Post-structuralist literary theory, in contrast, emphasizes the fluidity and multiplicity of meanings in texts, challenging essentialist notions and promoting a more dynamic approach to interpretation.

Definition of Essentialism as a Theoretical Term

Essentialism, as a theoretical term, refers to the philosophical perspective that asserts the existence of inherent and unchanging qualities or characteristics that define the nature of a particular object, concept, or phenomenon. It posits that these essential qualities are fundamental and fixed, serving as the core identity of the subject in question. Essentialism has been applied across various disciplines, including philosophy, education, and literary theory, often as a foundational concept that underpins beliefs about identity, meaning, and interpretation.

Essentialism: Origin, Theorists, Works and Arguments

Origin:

The concept of essentialism has ancient philosophical roots, with notable contributions from thinkers like Plato and Aristotle.

Theorists:

Plato: Essentialist elements are evident in Plato’s philosophy, particularly in his theory of Forms. Plato believed in the existence of abstract, unchanging forms or essences that define reality.
Aristotle: Aristotle’s exploration of essential attributes and qualities is a cornerstone of essentialist thought. His work, particularly Metaphysics significantly influenced the development of essentialism.

Key Works:

Plato’s The Republic: In this influential work, Plato discusses essentialism within the context of his theory of the ideal state, emphasizing the role of essential qualities in the governance of society.
Aristotle’s Metaphysics: Aristotle’s examination of essence and essential attributes is central to the concept of essentialism. His exploration of these concepts in Metaphysics played a pivotal role in shaping later essentialist thinking.

Arguments:

Essentialism asserts the existence of inherent, unchanging qualities or characteristics that define the true nature of objects, concepts, or ideas.

It contends that understanding these essential attributes is crucial for gaining insight into the essence and significance of a subject.
Critics of essentialism argue that it can oversimplify complex phenomena, disregarding the influence of context, culture, and temporal change, which may lead to reductionist interpretations.

Essentialism and Literary Theories

Classical Criticism: Essentialist ideas are evident in classical approaches to literature, where texts were often interpreted to reveal universal truths or essential human experiences. For example, Aristotle’s theory of tragedy seeks to uncover the essential elements that make a tragic story.

New Criticism: This mid-20th-century literary theory emphasizes the inherent structure and meaning of a text, focusing on close reading and formal analysis to uncover the work’s essential qualities. New Critics argue that the meaning of a text can be found within the text itself.
Structuralism: Structuralist literary theory, influenced by Ferdinand de Saussure, seeks to identify the underlying structures that give meaning to language and narrative. Structuralists look for the essential binary oppositions and structural patterns within texts to decipher their meaning.
Formalism: Formalist literary criticism, similar to New Criticism, concentrates on the formal elements of a text, such as structure, style, and language. Formalists believe that the essential meaning of a literary work can be derived from these formal elements.

Archetypal Criticism: This approach, popularized by Carl Jung’s theories, seeks to uncover universal archetypes and symbols in literature that represent essential, recurring elements of the human experience. Archetypal critics argue that these symbols tap into a collective human consciousness.
Essentialist Interpretations: Some literary critics and scholars, though not adhering to a specific literary theory, may employ essentialist interpretations when analyzing texts, looking for unchanging and fundamental meanings or themes within the work.

While essentialist approaches have been influential in literary criticism, it’s important to note that many contemporary literary theories, such as post-structuralism, deconstructionism, and reader-response criticism, challenge essentialism. These theories argue that meaning in literature is not fixed but is dynamic, context-dependent, and subject to diverse interpretations. As a result, essentialism in literary theory has faced criticism and evolved over time.

Essentialism in Literary Criticism

Book	Essentialism Critique
*The Vanishing Half* by Brit Bennett (2020)	– Essentialist Perspective: An essentialist analysis might attempt to distill a single essential meaning from *The Vanishing Half, such as the exploration of racial identity through the lives of the Vignes sisters, Desiree and Stella, who take divergent paths in life, one passing as white while the other lives as a Black woman. – Critique*: While this interpretation is valid, essentialism might not fully capture the novel’s complex portrayal of the sisters’ individual journeys, their relationships with their respective daughters, and the enduring impact of their choices. Reducing it to one theme could overlook the intricate character development and intergenerational dynamics.
“Cat Person” by Kristen Roupenian (2017)	– Essentialist Perspective: An essentialist reading of *Cat Person* might focus on a singular, essential message, such as the portrayal of the protagonist Margot’s experience in a brief, disheartening relationship with Robert. – Critique: Essentialism in this context could miss the nuanced portrayal of Margot’s inner thoughts, the exploration of consent, and the story’s resonance with contemporary discussions about online dating and modern relationships. Reducing it to one aspect could overlook its psychological complexity.
*The Underground Railroad* by Colson Whitehead (2016)	– Essentialist Perspective: An essentialist reading of *The Underground Railroad* could center on the character of Cora’s journey as a metaphorical representation of the historical Underground Railroad, highlighting themes of escape and freedom. – Critique: Essentialism might miss the novel’s innovative approach to historical fiction, its exploration of the psychological impact of slavery on various characters, and the allegorical elements that challenge conventional narratives of escape and freedom. Reducing it to one character’s journey could overlook its narrative depth.
“The Paper Menagerie” by Ken Liu (2011)	– Essentialist Perspective: An essentialist approach to *The Paper Menagerie* might emphasize a fixed, essential theme, such as the preservation of cultural heritage through the relationship between the protagonist Jack and his mother. – Critique: While these themes are central, essentialism might not fully capture the emotional depth, blending of fantasy and reality, and the exploration of the immigrant experience through Jack’s perspective and his interactions with his mother. Reducing it to one aspect could overlook its narrative richness.

M	T	W	T	F	S	S
		1	2	3	4	5
6	7	8	9	10	11	12
13	14	15	16	17	18	19
20	21	22	23	24	25	26
27	28	29	30	31